10 WWE Undercard Matches That Outshone The Royal Rumble
Daniel Bryan was the 2014 Rumble's main draw, whether WWE liked it or not...
The Royal Rumble was made for moments like Roman Reigns eliminating The Undertaker and having a stare down with the veteran in 2017. That one eye-to-eye between legend and current poster boy set wheels in motion towards WrestleMania, and that's surely the point of the Rumble these days.
Look back to the previous 30 (yes, thirty) Rumble shows since 1988 though and it becomes clear that the annual 30-man match the event is named after doesn't always grab the most attention. Sometimes, there are those matches that draw eyeballs away from the Rumble and actually outshine it. 2017 was no different.
Sit down and get cosy, because you're unlikely to agree with everything here.
That's fine, but nobody can argue that the Rumble pay-per-view series hasn't provided us fans with some damn fine matches. Even if you did enjoy Rumble matches from the years in question, don't discount the impact others on the same show had...
10. The Rock Vs. Mankind (1999)
What do you remember most from the 1999 Royal Rumble? The ongoing fight between Mr. McMahon and Steve Austin? The fact McMahon bizarrely won the match and looked to be 'Mania bound? How about poor Mick Foley's young children crying as their daddy was bashed over the head by a steel chair-wielding Rock?
Barry Blaustein's excellent 'Beyond The Mat' doc captured the harrowing footage of Foley's wife and kids shedding tears as Mick shed braincells. Maybe that's why the 'I Quit' match between Mankind and The Rock has become so memorable. Maybe, although we'd err on the side of drama and the fact both put so much effort in.
McMahon vs. Austin dominated the Rumble. Without that story, the match would have been fairly bland. Meanwhile, Rock vs. Mankind was a meaty brawl which captured the 'screw loose' mentality of Foley (those unprotected chair shots) and the vicious side of a heel Rock.
Trust us, it's the match to watch.
9. Shawn Michaels Vs. The Undertaker (1998)
Steve Austin's name dominated the Attitude Era so much that he was the focal point of 3 consecutive Royal Rumble matches from 1997-1999. His marked man saga was the most striking aspect of the 30-man melee in 1998, but it wouldn't end up being the main event or the show's lasting legacy.
That distinction goes to a Casket Match between The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels. This would end up being Shawn's last match for close to 4 years; a nasty bump onto the coffin suffered when spilling out of the ring damaged HBK's back terribly, so much so that he was forced to retire from wrestling and wasn't expected to return.
If the Rumble had Austin's solo act, then 'Taker vs. Michaels had the Casket stipulation, some world-class exchanges between men who had perfected their act in prior matches and the notable image of Kane burning Undertaker's helpless body in his sarcophagus. Stellar stuff.
8. Daniel Bryan Vs. Bray Wyatt (2014)
If you're being honest with yourself, you probably don't even remember what happened in the opening match of the 2014 Royal Rumble. There, Bray Wyatt beat Daniel Bryan, and everybody in attendance fully expected Bryan would the Rumble later that night. You probably do recall that this didn't happen.
Instead, Batista returned and won the thing. Even poor Rey Mysterio (taking the spot of #30) was booed heavily for having the audacity to steal a Daniel Bryan entrance that was never coming yet everybody desperately hoped would. Oh, for the record, Rey Rey lasted just over 2 minutes and that only infuriated fans more.
The Consol Energy Center in Pittsburgh had come unglued for Bryan earlier on the card. He was the one everybody doted on, and it was he who people wished to see pushed into the WrestleMania headline slot. They'd get their wish, and yet it was never planned during the Rumble.
Somehow, despite only having an above-average match against Wyatt, Bryan's kinship with the audience ended up stealing the show.
7. Brock Lesnar Vs. John Cena vs. Seth Rollins (2015)
Things got worse for the Royal Rumble when Roman Reigns was shoved into the limelight just 12 months after Batista's debacle. Not even an in-person endorsement from The Rock could stop people from booing Reigns. Praise the lord we were given a stunning Triple Threat match earlier in the night then, otherwise the card would be considered a full-on disaster.
The 2015 Rumble was trundling along before Brock Lesnar, Seth Rollins and John Cena entered the ring for their WWE Title 3-way. In 22 minutes, they washed away all that mediocrity of the prior 3 matches on the card and set a bar the Rumble itself couldn't hope to reach. One of the quicker-paced matches starring Lesnar over the past few years, it's more than worthy of a re-watch.
Rollins proved yet again that he belonged despite worries he'd be the third wheel between Brock and Cena on the night. Although people didn't know it then, this was a nice prelude to his MITB cash in and title win at WrestleMania 31.
6. Chris Jericho Vs. Chris Benoit (2001)
The 2001 Royal Rumble will forever be remembered as the night Kane set a new record for eliminations by a single wrestler and Steve Austin won his third Rumble. Outside of the titular match itself, Kurt Angle and Triple H had a decent WWF Title match, but real-life friends Chris Jericho and Chris Benoit managed to upstage everyone.
Their Intercontinental Title ladder war has been virtually scrubbed from the current conscious due to WWE's (understandable) hesitancy to push anything involving Benoit on the Network. He isn't even mentioned in the bookmark bubble for the match. All it says is something like, "Chris Jericho in an Intercontinental Title Ladder Match".
That's a shame, because this bettered anything else on the pay-per-view, and that includes the actual 30-man Rumble. When the show was over, the Intercontinental Title match was the one most rewinded their VHS tapes to watch. If only it could receive the credit it richly deserves.
5. Triple H Vs. Shawn Michaels (2004)
Don't be surprised to see Shawn Michaels for a second time on this list. HBK's return in 2002 ushered in a career rebirth and arguably led to a more fruitful run than he had the first time around. That takes some doing, but it's thanks to matches like this one against Triple H at the 2004 Rumble that Shawn's latter stint is even in the conversation.
Up until the Last Man Standing clash between former DX pals, the '04 Rumble had been pretty damn tepid overall; that's not easy to say on a card including matches like Eddie vs. Chavo Guerrero and Evolution vs. The Dudley Boyz. Only the Rumble match itself and this World Heavyweight Title beauty could save the show.
Chris Benoit's emotional 60-minute performance (and victory) in the Rumble aside, there's nothing else to report from the main event. Nope, it was the match that fed into it we remember the most. Sadly, this chapter of the HBK vs. HHH series has been largely forgotten in favour of others.
Set that right immediately, then settle in to watch Benoit lock in his 'Mania moment.
4. Kurt Angle Vs. Chris Benoit (2003)
The previous year, Benoit wasn't even in the Royal Rumble match. Neither was his opponent for the night, Kurt Angle. WWE rightly gave them the gift of sole focus on a 20-minute head-turner for the WWE Title, and oh what a match it turned out to be. This was a solid 10/10 in terms of technical wrestling, storytelling, and making the match look like a real struggle.
Angle and Benoit must have been pleased to learn that Scott Steiner vs. Triple H would be going on before them. That match would turn out to be a stinker, clearing the field for both workhorses to prove that they were the real deal. They even managed to take attention away from Brock Lesnar's journey towards Rumble success.
That was no small achievement. Lesnar had quickly turned into one of the most over babyfaces in the entire company and an outstanding performer in his own right. The fact Angle and Benoit managed to absorb fans so much they temporarily forgot about 'The Next Big Thing' is astounding and just shows that WWE fans will enjoy technical wrestling if there's a story to back it up.
3. John Cena Vs. AJ Styles (2017)
Cracks have been appearing in WWE's Rumble format for years now (just look at previous entries for proof of that). Finding the balance between a winner they want to push and one fans will accept has become one of the biggest challenges each year. Randy Orton was never going to satisfy both, which is why he was trumped by AJ Styles vs. John Cena.
In fairness to Randy, most would have struggled to top what Cena and Styles did right before the Rumble started. Going almost half the Rumble's length and cramming in countless killer exchanges that left Cena critics looking foolish, the pair even ended things by crowning Cena as a 16-time World Champion.
There was a lot going on here.
A year on from his WWE debut, AJ looked comfortable in such a featured position. He and Cena were the real story from the Rumble, not who was going to win the 30-man match. That speaks volumes to their chemistry, AJ's top notch skills and Cena's ability to adapt against different workers.
2. Triple H Vs. Cactus Jack (2000)
When you somehow manage to outshine The Rock, you know you've done well. Take a bow, Triple H and Mick Foley, because that's precisely what both did at the 2000 Royal Rumble. Aided by the backdrop of Madison Square Garden (the old MSG, no less), Triple H and Cactus Jack produced a sensational Street Fight that topped Dwayne Johnson's big moment.
Everything was perfect. The story going in was tense and laced with moments fans of Foley could use as excuses to punch the air in delight. Their hero was going to storm into New York and put that big-nosed git who married the boss's wife in his place. Or not, and that was the most emotional part of it all.
Jack's never say die attitude giving way to Triple H's cerebral brilliance and hidden toughness weaved a tale the Rumble was never going to beat. There's a reason some who lived through this era count the 2000 Rumble as a favourite, and it has to do more with this Street Fight than what happened next.
Sorry, Rocky.
1. Diesel Vs. Bret Hart (1995)
Truth be told, the 1995 Rumble was a bit naff. Yes, the narrative that Shawn Michaels went from #1 to the end is exciting, but it's hard to keep the thrill going for long upon realising the Royal Rumble lasted just over 38 minutes. To put it into perspective, that's just around 10 minutes longer than that Triple H vs. Cactus Jack effort examined in the last entry.
Incredibly, it was only 10 mins longer than the WWF Title match that had happened earlier between Bret Hart and Diesel too. Part of Bret's legacy was giving Kevin Nash some of his best matches on top in the mid-90's, and this was one of them. It was also Diesel's first pay-per-view match as champion, so he was eager to impress.
Ignore the interference and cop out ending (a draw), because there's a sublime 'big man vs. little man' story waiting beneath the surface. It's true that HBK winning the Rumble was big news, however it couldn't hold a candle to the quality of Bret's Diesel-enhancing performance.
What other matches from Royal Rumble cards do you feel managed to outshine the Rumble itself? Let us know down in the comments section!