2 Ups And 4 Downs From WWE 205 Live (December 13 2016)

In which the Cruiserweights receive Titan Training.

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE.com

This past summer’s Cruiserweight Classic tournament was so well received because it differed massively from the WWE norm - and yet, it was presented under the WWE banner.

Advertisement

A celebration of diversity, the tournament was presented in a rewarding real sports framework and commentated upon by the enthusiastic and knowledgable Mauro Ranallo and Daniel Bryan. There were no clusterf*ck opening segments, no romantic sub-plots, no authority angles. It was antithetical to the company which presented it. Brian Kendrick even whipped out a move so kayfabe deadly that it was only deployed seven times in the legendarily brutal All Japan Pro Wrestling and Pro Wrestling NOAH.

When WWE announced 205 Live, that wave of optimism receded into suspicion. The ECW revival of 2006, for one, confirmed that Vince McMahon was only interested in promoting one style of wrestling. Most expected 205 Live to blend into the background, acting as a glorified Superstars with only 10% more aerial manoeuvres. McMahon famously equates small with weak, and mandates a safer and slower style for what Kevin Nash loves to call vanilla midgets.

Advertisement

Has he reverted to type?

Downs...

4. 205 TAPED

WWE.com

It took three weeks, but WWE has already undermined the very title of the show; owing to Tuesday’s post-SmackDown Tribute To The Troops taping, 205 Live was relegated to the pre-RAW slot.

Advertisement

This inconvenience created a bizarre raft in the time/space continuum when Jack Gallagher, in a pre-match backstage interview, made retrospective reference to events that had yet to occur. Facetiousness aside, that the show was taped was an unenviable prospect. Taping NXT works because it’s an established critical darling - but it is the rule-proving exception. SmackDown! was borderline pointless for years because it lacked any inherent intrigue. If something memorable had occurred on a Tuesday night, news of it would have been posted online within minutes. When it invariably didn’t, Thursday and Friday nights were all but confirmed as inconsequential.

Worse still, the disaster that was 205 Live episode one, in which the Empty Arena match was more oversaturated than Hell In A Cell, may yet move WWE to rethink the show altogether. There’s no doubt that WWE is capable of dreaming up an alternative title; this is the promotion which brought us Jakked, after all. But creating intrigue, without the benefit of immediacy, for a taped one hour show with no genuine stars, is another matter.

Advertisement

At least the arena was full.

3. Austin Aries' Commentary

WWE.com

Austin Aries refers to himself as The Greatest Man That Ever Lived - but that greatness does not extend to the commentary booth.

Advertisement

Unsteady and almost palpably disinterested, the dismissive apathy he uses to such stellar effect in promos doesn’t really translate to the desk. Much of Jack Gallacher’s unique offence rests precariously on its petard - and Aries detonated it by moaning that his rolling crucifix pin series was pointless. A great commentator elevates a wrestler through criticism. Aries is only subbing in, mind, so it’s understandable that he is yet to master the concept.

What can’t be excused is his ugly homophobia. Referring to Gallagher and opponent Drew Gulak’s shared carny history, Aries stated that “after they’re done here, they can find themselves back playing with balls and swinging on poles.” Lame jokes are ever-present in WWE, from Sparklecrotch to The Mountie cosplay. We don’t need lame gay jokes, too.

Advertisement

Whether you’re a social justice or status quo warrior, the stupidity of Aries’ comments cannot be ignored. The man is working for a corporate company with a strict PG rating.

2. Middle Eastern Wrestlers: AUTOMATIC HEELS

WWE.com

During the aforementioned backstage interview, Ariya Daivari interrupted Jack Gallagher and started speaking in Persian. He didn’t speak in a gentle brogue; he angrily framed the language as if he was speaking not to Gallagher but rather a camera filming some ungodly random video. Seemingly possessed by some demonic tongue, the message was clear: ARABS ARE BAD.

Advertisement

Daivari’s ethnic heritage automatically designated the Minnesota native as a villain.

WWE then decided to trot out another middle eastern wrestler, Mustafa Ali. Billed from Pakistan, WWE went full-on Muhammad Hassan with him. Ali was once part of a stable named ‘Team Taliban’ on the Independent circuit - a stigma he’d hoped to extricate himself from upon arriving in the big time.

Advertisement

As Ali made his entrance, the camera panned to a ringside fan giving him the thumbs down. This acted as a neat segue to Ali’s pre-taped promo. “As soon as you hear my name, you’ve already made up your mind about me,” he opined. While not strictly untrue, it is impossible to envisage WWE playing the long, redemptive game with Ali. Instead of conditioning their audience to hate him and justify his radicalisation, why not just position him in the babyface role? Wouldn’t that be more progressive, more newsworthy?

Besides which, they already have one pseudo-terrorist on the show!

Advertisement

1. Noam Dar's Cruising

WWE.com

Noam Dar is one of the finest young British talents to have emerged from a white-hot scene in recent years. As engagingly brash as he is technically gifted, he overcame a shaky start in the CWC (thank you, Ho Ho Lun) and restored his confidence in an excellent losing effort opposite Zack Sabre Jr. That finish was, quietly, one of the most brutal to end a wrestling match.

Advertisement

None of that particularly matters to WWE, who have opted to mine the past and bestow upon Dar a PG variation of Dean Malenko’s infamously naff Double Ho Seven schtick.

Yes, Mr. Dar has googly eyes for the noticeably taller Alicia Fox, oozing up to her in backstage segments typical of RAW and SmackDown! The singular magic of the CWC has been diluted and homogenised into the overarching scripted archetype. Dar has installed himself as the third point of a love triangle also incorporating Fox and boyfriend Cedric Alexander. Since WWE’s treatment of women is often as retrograde as its treatment of muslims, be sure to expect Fox to expose the snake beneath and betray her current beau.

Advertisement

From legitimate athlete to soap opera supporting cast, Dar is the plight of the Cruiserweights, in microcosm.

Ups...

2. Jack Gallagher Is Awesome

WWE.com

Jack Gallagher is one of the few wrestlers to live up to those famously exaggerated nicknames, many of which are impossible to take seriously. Titus O’Neil calls himself The Big Deal - yet he’s never done anything even remotely significant.

Advertisement

Gallagher, however, truly is extraordinary. His match opposite Gulak was hugely entertaining; at once funny and scientific, it was immaculately paced to incorporate a stiff, strike-based brawl at the finish (I will never tire of Mauro Ranallo referencing Katsuyori Shibata on WWE television).

It was little more than a showcase for Gallagher, but his novel offence is such a joy to watch that it’s difficult to envisage it ever growing old. His character work was equally impressive. Effectively every WWE babyface is a wise-cracking, breezy, smug guy, as quick to throw a zinger as they are to lace up their boots. To confirm this, all three former members of The Shield currently play the same character on WWE TV.

Advertisement

Gallagher is a different breed - charming, polite, naturally witty - and his presence is welcome. Even the word ‘Sparklecrotch’ would sound endearing emanating from his gentlemanly mouth.

1. Eclectic(ish) Action

WWE.com

There were three matches on this week’s episode of 205 Live - all of which were fairly different in style, if similar in psychological construction.

Advertisement

The opening match, between Messrs Gallagher and Gulak, was a tidy mat-based affair. Lince Dorado’s similar showcase match differed almost entirely in style, in which he showed off his ultra-smooth lucha things. The main event was a very good all-babyface outing, one rich in character work and body language. The almost mirthful look shared between TJ Perkins and Rich Swann after the Dynamite Kid Vs. Tiger Mask-inspired p*ssing contest was expert in setting a tone of sportsmanship.

Though an eclectic range of styles was showcased, the first two matches in particular followed the rote WWE mode to the letter. The face got the opening shine, the heel cut it off. Some back and forth. Rinse and repeat.

Advertisement

On this evidence, 205 Live is just another WWE show. But, with Gallagher as its prospective face, there is scope for some extraordinary quality in 2017 - provided they don’t book him to take a fancy to Nia Jax. Wouldn’t that be funny? They look so different!