20 Awesome WWE Royal Rumble Debuts And Returns

The biggest surprises we've seen when the buzzer sounds.

By Scott Carlson /

No matter how dour they might be, wrestling fans can’t deny that every January there’s a sense of optimistic curiosity as the Royal Rumble draws near.

Advertisement

For years, the Rumble has presented even the most cynical fans with an opportunity to hope for something fun and memorable. There’s the mystery of who is coming out next as the timer winds down, whether it’s a dominant superstar to clear the ring of deadwood or some hapless schmo to be fed to said monster.

But there’s also the element of total surprise: a wrestler no one expected to show up makes his (or her) appearance, sending the crowd into a frenzy. This has been more of a recent phenomenon, with WWE trying to use the surprise spot to bring back an injured superstar, debut an NXT call-up, or just juice the fans with a legend returning for one night only.

Regardless, we’ve seen a bunch of these throughout the years, so it’s worth taking a look back at some of the better Royal Rumble surprises we’ve seen, and see how they stack up against each other. Which fares better? A returning superstar, an injured wrestler showing up, or a brand-new WWE debut?

Let’s get to it…

20. Mick Foley (2012)

This is the first of two entries for the Hardcore Legend, who technically retired in 2000, but made a few returns to a WWE ring. This would actually be his final in-ring appearance.

Advertisement

Foley was beyond the point of doing anything serious in the ring, so his appearance was merely a nostalgia deal, but we got a fair amount of comedy, which you either loved or hated. Mick entered at #7, followed at #9 by Santino Marella, which led to one of the greatest (or worst) standoffs ever.

The match came to a dead stop as Foley and Marella dug into their wrestling gear and produced Mr. Socko and the Cobra respectively, for an epic in-ring confrontation between the two. They battled momentarily before Cody Rhodes would eliminate both men.

Foley would last less than 7 minutes, but it was a memorable send-off for a beloved character that produced some genuine laughs.

19. Rusev (2014)

These days, NXT wrestlers getting the call to appear in a Royal Rumble match is an annual rite of passage. But several years ago, it was a novel idea.

Advertisement

Before he had Lana at his side and before he lost his first name, Alexander Rusev made his main roster debut at the 2014 Rumble, entering at #6 and looking strong. He didn’t eliminate anyone, but it took four men to toss him.

But it was what happened afterward that lent more oomph to his appearance. Seconds after Rusev was tossed, Kofi Kingston also was ejected, landing in Rusev’s arms. The Bulgarian Brute dropped Kofi on the barricade and pummeled him before storming off, leaving Kingston to ruminate how to get back into the ring since he hadn’t been eliminated.

That led to Kofi’s epic leap back to the apron, which was an incredible visual.

18. Bo Dallas (2013)

The first real NXT Royal Rumble debut belongs to someone who today is more of a punchline, but back then was a rising star.

Advertisement

When Bo Dallas showed up in the 2013 Rumble, he was five months away from winning the NXT Championship. He turned in a respectable performance, lasting more than 20 minutes and eliminating Wade Barrett, who at the time was the Intercontinental Champion. Barrett would turn around and toss Dallas, setting up a mini-feud between the two.

It's quite the difference between then and now, but you've got to give WWE kudos for trying to give Dallas some shine via the Rumble.

17. Diamond Dallas Page (2015)

From one Dallas, to another.

Advertisement

It’s really hard to believe that Diamond Dallas Page was 58 years old when he showed up at #14 in the 2015 Royal Rumble, but it’s true. DDP was a surprise entrant in that much-reviled Rumble, managing to make his 3-minute appearance before fans turned on the match when Daniel Bryan was eliminated moments after Page was tossed.

DDP managed to fire off a couple Diamond Cutters for old-time’s sake, but there wasn’t much else to his appearance than a brief nostalgia run.

16. Diesel (2011)

When you’ve got a 40-man Royal Rumble to fill, you can reach deep and pull off some unique surprises.

Advertisement

In the case of the 2011 Rumble, WWE took full advantage of recent TNA departures to bring back a couple of WWE legends. In the case of Kevin Nash, it was a decidedly big coup, but it unfortunately was muted by the decision to bring him back under his Diesel moniker, a character he hadn’t played in 15 years, and many fans might not have recognized.

But it was undoubtedly Nash, which led to a big pop - although not one as memorable as the one another WWE legend got that year. More on him later.

15. Mr. Perfect (2002)

Let’s be honest: Mr. Perfect’s return to WWE in 2002 reached its high point with his initial appearance.

Advertisement

Curt Hennig showed up at the 2002 Royal Rumble in the #25 position to a big pop as a legit surprise. Perfect had last been seen in WWE in late 1996, and his WCW contract had already expired when WWE took them over in 2001.

Mr. Perfect managed to last until the final three, even pulling off a memorable gum swat as he was being shoved into a corner. Although he didn’t really do much else during his brief run, it was a memorable moment for fans.

14. Kharma (2012)

When you talk about wasted opportunity in WWE, Kharma has to be at the top of your list.

Advertisement

A huge signing, the former Awesome Kong was set to be a world-beater in the divas division before getting pregnant. She would then return at the 2012 Royal Rumble, the last woman to enter the match before last year’s all-women’s Rumble. Kharma would terrorize Michael Cole (yes, he was actually in a Rumble) and eliminate Hunico before being tossed herself.

And that was that for Kharma in WWE. Today, Kia Stevens plays Welfare Queen on Netflix’s popular series GLOW, making her the kind of crossover success that WWE desires. But still, she has not made a return to the company.

13. Rob Van Dam (2009)

Rob Van Dam was arguably one of WWE’s most popular superstars throughout his initial run with the company, which ended in 2007.

Advertisement

So when he turned up in the 2009 Royal Rumble, it was a wonderful surprise for fans. RVD didn’t eliminate anyone during his 15-minute run in the match, but seeing him back in WWE for that one night was reward enough and would foreshadow a fulltime return four years later for Mr. Monday Night.

Since then, RVD has been a perennial rumored return for the Rumble, which no doubt includes this year’s edition.

12. Tye Dillinger (2017)

Speaking of NXT wrestlers getting notable spots in the Royal Rumble, look no further than Tye Dillinger.

Advertisement

His WWE career since this debut has been a disappointment to say the least, but the company at least paid off The Perfect 10’s popularity by having him debut at #10 in the 2017 Rumble, giving fans the opportunity to explode and chant “10!” along with Tye.

Even if his WWE career were to end tomorrow, he’d always have one of the most memorable WWE debuts in recent memory.

11. Adam Cole & Andrade Almas (2018)

We’re going to group the two most recent NXT surprises, as they both took place in the same Royal Rumble last year, and because it’s tough to distinguish between them.

Advertisement

Adam Cole and Andrade “Cien” Almas turned up the night after NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia, where Almas defended his NXT Championship and Cole lost a punishing bout against Aleister Black. Both men got huge reactions from the Philly faithful and put in good showings, which is what you’d hope for from these two stars.

Almas would get called up to the main roster later that year, while Cole’s Undisputed Era continues to play a prominent role in NXT.

10. Chris Jericho (2013)

This is an interesting entry as we start moving into some of the bigger returns and debuts on the list.

Advertisement

In 2013, Chris Jericho was moving into a phase of his career where he would appear for a period of time, disappear, then reemerge for another run. In this case, Jericho has been gone since August 2012, returning unannounced at the 2013 Royal Rumble as the #2 entrant, resuming a feud with Dolph Ziggler, who was #1.

The pop from the crowd was pretty damn loud, and Y2J would last until the final six. He would go on to lose to Fandango at WrestleMania 29 that year, but his return and the crowd reaction showed that there still was plenty of interest in Jericho, and we would be treated to better Y2J moments in future years.

9. Mick Foley (2004)

In terms of a surprise return, this was quite a clever one.

Advertisement

Randy Orton was on a tear in the 2004 Royal Rumble, as the Legend Killer had eliminated five men from the #2 position and was looking like a possible winner as the match moved into its final third of entrants.

Cut to the back and we saw Test laid out and 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, Raw’s sheriff, yelling at an unseen wrestler for attacking him. Austin ordered the mysterious wrestler to take Test’s spot, which led to Mick Foley coming out at #21. Orton immediately lost it.

Foley quickly eliminated himself and Orton, which would then set up the awesome 3-on-2 tag match pitting Evolution against the Rock ‘n’ Sock Connection. Just a superb display of how to do a surprise entry that served a greater purpose.

8. Sami Zayn (2016)

And speaking over surprise entries that set up something else…

Advertisement

The rivalry between Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens was well-documented in NXT, with Owens attacking Zayn moments after his NXT Championship win in December 2014. Sami would land on the shelf after dropping the title to Owens in early 2015, with the injury attributed to KO.

That set up Zayn to return at the 2016 Royal Rumble, storming the ring and eliminating Owens, which kicked off a recurring main roster feud between the two that lasted well over a year before Zayn relented and partnered with Owens.

But that return (technically, Sami’s WWE debut was in May 2015 against John Cena) provided fans an incredible visual of the two longtime friends/enemies throwing down in the middle of the ring.

7. Bubba Ray Dudley (2015)

It’s a shame in many ways that the 2015 Royal Rumble is remembered for all the wrong reasons, because it got started with a bang.

Advertisement

Entering at #3 in a Rumble originating from Philadelphia was the ECW original and former WWE superstar Bubba Ray Dudley. Bubba had last been seen in WWE a decade earlier, and his departure was not an amicable one.

Dudley’s return naturally resulted in a huge reaction from the Philly faithful, and he quickly teamed up with R-Truth, who assumed the D-Von role, as they hit a 3D on The Miz and eliminated him.

His night would end shortly thereafter, with no real D-Von in sight, but the Rumble appearance would serve as a preview for the Dudley Boys’ return later that year.

6. Booker T (2011)

As mentioned earlier, filling out the oversized 2011 Royal Rumble required some former superstars making their first appearances in some time.

Advertisement

In this case, the New Nexus was rolling along at the midpoint of the Rumble, looking invincible, and fans were eagerly awaiting someone who would stop them. Cue the, “Can you dig it, sucka?” theme music.

As you can imagine fans (and a childlike Matt Striker) lost their minds as the former 5-time (5-time, 5-time, 5-time, 5-time) WCW and WWE Champion made his way out to enter the Rumble. Booker hung in there for a while, but eventually was tossed. In his case, Booker’s appearance was not a one-off, but a full return to the company that continues to today in some capacity.

5. Women’s Rumble (2018)

During the past several years, WWE has been all about making history when it comes to women’s wrestling. And indeed, they have been doing just that, breaking new ground every few months with their female superstars doing something they’ve never done before.

Advertisement

And while a few women had entered a Royal Rumble match before, we had never seen an all-women’s Rumble – until last year. The moment a 30-woman Rumble was announced, you knew WWE would have to dig up several stars from the past to fill out its ranks. There simply weren’t enough women on the main rosters, and you couldn’t envision them burning nearly one-third of the slots on NXT superstars.

And so, we got a smattering of returning women showing up for one-off appearances, making the women’s Rumble a true must-see event. Among the women who turned up were Torrie Wilson, Molly Holly, Ivory, Kelly Kelly, Jacqueline, Vickie Guerrero, Brie Bella and Beth Phoenix. Of course, the godmothers of women’s wrestling (according to WWE) Lita and Trish Stratus competed as well.

Perhaps most interestingly, it was a surprise entrant, Michelle McCool, who would go on to set the record for most eliminations – five – despite not having competed in WWE for nearly seven years.

4. Rey Mysterio (2018)

Now we’re getting into some of the really good ones, with one of the best coming just last year.

Advertisement

The best returns and debuts are ones that are big surprises to most if not all of the audience. No one is expecting a person to show up on WWE TV suddenly. In this case, we got just that at the coveted #27 slot, when Rey Mysterio marked his return to WWE to a huge ovation from the crowd.

Mysterio is almost universally loved, so fans jumped for joy at his return. Perfectly, he was aligned briefly with John Cena and Randy Orton as the old guard facing off against the young guns Roman Reigns, Finn Bálor and eventual winner Shinsuke Nakamura.

As we all now know, Rey would show up again at Greatest Royal Rumble and then return fulltime to WWE at SmackDown 1000.

3. Edge (2010)

“Holy sh--!”

Advertisement

For once, Matt Striker hit the nail on the head when #29 came out during the 2010 Royal Rumble. Edge had been out of action for six months with a torn Achilles tendon and was rumored to be laid up for up to a year. During that time, former tag team partner Chris Jericho had laid into Edge for his injury, which set the stage for the Rumble.

Jericho had entered at #28 and was looking strong, only for Edge to blow the roof off the place and win the entire Rumble. He would go on to lose to Jericho (who won the World Heavyweight Championship the following month), but worse, one year later, Edge’s wrestling career would be over.

But at least we got this classic moment.

2. John Cena (2008)

This is probably the gold standard for Royal Rumble returns.

Advertisement

In October 2007, John Cena suffered a torn pec, which was likely to sideline him through WrestleMania XXIV and maybe even later. It also ended the longest world title reign in WWE in nearly 20 years.

But this is where Super Cena earned his nickname.

As the 2008 Rumble wound down, it looked like Triple H was going to emerge victorious, when #30 turned up – Cena. Months ahead of schedule. It was such a shock that the even cynical Madison Square Garden fans cheered for Cena’s return, amplifying the moment.

Cena would go on to win the Rumble, but could not win the title despite cashing in his shot the following month and then being inserted into the title picture at 'Mania. But man, oh man, what a return.

1. AJ Styles (2016)

If you’re going to make your mark in a debut, what better way than to show up out of the blue to face off against one of the most polarizing wrestlers on the WWE roster?

Advertisement

The hottest free agent in wrestling, AJ Styles, made his WWE debut at the 2016 Royal Rumble, coming out at #3 to confront Roman Reigns. The reaction from the crowd was deafening as they realized who it was and what that potentially meant.

All Styles would go on to do during the next three years was become one of the biggest stars in the company and a multi-time world champion. And his appearance that night really set the stage, as though fans realized the new face that runs the place had arrived.

Advertisement