2017 WWE Superstar Shake-Up Ranked - From Worst To Best

Seven months on from the Superstar Shake-Up, who are the winners and losers?

By John Bills /

WWE

Immediately following WrestleMania 33, Vince McMahon announced that he was going to ‘shake things up’ in WWE. The Chairman of the Board was alluding to another draft, giving Kurt Angle and Daniel Bryan the opportunity to get down to brass tacks and engage in a little bit of wheeling and dealing. The two former world champions had a week to negotiate, and on 10 ans 11 April the moves were made.

Advertisement

A total of 21 trades (two of which involved announcers) happened over two nights in April, as champions both former and current moved from RAW to SmackDown Live and vice versa. Many of the trades made sense at the time, with a number of superstars seriously in need of some fresh surroundings. Other deals made little sense, or simply involved irrelevant performers making irrelevant moves.

Just over six months have passed since the shake-up, and the time has come to take stock of the moves made back in April. Who has been a success? Has anyone stalled? Did RAW get the better of the shake-up, or was it another victory for Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon?

Advertisement

19. The Shining Stars

WWE.com

If this were a Sporcle quiz naming the performers who moved brand back in April, the chances are that Primo and Epico Colón would be the last two named. Going one further, most fans probably couldn’t guess which brand they were on in the first place. The Shining Stars are at the very bottom of the WWE tag team totem pole these days.

Advertisement

The Colóns’ life on the blue brand got off to a decent start, when they picked up a win over former SmackDown Tag Team Champions American Alpha. This was followed by a whole lot of nothing, before Primo picked up a serious knee injury in June. The former matadors haven’t been seen since.

Despite being two undeniably talented professional wrestlers, it is hard to imagine a world in which Primo and Epico Colón are important cogs in the WWE machine. Whether The Colóns return to SmackDown Live is somewhat irrelevant at this point.

Advertisement

18. Curt Hawkins

WWE.com

Poor Curt Hawkins. No wrestler in the history of WWE has ever gotten over with a losing streak gimmick, and that is all the former Edgehead has at this point. It is even more distressing when your losing streak begins to get acknowledged on television, only for that to be dropped as well.

Advertisement

Curt Hawkins’ plight since moving to RAW is made even more apparent by the success of the man who went in the other direction. When Hawkins moved to RAW, the jobber who made the move to the blue brand was none other than the 'Modern Day Maharaja' himself, Jinder Mahal. Within a month of jumping to Tuesday nights, Jinder was WWE Champion. Curt Hawkins is still yet to win a match.

Every wrestling promotion needs enhancement talent, and that is exactly the role that Curt Hawkins currently plays. The problem is that it is difficult to see who he has enhanced during his six months on RAW. Curt is yet to win a match on RAW - he’s yet to even come close.

Advertisement

17. Bray Wyatt

WWE.com

Oh Bray. Poor, poor Bray. In a parallel world, Bray Wyatt is a multi-time champion in WWE, an anti-authority babyface running roughshod over the company and delivering the best promos in professional wrestling. The men he has defeated have all been changed in some way or another, and 'The Eater of Worlds' is a genuine main event performer in every sense of the world.

Advertisement

In this world, Bray Wyatt wrestled in a haunted house and had a nothing rivalry with Seth Rollins over the summer, before embarking on what may be WWE’s worst feud of 2017. The Wyatt/Finn Bálor story was supposed to be a tale of two mind games masters - it almost ended with Bray in drag fighting a Goosebumps-pumpkin version of Bálor.

Bray was saved the ignominy of wrestling in a burlap sack by the mumps. I wouldn’t wish that miserable virus on anyone, but it may well end up being the most silver of linings for Wyatt. No individual in WWE has been damaged more in 2017 than Bray Wyatt - he needs to find the hard reset button, and fast.

Advertisement

16. Heath Slater And Rhyno

WWE.com

If nothing else, Heath Slater found a bittersweet reason to celebrate in 2017. When Darren Young was released at the beginning of November, the 'One-Man Band' found himself standing tall as the only member of Nexus to still be active inside a WWE ring. When you get as little TV time as Heath Slater, even the smallest victories must be accepted.

Advertisement

Heath Slater and Rhyno have been more anonymous than most since the Superstar Shake-Up. The duo have wrestled just seven tag matches since the move, one of which was the utterly dreadful All Hallows Eve Trick or Street Fight against Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows on Halloween. Just four of those bouts have been two-on-two matches, with an average bell-to-bell time of just two minutes and 48 seconds.

Beauty and the Man-Beast’s move to RAW seems like one of the more pointless switches of the entire Superstar Shake-Up. Much like Hawkins, the duo are enhancement talent these days, but what good is enhancement talent if it isn’t given the chance to enhance anyone?

Advertisement

15. Lana

WWE.com

Has WWE completely given up on Lana as an in-ring competitor? It appears so. If not, they really should think about doing so. The days of taking models and turning them into professional wrestlers seem to be over, and Lana is something of a throwback to those days. Rusev’s former manager isn’t going to be a great worker, and that is absolutely fine.

Advertisement

What she is however, is a fantastic presence on WWE TV. Lana moved over to SmackDown Live as part of the Superstar Shake-Up, and she received a number of vignettes ahead of her debut - a SmackDown Women’s Championship match against Naomi. She wasn’t able to win the title in her debut, and there has been a whole lot of nothing ever since.

Lana’s 2017 has been disappointing, but that isn’t to say that all is lost. The well-publicised backstage issues seem to have come to an end, and WWE clearly wants to use her in a focused role. If Daniel Bryan leaves his position as SmackDown Live General Manager, the Ravishing Russian could be an outside bet to replace him.

Advertisement

14. Tamina

WWE.com

At some point in the future, WWE is simply going to have to give up on Tamina Snuka. The daughter of WWE Hall of Famer (and suspected murderer) ‘Superfly’ Jimmy Snuka, Tamina is up there with Wes Brisco and David Flair when it comes to distance between the apple and the tree. Superfly was a wildly charismatic man who had a genuine connection with the fans - his daughter could not be more different.

Advertisement

It isn’t really fair to compare Tamina and Jimmy Snuka, but the picture doesn’t get any better for the former when compared with contemporaries. Alexa Bliss, Carmella, and Nia Jax have all improved tremendously over the last 18 months. Tamina has barely improved in her seven and a half years on the roster.

Tamina was the only un-drafted performer to feature in the 2017 Superstar Shake-Up. Injury prevented her from making a splash during the first nine months of the brand split era, and her general lack of improvement has hindered her ever since.

Advertisement

13. Apollo Crews

WWE.com

Apollo Crews was the first individual to move as part of the 2017 Superstar Shake-Up, jumping to RAW after an uninspiring nine months on SmackDown Live. Crews has been tied to Titus O’Neill in the six months since, first as an unconvinced bystander and then a fully fledged member of Titus Worldwide.

Advertisement

The Titus Worldwide stuff has given Apollo a story of sorts, but he is still clearly little more than a bit-part player on RAW. Not everyone can be a main event performer of course, but the current position of someone as obviously gifted as Apollo Crews is a little hard to stomach.

Going into 2017, many observers said that Apollo Crews had it all with the exception of charisma. ‘Give him a manager’ they cried, ‘give him a manager and he will thrive!’ Apollo got a manager and has stayed around the same level. Hopefully the potential arrival of Ricochet will light a fire under Crews, and 2018 will be his breakout year.

Advertisement

12. Sin Cara

WWE.com

Sin Cara has been thrust back into the spotlight recently with a truly out-of-nowhere feud with Baron Corbin, but even the most enthusiastic lucha fan will guess that the story finishes with an End of Days and a W for 'The Lone Wolf'. Sin Cara is filling a space for the time being.

Advertisement

When the Corbin feud is over, what will become of Sin Cara? The masked man has done very little since moving to SmackDown in April, and one must assume that ‘very little’ is what the WWE creative team currently has penned in for his future. The man under the mask is an underrated performer, but the character has run its course.

In 10 years time, the Sin Cara experiment will be looked back on as one of the biggest flops in modern WWE history. This isn’t the fault of Hunico of course - the damage was done before he donned the mask back in December 2013. At this point, it really doesn’t matter what brand Sin Cara is on.

Advertisement

11. Mickie James

WWE.com

Mickie James was thrust into a RAW Women’s Championship match against Alexa Bliss at WWE TLC, but nobody believed she had a chance of winning the belt. Mickie had barely been booked since making the move to the flagship show in April, wrestling just six matches on Monday nights before her pay-per-view title challenge.

Advertisement

Mickie lost almost all of them as well, her sole wins coming against Emma in August and a DQ victory over Nia Jax three weeks before TLC. Even Emma, who’s sole character trait in 2017 was ‘I don’t get booked on TV’, had more matches on RAW than the six-time champion.

Mickie James is a fantastic performer to have around the division, and she will undoubtedly prove her worth on the flagship show over the coming months. It is difficult to expect more from someone who is so clearly positioned as past their prime, however untrue that may be.

Advertisement

10. Charlotte Flair

WWE.com

Has Charlotte Flair had a good year? She may well be on the verge of capping it off with a SmackDown Women’s Championship win, but the former four-time RAW Women’s Champ has been more of a bystander on the blue brand since making the switch in April.

Advertisement

This could be for the best in the long run. The RAW women’s division ultimately became stale when the conveyor belt of Charlotte and Sasha moved into overdrive, and Flair’s lack of presence in the title picture since moving to SmackDown has allowed others to shine. As a result, SmackDown’s female division looks a lot stronger than that of the flagship show.

You can’t keep Charlotte out of the spotlight for long however, and a SmackDown Women’s Championship match is beckoning. Will Charlotte win that title and go on to face Alexa Bliss at Survivor Series? 'The Nature Girl' has had a good year by virtue of having a quiet year - that is a rare occurrence in wrestling.

Advertisement

9. Rusev

WWE.com

How to judge Rusev? On the one hand, 'The Bulgarian Brute' is up there with Luke Harper in terms of under-utilised superstars. The man from Plovdiv has the size, the talent, the ability, and the charisma to be an absolute megastar, yet WWE seems reluctant on using him in any way other than as a gatekeeper heel.

Advertisement

If you accept that Rusev’s current position is also his ceiling, then he has been a fine acquisition for SmackDown live. His feud with Randy Orton wasn’t an all-time classic, but it allowed Rusev to form a partnership with Aiden English that gives the 'Drama King' a chance to grow. Rusev is making those around him better.

The prevailing feeling is that he should be in a more prominent position though. Jinder Mahal’s WWE Championship run was boring at best, and it is easy to say that the same results (or even better ones) would have been achieved with Rusev as champion. With that in mind, its a thumbs up thumbs down sort of spot for the former United States Champion.

Advertisement

8. Kalisto

WWE.com

Sin Cara’s former tag team partner has had a middling time on RAW since the draft. The 'King of Flight' picked up a shock win over Braun Strowman, although that only led to Kalisto being utterly annihilated by the 'Monster Among Men'. After recovering from hip and cervical trauma, Kalisto had a brief beef with Apollo Crews, before retreating back into obscurity.

Advertisement

Kalisto then moved into the cruiserweight division, even going so far as defeating Enzo Amore for the championship. The feeling is that the horse had long bolted however, and the Lucha Dragon’s arrival on 205 Live was about 14 months too late.

After a 2016 that promised much, 2017 has been a frustrating year for the former United States Champion. Kalisto looks void of confidence on RAW these days - one can only hope that he manages to regain some of it in the new year. Let the man go out and have thrilling matches with the other performers in the cruiserweight division and all will be fine.

Advertisement

7. Dean Ambrose

WWE.com

Is Dean Ambrose in a better position now than he was in 12 months ago? It is difficult to argue in favour of that. Ambrose was initially the big winner of the brand split - he went from being a guy struggling to establish himself as a main event man to a genuine champion. The first few months of post-draft SmackDown were marked by Dean Ambrose becoming a major, major player.

Advertisement

One year later, The Lunatic Fringe is back in The Shield. Times have changed in that faction however. The first time around, Ambrose was the big singles star in waiting. In 2017, Ambrose comes across as the gooseberry in a three-man team.

The move to RAW was far from catastrophic for Ambrose, but it did him no favours whatsoever. He went from being a top babyface to another guy in the packed upper-midcard. Sure, he was saved the indignity of losing to Jinder Mahal, but the good work of those first few brand split months went to the dogs in April 2017.

Advertisement

6. Sami Zayn

WWE.com

Where Kevin Owens goes, Sami Zayn invariably follows. Or maybe that should be where Zayn goes, Owens follows, but the point remains the same. The men formerly known as Kevin Steen and El Generico are as inseparable as inseparable gets. Fans rolled their eyes when they were drafted to RAW together, and those same eyes went a little further back when Zayn came out to interrupt Owens back on 11 April.

Advertisement

Oh how wrong we were. Zayn did little more than tread water for the first few months of his tenure on SmackDown, picking up losses against Mike Kanellis (remember him?), Jinder Mahal, and Aiden English along the way. It seemed for all the world as though Zayn’s immense talent was being wasted, until the man took it upon himself to pull Owens out of the way of a falling Shane McMahon.

It is no exaggeration to say that Sami Zayn has been a total revelation as a heel. For months it looked like the move to SmackDown was a major mistake for Zayn, but now it looks like it could very well have been career salvation.

Advertisement

5. The Miz

WWE.com

It was touch and go for a while, but The Miz has well and truly found his place in WWE. Almost seven years have passed since his WrestleMania main event and WWE Championship reign, and the A-Lister has never felt closer to another shot at the top of the card. For now though, The Miz is destined to be Intercontinental Champion.

Advertisement

Miz’s run on RAW wasn’t helped initially by the immediate arrival of Dean Ambrose, and the two continued their feud which may well have started back in Rio de Janeiro in 1979. The 'Most-Must See Superstar In WWE' is the longest-reigning champion in the company at this point, and that must count for something.

The Miz is a superstar who seems at home on the flagship show. He may never main event another WrestleMania, but the consistent quality of his promos and his company-friendly style will stand him in good stead for a long while yet. The Miz is going to be a marketable WWE performer for as long as he wants to be.

Advertisement

4. Kevin Owens

WWE.com

What a WWE career Kevin Owens has had to date. The French-Canadian burst onto the scene in 2014 and has already won a plethora of championships, not to mention putting together a two-match Hell in a Cell winning streak and a feud of the year program with Chris Jericho.

Advertisement

Owens was the first man to make the move from RAW to SmackDown on-screen (Jinder was announced via social media), and he has proven to be a top star for the blue brand ever since. Owens is the perfect main event heel for SmackDown Live - he can dominate the top of the card without having to vie for attention with the company favourites.

KO has been feuding with Shane McMahon for a few months now, and also has his best friend Sami Zayn by his side. Owens is all set to become SmackDown’s most important star, European tour shenanigans be damned. Would KO be featured at the top of the table if he was still on RAW? I’m not sure.

Advertisement

3. Jinder Mahal

WWE.com

What a year it has been for Jinder Mahal. Jinder was the first superstar to officially move from red to blue, in what many believed was a straight jobber swap with Curt Hawkins. In his first appearance on the show, Jinder was embarrassed by American Football star Rob Gronkowski and defeated by Mojo Rawley. Nothing had changed for the soon-to-be 'Modern Day Maharaja'.

Advertisement

Little did we know then, but Jinder Mahal was about to embark on a six-month reign as WWE Champion. Jinder held the title for 170 days, meaning he was WWE Champion for more days than Edge, Daniel Bryan, Mick Foley, and other arguably more esteemed colleagues. It is still difficult to truly fathom.

Whether you like him or loathe him (nobody seems to love him), Jinder Mahal’s career has been revolutionised by his move to the blue brand. His WWE Championship wasn’t exactly the most interesting, but Mahal is now established as a midcard heel at the very least. The 'Modern Day Maharaja' is a modern day success story.

Advertisement

2. The New Day

WWE

Has there been a better in-ring feud in WWE all year than that between The Usos and The New Day? The two teams put on a list of classic tag team matches, bouts that have single-handedly kept the blue brand’s tandem division alive throughout 2017. The New Day brought some much needed star power to SmackDown’s tag division with their move in April.

Advertisement

Kofi Kingston, Xavier Woods, and Big E. have also been at the forefront of SmackDown’s attacks on RAW, so the trio must be viewed as an integral part of the Tuesday night puzzle going forward. The New Day are unique - they are a tag team trio that seem to transcend their own division in terms of popularity.

The New Day’s move to SmackDown Live has been an objective success for all involved, and will continue to be so for as long as both sides want it to be. Three years into their run, there is plenty left in the Power of Positivity tank for now.

Advertisement

1. Alexa Bliss

WWE.com

When Alexa Bliss was managing Blake and Murphy on NXT, the odds on her becoming a multi-time champion within a year of arriving on the main roster would have been obscenely long. The 'Wicked Witch of WWE' has overachieved dramatically since the brand split, and is the only women to win both the RAW and SmackDown Women’s Championships on more than one occasion.

Advertisement

There is more to it than that as well. Bliss has been booked extremely strong on the main roster. It can be argued that no one on RAW or SmackDown has been protected as comprehensively as the current RAW Women’s Champion.

Bliss swiftly defeated Bayley for that title before vanquishing The Hugger again, doing irreparable damage to Bayley in the process. Alexa briefly lost her title to Sasha Banks, before calling out The Boss’s inability to defend the championship - proving herself right in the process. She then told Mickie James that she was over the hill, defeating James twice to ram that point home.

Advertisement

Alexa Bliss is the most dominant female performer on the main roster right now. In 2015, that seemed entirely improbable. No performer has enjoyed as much success as Bliss since the Superstar Shake-Up.