3 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE NXT (Jan 25)
A quietly good omen for Saturday.
TakeOver: San Antonio is probably the least anticipated NXT special in aeons - but this week’s episode, the best Royal Rumble weekend go-home of the week, demonstrated that the burning fire has not quite faded to its last embers.
RAW did a sterling job of creating hype for the 30 man main event - even if the three-legend squadron of Goldberg, Brock Lesnar and The Undertaker faced off in parallel with the member berries marketing campaign, hinting towards more myopic part-timer short termism. Still, that segment was powerful. All but the most jaded fans could not have enjoyed it for what it was.
SmackDown drained the "Cena isn't an indy guy but damn proud of it" well in the sort of angle which has grown tiresome. The show also all but confirmed that a member of the RAW roster is set to win the Rumble. Outside of confirming Mojo Rawley's participation - and thank God for that, I was getting worried there - hype for the Rumble match itself was curiously absent. 205 Live, meanwhile, built anticipation for the Rumble undercard Cruiserweight Title match by presenting a lengthy main event, between Neville and Cedric Alexander, which all but telegraphed the emotional beats and structure we can expect on Sunday.
NXT this week channeled the spirit of its glory days and showed the main roster how to build intrigue without giving too much away...
Downs...
2. No Way Is Jose Remotely Entertaining
As promised last week - "promised" is a cruel word, in this context - No Way Jose squared off against Kona Reeves to settle their dispute.
It was, as you might expect, the forgettable and mediocre comedy match with which Jose has become synonymous. Inoffensive for the most part, it did raise the hackles when Jose again positioned himself as the dumbest wrestler on the planet. He bought Reeves' feigned olive branch and danced with him before eating the obvious elbow to the face. Traditional babyfaces barely work in the current landscape. A stupid babyface stands no chance. We're being given zero reasons to care about No Way Jose. His act is received with detached mirth by the all-too-ironic NXT crowd - but that they approved of Bull Dempsey just underlines that they are no reliable barometer of an act's popularity.
Even more dispiritingly, Jose's victory celebrations were interrupted by the toneless dirge that is Elias Samson's singing. That is also an accurate description of his entire act.
NXT, at its best, embodies the future of its marketing slogan - but this stand off, between a dancing dolt and a drifter troubadour, captured the zeitgeist about as well as Thurman 'Sparky' Plugg and Phantasio did in the dark days of 1995.
1. Rushed Hype
The TakeOver specials hold an advantage over their main roster counterparts because the longer duration between them creates scope for more storied and subtle builds. That the match between Roderick Strong and Andrade "Cien" Almas has been thrown together with almost tangible desperation calibrates the brand's wider downfall.
Their backstage confrontation was unassuming in the extreme. Almas trotted out some Spanish before the inevitable interruption. "If you wanna kick me in the face," said Strong. "How about you kick me in the face right now?" Those were words were uttered by a Random Babyface Spiel Generator. Anybody at any time could have spoken them. They shed no light on Strong's character because he barely has one.
Both men, in fairness, are undergoing a period of transition. Strong is almost as new to the face role as Cien is to his - but the rushed hype job did little to create intrigue for what promises to be a better match than it looks on paper.
Almas is excelling in the heel role - between the ropes, at least - but cutting blistering promos in a foreign language just isn't an effective tactic of generating heat. It didn't work for Alberto Del Rio. Geopolitics are passé in wrestling, with Rusev the rule-proving exception.
Ups...
3. Better Showcase Matches
The opening match, between Ember Moon and Liv Morgan, started out badly. In a transparent attempt to position the two women on an even keel, they exchanged a very awkward-looking rolling pin sequence, which fell apart when they clumsily fell into the ropes. Not inconspicuously, it picked up some momentum when Ember Moon, the far superior talent, assumed the advantage.
It's important to bear context in mind when watching NXT. Morgan has been wrestling for all of two years. It would be unfair to expect anything beyond minor advancement, but unlike Riddick Moss, she is showing signs of improvement. The camera work was choice here; as Ember Moon ensnared Morgan in a crossface, it shot the action from a low angle, drifting across the apron, creating an illusion of expanse in which Morgan looked helpless. For all its faults, WWE is absolutely peerless in the production department. Ember Moon looked monstrous when she reversed Morgan's guillotine by simply throwing her over the top rope like a sack of sh*t.
Less effective was Eric Young's squash win over Chris Atkins, which might as well have taken place in a library. Young barely generated a reaction in what was a muted performance, but his mimicry of Tye Dillinger's "Ten!" chants at least played into a sequential story.
Young's gear was brilliant too, which isn't as superficial a comment as it may seem. Wardrobe is critical in establishing the tone of an act- just imagine if Steve Austin wore bright blue. Both of Young's knee pads looked like they belonged to entirely different wrestlers, hinting at the fractured psyche within.
2. Awesome Video Packages
Bobby Roode, Shinsuke Nakamura, DIY and the Authors of Pain did not make an appearance on last night's episode, but their services weren't required. NXT's excellent production department compensated for the inauspicious hype by producing two cracking video packages.
The tape hyping the tag Team Title match was marginally the better of the two. The Authors of Pain often struggle, even in short matches, because they are unable to engage crowds outside of their basic power move repertoire - but re-contextualised in a devastating highlights video package, in which Paul Ellering was astutely cast as a sermon-spouting godly leader, they looked supernaturally devastating. Unstoppable. And, contrasted beautifully with DIY's uplifting and arduous journey, ominous.
If Johnny Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa can make them look even half as good as they did here, they might overtake The Revival as the best tag team on the planet.
There was one incredible touch in the NXT Title bout preview; as the orchestra began to swell, building up to Roode's 'Glorious Domination' theme, it was brought to an abrupt halt when footage was played of Nakamura sticking his hand in Roode's face. It planted the idea, with some subtlety, that Nakamura is set to similarly quell Roode's ascendancy on Saturday, making the prospect all the more enticing.
1. A Killer Main Event Segment
This was the single greatest segment NXT has produced in months; it made use of all four women brilliantly, hinted at but did not telegraph the dynamics of Saturday's Women's Title match, and positioned Nikki Cross, in particular, as the most believable threat to Asuka's crown.
For once, the teeth-grinding obnoxiousness of Billie Kay and Peyton Royce was more effective than alienating, given that they are close enough to having their faces kicked in. An act as grating as theirs cannot go too long without receiving their comeuppance because it is much too reliant on cheap shortcuts.
Nikki Cross entered the fray after some token antipodean screeching, shortly followed by Asuka, who chased Peyton and Royce out of the ring. She then turned her attentions to Cross in a crazed, tense standoff. Foreshadowing the only realistic tactic at their disposal, Royce and Kay then set about Asuka and Cross before the two lunatics formed an uneasy alliance. A flank of security guards separated their teased confrontation, but their lunacy could not be contained. In a raucous and somehow believable scene, Asuka and Cross, in a testament to their unhinged credibility, kicked their faces off. Cross then floored everybody - Asuka, security guards, the crowd - by diving off the top rope to the outside.
Royce and Kay, to their credit, sold the chaotic scene at the top of the entrance ramp with perfectly-judged horror. You could see the blood draining from their faces even underneath the fake tan.
The NXT Women's division was dead, supposedly. The NXT thinktank clearly has enough armour left to withstand the threat faced by the departure of the Four Horsewomen.