4 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (April 5 - Results & Review)
AEW Rampage improves on last week's awful effort, but Tony Khan still has a HUGE problem.
Let's be upfront and honest about one thing straight away: AEW programming has no chance up against the might of WWE's WrestleMania 40 this weekend. Shows like Rampage and Saturday night's Collision will perhaps draw record-low ratings, and staunch defenders of the All Elite cause will point to 'Mania as an excuse.
That's valid, but it doesn't explain why there's such a shocking lack of oomph to AEW's product generally. Look, it depends what kind of fan you are. Tuning in for some technically sound matches/flashy spots and nothing else? Tony has you covered. However, if you're looking for properly-fleshed out characters and carefully-constructed stories then you might want to look elsewhere.
Rampage was indicative of Khan's struggles right now. All four matches presented on the show get an 'Up' here, so you'd be forgiven for wondering why this intro is laced with negativity. Well, simply put, it's because All Elite Wrestling should be better than it is in April 2024.
It is possible to admire in-ring work and be concerned about where the company is going creatively at the same time.
Here's all the good and bad from Friday's latest!
Downs...
2. Nobody Cares Anymore, Guys!
There's nothing to admire here though.
Zak Knight, Saraya and Harley Cameron gave a big sales pitch for Zak vs. Angelo Parker next week, but the ship sailed on this feud long ago. It's proof that AEW does have stories, and yet...that doesn't matter much when they're as dreadful as this one has been. Does anyone actually give a sh*t about this drama anymore?
It might actually be the worst plot going in pro wrestling right now, to be honest. Knight and Parker are going to have to be Steamboat and Savage if they want to get fans back onside after some of the tripe Tony Khan has made them sit through with these promos and other assorted backstage skits.
No amount of sexual innuendos from Saraya, talk about Harley's breasts or Zak mean-mugging for the camera will get the job done. Then, there's Ruby 'I Can't Make My Mind Up' Soho. Genuinely one of the most painful excuses for a rivalry going, guys.
1. Tony Khan’s Big Problem Continues
Again, AEW does have feuds that technically count as stories, but the narrative weight behind most of them is seriously lacking. Tony Khan runs a "dream match" factory. Truthfully, even that's up for debate depending on tastes. Ratings/interest won't grow until Tony stop just booking matches he personally wants to see and actually develops characters/stories properly.
Sorry.
A lot of All Elite's matches have value bell-to-bell, but that's where the party stops. Many feel like one-offs that won't matter 10 minutes after they've concluded, and that's a real problem. Case in point: Rampage's main event. Whilst it was a fun watch in the moment, it's something you'll forget in a hurry anyway.
Critics say Khan books for a niche hardcore wrestling audience. He does. It's fine to do that, but it isn't working as a growth tool for AEW. The bloom came off the rose ages ago, and no number of 'indy with great production' matches can change that.
Story and emotional investment in characters can.
Ups...
4. Really Good Opener
Thankfully, Khan has a killer roster to fall back on.
The boss knows he can slap pretty much any combo of names on a sheet of paper and it'll make for a fine match. On Friday, the opener between Christopher Daniels and Malakai Black was so slick and well-worked - it was a bout between two pros who really know their craft and visibly enjoy working.
It's also always a treat to see Daniels wrestle these days, because the dude's defo in the twilight years of a celebrated in-ring career. Black met his vigour halfway, and was typically giving throughout. As a result, it became clear that Malakai had to scratch, bite and claw to earn his win here. That's a good thing.
Sure, it may sound contradictory to blast AEW's formatting then praise all of the matches on Rampage, but the men and women on All Elite's roster take the praise for that. Now, can you imagine if their talent was matched by storytelling know-how and character development?
3. An Enjoyable Underdog Challenge
London Lightning can be proud of his performance this week.
He entered the best kind of spirited underdog showing, and Roddy (like Malakai against the admittedly higher-profile Daniels) was incredibly giving whilst playing the cocky heel. Yes, the problem with AEW is that this strong showing probably won't lead to anything for Lightning, but he can cherish the match regardless.
There's a cool contrast between Roderick as International Champ and ex-titleholder Orange Cassidy too. Tony Schiavone did a great job of putting that across on commentary during Strong vs. London, and even pointed out that Roddy needs his Undisputed Kingdom buddies to bail him out against opponents you'd expect him to defeat handily.
Credit to the live crowd for hanging with what could've been a lowkey effort as well. They bought into the cheap heat of Lightning's home town story, and the fans played along with Strong mocking them. Fingers crossed Roderick's story leads to something long-term.
2. Another Fun One
AEW gave Serena Deeb and Trish Adora plenty of time to work with, and that meant Deeb could lace the match with a clear story which was easy to follow. Her experience edge was the glue holding this bout together, but kudos to Adora for willingly forgoing some of her usual fire so that tale could be told.
Workers who adapt their style to suit the actual match are the best.
This one was zippy and competitive, and the announcers talked up All Elite's on/off rankings system plenty. You can't ask for much more than that, especially when Serena's experience means she'd be a fine success story in the women's division. It looks like the company fancies programming her vs. Toni Storm eventually.
Trish will survive a loss like this. Defeats are fine if wrestlers get to show out mid-match first - Adora wasn't squashed, or anything. Of course, it would be nice if Tony Khan fleshed out her character a little more beyond, 'She's eh...with The Infantry!'.
1. A Multi-Man With Selling!
OK, so it's uncommon for AEW's multi-man matches to have this much selling in them. Normally, wrestlers ignore selling in favour of bouncing around like invincible characters in a video game, but not here. Action Andretti sold his knee pretty well during the main event four way, and that should be encouraged.
See?! Selling counts.
Andretti tried to keep leaning on his high-flying style whilst injured, and that ultimately cost him. Plus, Daniel Garcia looked like a real opportunist for spotting Action's bad wheel and exploiting it for the victory. His win got a respectable pop from the live crowd too. People really dig Danny.
Being brutally honest, things got even better once Bryan Keith and Komander were eliminated. That's not meant as damning criticism of either man; there was just more juice in Andretti vs. Garcia one-on-one, especially once Action's selling became the bout's most prominent plot point.
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more like this, check out WWE WrestleMania 40: 20 Things That Must Happen and WWE WrestleMania 40: 20 Nightmares That Could Come True!