4 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite (December 13 - Results & Review)
AEW hit Texas with The Good, The Bad & The Ugly of everything the promotion has to offer in 2023.
There's been lots of discussion lately about the need within AEW to restore and/or revive "the feeling".
MJF himself tweeted about it, knowing exactly where much of the conversation was at because he's had much of the criticism pointed directly at him in his position as Champion and somebody with fairly tight control on his own creative. He knows better than most what people mean by it too - in programmes against Cody Rhodes, CM Punk and Wardlow, he was responsible for the feeling more than just about anybody to walk through the doors of All Elite Wrestling beyond the stable that bear its name.
He wasn't advertised for this week's show, but the spectre of his current storyline situation loomed large in the background. What was Samoa Joe - his World's End opponent and current protectorate - going to say? What might The Devil fancy doing with the World Champion shelved either legitimately or as part of an elaborate ruse? And away from all that, could the penultimate week for the Continental Classic continue the restorative sensation it's cultivated over the course of the last experimental month?
Let's light the fuse...
Downs…
5. Rush Vs Jay Lethal
Rush Vs Jay Lethal was pro wrestling happening in front of you, and while the Continental Classic has been well calculated to result in a zero-pointer between the former best friends, but Rush wasn't quite as impressive extracting his win from Lethal as Jay White was from Mark Briscoe elsewhere on this show.
Not quite a squash or flash win but not long enough to be viewed as a particularly even-handed fight, Rush believably portrayed the anger and shame he felt over getting choked all the way out last week, but as sprints go, this was weirdly lethargic.
Upon the announcement of the Continental Classic, the brackets obscured matches or weeks that were destined to be a little on the dry side. This was that despite the agenting at least attempting to make something relatively meaningless a little more exciting. Ultimately, this was as New Normal as wrestling gets in 2023 - we're spoiled as a fanbase, but understandably over-fed on "well-worked". The fans in Arlington were quiet for this, but they've seen everything more times than Patrick Stewart in Extras. What could AEW or the wrestlers themselves have expected?
4. Riho Vs Ruby Soho
Riho looked impressive in her first Dynamite match since April, and there's possibly a supplemental "up" that could be afforded to AEW for tethering that to the present day drama with The Outcasts and reinvention of Toni Storm.
Unfortunately, what stood to tie everything together in fact ripped things apart.
Your writer is a fan of "Timeless" Toni Storm for the most part, in spite of how the character sometimes gets in the way of the product rather than contributes logically and positively to it. Unfortunately, this was the former rather than the latter. Storm in black and white with every cut was cute, but otherwise she was a distraction from a match that existed to convincingly sell a title match.
It's bad enough when women's storylines are virtually fight-for-a-championship or bust, but it's another when even that gets sidelined to a joke that has already worn thin for many. Storm Vs Riho will eventually rule, same conversation same problems etc etc etc forever nothing will ever change.
Timeless.
3. A Borderline Bait & Switch
The Von Erich Texas pop being saved for a Rampage multi-man is a reality of the content super-service era, but it was tough not be either angry or disappointed by the sight of Kevin, Ross and Marshall stationed backstage for a chat with Renee Paquette rather than getting the good stuff live.
The ground temporarily shook in the building, but a combination of the usual audio mishmash in these interviews and the sterile backstage atmosphere diluted the magic. As is tradition/the rule/really quite annoying, they were cut off before anything meaningful was said and became the latest friends of Orange Cassidy.
It's 2023; get in the long and frankly ridiculous queue.
2. Roderick Strong Vs Hangman Page
...just...wasn't particularly good?
Chemistry issues perhaps? AEW possibly not having either man wrestle quite enough in 2023? A bad night that would be much better on any other one? Hard to say several hours after the bell rang, but a match that promised so much delivered so little.
Page's massive frame wasn't violently folded up by that one backbreaker that'll stick with you for weeks. Hangman targeting Strong's neck right up to the point that he wrapped things up with the Deadeye was decent story stuff and speaks to the former Champion's darker side coming to the fore, but it didn't exactly feel like the fallen cowboy was getting back on the horse, as it were.
A uncharacteristically quiet crowd were there for the wrestling at other points during the show, but perhaps the pair's contest being non-tournament on a night with so many points left to play for made the fight feel more like a friendly.
Based on what followed later on the show, this most likely won't be the last time they fight. But the follow-ups will most likely be better than the first.
1. The Golden Jets, Ricky Starks & Big Bill And Whatever The Hell That Was
At NXT’s recent “Deadline” Premium Live Event, the show opened with a Shawn Michaels/CM Punk promo that was mostly a total car crash.
It felt as if two veterans assumed they could just call it in the ring brother, but as they then proceeded to awkwardly prove, it’s not as easy as that. That, at least, was realistically just to give the live crowd a pop and drop a returning Punk into NXT canon for future reference. The Golden Jets’ Dynamite disaster-piece with Big Bill and Ricky Starks was to sell a brutal beatdown and upcoming Tag Team Title match.
What a mess.
Kenny Omega got The Golden Jets’ team name wrong but that sort of thing happens and was about the least offensive element of this sub-WWE exchange of insults. Did you know the titleholders don’t even have a team name? Chris Jericho does, and he’s got a tight five on it! No jokes, mind, but he’ll take the minutes anyway! “Big Billy Starks?” Go away mate. Bless Excalibur for trying to sell an ROH show off the back of that too.
In order for the Champions to stay credible, Starks had to bury the dying gags. In response, the Challengers got pettier, dumber, and in Omega’s case all the more disinterested. All four of them may as well have been saying “I’m not owned, I’m not owned” at the same time before transforming into corncobs.
$50 for the match at the end of the most expense month of the year. See you there.
Ups…
4. Jay White Vs Mark Briscoe
Relatively early eliminations from the Continental Classic for Mark Briscoe and Jay Lethal appeared to reveal the flaws in a relatively short round robin format, but Mark Briscoe has been the safest pair of hands for playing the plucky loser and beloved underdog.
Here, in his penultimate Gold Group encounter, he was cast against the best possible heel.
White's escapes, counters and limb work flourishes were as smooth (and cruel) as ever, and ensured that this pattern of Briscoe being the hottest babyface on the show in spite of his win-loss record continued. There's absolutely no way that his bout with Jay Lethal next week isn't one of the hottest bouts on the final Dynamite of 2023, with avoiding ending on zero feeling just as powerful a ramification as a top-of-the-table clash.
It's the pop of a lifetime if and when he notches the three at long last, or a World's End singles match-in-waiting with Jeff Jarrett if Lethal procures a guitar from somewhere to cheat to win.
3. The Devil & The Details
It was a good week for what many viewers have deemed AEW’s worst storyline of the year, and maybe one of the company’s worst ever.
Top-and-tailing a wrestling-heavy edition of Dynamite with a thickening plot showed good restraint and was presumably an exercise in balancing out the importance of the masked attacks along with the high stakes tournament matches. The folding of Adam Page into its orbit hasn’t figuratively hurt the former AEW Champion either, and the Devil himself showing up at the end to effectively rule Hangman out of contention raised the voices of speculation for who the figure causing all of this might be.
Roderick Strong drew attention to MJF’s attack last week not being seen, as if to establish a contrast to the Page one at the climax of the show. As per most car park assaults, they dropped him on a windshield. Was this “real glass”, and if so could Jack Perry’s dramatic return be imminent? Or is it as simple as just being the injured Adam Cole? Strong, Matt Taven and Mike Bennett have been repeatedly linked with the henchmen roles - was that Roddy’s red trunks you could see? - and Page’s victory earlier in the show created further motivation for them to do the deed.
World’s End being the finale for all of this suits everybody, but as long as AEW have a solid plan for where the new group goes in the aftermath, time will likely be much kinder than the current consensus.
2. Andrade Vs Brody King
Good wrestling alone will not reverse current trends in AEW’s business or output, but the flashes of greatness that appeared in plain sight during certain Continental Classic matches last night may one day expedite a philosophical shift the company probably needs.
There were moments during Brody King Vs Andrade that had you roaring and barking as loud as the House Of Black’s monster himself. It doesn’t hurt that CJ Perry’s client is Yolk Jones right now either. Amidst speculation that he’s not long for All Elite Wrestling, he seems keen to leave enough visual memories of his time here after a run that’s mostly flattered to deceive. And yet again, that couldn’t be applied to this undercard tournament ripper.
Andrade snapping King’s streak was realistically a far bolder move than booking him to double break Bryan Danielson’s eyeball. This is the commitment he’s apparently been craving since landing in AEW, and if he can continue to return the same in kind, the end of this middling relationship stands to be far more satisfying than the beginning.
1. Jon Moxley Vs Swerve Strickland
The main event of this Dynamite and clearly one set for a 2024 pay-per-view, Jon Moxley Vs Swerve Strickland was the best advert for the Continental Classic yet, proof that Tony Khan can find a crunch time fixture in a tournament that he booked on the back of a packet of tabs, and hard evidence that Swerve is The Guy for the company going forward.
Measure-for-measure rooted in the experience of Moxley and the incredible confidence of Strickland, the two located the "big fight feel" before they'd even touched. They maintained it over the following absorbing 15 or so minutes, crafting arguably the best match of the tournament and inarguably the most significant.
The booking was sublime and bold. Moxley had to cheat to win, a strategy he hid in plain sight in his promo last week where he promised to do whatever it took and didn't have the courage to guarantee a win. With his handfuls of tights and a rolled Swerve shoulder that the commentators immediately highlighted, the story was that the unbeatable John Cena of AEW had in fact cheated to win. There's no nobility in that, which will certainly come in handy should be be the one to steal Eddie Kingston's belts at the end of all of this.
If there was anybody left that doubted Strickland as a made man, they were silenced here. A shrewd shark of a pro wrestler and the company's most reliable top star gave him everything but the three-count. That comes when they fight again one day. By then, it'll be for much more than a Triple Crown.