5 Potential Destinations For Jay White
The Raw after WrestleMania may finally be getting its buzz back.
The two are not comparable - they both became massive stars in Japan, however, their star power outwith the country is in no way equal - but Jay White's exit from NJPW shares some similarities with that of a Kenny Omega who, in 2017, took time to reassess his future.
Omega ultimately chose to stay in NJPW but before this, there was a real, genuine belief that Omega could've been WWE-bound. Just one year prior, AJ Styles jumped ship to WWE following his own departure from the Gedo-booked organisation, cropping up at number three in the 2016 Royal Rumble; the 'Cleaner' following suit twelve months after would've received twice the reaction. Audiences were convinced that the soon-to-be IWGP Heavyweight Champion held the often-prestigious number thirty spot in the 2017 Rumble.
He didn't. Roman Reigns did.
Kenny Omega instead stayed in New Japan for another two years, wrote further chapters in his illustrious lore vs. Kazuchika Okada, broke NJPW World records, and, because of that, arguably overtook the 'Rainmaker' when discussing the best all-round professional wrestler.
Jay White's situation is entirely different. His departure isn't a rumour, he isn't leaving at the peak of his significance, and it isn't known where, exactly, he's headed.
So, what's next?
5. NJPW Strong
Jay White vs. Hikuleo was a Loser Leaves Japan match; that sounds oddly specific, given that NJPW has an established branch in the United States. It's been in operation for several years and is due to ramp up further in 2023. Jay White has wrestled for the branch on numerous occasions. He'll do so again on 18 February at Battle In The Valley vs. Eddie Kingston, meaning that he isn't yet finished with his NJPW commitments.
Could he...just not be going away? Perhaps.
But NJPW runs the risk of dividing its audience.
Jay White, already a divisive figure with New Japan diehards, is a major star. At the time of his inaugural IWGP Heavyweight title ascension in February 2019, he was heralded as the greatest heel in professional wrestling. Hyperbolic as it may sound to current-day ears, his case could be argued. White was detested, not because he was an outright boring performer, but because he was a d*ck. A cold, black-souled d*ck who could - and did - do whatever he pleased. It was a style so unnatural to NJPW.
This is precisely why NJPW STRONG is not the answer his career path needs. He's too major a player in current company lore to be restricted to its American counterpart, particularly when that counterpart is given less care and attention than 2020 NJPW.
Probability: 10%.
4. Free Agency
It sounds strange to even think of a multi-time IWGP Heavyweight Champion departing NJPW and posting a tweet taking WrestleMania weekend bookings.
Imagine Kazuchika Okada doing it. Tomohiro Ishii. Hiroshi Tanahashi. At this stage, even a Toru Yano or a Taichi posting such filth on social media would attract attention from local authorities on suspicion of a cyber attack.
It technically happened recently when former IWGP World Heavyweight Champion Kota Ibushi was confirmed for two GCW dates the day he became a free agent. Ibushi is a different commodity, though. He didn't become a star in NJPW; he already was one and, frankly, he's done stranger things in his career than wrestle for the Invisible Man's home promotion.
Jay White, like Okada and the others above, would gain significant buzz if he were to spend a few months to a year working on the indies. There's a pantheon of talent out there that the 'Switchblade' presumably hasn't had the chance to meet, let alone wrestle, each providing White with the chance to learn a completely different style to what he's used to in Japan and vice versa.
He's spent close to a decade working in the same place, working the same people, working the same style; stylistically, he could come out a different wrestler by the time his indy run was finished.
Just don't bet on it happening.
Probability: 5%.
3. IMPACT Wrestling
IMPACT Wrestling typically attracts three key demographics to its roster:-
- Legends who refuse to retire.
- Relative unknowns from the independent circuit looking for their first big break.
- Rejected WWE goobers.
Not since the 2000s and the era of the Kurt Angles, the Stings, and the Mick Foleys have they attracted a major name of the ilk of Jay White. They probably won't if we're honest but for clarity, it was either IMPACT listed here or the NWA, and Jay White vs. Josh Alexander sounds far more appealing than Jay White vs. Tyrus.
Jay White has been in IMPACT previously for two brief spells, first to acquire the Bullet Club services of Chris Bey and the second to eject Tama Tonga and Tanga Loa. He last appeared on the go-home to Slammiversary, taped a month beforehand, where he and Bey were felled by the Briscoes. Before this, he impressed in bouts opposite Steve Maclin, Alex Shelley, and Eric Young. Each time he appeared, social media responded accordingly, reacting as any wrestling fan should under the circumstances. Its fanbase is supportive of IMPACT without developing tribalistic tendencies.
Unfortunately, White is too major a star to remain in IMPACT for any longer than a year, but another brief spell before he decides on his next full-time gig would be welcomed by the ardent IMPACT audience.
Probability: 20%.
2. AEW
Tony Khan needn't sprinkle subtle hints at Jay White's reemergence in AEW. Not only should White's hypothetical AEW comeback be a surprise at the conclusion of a pay-per-view, but it's believed that he's not contractually signed to AEW quite yet. Teasing Jay's return, being unable to come to terms with him, and instead sending out Adam Page in his place damages all involved, not least AEW's traditionally trusted relationship with its fans.
The very way in which he debuted in AEW - on Dynamite's 9 February 2022 broadcast - was a meticulous ploy by the company to garner the reaction White could attract in the company. Again, he's a major star within New Japan but outside, he's no Kazuchika Okada. Aiding the Young Bucks in a backstage beatdown of Roppongi Vice, the back of Jay White's leather jacket appeared before his face was shown; his Switchblade branding got him over in one fell swoop.
AEW knows precisely how to cater to Jay White's needs as a top star, but would he survive? The roster is bloated, top stars are already falling off the radar, and behind the scenes, it isn't exactly a wholesome landscape as was once portrayed. White would have thrived during the company's infant years - now, he may be nothing more than a dot on the map.
Still, Tony Khan knows when to throw his money around, so...
Probability: 50%.
1. WWE
Vince McMahon would give you the death sentence for mentioning the words professional wrestling on commentary; WWE is sports entertainment! This professional wrestling nonsense died off when he took control of WWE's day-to-day operations from his father. There's no New Japan Pro-Wrestling, no Ring of Honor, no IMPACT Wrestling, no Pro Wrestling Guerrilla, and certainly no All Elite Wrestling. These are all fictitious organisations that wrestling fans have played out in their minds.
Someone probably should have told WWE's BT Sport partner account then.
On 25 January, the very Twitter account posted a graphic consisting of five Royal Rumble scenarios that could happen:-
- Brock Lesnar enters first in the men's Royal Rumble and eliminates half the opposition.
- Rhea Ripley lasts an hour in the women's Royal Rumble and tosses out at least ten competitors.
- Jay White debuts.
- Asuka returns to her Kana roots.
- The Rock returns to win the men's Royal Rumble.
Brock Lesnar lasted less than three minutes as he entered twelfth, eliminating just three men. Rhea Ripley lasted an hour, but only had seven eliminations. Asuka returned to her old roots. The Rock was nowhere to be found, but Nia Jax was.
Jay White? Nowhere to be found.
For now.
Probability: 80%.