5 Signs WWE's NXT Bubble Is About To Burst

Are the best days of NXT already behind us?

By Marzi /

When WWE reconfigured NXT from a cheesy reality show format and launched it as their new developmental brand, few would have expected it to garner attention from the industry the way that it has. Since its inception in 2012, NXT has gone from a simple developmental territory into its own distinct brand. With high quality matches, an extremely talented roster from all over the globe and a dynamite womens division in particular, it has captured a new following more in common with an indie promotion doing it their own way. 

Advertisement

Many comparisons have been drawn to the original ECW, including its preference for smaller, localised venues and its passionate, cultlike audience. Plus, NXT chants have started to become a mainstay, both on the brand itself and on mainstream WWE programming. And when you get people chanting the name of the show itself, you KNOW you've done something right.

With some of NXT's graduates going on to great things in WWE and some huge signings from the independent scene in the last two years, NXT has been riding high.

However, there are some worrying signs that the peak of the brand's success has already come and gone...

5. The Main Stars Of NXT Will All Graduate

First and most obviously, the roster is a revolving door, especially at the top of the card. With how popular the brand is and how talented every performer across the roster is, it can be easy to forget sometimes that NXT is a developmental brand. It's the breeding ground, the training camp for the main WWE programming. This means that no matter how popular a wrestler is, eventually they will leave the show. In fact, it means that, ideally, they leave the second they peak. The second they get as popular and successful as they possibly can, they're gone. This is a fact.

Advertisement

It should be a good thing, really. Finding acclaim in NXT should ideally mean you're capable of finding it in WWE. Whether you're actually given that chance is another story *COUGHCOUGHASCENSIONCOUGH* But when you think about NXT's biggest stars, who springs to mind? Sami Zayn, Adrian Neville, Tyson Kidd, Finn Balor, Kevin Owens, Hideo Itami and so on.

Out of that small selection alone, Neville is on the main roster full time, with Owens and Balor soon to follow. Kidd and Zayn are on the shelf with injuries, but as soon as they're healthy, you can bet that they wont be going back to NXT.

So the main event scene is left on the shoulders of Hideo Itami. And the better he carries it, the quicker he's gone too. So who's left? Who becomes the next one to lead the next generation?

4. There Is A Lack Of Young New Names To Sign From The Indie Promotions

Cast your mind back about 5 years or so and think of some of the youngest, biggest names of the "indie" scenes in wrestling. Kevin Steen? Yep. El Generico? Definitely. Prince Devitt, Jon Moxley, Tyler Black, PAC, Sami Calihan, Samuray Del Sol, KENTA, all could be mentioned as dream signings for WWE, and all have been snapped up, put through rebranding and have been reborn as WWE superstars.

Advertisement

Jolly good for them but look around the rest of the wrestling world and think... realistically, who's left? Who among the wide world of independent wrestling, from the bingo halls of Pittsburgh to the trade centres of Tokyo, who can WWE sign up and expect to become a WWE superstar for the next 10 years?

Looking at the latest NXT signings, there's a list of men and women with excellent resumes, but no real reputation. That's fine in itself, there's every chance they can build their reputations from the ground up under the WWE banner, but none of them are going to bring that instant "buzz" of excitement to NXT the first time they perform. The one exception to this would be Uhaa Nation, who wrestled in Dragon Gate USA for a few years. No offence to the man, but that's not exactly up there with the reps that Zayn or Owens brought with them when they arrived.

That's not to say that there aren't prominent young stars out there still, its just that they're getting signed by the competition. Speaking of which.....

3. Unlike WWE, NXT Actually Faces Competition

The Monday Night Wars are well and truly over, and in 2015, there is not a wrestling company on Earth that can compete in terms of size and success with the juggernaut that is WWE. It would also be fair to say that the WWE style of "sports entertainment" is unique, and that you can't find that anywhere else in the world. NXT, however, styles itself as a brand apart, focusing on smaller venues, connecting massively with the audience, and delivering a high quality calibre of matches. And in that spirit, NXT has some serious competition in the wrestling industry.

Advertisement

Please note, this isn't a competition in terms of brand survival. NXT has WWE's money behind it, it's not going anywhere. But in terms of viewership, and specifically talent aquisition, they could be in for a real war. Recent years have seen the rise and relative success of new wrestling promotions. Global Force Wrestling and Lucha Underground were both created in 2014 and both have gathered a lot of attention from wrestling fans worldwide. Interestingly, both brands are affliated with Mexico's AAA promotion, with GFW also having ties to New Japan Pro Wrestling. And let's not forget USA mainstays such as Ring Of Honour, Dragon Gate or Pro Wrestling Guerrilla (although at this stage, we can probably forget about TNA)

Speaking of TNA, one of their former roster would have made a huge splash in NXT, namely former TNA World Heavyweight Champion and Tag Team Champion Magnus. At only 28 years old, the British born wrestler could have catapulted right into the NXT Title scene. Instead, he signed with GFW. Other promising young prospects include Ricochet, The Young Bucks, Jay Lethal, Adam Cole, Johnny Gargano, etc... all signed to other companies at present. Not to say they wont eventually be signed, but WWE might have to work harder to get them now.

2. Adding Older Big Names Goes Against NXT's Entire Point Of Existence

Skeptics of the IWC, I can hear your thoughts. All this indie wrestler name dropping and asking "There's no-one out there, who could they possibly sign?" I can hear you swearing at me and shouting names like "AJ STYLES! AUSTIN ARIES! JAMES STORM! CHRISTOPHER DANIELS! WWE SHOULD SIGN THEM TO NXT THIS INSTANT!"

Advertisement

No, they shouldn't, and heres why: they're too damn old.

This is not to discount their skills or ability, far from it. I'm well aware that Austin Aries alone is considered one of the best wrestlers in the world. But he's also 37. Bringing him into NXT serves no purpose at this stage. Again, NXT is a DEVELOPMENTAL brand. What does Austin Aries, of all people, have to develop?

Signing the likes of Rhyno to NXT is a different matter. He's worked for WWE before, he has a connection with fans and management, and he can be trusted. He's in NXT as an enhancement talent, basically. He's a big name to make the young guys look good. But the likes of AJ Styles, James Storm, or Samoa Joe, for that matter? These are men who have long since wrestled their best matches, and if you worked in talent aquisition for WWE, these are not the guys you bring in and expect to build the company around for ten years or more, its not going to happen. 

WCW and TNA both made the mistake of signing guys long past their prime simply because they were big names and trying to build the company around them instead of the younger talent. NXT is the exact opposite of that philosophy, which is why signing guys past their mid 30s to a developmental brand is pointless in the long term, and why I find it difficult to see Samoa Joe making it in WWE.

1. The Hardcore Fans Will Eventually Get Bored

1021844

Wrestling fans face many accusations on a daily basis, especially from themselves. They're fat and have neckbeards and body odour, they have low intelligence, they're all marks for John Cena or Roman Reigns or Daniel Bryan or whoever, yadda yadda yadda. But one accusation that holds weight is the fact that wrestling fans turn on anything that gets too popular.

Right now, NXT shares a lot of similarities with the original ECW, including the passionate audience. But part of the appeal in being NXT's audience is setting yourself aside from the regular WWE fans. Deny it all you want, but it feels good to know that all the kids and marks don't watch the same show as you. You feel like a different market altogether, like this brand caters to the specific niche that "real wrestling fans" seem to occupy. 

Advertisement

However, more and more NXT is getting some serious exposure on mainstream programming. Kevin Owens shows up on Raw with the NXT logo all over the stage lighting, and the chants follow him, Neville and others everywhere. That is bound to come into effect as an audience crossover, as more mainstream fans who have the WWE Network tune in. What happens next is what always happens when something gets big and successful, the product will change to cater for its new audience, and the IWC will get snarky and start saying "NXT sucks since Zayn left, I was watching it from 2012 before it was "cool" to do". That is GOING TO HAPPEN. 

For all the negativity talked about here, NXT is still a great show, and arguably still leaps and bounds ahead of Raw and Smackdown in terms of in-ring action. But with all these factors taken into account, you can't help but feel that NXT's popularity, and indeed quality, is going to peak soon, if it hasn't already.

Advertisement