5 Things To Watch For During XFL Week 1
What should you keep an eye out for during the first week of Vince McMahon's revived venture?
On 8 February, a professional football league called the XFL will air on national television for the first time since 2001. Of course, a lot has changed in the close to 19 years since we last saw an XFL game, and so has the league bearing its name.
The brashness of the original XFL of old has been replaced by a more subdued and buttoned-down appearance. The backs of jerseys no longer flaunt nicknames like "He Hate Me" or "Deathblow". The league has steered clear of controversial commercials and WWE tie-ins, although the pro wrestling giant's founder, Vince McMahon, is still very much in charge.
In its place, the XFL has promoted a fan-first personality dedicated to the love of football. Eight teams have been fielded, all owned by McMahon, and a new set of rules focusing on quickening the pace of play was created.
Will those changes be enough to save this incarnation of the XFL from befalling the same fate as its predecessor? Only time will tell, but there should be several areas to keep an eye on in the first week of action that can give us some clues as to how the 2020 edition of the XFL will fare.
5. How Effective Are The New Rules?
The most attention-grabbing element of the XFL this time around is the rulebook. The changes the league is poised to make could be innovative or disastrous to the game.
Chief among them is the shortened play clock designed to keep the action pumping. The standard NFL play clock is 40 seconds, more than enough time to call a play and get the team lined up in most cases. The XFL would argue a little too much time in fact, and has cut the play clock down to a slim 25 seconds. Additionally, the game clock only stops during the final two minutes of each half, just to further keep the pace up.
In theory, these could be welcome changes. There's no denying that football has a lot of downtime compared to other popular sports like basketball or hockey. Cutting some of that down might keep fans better engaged.
It might very well put too much pressure on the quarterbacks though. There's a reason NFL teams rarely play under a no huddle offense, yet that might have to be more commonplace under the restrictive play clock in the XFL. Quality of play could easily suffer if penalties become more regular, or rash decisions are made in the heat of the moment.
While those are the most obvious pace of play changes the XFL is making, there's a few other noticeable differences that could sneakily be just as impactful.
For one, there's going to be a dedicated referee for spotting the ball. That may seem like a rather innocuous change, but don't be the least bit surprised if the NFL looks into that to quicken their own games as well.
Additionally, each team will only have two timeouts, and each play will be reviewable by the booth, thus eliminating the coach's challenge. Those are a tad more radical, but may help liven up the end of games and reduce the amount of time debating the increasingly popular challenges on receivers' possession of the ball.
It's rule changes like that which, while less easy to spot from the viewer, could be crucial to the league's success at one of it's key initiatives.
Not every rule change is dedicated strictly to keeping the action moving however. More gimmicky rules, such as the double-forward pass and eliminating the extra point in favor of one, two, or three point conversion plays after a touchdown, have certainly garnered a lot of attention heading into week one. Those seem the most likely to change as the XFL evolves, and could be some of the first areas we see addressed or emphasized if the league stays true to its goal of listening to the fans.
All together, it's not hard to imagine that the rulebook becomes the most talked about part of the XFL's first week depending on the success of these unique changes.
4. What Are The Identities Of Each Team?
The rules are only going to go so far in making the 2020 XFL a success. No amount of rules, whether they turn out to be brilliant or terrible, will be able to hide the quality of play in week one.
While we know the roster and coaching staffs for each team, we still don't really know what the depth chart will be or how each team will run. Nevertheless, thanks in large part to some big name coaching hires, each of whom will bring a distinct personality to the position, we still have good reason to feel some level of confidence in the on-field product going into week one.
University of Oklahoma legend Bob Stoops has came out of retirement to lead the Dallas Renegades, and brought with him an expert in the innovative air raid offense in Hal Mumme as offensive coordinator. The head coach and general manager of the Tampa Bay Vipers is none other than Marc Trestman, a multi-time Grey Cup winner in the CFL and former pass-heavy coach of the Chicago Bears. Former elusive quarterback of the Seattle Seahawks and longtime NFL QB coach Jim Zorn will be heading up the Seattle Dragons.
All three provide just a small example of the unique backgrounds and experiences of the coaches the XFL has chosen to guide each of its franchises.
If the players in the XFL can help unlock some of these coaches' on-field personalities and successfully open up their playbooks, then the XFL will easily be on the fast track for success. Unfortunately however, that might be easier said than done.
These teams still really haven't sounded like they've had the same level of practice as say, an NFL squad. They also don't have the elite talent of an NFL team either, although the big bucks reportedly spent at the quarterback position will help shore some of that up.
A barometer of success for the XFL as a whole then will be how well each team will be able to meet their coach's expectations and pull together to create some of the entertaining football we know these playcallers can provide.
3. Was The Extra Money Spent On Quarterbacks Worth It?
Speaking of those quarterbacks, one of the few things that's been heavily reported about the XFL's roster creation process has been its pursuit of quality QBs.
According to Yahoo Sports, quarterbacks will be making significantly more than their teammates with contracts reaching above the NFL's rookie minimum. Is that a good thing? Well, sort of.
For one, we know the XFL has pulled some good quarterbacks from the NFL and collegiate ranks. Players like former Pittsburgh Steelers backup Landry Jones and ex Ohio State quarterback Cardale Jones could be under center for their respective teams. Names like Connor Cook, Matt McGloin, and Josh Johnson will also probably ring more than a few bells for diehard football fans.
With players like that leading these teams, there should be an easier path to creating some enjoyable action in the XFL. QB play is just that important to the watchability of the sport that it makes sense that the XFL would invest heavily in the position.
At the same time however, that's come at a cost. The XFL has already been on the receiving end of some controversy over its low pay for other positions, potentially hurting their chances of fielding some decent players at other key spots on the roster. By just taking a look at the rosters, you can tell that the defenses of these teams feel a little lighter on the noteworthy names compared to the offenses.
That's not to say these defenses are devoid of talent, far from it in fact. It's just that there's not really a collection of big-name players that lots of fans remember on that side of the ball. How much that hurts the league, especially if there's some uncharacteristically high-scoring games in week one, is up for debate. What's done is done though, and now we can only wait to see what week one brings before truly knowing if the XFL's roster decisions were wise.
2. How Do Former NFL And College Stars Fare?
While its true that many of the big names come from the quarterback position, there are some players that fans could be familiar with at other spots on the roster.
At running back, for example, the Dallas Renegades have two former NFLers in longtime Carolina Panthers backup Cameron Artis-Payne and former Dallas Cowboys reserve Lance Dunbar. The St. Louis Battlehawks halfback Christine Michael, a four year NFL veteran himself, will likely be a name that football fans recall as well.
Past that, you have players like the entertaining punter Marquette King, former Pittsburgh Steelers wideout Sammie Coates, and ex Baltimore Ravens safety Matt Elam on XFL squads. How they adapt to the XFL's rule changes, and whether or not they can use their NFL experience to become stars in their own right, will be key to the league's development.
Additionally, it's worth noting that many players on both side of the ball have some level of quality college experience under their belt. That means that these teams should, in theory, be at an OK starting place in spite of their lack of experience together as collective units.
For the crucial first week games when the most eyes will likely be on the league, that could play a major role in the XFL's early success, or lack thereof, by affecting the quality of the on-field product.
1. How Is The New XFL Presented?
For all the mistakes of the original XFL, one of its lasting legacies was the innovations it popularized in how football is presented. The NFL essentially owes the skycam to the XFL, as even reports at the time hailed the league's unprecedented access and camera angles.
This time around, the XFL looks poised to continue trying to bring some of those innovations to the sport's broadcasts. According to the Sports Business Journal's John Ourand (h/t Awful Announcing), the XFL is going to return to giving fans unprecedented access into the minds and mentalities of the coaches and players on the field as the action unfolds.
The success of broadcast decisions like that could draw in more viewers and help the league create stars by showcasing their personalities to the world during games. In other words, it could be a way for the XFL to further differentiate itself once again by hooking viewers with compelling content that they can't get from any other football league.
That could go a long way towards making the XFL a success, at least in the short term, even if it were to take a little while for the quality of play to pick up.