5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE Fastlane 2023 (Results & Review)
A title change, a surprise return, mist, more Charlotte Flair, and a dose of John Cena.
How does one rate a WWE PLE that has only five matches, a few mild surprise returns, and a pretty major title change?
WWE Fastlane 2023 was the definition of a B-show: an event with a couple of memorable moments but nothing that stands out in a significant way. One of the returns was an on-air personality who was in his hometown, and the other was a guy who last appeared in WWE five months ago, but his return was indeed very cool.
Titles changed hands and got a huge reaction, but that was the least-surprising title switch of the night once anyone stopped and thought about it.
Still, Fastlane avoided any huge pitfalls and kept this entertaining overall, with Carlito’s return to join the LWO being a really fun talking point, as it adds a new wrinkle to the faction. And really, Cody Rhodes and Jimmy Uso are too big of stars to come up short in their tag title bout with the Judgment Day. The loss also only serves to stir the pot with the faction, which is WWE’s bread and butter these days.
Fans however had to deal with another Charlotte Flair title match, a new faction losing at an inopportune time, and two matches relying on an identical gimmick that ultimately didn’t pay off.
While not something that will make anyone’s top 10 list for the year, Fastlane gets passing marks for its even keel.
Let’s get to it…
Downs...
3. A Couple Of Mist Opportunities
Wrestlers using mist in matches is almost always awesome. It’s a great little trick to rile fans and throw a match into chaos.
However, you would have thought that WWE would have made sure if they were planning to use mist in a title match, they wouldn’t then use it in a second title match on the same card. Both Asuka and Shinsuke Nakamura sprayed the mysterious substance on opponents, with Asuka nailing Charlotte Flair to start the match, and Nakamura blinding Seth Rollins in the main event.
Both instances, by themselves in the moment, were really great spots. Asuka starting the match by misting Flair was a brilliant way to try to take one of the competitors out of a triple threat to increase her chances of winning. And Shinsuke spraying Rollins was a perfect move to try to capture the World Heavyweight Championship.
But in both situations, the victims recovered pretty quickly and went on to compete at a high level, with Rollins retaining his title, and Charlotte getting a visual tap-out that the referee didn’t see. Mist is supposed to be debilitating, and in both instances, it was more of a nuisance than anything else.
This wasn’t a tragic violation, but there definitely should have been more thought put into those spots.
2. Team Lashley Falters Again
WWE seemingly has a really good thing with the reinvention of the Street Profits in Bobby Lashley’s preferred image, but they’re playing a dangerous game.
Lashley, Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins lost a six-man tag match to the LWO at Fastlane when Carlito made his return to aid Rey Mysterio and Santos Escobar. The All Mighty-led faction has stumbled with direction a bit after a really intriguing start, with the group seemingly facillating between face and heel, though it was explained that Lashley wanted the Profits to channel their aggression and get serious, or else he was done with them.
Losing Saturday night could be a catalyst for the group to really embrace the heel side, or it could prompt an edict from Lashley that yields results. But the risk here – and what merits a down – is that losing matches early in their formative days could brand the group. And no amount of cool suits and poses will undo that.
It’s too early to deem this a booking failure, but it’s being designated as a caution at this stage.
1. When In Doubt, Push Charlotte Harder
Charlotte Flair is a highly decorated, talented wrestler who is a valuable asset to WWE. All of that can be true, and she can be horribly booked.
While Flair did take the pinfall during the triple threat match for the WWE Women’s Championship, Charlotte was dominant throughout the entire contest, shrugging off the vast majority of offense, sometimes even tandem attacks from Asuka and Iyo Sky. Both women bounced off Flair like ping-pong balls at various points. And fans were… surprisingly subdued for a lot of her offense.
Flair even got a visual submission from Asuka that the referee missed, just in case fans thought for a minute that she was vulnerable. Expect them to parlay that into another title shot for the Queen.
None of this is to say that Charlotte shouldn’t be booked strongly, but she shrugged off debilitating mist in less than five minutes and dominated large parts of the match, overwhelming Asuka and Iyo individually and even simultaneously. She by far looked like the strongest person in the bout despite not being the champ, and one that ostensibly could be turning babyface in the near future.
It's not like Flair is in danger of being thought of as an inferior wrestler and needs to be kept strong.
Ups…
5. At Least It’s Over, Right?
The World Heavyweight Championship feud of the past couple months between Shinsuke Nakamura and Seth Rollins has been a huge letdown. Short of a blow-away match at Fastlane, this rivalry is going to be remembered as one of wasted potential.
Their Last Man Standing match definitely wasn’t blow-away good, nor did it simply blow. The match – as many of these WWE varietals do – plodded along at times with the numerous counts off a suplex or some moderately damaging bump.
The contest picked up steam toward the end, with tables getting broken left and right, and both men breaking out their finishers to try to keep the other down for the full 10 count. It finally ended with Rollins hitting a Falcon Arrow off a platform and through a couple tables, getting back to his feet at nine while Shinsuke couldn’t answer the count.
The match was fine, but more importantly, this hopefully marks the end of this feud, as that is now two definitive losses for Nakamura. For those reasons, this item gets positive marks. If WWE decides to go for a third installment, then the downward-facing thumbs will come out in force.
4. Señor On-The-Sidelines
Heading into Fastlane, the smart money had to be on Damian Priest cashing in his Money in the Bank briefcase at the conclusion of the Last Man Standing match between Seth Rollins and Damian Priest. After all, whomever emerged victorious was going to emerge severely knackered, making Saturday the perfect opportunity.
But a cash-in was not in the cards, and at least WWE acknowledged this and provided a solid in-universe explanation.
During their unsuccessful tag title defense, the Judgment Day enlisted the help of everyone to try to keep Cody Rhodes and Jey Uso down. In the melee, JD McDonagh struck Priest in his already injured knee with the briefcase. This took him out of the remainder of the match.
Later on backstage, Priest was fuming about losing the tag titles and declared he wasn’t leaving Fastlane empty-handed and went to walk off to cash in during the main event. But as he started to limp away, Finn Balor and Rhea Ripley interjected, reminding Damian that they had all agreed to not do anything rash with the briefcase and make sure he’s at 100% so he’s successful.
This wasn’t some A-plus storytelling, but it at least informed fans that there was a reason Priest wouldn’t be taking a shot at the World Heavyweight Championship. It wasn’t perfect, but it made sense and removed what would have been a gaping plot hole in the program.
3. That Was Cool
It only took five months for WWE to figure out what to do with Carlito, but they definitely delivered smartly Saturday night.
With Jaoquin Wilde and Cruz Del Toro taken out on SmackDown Friday night, Rey Mysterio said he’d place a call for backup. A fair amount of the chatter was that Dragon Lee would answer the call, but once it was revealed that the person Rey called didn’t answer, it ruled out Lee, who also was on SmackDown.
Enter, Carlito.
The late arrival in tag matches is a rarely used trope that can seem really hackneyed and forced, but when you’re talking about a literal last-minute substitute and the guy answering the call lives a plane ride away, it’s not out of the realm for him to arrive at the arena mid-match and rush to the ring.
Carlito looked great in his return and picked up the quick win for his team, putting him on the map from the jump. The question now will be how he fits into the LWO and how that impacts the group dynamic.
2. A Boisterous Opener
Cody Rhodes and Jey Uso were not a tag team before Saturday night. They had never teamed together, despite somehow earning a match graphic that they would be vying for the Undisputed WWE Tag Team Championship at Fastlane.
And still, their win over the Judgment Day to capture the tag titles was a fantastic moment because everyone involved is just committed to getting everything over by sheer force of will. This goes for Rhodes and Uso, but also the entire Judgment Day, and especially groupie JD McDonagh, who took the most perfect Cross-Rhodes bump ever.
The tag title match opened the PLE, but it got plenty of time to breath, with multiple heat segments, a flurry of run-ins, and a fantastic finish that even included an explanation of why we wouldn’t be getting a Money in the Bank cash-in later that night.
If anyone wants to pick nits, the West Side Story standoff trope still needs to be killed off, as both teams had a standoff before heading into the finishing sequence. Still, this overall was a solid match that didn’t finish Cody’s story, but definitely completed a chapter.
1. Getting That Sweet, Sweet Cena Rub
John Cena has officially morphed into the legendary veteran who is in the twilight of his wrestling career, looking to share his abnormally large spotlight with others.
The 16-time world champion tagged with rapidly rising star LA Knight (yeah!) to challenge the Bloodline B-Team of Jimmy Uso and Solo Sikoa. Cena spent the entire match being beat down by the heels, with Solo dominating large chunks of the contest. It wasn’t until fans had been sufficiently whipped up that he made the hot tag to Knight, who ran wild on everyone.
Knight and Cena had some decent chemistry as they confounded Sikoa and Uso before LA put Jimmy away with a BFT. But this match wasn’t about workrate or star ratings. It was about Cena making sure everyone else in the match looked strong and got some shine in his first televised match since WrestleMania 39.
Who knows how many more matches Cena has left in him before this latest run dries up, and then whether he returns to the ring again later on? It’s nice to see him giving Knight the stamp of approval and getting Solo across as a physical threat. Saturday can only help both of them.