5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (April 5 - Results & Review)

WWE put a bow on WrestleMania build during a by-the-numbers episode of SmackDown.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

This 'go home' episode of SmackDown could've been better, but maybe it was always going to be functional. After all, WWE went hard with killer segments aplenty during a colossal push towards twin main events like Saturday's tag-team main event and the Roman vs. Cody blowoff before reaching Friday.

Advertisement

Perhaps there was just nothing left to do pre-'Mania, and that's fine.

In fairness, the company did sign off with a strong babyface promo, but some of the other stuff on the undercard was a little tepid. Things haven't clicked at all in the United States Title picture, and even red hot newbie Jade Cargill toiled in a totally unnecessary bit of business that really shouldn't have been booked.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, Triple H tweaked a tag match for Saturday night (at least one guy will be disappointed with that decision), the winner of the latest Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal was revealed, and there was a quite remarkable lack of chemistry in what should've been an ace main event.

Think of SmackDown as a 50/50 kind of episode. WrestleMania 40 will surely be superb across two nights in Philadelphia, but a few fans will be bummed out that major players like Rock and Reigns weren't on tap yet again.

Advertisement

Here's all the good and bad.

Advertisement

Downs...

5. This Was A Miss

WWE.com

Bianca Belair, Naomi and even Jade Cargill said a whole load of nothing during their in-ring promo on Damage CTRL. All three were tasked with spinning out weak material and vowing to take the (already weakened) faction down. This is the kind of thing video packages were made for - a recap of Jade's impact last week would've sufficed here.

Advertisement

Also, can WWE please move on from all that sign pointing business? We get it by now, guys. Wrestlers pointing at the big neon 'Mania sign is one of the most uninspiring visuals in modern wrestling, but it's supposed to be the opposite. Does anybody actually get excited for it anymore?!

Sorry to be so negative, but this skit didn't have much purpose or fire to it at all. It just...existed, and acted as one of those time-killing exercises you typically see on 'go home' programs once the main hype has been done. This fan isn't certain Cargill should be in that sort of spot, especially when she's so new.

Advertisement

Meh.

4. Main Event’s Surprising Lack Of Cohesion

WWE.com

Jey Uso vs. Solo Sikoa should've been a banger.

Advertisement

It never really got going before the finish though. In fact, it was shocking how little chemistry the brothers had out there. Plus, people in the stands knew Jimmy Uso was poking his nose in for the DQ at some point, so the bout turned into six minutes of sitting around waiting for that ending to happen.

Hopefully, Jey and Solo get the chance to show they're capable of more in the future. They're the kind of combo WWE will come back to with a title on the line in years to come, so fingers crossed those matches turn out better than this one did. Got to break out that functional word again!

Advertisement

Yes, Jey and Solo had a job to do here. They scrapped, Jimmy interfered, and then there was a big babyface promo ending for SmackDown heading into WrestleMania. That's fine, but one can't shake the feeling that this battle of brothers could've been more exciting bell-to-bell.

3. Give Them A Chance, WWE!

Wow, the live crowd was dead for this short match.

Advertisement

Zelina Vega and Elektra Lopez haven't had a lot of ring time lately though, and neither has been properly fleshed out as a character with any motivations fans can hang onto. Perhaps because of this, they yawned their way through just three minutes of action. Yikes - WWE should be worried about that.

This is what happens when workers are background noise for too long (Vega) or fresh faces who haven't been given the chance to explain what they hope to achieve (Lopez). Triple H shouldn't be stunned that the crowd was apathetic, nor should he be surprised that Zelina and Elektra couldn't do much with so little ring time.

Advertisement

Again, like the aforementioned main event, this was only on the show to lead to an angle afterwards. Whilst that's acceptable, y'know what isn't? Giving two wrestlers around three minutes to show their wares without any promos leading into it that'd make fans interested.

AEW Rampage wants its format sheets back!

Advertisement

2. That Low Energy Kickoff

WWE.com

SmackDown opened with Kevin Owens inviting Randy Orton onto the KO Show so they could gang up on Logan Paul and tell the world how much they despise him. Thrilling, eh? Nah, this segment didn't cut it at all. The build towards 'Mania's Triple Threat has honestly felt so forced, and this was a prime example.

Advertisement

No pun intended.

The road to this three-way has totally lacked any of the intensity or vibes Kev's one-on-one rivalry with Paul had. Worse, Wade Barrett referred to the babyface duo's quest to find LP as a Benny Hill skit. That kinda sums up how lame the whole booking ploy has been. Chalk this one up to experience.

Advertisement

WWE's writers should know better though. They need told that they had something special on their hands with Orton vs. Logan in a singles. People were into that thought, but KO's own feud with Paul needed something more so he's third-wheeling when he shouldn't be.

Creative painted themselves into that corner.

Advertisement

1. Buddy Buddy

WWE.com

Later, LP showed up at the venue and was cornered by Randy and Kevin.

Advertisement

Owens and Orton are still playing buddy cop movie leads during this rivalry, and it sucks. There's absolutely no friction between them, which hasn't helped the build towards this weekend. Here, everyone went through the motions, and Paul very-nearly came out looking more sympathetic than intended.

What's the end goal here? If it's to dilute how good Owens and Orton are and possibly put some support behind the unlikable Paul, then...mission accomplished? Yep, Randy gunning for the United States Title without KO there as a third wheel would've been the better way to go in retrospect.

Advertisement

Things might've been a tad different had WWE booked any tension or heat between the babyfaces, but they haven't. As a result, even that'll come out of the blue during Sunday's match. 'Mania 40's US Title sprint has been a textbook example of how not to book a three-way story.

Ups...

5. Andrade Replaces Dragon Lee

WWE.com

Right, so this clearly sucks balls for Dragon Lee, but one of WrestleMania 40's least-enticing bouts will benefit from it. Andrade has replaced Lee as Rey Mysterio's partner vs. Santos Escobar and Dominik Mysterio over the weekend; the tag effort will still be a struggle, but seeing Andrade and Santos tear it up should be fun.

Advertisement

You've got to feel for Dragon, but what can anyone do?

There's another wrinkle in the tale too. Carlito is rightly miffed at Rey for overlooking him yet again once it became clear that Lee wouldn't be medically cleared to tag with him. That''s twice Mysterio has looked past his mate - once for Dragon and again here for Andrade. A turn is surely incoming from Mr. Caribbean Cool.

Advertisement

The best heel turns have some realistic justification, and this one does. Carlito can begin to see where Escobar was coming from by calling out Mysterio's lack of leadership skills, then say he's too long in the tooth to put up with them. Meanwhile, Andrade can slip neatly into his slot as part of the LWO.

4. LA Knight Shows Them How To Do It

WWE.com

Contrast and compare LA Knight's promo to the one produced by Bianca, Jade and Naomi earlier in the evening. Knight was on, had something to say, and kept the live crowd interested whilst he recapped the AJ Styles story and put a final tick next to one of SmackDown's best undercard dramas.

Advertisement

It was simple stuff, but LA is really good at talking.

There was a sense of danger in the air too, because these lads have been ambushing one another frequently. Knight even attempted to invade AJ's house, for crying out loud. Also, Styles took a flight all the way to Australia just to make sure his foe didn't win Elimination Chamber. It certainly wasn't out of the question that fans would see another brawl on Friday.

Advertisement

WWE kept some powder dry for 'Mania instead, and that was the right call. Someone as skilled as Knight on the mic can carry segments like this without any physicality, which is precisely why he's so useful to creative. Again, contrast this to the women's division snore before it.

Knight and day.

Advertisement

3. A Serviceable Battle Royal

WWE.com

OK, everyone knows WWE's annual Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal is one of the least-important attractions going. It isn't even important enough to bag a slot on the 'Mania card(s) these days, and the winner rarely gets anything more than one of those posed shots you can see Bronson Reed doing above.

Advertisement

2024's attempt was a basic entry, but it was far from terrible. Seeing Omos again (first time since Royal Rumble) was a hoot, and the closing stretch between Ivar and Reed showed the value of big boys who can shift. Fans were into that bit of the match, at least, so Hunter will be happy there.

Hopefully, giving Bronson the win will heat him up a bit going forwards. That should be handy during the traditional post-WrestleMania lull period when all the casual fans go off to do other things and WWE feeds on creative scraps before SummerSlam's hype begins.

Advertisement

Reed has something about him, no doubt.

2. Better Tag Than Anything Last Week!

WWE.com

Last week, WWE put on three shockingly weak tag-team bouts that failed to get anyone excited about the division. Tag wrestling is fab, but that trio of matches flopped. The good news? New Catch Republic and the wonderfully-named A-Town Down Under were here to pull the nose up for WWE's doubles division.

Advertisement

Pete Dunne and Tyler Bate are already emerging as one of the best duos around, and this guy has always championed the thought of creative doing more with Austin Theory and Grayson Waller before the inevitable Theory face turn. It was a pleasant surprise to see what all four produced on Friday night.

The quartet worked hard from the off, and the combo of teams gave everything a fresh feel. Post-match, Judgment Day arrived to waste their tag title rivals. That made sense, and was an easy way to get the faction on the show without endless backstage skits for the sake of it.

Advertisement

Go out of your way to take a gander at this tidy tag.

1. Going Home With Something Strong

WWE.com

No, the headliner between Jey Uso and Solo Sikoa isn't one for the family album, but it did give Cody Rhodes and Seth Rollins an excuse to stop by SmackDown one last time before 'Mania. They saved Jey from Bloodline's background troops, then cut a nice promo on Roman Reigns and The Rock.

Advertisement

Job done.

Jey actually came into his own once the match was over and done with. He seemed to hesitate on joining in on the beatdown at first, but then realised what was going on and smacked his brothers around some more. Meanwhile, Rhodes took centre stage with a weight belt, and put a bow on the WrestleMania hype.

Advertisement

There was something decidedly house show-y about the whole thing, but that's not a complaint. WWE didn't need to go overboard on its final TV before 'Mania, and fans are always gonna be thrilled to see guys like Seth and Cody do their thing.

Strong finish.

Advertisement

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out WWE WrestleMania 40: 20 Things That Must Happen and WWE WrestleMania 40: 20 Nightmares That Could Come True!