5 WWE Superstars Who Have Struggled & Floundered After Injuries

By James Ferrarella /

The worst thing that could ever happen to a pro wrestler is an injury. Ask Magnum TA or Edge about forced retirement. Although, I am sure Edge prefers doing Haven over being paralyzed... But most injuries do not lead to retirement. They lead to time off, rehabilitation and a reappearance. Sometimes it works. I documented some examples last week on this very website. Returning superstar success is not common. It is not likely. Injuries ruin careers. They stilt them, make them matter less and most importantly remove the wrestler physically and mentally from the audience. How often do you miss Sheamus? I forgot he was on the roster until I saw him in the WWE 2k14 roster. Plus he is a terrible baby-face and about five Irish Stereotypes. And not super popular regardless... John Cena is popular and will be perfectly fine. To have a bad return, Cena would have to punch a WWII veteran on the Rachel Maddow show while burning Vince McMahon's money. Then it might be hard for him....depending on how much money he burned. But back to the Irish Curse himself; It is possible that Sheamus will have a successful return. He is strong, and liked by the powers that be. History tells us that sometimes that isn't enough. Let's take a look at the Top 5 Superstars Who Struggled and Floundered After Injuries.

5. Wade Barrett

Since Wade Barrett has been on the roster he has been The Leader of the Nexus, Leader of the Corre, the pain machine known as the Barrett Barrage, a bare knuckle boxer guy and IC champ a couple of times. Yet despite a fairly good resume (Justin Gabriel would kill for that resume), Barrett is currently being positioned for a gimmick change, which can be the kiss of death for any superstar. (With obvious exceptions of Stone Cold or Rock, etc) I like Wade Barrett. He's got a potential to be an IT guy. He looks like a title holder. He sounds like a title holder and he is good enough in the ring to be a title holder to be a title holder. Oh and he is British. British tough guy wrestlers are not super common in America and generally never super crazy successful. The two biggest, William Regal & British Bulldog, never captured the top prize. Barrett was on the move to becoming the first English World Champion in the United States. Which could have been great, because Brits tend to have a gravitas. Maybe its the accent...wish I had that accent. Back to the point: Barrett's lack of golden triumphs is on creative. The Nexus had the best potential as a group since Evolution. WWE really made them out to be a dangerous entity with Barrett as their leader...for approx 90 days. And that's a shame. Barrett's gravitas was the reason he won the first season of NXT and he held his own against Randy Orton at Survivor Series. And then... This was not a deal breaker in Barrett's case. WWE still knew it had a good hand, who had great potential. It was rumored that Barrett was in line for the 2012 World Heavyweight Championship MITB. It made sense. Barrett was the perfect choice. And then he injured himself. Barrett was landed on and dislocated his shoulder during the #1 Contender Battle Royal On Raw (Which Jericho won to face CM Punk at Wrestlemania). He was out until August 2012. It was one of those all to frequent Worst Time EVER injuries. And that was the stop on the push of Wade Barrett. His subsequent return as a "gritty" bare knuckled boxer went straight into a wall. He grew a BEARD! That's right a beard, which he no longer has. And he was IC Champ and lost to everyone all the time for the rest of forever. With the rumor that Barrett is supposedly going to be repackaged in some way, I have a suggestion. With WWE embracing more ridiculous characters again (Los Matadores), lets do a British stereotype. Maybe Sir Reginald Barrett, Duke of Suffolk. He drinks tea. Or maybe a Beatle impersonator. Yay!, Ringo Barrett! Barrett has fallen into a trap and it's one he looks unlikely to escape. He has no credibility and no one cares. That is a death sentence. Barrett you got injured and now you are done. Good Day Sir!

4. Mark Henry

Mark Henry has been in the WWE since 1996. He has been with the company longer than the character Kane has existed. He has had a 20 year career filled with multiple World championships... whoops, that's not correct. Henry has been injured so many times. He hurts himself at least twice a year at this point. He has been out twice in 2013. This doesn't work. Injury prone wrestlers never make it to their full potential. They can't. Henry should be a multi-time World champion. He should be a former WWE Champion. His promo in early June 2013 was the work of a master. He can talk. He can work. He can do it all. But the WWE can't trust that he won't fall down weird at a house show and miss six month again. They can't put the full weight of the MACHINE behind him. (We'll get to World champs who get injured in the next slide) I am not taking away from Henry his success with The Hall of Pain, his World title run or or the fact that this is, in fact, what he does. It is what he does...some of the time. A healthy Henry is a great Henry. Sadly it is something we've never really seen, and it's deprived us of something potentially awesome.

3. Batista

Batista is someone I never got behind. He is big. And he yells. And he looks good in a suit... Yup, that's Dave Batista. He has enough charisma and he pecks and arms look like filled with helium. A Vince "guy" through and through. And he was treated as such in late 2004/early 2005. Forget not, that in 2005, Batista was more important than John Cena. It was Batista who eliminated Cena to win the Rumble (after Batista accidentally eliminated himself with Cena. Like a pro.) It was Batista who headlined Wrestlemania 21 against Triple H for the World Heavyweight Championship. Cena had won the WWE championship earlier in the middle of the card. Dave was supposed to be the man. As 2005 went on, Dave and Cena were neck and neck, holding onto their belts when he got hurt. Cena was going to lose on the 8th of Jan (Edge cash in). Batista would have still had his belt, if he didn't get hurt. But he got injured..while holding the World Heavyweight Title. Injuries are always inconvenient for the promotion. They have to shift immediately to a unplanned story line. And bad things happen. For instance World Heavyweight Champion The Great Khali (granted not Batista's injury). The organization scrambles, which it does not like to do. Historically, it changes the injured guys' status with the company when he returns. He loses a dependability to carry the title. Batista never had a crazy super long reign again. And he never recovered from that slamming on the breaks in 2006. Now granted, Batista still had success. He still re-won the World Heavyweight Championship upon his return and did have a great match (one of HIS best) against the Undertaker at Wrestlemania 23. But that isn't the point. It was very nice to have Batista as a go to guy who they could have feud with the title holder (think Sheamus or RVD today) but Dave Batista was supposed to be the next Triple H. He was groomed for THAT position, not the Sheamus role. It was obvious by Wrestlemania 24 that Batista had fallen. He fought a sub par inter-promotional match against Umaga...just so he had something to do. But the kicker came in 2009, when Batista dug his own wrestling grave. (REST IN PEACE) He was finally given a run with the WWE championship. He beat Randy Orton for the belt and proceeded to immediately get injured again. HE DID IT AGAIN! Again with the World Title. Again with WWE having to scramble. Again with the disappearing off of television. The man who was almost Cena, got hurt again. And WWE always follows an old idiom (slightly modified); Injured once shame on us, Injured twice shame on you. When Batista turned heel in the later half of 2009, it was best for his character. His character was stale, because an unhealthy wrestler means a wrestler fans can't get behind. This was some of Batista's best work in the WWE. He flourished in that role, but seemed uninterested in doing it long term. He jobbed to Cena at Wrestlemania 26 and has never returned. I guess he lost the fire and the passion.

2. Mr. Kennedy

Poor Mr. Kennedy. Kennedy should still be employed by the WWE today. He was a hand picked main event superstar. He was the future Mr. Kennedy McMahon. A calamity of errors caused Kennedy to slowly flutter away from the organization that made him. Kennedy is the only man to win the MITB and lose that right. That is due to being injury prone (he also was injured in 2005). Regardless of what would have happened later, Kennedy would have won the World Heavyweight Championship if he just didn't get hurt. In May when Undertaker got hurt, the title was his... His injury, which ended up being not so serious, ruined that. Strike One. Kennedy returns, and WWE still sees something big. The fans love shouting Kennedy with him because he's got a microphone and is cool... and I also secretly wanted a microphone to scream my name in. FERRA...RELLA. But sadly, Kennedy was a guy who took pills, to make his body look better, because Vince McMahon likes definition, which is Kennedy's fault...ish. He was busted and suspended. That one was his fault. Never get caught. He made a bad judgement of error (not having prescription) and he paid dearly for it (lost his potential big push, championships, money etc). And due to his error, we received Hornswoggle McMahon for over six months. Thank you Mr. Kennedy (Do NOT ask the WWE to come up with something on the spot, that's when you get Gobbeldy Gookers.) Strike Two To be injury prone is one thing but to be pill popping and injury prone is another. Kennedy floundered about for most of 2007 and 2008. He competed again in MITB, which he lost and was drafted to RAW...to do nothing. He did shoot a movie for WWE Films. His movie started the curse of those who do a starring movie roles for WWE and aren't named John Cena. (How's Ted Dibiase doing?) The last straw was Kennedy's second injury. He was injured in August 2008, right after filming and was sidelined until April 2009. A movie couldn't be properly pushed to the WWE fans if the fans didn't care about the star. No one cared about Kennedy. He bad been gone too much and too long. In May 2009, Kennedy almost injured Randy Orton on Raw. Strike Three, You're Fired. It's one thing to be injury prone. It's another to injure others. Mr. Kennedy is the best example of someone who should have had great success. Without his injuries, Kennedy potentially could be Randy Orton level today. Instead he plays second fiddle to Bubba Ray Dudley on a second rate wrestling program. Whoops!

1. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Steve Austin is the best example of a successful return and the best example of an unsuccessful return from injury. The best thing to ever happen to Steve Austin was to get injured in 1997, and the worst thing was to disappear in the year 2000. The father of Attitude was missing for almost one full year recovering from surgery. While he was gone, the WWF flourished. Rock stepped in and in many ways surpassed Austin as the top babyface. Rock was different than Austin. While Austin was a unique, fight against the system every-man, Rock was ridiculous. He was the king of catch phrase. Austin may have opened the audience chant Pandora's box, but Rock spearheaded the normalization of catch phrases repeated with and by the audience. Can someone explain to me what a Ruddy Poo is?... The Rock isn't to blame for Austin's struggles when he came back. Stone Cold did that to himself. Austin & McMahon came up with the bright idea of turning Austin heel at Wrestlemania x7. Austin wanted it. McMahon wanted it. Fans did NOT want it and therefore it didn't work. Who exactly wants to boo Stone Cold Steve Austin? He is cool, he was gone for a really long time. The nostalgia pops alone would keep him going and he had been built as part of a redemption story line with his 3rd Rumble victory and his rematch against the man who took his spot, the Rock. No one was going to boo Steve Austin. But they went with it. The problem came, what do you do with a heel Stone Cold? How can you get the fans to boo him? The WWE didn't know. And so, we got a series of character modifications to Stone Cold, which in the end didn't stick and didn't work. Despite Stone Cold's ability, his turn was a flop. He tried unsuccessfully playing the heel comedy role, merged with Triple H (briefly before his injury) and created the end of the live wrestling promo, the "What" chant. From 2001, Austin's career is muddled. His Alliance tenure was illogical at best. (Stone Cold chooses WCW, who fired him over WWF, who made him?) He has expressed in interviews that his idea of turning heel in 2001 was a mistake. No one wanted to boo Stone Cold Steve Austin. By 2002, the damage was done. Stone Cold's stock was down. The WWE was very well aware of this when they had him wrestle Scott Hall at Wrestlemania X8. Austin went from main-eventing every Wrestlemania (that he was healthy for) since 1998, to wrestling the third tier guy of a revamped out of place NWO. By the middle of 2002, Stone Cold had took his ball home over creative difficulties. The fact that he was asked to job to Brock Lesnar on TV with no warning/booking/plans showed what the management thought of Stone Cold in June 2002. His stock had fallen greatly. And this can all be traced back to his injury. Without missing 2000, Austin continues on his path of domination and popularity. Even if he eventually turned heel, it would be an earned turn, not a sudden one. Sadly, Austin's career ended with a whimper. Like many great stars before him, his injuries became too much and he retired fully in 2003. Austin just never reached back to the level he attained in 98/99. He is proof positive that injuries even a main event level talent can be adversely affected by a injury. Let's hope Sheamus and John Cena (he'll be fine) have better luck.