50 Ups & 50 Downs For WWE's Decade: The 2010s
A decade of decadence or destruction? It was the best of times, it was the worst of times...
Where to begin with this?
"2010, f*cking clown" you flippantly reply, but WWE's decade has been both shallow and seismic to such wild degrees that a chronological trek through the last ten years wouldn't really service this particular Ups and Downs meander.
At the start of the decade, the company tried and spectacularly failed to push seven wrestlers all at once, when just one of them getting over would have been enough. When that exploded into flames, they flatly refused to anoint a man destined to become the biggest star in the company, only to welcome his return from retirement with desperate glow several years later. In 2018, the company reached a new financial height whilst simultaneously sinking to an all-time ethical low. In 2019 they rectified it with three history-making WrestleMania title changes. Two of those reigns were almost entirely nullified by the way they concluded. And so it went.
All of the above will feature as well as a host of others - the 2010s was the decade WWE crystalised a move towards a cleaner cut product they'd been working towards years earlier, the decade their own Network completely reimagined a tried and tested business model, and the decade in which they alienated enough wrestlers and fans that an actual competitor could find a footing by its end.
It all happened, even when it felt like nothing was. The following list isn't entirely in order of least-to-most significant either, so please save that line of rage when you fire into the comments over what didn't make the cut. There were matches, moments and other miscellany to celebrate and commiserate - for the massive pops, there were just as many emotional and physical drops...
Downs...
50. Edge Retires
A devastating start to the decade for all the Edgeheads but something of a lucky escape for the 'Rated-R Superstar' himself, the forced medical retirement of then-World Champion Edge reduced crowds of a certain age to floods.
The obvious plus to the tear-soaked scene was that he'd done it on his own terms, and before he could damage his legacy - the unexpected news came immediately after a successful WrestleMania 27 World Heavyweight Championship defence against Alberto Del Rio. He didn't want to go, but at least he left on top.
49. The 2-Out-Of-3 Falls Era
A vintage Vince McMahon ratings paranoia edict brought forth to a 2019 in which he was panicked enough to hire both of his business rivals at the same time to run his two biggest shows, the Chairman's sudden belief that matches shouldn't happen during commercials resulted in one of the strangest periods in Raw history.
Each week, writers weren't tasked with coming up with storylines for wrestlers, but excuses for why matches suddenly came to a stop or reset point right before commercials. For the first time since Michael Cole started smashing us to pieces with it a decade earlier, Raw actually stopped "rolling on".
The lifting of the ban actually made Raw better, presumably so McMahon could lie and say it was the plan all along.
48. "Tater Tots"
There are countless examples from the past decade where Roman Reigns was scripted and booked to talk and act so impossibly annoying that it's amazing the company weren't aiming for rank polarisation from the very beginning.
The nadir of his microphone missteps came as he prepared to tackle Sheamus for the WWE Title at December 2015's TLC pay-per-view. Apparently no longer incensed by Sheamus' robbery of his prize at the culmination of Survivor Series' one-night tournament, Roman instead referred to the Irish star's genitals as "tater tots". Over and over and over and over again.
The promo itself was a torturous watch. Reigns smirking and chuckling at his own joke was excruciating, and as a star-making vehicle, it catastrophically failed the pair of them.
47. Triple H Vs Roman Reigns, WrestleMania 32
Triple H's charmless WrestleMania headliner against Roman Reigns was the third case of 'The Game' misunderstanding the rules of what made a match worthy of headlining the 'Show Of Shows'. At least it was his only one this decade.
A lumbering and formulaic brawl that didn't overtly expose Triple H against his youthful opponent, the match was the first of several headline horror-shows for Reigns on the company's Grandest Stage.
Chants for "NXT" and "Nakamura" from the knackered Dallas crowd informed the WWE Champion where audiences really wanted his full attention to be paid, but the infamous ego had yet again landed mid-ring on the biggest show of the year.
46. Breaking Bobby Lashley (Again)
Many of the Downs in this list reflect one of Dave Meltzer's best ever takes - Vince McMahon really has forgotten how to ride a bike. Only that can explain comprehensive failure to yet again make the best of Bobby Lashley.
The former ECW Champion only returned in April 2018, but in that time has been submerged by managers more over than he was, several wretched storylines and a turn that seemed to occur without anybody noticing.
Thanks to almost wilful neglect, it appears as though he'll fail for the second time on the main roster despite his separate stints being decades apart.
45. Brock Lesnar Vs Braun Strowman, No Mercy 2017
Joining a first time outing between Roman Reigns and John Cena in bolstering a B-show, Brock Lesnar's Universal Title defence against Brock Lesnar performed so turgidly as a show-closer that most fans felt as though the derivative term was exactly what they'd just seen.
Derailing one of the best pushes of the decade (presumably with permission from horrifically slapdash booking) Lesnar wasn't remotely a*sed about getting the 'Monster Among Men' over.
Strowman was reduced to a state of ordinary within minutes - nine of them in fact. That's how long it took for one of the decade's biggest breakout stars and (then) heavily protected performers to succumb to a single F5 after a selection of the usual of the usual. There can be fewer moments featuring behemoths to have left Vince McMahon feeling quite so underwhelmed.
44. Sasha Banks & Bayley: 2018
WWE have dropped the ball so many times with Sasha Banks and Bayley as babyfaces in 2018 that it was of little surprise that they'd both end the following year as heels.
The duo came to symbolise how little WWE actually cared about the entire women's division outside of an astonishing rooking year for Ronda Rousey and (eventually) catering to the rise of Becky Lynch. Because the NXT icons weren't in the WWE title picture, their hostilities were reduced to silliness echoing the doldrums of the divas division rather than some of the decade's best battles.
Between make-ups and break-ups, the pair were sent to soulless "counselling" sessions (as if competing against one another wasn't their actual job...) after a tacit tease of something beyond just friendship and eventual break-up was hurriedly dropped.
43. The House Of Horrors
It took just seconds of the hideous House Of Horrors match at Payback 2017 match for fans to feel the unease and terror Bray Wyatt had spoken of in the weeks leading up to the event, but catching glimpse of Randy Orton sporting school trousers in a catered limousine wasn't perhaps the ugliness the 'Eater Of Worlds' had foretold.
With that spooky start cast aside, the pair did battle in a grotty little cottage until it was time to end things...with a pinfall in the arena.
No stranger to looking a f*cking idiot and long beyond keeping up appearances, Bray cut an Onslow-like figure as he mindlessly grinned along in his mucky vest before realising Orton had somehow beat him back to the building. The remainder of the match was relentlessly rubbish, topped off by Jinder Mahal cheaply affording Wyatt a token win.
Was it even the worst of their series?
42. Bray Wyatt Vs Randy Orton, WrestleMania 33
No, this was.
Worse than the House Of Horrors because WWE dared to consider this worthy of being the 'Show Of Show's WWE Title match, Randy Orton may as well have put a bullet in Bray Wyatt's head when he dropped him with the single, match-winning RKO just before the ten minute mark. Or at least a punt for old times' sake.
A good feud that had gone badly off the rails at precisely the worst time, Randy and Bray's rivalry was exposed a the steaming pile it really was when giant insects projected themselves on the WrestleMania canvas just to get close to it.
All of this was just more spooky magic from busted flush Bray - a surefire low ebb for the character until an end-of-decade debacle trumped them all. But more on that later.