6 Things AEW Got Right About CM Punk's Debut

For once, let's talk about the good - and near perfection - in professional wrestling.

By Scott Carlson /

If you consider yourself a wrestling fan, this past weekend was enough to get you geeked for days. Surprises galore permeated the big two promotions in the United States, and fans have spent the subsequent days debating which was more impactful, and what each means for their respective company.

Advertisement

The most seismic of these debuts/returns saw CM Punk arrive in AEW, confirming weeks of increasingly strong rumors and blowing the roof off the United Center in Chicago. Punk was last seen on national TV in a wrestling ring in January 2014, though fans have incessantly chanted his name for the past seven years.

Punk’s formal return to wrestling has been imagined and fantasy-booked almost since the day he left WWE, so it’s only fitting that we take a look at the execution of the actual moment and see what AEW got right about it. Truthfully, it’s hard to envision a better-booked scenario – returning to join a hot, upstart promotion that fits his persona, in his hometown no less – but there are plenty of things that could have gone awry.

So let’s dive into CM Punk’s return to professional wrestling and for once, let’s talk about what went right. Let’s get to it…

6. Organic Buildup And Hints

While Becky Lynch and Brock Lesnar’s returns to WWE at SummerSlam this weekend were surprises, CM Punk’s appearance at AEW Rampage was anything but.

Advertisement

AEW and its personnel spent a couple months hyping the First Dance episode of Rampage, emanating from Chicago, as being a monumental show and moment for the young promotion. The hints were so overt that things reached the point that fans were expecting Punk to show up, and if he hadn’t – even if were someone like Byan Danielson – the response would have catastrophic.

Then you had stuff like Darby Allin calling out anyone who calls themselves the “Best in the World” in the lead-up, and more subtle hints like Kenny Omega wearing a T-shirt that simply read, “Chick Magnet.” If you were paying attention, there were enough breadcrumbs to make an entire loaf, and when Rampage opened and “Cult of Personality” hit, you were instantly rewarded for playing along these past several weeks.

That is what professional wrestling should be like. Genuine surprises are great, but sometimes providing fans with the expectation and then that little injection of serotonin are even better.

5. Genuinely Moved

CM Punk made a name for himself in WWE in 2011 with a somewhat bitter, anti-hero persona. The Voice of the Voiceless delivered a pipebomb promo that scorched the landscape and launched him into the upper echelon of the company.

Advertisement

He continued that mindset throughout the remainder of his run with the company – even as a babyface, he never really was a cheerful guy, always picking on authority figures and maintaining an edge. While that suited Punk well in WWE, it wasn’t what we got Friday night.

Punk arrived in AEW and seemed overwhelmed by the deafening reaction. He did a stage dive into the crowd and hugged fans. He smiled and even seemed to tear up a bit. He spoke in positive tones about re-entering the world of professional wrestling and excitement at working with various wrestlers. Punk was genuinely happy to be there and at the reaction he received.

Had Punk come out and delivered a pipebomb-style promo where he complained and griped about everything that had gone wrong, it would have diminished the moment and the energy in the building. Instead, he delivered a pitch-perfect promo.

4. Veiled WWE Callbacks

Of course, CM Punk’s first in-ring promo in seven-plus years had to have some pointed jabs, or else it wouldn’t have been a Punk promo.

Advertisement

Easily his most direct shot at WWE came early on when he apologized to fans for walking out of the company in 2014, saying that he was never going to get healthy physically, mentally, spiritually or emotionally staying in the place that got him sick in the first place.

Afterward, he asked if he could tell everyone a story. Punk then sat down cross-legged in the ring, which was a direct callback to his infamous pipebomb promo. He also talked about how he left “professional wrestling” when he departed Ring of Honor in 2005, and he returned to professional wrestling in 2021. The heavy implication was that WWE – as the company loves to point out – doesn’t do professional wrestling, they do “sports entertainment.”

And then Punk closed out his promo by offering the fans in attendance a free ice cream bar, which was an ongoing gag of his during his 2011 ascent in WWE. If you forgot, Punk regularly bugged Triple H and Vince McMahon about wanting them to bring back WWE ice cream bars, using it as a negotiating ploy a few times.

He never said “WWE,” but the callbacks were unmistakable, yet they didn’t bog down the promo.

3. Sold Future Appearances

Friday’s early ratings reveal a boon for AEW due to CM Punk’s return, but the promotion clearly is banking on the Second City Saint to do much more for them in the long run.

Advertisement

So it was a great sign early on when Punk told the crowd that he had plenty of time on his hands on Wednesdays, Fridays and four weekends each year to show up. He then announced his own appearance on this week’s upcoming episode of Dynamite, as well as set up a match between him and Darby Allin at All Out in two weeks.

Just like that, Punk told people to tune in on Wednesday night, and to make plans to buy the upcoming PPV. It wasn’t just about popping a rating Friday night, it was about setting the table for the future, and you knew right away that you needed to make plans to see what he has to say next week, and that you have a PPV to buy if you want to see his first match in seven-plus years.

2. Put Over New Talent

Let’s face facts: CM Punk was a main event-level superstar when he left WWE seven years ago. His stature has only grown since then.

Advertisement

So when he showed up on Rampage and name-dropped Britt Baker seconds into his AEW debut, you got the feeling that he was here to do more than just assume a position at the top of the card and feud with other top guys. Punk talked about all the young talent in the back who had the same passion he had when he was in Ring of Honor, then directly called out Darby Allin and challenged him to a match at All Out.

Punk could have referenced guys like Chris Jericho (and rekindled their 2012 feud), or gone after AEW Champion Kenny Omega, or targeted former WWE superstars and top guys Cody Rhodes, Christian and Jon Moxley. (Yes, we know all of them are otherwise involved, but the point remains.)

The bottom line is that Punk’s initial appearance wasn’t to declare his pursuit of the world title, but to wrestle a young and up-and-coming talent. That says a ton right off the bat, and it could bode really well for fans thirsting to see fun and fresh matchups.

1. Perfect Execution

Go ahead, we dare you: Find fault with CM Punk’s return to the wrestling ring. Find any issue with his AEW debut.

Advertisement

Punk’s appearance was handled top to bottom perfectly: from the build to the actual debut. Fans were whipped into a frenzy and then got exactly what they wanted. They got a purely joyful moment to just enjoy – not an overbooked mess that knocked someone else down a peg at Punk’s expense.

From the first strains of “Cult of Personality,” there was a wall of deafening cheers and chants for four minutes straight, up until Rampage cut to commercial. The cheers continued throughout his entire promo, with the entire segment lasting about 12 minutes. You can’t manufacture that kind of reaction.

Everyone has seen the video of the fan in tears, and if you’re mocking him, you’re what’s wrong with wrestling fans. That guy’s sheer emotion is the perfect representation of what happens when professional wrestling is done right. And CM Punk’s AEW debut was damn done right.

Now, let’s see what the future holds.

Advertisement