In May 2006 WWE announced a revival of the ECW brand. In response, .some wrestling fans rejoiced while others groaned. Itd been five years since the original Extreme Championship Wrestling filed for bankruptcy, but the legend of ECW had only grown larger in the interim. A significant part of that momentum was the success WWE's "The Rise and Fall of ECW documentary and subsequent massive interest in the ECW One Night Stand pay-per-view event. However, a new ECW could not be just nostalgia - the true art was not merely copying the original but attempting to reinvent the brand for a modern audience. Did they succeed? And also, from a financial, creative and popularity standpoint - which incarnation was more successful? This article will examine the wrestlenomics of ECW. It's a tale of two extremes.
6. History
The original ECW saga takes many twists and turns. ECW was the spiritual successor to Joel Goodharts Tri-State Wrestling Alliance out of Pennsylvania. ECW morphed from Tod Gordon-owned NWA affiliate Eastern Championship Wrestling to Paul Heyman-owned NWA title defacing Extreme Championship Wrestling. For the purposes of this piece, our focus is on the 1996 to 2001 Original ECW with a added emphasis on the August 1999-December 2000 ECW on TNN cable television deal when Extreme Championship Wrestling truly was a national pro-wrestling company. In 2006, WWE relaunched ECW on the SciFi channel (ECW: Extreme Championship Wrestling) with former owner and creative masterminds Paul Heyman again at the forefront. He wrote the scripts (along with others in the WWE Creative Team) and served as the on-air ECW Representative. The new TV show lasted nearly two hundred episodes on the SciFi (later SyFy) network running weekly from June 13, 2006 until February 16, 2010. However, it was Heyman himself who didnt even a first year. Following the disastrous reception to the new ECW's lone solo PPV "December to Dismember PPV, Heyman was booted off the creative team, removed as an on-air personality, and demoted to a role in the WWE developmental system. He left the company shortly thereafter. It was several years before Paul Heyman again reappeared on WWE television. In May 2012 he emerged as Brock Lesnars Legal Advisor. It's important to emphasize that attempting to compare the two ECW incarnations is quite difficult. The climate of professional wrestling changed so much in the interim. In the late 1990s, WWF and WCW engaged in a weekly ratings war. Raunchy, violent and sexy programming was in accepted and the products reflected that. Each behemoth was looking for the next big thing and lateral talent acquisitions (including signing/stealing wrestlers from ECW) was common. By contrast, by the middle of the 2000s, WWE stood alone as the global professional wrestling force. Most of the key players from the Attitude era (such as Steve Austin or The Rock) werent wrestling any more and it was clear that interest in pro-wrestling had peaked many years prior. UFC was the brand on the rise and WWE was just humming along with only TNA posing as weak competition.
5. Attendance
The rebooted ECW tried to run separate WWECW live events during the latter part of 2006. The fact it only lasted from late June to early November should say a lot about how the tertiary brand fared as a house show entity. In total, there was just 38 solo shows before WWE pulled the plug on ECW-only house show tours. They started in ECW's stronghold - June 24, 2006 the first ECW show was at the New Alhambra Arena (formerly been known as the ECW Arena). It was clear that touring just on nostalgia was going to be a lot harder than originally anticipated. After disappointing house show receipts, the idea of ECW as an independent touring brand was struck down. As WWEs 2006 annual report stated:
We produced 38 Extreme Championship Wrestling (ECW) branded events in the transition period which had an average attendance of 1,100 and an average ticket price of approximately $25.00. ECW events were held in smaller venues which generated lower attendance and revenues per event as compared to our Raw and SmackDown brands. Going forward, ECWs live events will be combined with SmackDown until the brand is large enough to tour independently.
Drawing over a thousand per show would be considered strong results for an independent organization, but not for a branch of the mighty WWE. By contrast, the original ECW grew from a regional promotion which drew about 600 per show (average attendance from about 40 annual shows) in 1994-1995 to 1,500 per show (average attendance from about 110 annual shows) in 1998-1999. In their final year, the promotion was drawing almost 2,000 per show (average attendance from about 60 annual shows). It's noteworthy that the company didn't collapse due to lack of audience and in fact, the original ECW outdrew the later incarnation as an independent touring brand. Still, while its clear that the original ECW drew more fans to their shows, its more fair to compare the promotional drawing strength against the other major players at the time. In the late 1990s, ECW was a distant number three promotion behind WWF and WCW. This was made abundently clear when from 1998 to 1999, the World Wrestling Federation averaged attendance over 10,000 for live events. Also during that same timeframe, World Championship Wrestling averaged attendance above 7,000 for live events (though the latter half of 1999 took a serious downturn). ECW shows drew rabid fans. However, they were only about 15% of WWFs average attendance and 20% of WCWs average attendance. In the mid 2000s, ECW was a pretend "division" of WWE. WWE's closest American rival for pro-wrestling was Dixie Carter's TNA. By 2006, TNA was often filling the Impact Zone at Universal Studios in Orlando, FL but that was for tv tapings with free admission. Under that model, drawing 900 people wasn't that impressive of a feat. By contrast, the ECW of 2006 appeared as a stronger live event draw than TNA of 2006. Still, ECW's 1,100/show average was not considered adequate for WWE standards when Raw & Smackdown or co-branded shows regularly drew an average of almost five times as much.
4. Television Ratings - ECW On TNN
Moving ECW to national television was a huge coup for Paul Heyman. ECW signed a three year contract with TNN (then The Nashville Network) and debuted during the last week of August 1999 as part of channel's "Friday Night Thrill Zone". Ironically, that the TNN contract was really actually ECW's death warrant. Unlike today's TV rights deals (where WWE earns hundreds of millions in total worldwide revenue for Raw & Smackdown and TNA surviving on life support via Spike's payments), ECW wasn't paid for their television product. Instead, ECW had to shoulder the cost (and upgrades) of the television production in exchange for the publicity that came with a national television deal. While ECW did get some control over the advertising time (and revenue) during their TNN show, that paled in comparison to the provisions in the contract which promised Viacom a portion of the future gross revenues that ECW earned and set baselines for minimum average ratings the 60-minute show needed to deliver. In his book about the rise and fall of the original ECW, Turning the Tables, British Wrestling Historian and Writer John Lister calculates that just to break-even, ECW would have needed to grow at least 30% in the post-TNN era. Going national was expensive and without a huge influx of cash, Heyman's already financially troubled situation was only getting worse. The uneasy alliance between CBS/Viacomm's TNN cable channel and Heyman's Extreme Championship Wrestling was consistently rocky. It wasn't like ECW had hidden their roots (the network had brought on board a famously violent and raunchy product), yet immediately it was evident that Paul Heyman's vision and TNN President David Hall's guidance were not in sync. The premise had been simple: Pro-wrestling was hot and TNN wanted the ratings. However, TNN was clearly not comfortable with what ECW aspired to be. This even evolved into a ECW storyline: Cyrus (Don Callis, WWF's The Jackyl) was the heel Network representative fighting against the filth of Paul Heyman's ECW. In one famous exchange, Heyman roundly denounced TNN in a long tirade which was the network wouldn't air (though loyal viewers could find the uncensored version on the ECW website). Heyman later complained that despite being the top rated TNN show the network never aired a commercial, held a press conference or paid for printed television advertisements to promote ECW on TNN. The network went as far to allegedly express great displeasure that the ECW themesong as being "too demonic". It's really no surprise the marriage couldn't last thee years. There were issues with talent depth as well - Shane Douglas joined WCW in July 1999; Bubba Ray & D-Von Duley joined WWF in August 1999; Taz also went to WWF soon after (which was a particular blow to ECW) and replacement champion Mike Awesome joined WCW in April 2000. This hurt a lot. While ECW tried to build new stars, the fresh talent in the final years of ECW (CW Anderson, Rhino, Yoshihiro Tajiri & Super Crazy, Simon Diamond, Steve Corino, Spanish Angel & Tony DeVito, Bo Dupp & Jack Dupp, Jazz, Chilly Willy and EZ Money) were hardly superstars on par with Taz, Sabu, RVD, Dudleyz or Shane Douglas. Instead, as TNN changed owners from CBS to Viacom, the cable channel attempted to rebrand as "The National Network". Viacom wanted TNN to grow in stature . Meanwhile, red hot WWF had grown discontent with their long-time partner - USA network. They were annoyed at Monday Night Raw pre-emptions for the Westminster Dog Show and US Open Tennis. After all, the Attitude era was exploding. Vince McMahon was negotiating from a place of strength and Viacom (who owned UPN where WWF Smackdown! had succesfully debuted as a second show) was wooing WWF to jump ship. A bidding war broke out and by the end, TNN had won the rights for WWF Monday Night Raw. Domestic TV rights quickly tripled from $11M to $31M. Raw's gain was ECW's loss. TNN cancelled ECW and the final episode aired on October 5, 2000 to record low ratings (0.6 rating). ECW on TNN only aired 59 episodes (19 episodes in 1999, 40 episodes in 2000) and their 0.94 average rating was well below the minimum threshold that TNN had established in their original contract. Now ECW didn't have a national television vehicle to promote their product. Financial problems continued to mount. To put that in context, during ECW on TNN's run, WWF Raw averaged a stunning 6.02 rating, WWF Smackdown averaged 4.64 rating, WWF Sunday Night Heat averaged 3.06 rating, WCW Monday Night Nitro averaged 2.93 rating and WCW Thunder averaged 2.25 rating. (As you may recall, there was a lot of weekly wrestling on television back then.) ECW on TNN's highest rated episode was on March 3, 2000 with only a 1.28 rating. ECW's average rating was about one-sixth of raw, one-fifth of smackdown, one-third of Heat & Nitro and half of Thunder. Friday night wasn't a great night for wrestling, but even taking that into account, ECW was a distant third for American Professional Wrestling supremacy. Without a television home, the omnious vultures circled ECW as they desperately tried to find a new television home. However, the other major cable networks were either not interested (Turner had it's own problems with WCW and certainly wasn't about to get expand their forray into the pro-wrestling game) or taken (Viacom had just won an expensive and litigious cable coup and planned to quickly load up both TNN and MTV with WWF programming). Heyman's best hope was convincing jilted lover USA Network that Extreme Championship Wrestling was their redemption - a sort of booby prize for losing Monday Night Raw. But USA's philosophy was simple - they wanted the best or nothing at all. And at this point it was abundantly clear that ECW was far from being the best. While Tommy Dreamer did manage to wrangle a bid from some small regional sports networks, Paul saw the writing on the wall and cashed in his chips. Their national expansion had failed and it was just a matter of time before the inevitable end.
3. Television Ratings - ECW On Sci-Fi
When McMahon decided to resurrect the ECW brand as a separate entity, Vince was conflicted. The excellent sales of the "Rise & Fall of ECW" DVD released in November 2004 and the success (and more importantly the massive internet buzz) that the original "ECW One Night Stand" produced in June 2005 convinced the WWE that they could make a go at an ECW revival. But Vince hates promoting things that he didn't create. News broke during the end of April 2006 that head honcho and "evil genius" Paul Heyman (who had been working in WWE's developmental territory OVW) had signed on alongside Tommy Dreamer to lead a team to restart the ECW brand. Former ECW stars were offered one-year deals (with options for extensions) and WWE developmental talent was evaluated at Ohio Valley and Deep South Wrestling. New bodies were being called up. Originally, WWE wanted a late-night, weekend timeslot on USA Network so they could produce an edgy ECW television program. What they ended up with was very different. Instead, it was a Tuesday night one-hour slot at 9 PM EST on the SciFi network. It wasn't a perfect fit. Still, it had to do. The show lasted several years - June 13, 2006 to February 16, 2010. While it only averaged 1.37 rating, it was significantly above the network's average rating. There was 193 episodes of ECW on SciFi (later ECW on SyFy). During that time, WWE's Monday Night Raw's averaged a 3.53 average, WWE Smackdown averaged a 2.30 rating and TNA Impact averaged a 1.05 average rating. At least this time ECW was beating some real competition. The experiment primed the pump for moving Smackdown to SyFy Network in October 2010. At the beginning of 2010, ECW ended (with talent redistributed to Raw & Smackdown) and NXT, a weekly "rookies" program, took over the slot. The rebooted incarnation of ECW was made up of a mixture former ECW stars, established older stars they didnt know what to do with and brand new talent. Arguably, the biggest star to come out of ECW was Heyman's pet project: CM Punk. However, the program also established new life for struggling wrestlers ranging from Ezekiel Jackson to Big Show to Miz & Morrison. It was always clearly positioned as a "C-level" brand, but it did provide excellent opportunity for introducing dozens of new wrestlers to the WWE audience. Former ECW Stars: Tommy Dreamer, Sabu, Rob Van Dam, Stevie Richards, Nunzio, The Sandman, Balls Mahoney Established Older Stars: Shelton Benjamin, Fit Finlay, Mark Henry, Christian, Kane, The Big Show, Chavo Guerrero Jr, Hardcore Holly, Matt Hardy, Test, Kurt Angle New Talent: Mike Knox, CM Punk, John Morrison, The Miz, Elijah Burke, Kevin Thorn, Evan Bourne, Zack Ryder, Matt Striker, Colin Delaney, Jack Swagger, Yoshi Tatsu, Paul Burchill, Vladimir Kozlov, Kofi Kingston, Tyson Kidd, Kelly Kelly, Layla, Ezekiel Jackson, Marcus Cor Von, Ricky Ortiz, Armando Estrada
2. Money
Among the premiere challenges for the original ECW was retaining their top talent. When you're the number three player, you're already at a disadvantage about attracting the hottest new talent. Additionally, ECW was stuck between two large (and cash-rich) companies in the middle of an expensive promotional war. As expected, it was exceptionally difficult to keep ECW stars from taking better contracts with WCW and WWF. Even when ECW went under, Eric Bischoff had big plans for ECW wrestler Rob Van Dam, ECW announcer Joey Styles and ECW manager Don Callis. He wanted them to join his revamped version of the WCW (should his consortium had bought the company - a business transaction that was halted once Turner cancelled WCW programming on their networks.) Throughout the late 90s, we saw wrestlers bouncing back and forth between companies. As revealed in the "Rise & Fall of ECW" DVD, at this time WWF was paying (and loaning) ECW some money. However, this amount has been greatly exaggerated over time to become "WWF was completely supporting ECW". That was never true. What is true is that WWF did pay Heyman as a "consultant "- but it was a nominal amount (about $1,000/week) which hardly kept the company afloat. In theory, this gave WWF the opportunity to have first crack at recruiting ECW talent. Also, WWF did use ECW as a sort of "development territory", especially for young talent they didn't have a place for - guys like Droz, Al Snow and even Brakkus worked some ECW shows while under WWF contract. At the very end of ECW, WWF did make a substantial "loan" to the company which they never really expected would be paid back. The purpose of this was to avoid a confrontation with Heyman over ECW losing their TNN timeslot when it was clear Viacom wanted WWF programming and also so WWF would have a claim to ECW assets when the company finally went under. It's an understatement to say that the original ECW had money troubles. ECW's bankruptcy filing lists $8.8M in debts with only $1.4M in assets. Numerous wrestlers were owed money ranging from small amounts ($300 for EZ Money, $500 for CW Anderson and members of the Baldies, $600 for Tony Mamaluke) to moderate amounts ($4,000 to Balls Mahoney, $5,000 for Bill Alphonso/Tajiri/Super Crazy, $7,990 for Justin Credible and $9,000 for Simon Diamond, $12,000 to Mikey Whipwreck) to significant amounts ($25,000 for Little Guido/Nunzio, $47,275 for Francine, $48,000 for Shane Douglas, $50,000 for Rhyno, $50,480 to Joey Styles) to enormous amounts ($100,000 to Tommy Dreamer and $150,000 for Rob Van Dam). To illustrate how inflated contracts grew in the late 1990s during the wrestling wars in the United States, here are some actual salaries and contract figures of ECW wrestlers who joined WCW and WWF: Stevie Richards - earned $30,000 from WCW in 1997 (he ended back in ECW shortly thereafter and then moved on to WWF) Mikey Whipwreck - earned $75,000 from WCW in 1999 Chris Candido - signed a contract with WCW to earn more than $104,000/year Each member of Public Enemy earning $160,000 (1997) to $175,000 (1998) in WCW (Public Enemy's exceptionally short-lived run with WWF was an example of how influential Heyman was at getting people to "buy the hype" of a smoke & mirrors tag team) Perry Saturn - earned $165,000 (1998) to $274,000 (1999) in WCW Raven - earned $120,000 (1997), $250,000 (1998), $190,000 (1999) from WCW; conversely, his WWF contract that begun in July 2000 (after ECW folded and it was clear WCW was dying) was just a minimum guarantee of $75,000 (Y1) /$150,000 (Y2) /$200,000 (Y3) Terry Funk - earnied about $4,000 per appearance in WCW in 2000 Shane Douglas - signed a contract with WCW to earn more than $350,000/year Mike Awesome - signed a contract with WCW to earn more than $350,000/year (was a very controversial departure) Bam Bam Bigelow - signed a contract with WCW to earn more than $400,000/year Sid Vicious - earned more than $800,000 per year from WCW (his ECW run was exceptionally short and expensive) Taz - signed a $250,000 per year with WWF after turning down a ECW offer for $308,000 per year (which was probably best for both companies because Heyman couldn't have paid him that much) The ECW of 2006-2009 was in a very different climate. The biggest American pro-wrestling challenger to WWE in 2006-2009 was TNA which hardly registers as a competitor to WWE. In fact, if anything ECW was competing with Raw & Smackdown for airtime, attention from creative, merchandise and talent. It's telling that ECW on SyFy was replaced with rookies programming NXT -- in many ways that's what the new ECW was, an opportunity for new wrestlers to develop their skills and make their name on WWE television.
1. Outcome
The lifetime of the original ECW greatly surpassed the reincarnated WWE version. From the landscape of talent (including so many future superstars ranging from Steve Austin, Mick Foley, Rey Mysterio, Eddie Guerrero, Chris Jericho to homegrown talents including Dudleyz, RVD, Sabu, Taz and Shane Douglas) to the innovative and modern television production, the original ECW was a huge breath of fresh air in the mid-1990s. Their violent, dark and unique wrestling style and tone would be copied by both WWF and WCW. Heyman loved building his company, but he also recognized when the battle was lost. It was too expensive and too difficult to be a number three national player, even during the wrestling boom. PPV and Video Game revenue took too long to be realized. The only lucrative pro-wrestling Television Rights were for highly rated programs that could sell advertising. ECW was stuck where their live events were too big to be small and too small to be big. They were rebels, but inevitably the expenses and excesses of running the company caught up with Heyman. While WWE generated millions off the ECW name and library (arguable ECW became profitable the day after the first One Night Stand PPV), their revamped brand never ascended to the heights of the original. It did provide a platform for new talent and an avenue for aging stars to reinvent their WWE personalities. However, it had a shelf life and once it ran it out, Vince pulled the plug. Even though ECW transformed from a reincarnation of the original to a brand new roster, there wasn't enough interest in keeping a third weekly TV show with their own storylines, performers and announcers. The relationship with SyFy network lives on (though Smackdown) and ECW proved that nostalgia will always get a big pop, but it's very hard to reshape that into a sustainable modern product. SELECTED BEST MATCHES Original ECW 1997-2001 4/13/1997 Great Sasuke, Gran Hamada and Masato Yakushuji vs. Men's Teoh, Dick Togo and Taka Michinoku 4/13/1997 Terry Funk vs. Sandman vs. Stevie Richards 8/17/1997 Shane Douglas vs. Sabu vs. Terry Funk 8/2/1998 Masato Tanaka vs. Mike Awesome 8/2/1998 Taz vs. Bam Bam Bigelow 1/10/1999 Yoshihiro Tajiri vs. Super Crazy 3/21/1999 Rob Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn 3/21/1999 Taz vs. Sabu 5/16/1999 Rob Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn 8/2/1999 Rob Van Dam and Jerry Lynn vs. Lance Storm and Justin Credible 9/10/1999 Rob Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn 9/19/1999 Justin Credible vs. Sabu 9/19/1999 Mike Awesome vs. Masato Tanaka vs. Taz 9/19/1999 Yoshihiro Tajiri vs. Super Crazy vs. Little Guido 11/7/1999 Jerry Lynn vs. Yoshihiro Tajiri vs. Super Crazy 11/7/1999 Mike Awesome vs. Masato Tanaka 12/31/99 Mike Awesome vs. Masato Tanaka 1/9/2000 Mike Awesome vs. Spike Dudley 5/14/2000 Jerry Lynn vs. Rob Van Dam 7/16/2000 Yoshihiro Tajiri vs. Little Guido vs. Psychosis vs. Mikey Whipwreck 10/1/2000 Jerry Lynn vs. Justin Credible 10/1/2000 Kid Kash vs. EZ Money 12/23/2000 Tajiri and Mikey Whipwreck vs. Super Crazy and Kid Kash New ECW (2006-2009) 6/12/05 Masato Tanaka vs. Mike Awesome (ECW ONS) 6/12/05 Sandman/Tommy Dreamer vs. Bubba Ray Dudley/D-Von Dudley (ECW ONS) 6/27/06 Kurt Angle vs. Rob Van Dam 9/26/06 Rob Van Dam vs. Hardcore Holly 10/3/06 Rob Van Dam vs. Test 12/17/06 Paul London/Brian Kendrick vs. Joey Mercury/Johnny Nitro vs. Jeff Hardy/Matt Hardy vs. Dave Taylor/William Regal (Ladder) 1/8/08 Jimmy Wang Yang/Shannon Moore vs. The Miz/John Morrison (15 Minutes of Fame) 7/22/08 Matt Hardy vs. Finlay vs. The Miz vs. John Morrison 2/24/09 Jack Swagger vs. Christian 3/10/09 Primo Colon vs. The Miz 4/14/09 John Morrison vs. Evan Bourne 6/2/09 Christian vs. Tyson Kidd 7/28/09 Christian vs. Zach Ryder 10/27/09 Christian vs. Yoshi Tatsu