6 Ups & 4 Downs For AEW Collision (Feb 10 - Results & Review)

While certain things didn't quite hit home, it was another week of solid in-ring work for Collision.

By Andrew Pollard /

AEW

Another week, another episode of AEW Collision in the books.

Advertisement

Much like most other weeks with AEW, this Collision was full of great in-ring work. The thing is, sometimes there needs to be a little more going on that just great ringwork. That said, there were some nice story advancements on this week's Saturday show, but other elements just don't seem to be clicking right now in that regard. Not least, because Collision so often feels so damn predictable.

On headline duties this time out, it was Orange Cassidy defending the AEW International Title against CHAOS buddy Tomohiro Ishii... because rankings matter, right? Elsewhere, champion and challenger were in action, as AEW Women's Champion Toni Storm and her Revolution challenger Deonna Purrazzo had singles bouts. Then there was the fun prospect of Mark Briscoe vs. Brody King, Daniel Garcia vs. Shane Taylor, and a sprinkling of CMLL stars with the Blackpool Combat Club taking on Star Jr. and Esfinge. We also can't forget a Brian Cage squash match that was simply there to advance his brewing story with former Team Taz cohort Hook.

Advertisement

A little more of a mixed bag than Collision usually is - at least for your writer's tastes - let's get to it.

As Elton John has long told us, Saturday night's alright for fighting...

Advertisement

Downs...

4. CMLL Invasion Still Fails To Click

AEW

From an in-ring standpoint, the matches involving CMLL talent so far have all been fairly decent; some - Bryan Danielson vs. Hechicero - even excellent. The problem is, why should we particularly care about the wrestlers of CMLL invading AEW just because?

Advertisement

Collision's opening match nicely summed things up. Jon Moxley & Claudio Castagnoli vs. Star Jr. & Esfinge was fine in terms of ringwork, with Star Jr. particularly shining. No amount of great in-ring work can solely be relied on to sell a wider story... when there's really been no wider story established.

Basically, Mox cut a promo a few weeks ago to put everyone on notice, and seemingly the stars of CMLL used that as an opportunity to somewhat 'invade' AEW and target the Blackpool Combat Club. That's about all we know right now - and even some of that knowledge is just assumption.

Advertisement

Wrestling fans don't always need things spelled out for them, but this supposed invasion from CMLL is so lukewarm in its current form. There's no real motive for CMLL so far, there's no real heat or animosity to any of this, and it feels like yet another case of Tony Khan using outside talent just because he can.

While it's so often fun and unique to see other promotions' stars appear in another company, it can become a little overdone when this 'unique' occurence stops being unique. And in the case of this current CMLL story, there's still no real juice behind it - regardless of how much Jon Moxley will bleed and offer to take on all-comers.

Advertisement

One also has to question how AEW's "open door policy" - as Kevin Kelly called it - can impact the excitement of shows like Forbidden Door. Is a door particularly Forbidden if it's open on such a regular basis?

3. Surprisingly Sluggish And More Questionable Officiating

Mark Briscoe is great. Brody King is great. Despite this, their singles match seemed to struggle to get properly going, with a lukewarm crowd response to most of the action bar the ever-popular chop sequences and the final few minutes.

Advertisement

Both Briscoe and King worked hard, of course, but it just felt there was something missing here to make the bout anything more than just 'okay'. Added to that, referee Rick Knock was infuriatingly bad on this one.

At one point, Brody dumped Briscoe into the guardrail, which led to a sequence where both opponents were outside the ring for just shy of two minutes. Not only did this not result in anything close to a count-out, but Knox didn't even start a one-count until after one minute; a one-count that just, basically, stopped at one.

Advertisement

It may sound picky, but hey, if watching a wrestling match with defined rules in place - as in, a ten-count outside the ring - then it's not asking a lot to just have such simple rules be adhered to. Also, how is Brody King putting Mark Briscoe through a table, as the ref watched on, not a DQ?

Some people may be able to look past such slack officiating, but for your writer, such frequent issues will forever take away from the enjoyment of a match.

Advertisement

2. So, Why Rankings?

Orange Cassidy vs. Tomohiro Ishii was an extremely solid match - more on that later - but how and why was this AEW International Title match even taking place?

Advertisement

AEW has recently brought back the rankings system as a way to make wins and losses matter, and for suitable championship challengers to be established based on their placement in these rankings.

Earlier in the show, we'd heard Adam Copeland outright state that his ranking position means he's earned a shot at either the TNT Title or the International Title due to having won four singles matches on the bounce. So, Copeland has grinded his way to a place where he's entitled to a crack at some championship gold? Fair enough.

Advertisement

With Tomohiro Ishii, he's not competed for AEW since June and his never won a singles match in his AEW appearances. By that logic, what has the obviously-brilliant Stone Pitbull done to warrant getting a shot at AEW gold?

Cassidy giving Ishii a title shot purely because they're CHAOS buddies is just absolutely nonsensical, for that negates the point of rankings entirely. Added to that, that AEW is still doing Proving Ground contests and Eliminator offerings... and the return of the rankings is currently feeling a little redundant in some cases. That's without even addressing the rankings listings themselves right now.

Advertisement

1. The Tired Feeling Of Predictability

AEW

Recent reports have suggested that the approach to AEW Collision is for established stars to face lesser-known names in a way that shines a smidge of spotlight on these lower-on-the-food-chain talents while also giving a W to the bigger name.

Advertisement

The problem is, AEW Collision has become an utterly predictable show. Yes, the in-ring action is usually good-to-great-to-excellent across the show's two hours, but Collision hasn't featured any real stakes or a sense of uncertainty about how things will go since the Continental Classic wrapped up.

If looking at this week's Collision card, only the Mark Briscoe vs. Brody King bout might have any even slight semblance of questions surrounding its result. And even then, AEW has positioned Briscoe as a spirited loser, as reflected by only two AEW singles wins in the past six months for Chicken; those coming against Jay Lethal and Jeff Jarrett. In a world so often filled with same-old, same-old, Mark Briscoe is a magnetically unique beast who stands from the pack and is such a phenomenal talent. Unfortunately, when you see someone lose time and again, you come to expect them to lose the next time they're in any match of note. In that regard, Brody was clearly expected to win here, and win he did.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, Jon Moxley & Claudio Castagnoli, Daniel Garcia, Brian Cage, Deonna Purrazzo, Toni Storm, and Orange Cassidy were all ridiculously predictable picks to score victories. While the wrestling action is clearly infinitely better and more competitive, AEW Collision nowadays effectively has the feel of a classic WWF Superstars or WCW Worldwide when it comes to guessing who'll win each and every match.

Ups...

6. FTR Vs. BCC? Yes, Please!

While Jon Moxley & Claudio Castagnoli vs. Star Jr. & Esfinge was just there, the post-match at least brought something hugely intriguing.

Of course, that post-match had Mox cut a promo where he essentially challenged any team to try and step up to the Blackpool Combat Club, and that any and all of those teams would be stepped on. That bold promise brought out FTR, with Dax Wilder and Cash Wheeler priding themselves on being regarded as the greatest tag team on the planet.

Advertisement

A heated off-mic verbal back-and-forth led to Moxley shoving Dax in the face, which obviously led to a brawl between the two tandems. Setting up Mox & Claudio vs. FTR is something that should catch the attention of any wrestling fan, and any such match-ups should be can't-miss bangers.

5. Daniel Garcia's Momentum Continues

AEW

Having finally dumped the buffoonish JAS schtick way behind him, the momentum of the refocused Daniel Garcia once again continued on AEW Collision, scoring a win over Shane Taylor.

Advertisement

As he's done in recent appearances, Taylor again impressed, with his slaps, sheer physicality, and agility always good to witness. But while the Shane Taylor Enterprises boss spent chunks of this bout on top, the story was clearly Garcia.

If Red Death wasn't showcasing his fantastic technical prowess - in particular targeting the legs of Taylor - he was showing gritted determination to keep fighting back against the power and brutality that Shane Taylor brings to the table. This was Garcia again overcoming supposed odds, establishing himself as a serious player and keeping himself in the conversation for a shot at Christian Cage's TNT Title.

Advertisement

Also, a shoutout to Garcia's great fakeout punch, which then saw him hit Taylor with a low dropkick. Da iawn!

Where the finish is concerned, the knee bar was enough for Danny to get the submission win and move on to something next Wednesday. More on that later.

Advertisement

4. Solid Continuation For Brian Cage And Hook

Brian Cage in a handicap match against a couple of no-hopers like the Outrunners would usually be pretty much a waste of time. However, this whole segment was a pretty darn entertaining one, for a number of reasons.

Advertisement

Aside from the Machine squashing Truth Magnum and Turbo Floyd in barely a minute, Golden Knights' mascot Chance doing the dance with Prince Nana was way more fun than it had any right to be. Of course, the party was brought to a crashing halt as Cage put a beating on Chance, which then led to Hook making the save.

As Hook and his former Team Taz buddy brawled up the ramp and to the back, the clear and obvious message was Cage being the dominant, bigger, stronger man, while Hook refused to stay down and kept getting back up to scrappily take it to the Mogul Embassy powerhouse.

Advertisement

Simple, effective, and nicely keeps things chugging along ahead of Brian Cage getting a shot at Hook's FTW Title.

3. Great Stuff All Around

With Adam Copeland having some mic time again here, the Rated-R Superstar didn't disappoint. But this segment wasn't just about Copeland, nor his quest to beat Christian Cage.

Advertisement

Firstly, the 11-time World Champion sowed the seed for something down the line with the Young Bucks, explaining how what Nicholas and Matthew did to Sting and Darby Allin wouldn't have happened on his watch. On top of that, Copeland referenced Eddie Kingston and his Triple Crown, stating how he absolutely wants to face the Mad King somewhere down the line.

The Canadian was then interrupted by Daniel Garcia, who clearly has his own sights on Christian Cage. As such, Garcia and Copeland are in each other's way of getting to the TNT Title. While there was a mutual respect between these two babyfaces, the chemistry between them felt extremely promising, solely from their verbal exchange and body language.

Advertisement

For Garcia, he openly talked about his doubt at "pulling a Daniel Garcia" and coming up short in the big match, as has happened many times previously. Still, he's always prepared to continue to bet on himself, dust himself down, and do it all again.

Where Adam Copeland is concerned, he talked fondly of Red Death, noting how FTR - two close friends of Copeland's, who've also recently teamed with Garcia - spoke highly of him. The respect of Dax and Cash is enough for the one-time Edge to have respect for the former JAS man.

Advertisement

This segment ended with a stern handshake, and Copeland letting Garcia know that the only reason he hasn't ripped Danny's face off tonight, is because the New Yorker had already competed earlier in the show. Still, it's very much on next week, as Adam Copeland views Daniel Garcia as wanting to take food off his family's table. Obviously, because the multi-millionaire Copeland family are clearly strapped for cash and can barely keep the lights on...

All of this was great from top to bottom, with the segment immediately followed by the official announcement of Copeland vs. Garcia for next week - with the winner getting that shot at Christian Cage.

Advertisement

2. Nice Showcase For Champion And Challenger

It absolutely remains a breath of fresh air for AEW Collision to feature more than just one women's match per episode, and hopefully that's something that remains in place for the foreseeable future. And this week, Collision's two ladies bouts served to nicely highlight both the champion and challenger ahead of the AEW Women's Title match at Revolution next month.

First up, Deonna Purrazzo got herself a very comfortable win over Kiera Hogan, getting the verbal tapout with the ever-impressive Venus de Milo. Obviously, this bout was simply here to make the Virtuosa look like a top-tier challenger ahead of facing Toni Storm at Revolution. As such, it was fairly basic, relatively one-sided, and did exactly what it needed to do.

Advertisement

As soon as Purrazzo made her way to the back, though, she was passed by Timeless Toni, Luther, and Mariah May as they made their way to the ring for Storm vs. Queen Aminata. This one was a smidge more competitive than Purrazzo vs. Hogan, and a few minutes longer, but Toni did get to show some great aggression, making it feel as if she's trying to hammer home a message to Deonna.

Aminata may have got a little too much offense here for some, but she was eventually put away with the Storm Zero, before Toni then announced the premiere of her latest movie, Wet Ink, for next week's Dynamite.

Advertisement

Any frequent readers of the Collision Ups & Downs will have seen plentiful calls for AEW to sign Queen Aminata, and those calls won't be going away any time soon. However, Animinata is in a somewhat tricky place right now, where she forever impresses with each subsequent AEW outing, yet her not being under contract with the promotion means she's unlikely to be given any notable wins - as shown by her AEW TV record being eight losses from eight matches.

If Queen Aminata is to be taken seriously, she simply can't keep losing each and every week. Get her signed, get her some wins, and AEW will have a hugely promising talent on its hands.

Advertisement

1. Title Shot Aside, A Nicely Worked Main Event

While I'll happily whine and moan about Tomohiro Ishii getting an AEW International Championship shot at a time when focus has been put on the returned rankings system, that's not to say that Ishii and Orange Cassidy didn't put on a brutal, brilliant main event.

As is always the case with Ishii, he laid everything in thick, with Freshly Squeezed his usual great sell job when taking such offense. One particular highlight saw Cassidy take some heavy hits from the Stone Pitbull, firing himself up to make the big comeback, just to collapse to the mat as a mildly concerned Ishii looked on.

Advertisement

For those who don't like Orange Cassidy's particular form of pro wrestling, they'll have likely cringed at several points here. For the rest of us, you can't help but raise a smile at spots such as Ishii hitting OC so hard that Cassidy's hands came out of his pockets. Daft? Absolutely. Entertaining? Absolutely.

This played out in a similar fashion to other Orange matches against opponents in the mould of Tomohiro Ishii - though, really, who is built from the same mould as Ishii? - where he spends the first half of the contest battered, before using his smarts and familiar tricks to eventually gain an advantage over that opponent. In terms of that advantage, after Ishii had survived the Orange Punch and the Beach Break, it was a small package from Cassidy that got the 1-2-3.

Advertisement

Post-match, the Undisputed Kingdom attacked Orange, and Ishii made the save, bringing an end to a Collision that was fairly solid throughout in terms of ring work, but one that maybe fell a little flat at points.