6 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw (6 Nov - Results & Review)
New title challengers emerge, WarGames match set up during inoffensive show.
Those looking to sum up this week’s episode of WWE Raw in one word can probably agree on this one: inoffensive.
WWE delivered a show highlighted by an enjoyable world title main event the gave way to setting up a WarGames match for Survivor Series. But Raw also named a new Intercontinental Championship challenger in a completely flubbed manner, overshadowing a perfectly decent match. The next Women’s World Championship challenger had a nice crowning moment Monday night, but it was on the back end of a boring and forgettable battle royal.
The company that can successfully book Ivy Nile’s in-ring Raw debut during a dismal battle royal also then booked Nikki Cross to stand in the ring like a zombie during the same match. They continue to set Chad Gable up for success, but they do it by having comedy jobber Akira Tozawa suddenly trying to be taken seriously (or is he?).
At this stage, it’s not enough to just deliver good matches – any major wrestling promotion in 2023 should be able to produce entertaining in-ring action given the available talent. There needs to be compelling, relatable stories that make you want to tune in, that drive the action in the ring.
WWE has seemingly opted for inoffensive programming. The horribly dire shows of yesteryear are in the past, but eventually, that’s not going to be enough. Even when there are more positives, the absence of negatives doesn’t mean it’s a great show.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
5. Comedy Or Serious?
How are fans supposed to receive Akira Tozawa?
For years, Tozawa has been nothing more than a comedy character, decked out in ninja garb and chasing the 24/7 Championship. Triple H ditched the vaguely offensive gimmick, but Akira still has been little more than a background character played for “laughs” in backstage segments. Now, he’s Alpha Academy’s latest project, a goof in a T-shirt six sizes too large.
Monday, Tozawa faced Shinsuke Nakamura in what was pretty much guaranteed to be a massacre. And then Akira hit a small flurry of offense and reversed a Kinshasa attempt into a rollup, reminding longtime fans that this guy actually is extremely skilled… and then he got waffled with a Kinshasa and was put down.
Whatever WWE was going for here, it didn’t quite work. If this is a buildup to Nakamura facing Chad Gable – and with Otis facing Shinsuke next week, that seems to be the case – that could be great, but Tozawa’s mini-arc here just fell flat. And he’s supposed to have an NXT Heritage Cup match Tuesday night. Great way to build that match.
4. Where Does New Day Go From Here?
It doesn’t matter how often Michael Cole refers to the New Day as one of the most decorated tag teams in WWE history. If Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods are beaten multiple times, that legacy loses its luster and beating them means about as much as anyone toppling former WWE Champion Jinder Mahal.
Kingston and Woods lost to Judgment Day in a non-title match Monday night, a result that previously would have felt like a bigger deal, but in 2023, it might as well have been the Brawling Brutes or the LWO who were defeated.
The two New Day members lost their singles feud(s) with Ivar, which was a good way to put the Viking Raider on the map as a solo act, but after beating Alpha Academy a couple of weeks ago, they came out Monday and lost a pretty average match to the tag champs. There was no fanfare, no hype, no glitz to it.
Sadly, New Day might just be in that rut where they’re a popular act, but fans aren’t living and dying by how they fare as a tag team. They’re still fantastic wrestlers, so hopefully WWE has plans for them, because sending them out to lose when the division has several really solid teams is a scary proposition.
3. ‘Let’s Go Miz!’
Far be it for one fan/critic to call out other fans, but are people really chanting for Miz as a babyface in 2023?
The near-parody act who comes out and reads his Wikipedia page of accomplishments every week – to the point where Adam Pearce mocked that fact recently – is suddenly “serious” and wants to be treated as a legit threat to the Intercontinental Championship. In 2023.
Miz won the fatal four-way (more on that later) to become number one contender to Gunther’s title, pinning Bronson Reed after he missed a Tsunami. Yes, Miz pinned a guy who has been booked as a monster heel after Reed simply missed a top-rope splash. But he hit a springboard crossbody and a satellite DDT, so he clearly is a babyface worth cheering.
Longtime fans have seen this before: Miz busts out a small arsenal of higher-risk moves that surprise fans because of his generic and repetitive offense, and crowds react like he’s suddenly moved into a workrate zone. The sheen wears off after a bit and he’s back to diminishing reactions until he turns heel again and reads his list of accomplishments weekly.
Miz as a midcard title challenger-of-the-month isn’t a bad idea. But he shouldn’t be anything more than a speedbump, not someone built up as the guy, no matter what his CV says.
2. A Mostly Dull Affair
Fans should be forgiven if they fell asleep during the third hour of Raw watching the women’s battle royal.
The match was mostly filled with your typical battle royal tropes of women pairing off and fighting in the corners, leaning on the ropes, gently pushing someone onto the apron and then inexplicably meandering around the ring without making sure they had actually eliminated the wrestler.
Oh, and the Nikki Cross routine was just more bad “comedy” from WWE, as fans are supposed to care about the former near-superhero reverting to a character whose time had come and gone more than five years ago.
Things would pick up a bit late in the match, but by the time it got interesting, the match had already cured insomnia.
1. What A Four-Way Mess
The fatal four-way match to determine Gunther’s next challenger for his Intercontinental Championship was steaming along really nicely Monday night, looking like an easy guilty pleasure.
And then the last 20 seconds happened.
With Ricochet and Miz laid out, Ivar and Bronson Reed started climbing the turnbuckles to deliver knockout blows, pointing at each other the whole time. Ivar nailed Ricochet with a moonsault, while Miz evaded Reed’s Tsunami. Ivar and Miz covered their men… and Miz got a three count, while Ricochet kicked out.
And then it got worse.
The referee tried to wave off the pinfall and looked to tell Samantha Irvin to not announce Miz as the winner, which she did anyway. It was clunky, messy and just bad. The result didn’t even make sense logistically, with a monster like Reed getting pinned off a missed splash while Ricochet kicked out of being flattened by a 350-pound moonsault.
Just a horrible mess that completely undercut any goodwill built up during the match.
UPS…
6. Xia Li Picks Her Spot
Last week’s debacle involving Xia Li knocking Candice LeRae out was more about the execution, not the idea itself. The idea that she had a killshot in her arsenal was a sound one – it just looked clunky and awkward last week.
Monday night, however, Li made up for it by jumping the target of her rage, Becky Lynch. Xia attacked The Man outside the ring before the women’s battle royal, taking her out with that tornado kick and knocking her out of the match to crown a new number one contender. Li clearly was still miffed at being overlooked as a challenger for the NXT Women’s Championship when Becky was parading around with and defending it against several women on the Raw and NXT rosters.
The attack sets up a rivalry that could actually elevate Xia if done properly. Lynch certainly has seemed to relish the role of bringing along younger and newer wrestlers, so while last week’s match was a dud, this attack does pique some interest.
5. A Solid Debut For Ivy
The proverbial diamond in the rough of the women’s battle royal had to be Ivy Nile, who had her first main roster match Monday night.
Nile was always the longest of long shots to win the battle royal, but she acquitted herself well, eliminating both Kayden Carter and Katana Chance after battling both women on the apron, booting one and pressing the other to the floor in impressive fashion. She also managed to bump Natalya out of the match later on.
Ivy’s most notable part came when she went right at Nia Jax with strikes, showing some fire and fearlessness. Her night came to a close when an already-eliminated Jax pulled Nile off the apron, but it still was a solid showing for the rookie. And if her first feud is with Nia, that could be interesting… or it could be a disaster.
But for now, hats off to Ivy Nile in her Raw debut.
4. #DIY, Creeds Put In Work
When the match between the Creed Brothers and #DIY was announced, it felt like one team was going to get the short shrift, or worse, the match itself was going to play out to silence.
Thankfully, both teams worked hard to pull the fans into the contest, with a series of false finishes at the end leaving you guessing which of the two teams on the ascent was going to falter. It turned out that Ludwig Kaiser played a pivotal role, getting revenge for Imperium’s loss last week by booting Johnny Gargano and sending #DIY to defeat.
The match wasn’t a classic or anywhere on par with what one would think these four would be capable of delivering, but it was a solid little TV match that further established the Creeds as a team to watch, while setting up a return match between #DIY and Imperium, which could be fun if given some time.
Now, if Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa are still spinning their wheels with Kaiser and Giovanni Vinci in another month, this is going to have aged poorly.
3. Stark Gets Her Moment
Zoey Stark has all the qualities and tools needed to be successful in WWE, so it was satisfying to see her take a step forward Monday night.
Stark won a battle royal on Raw to become number one contender for the Women’s World Championship, setting up a title match against Rhea Ripley at Survivor Series. Zoey has come a long way from a lackluster debut, to being Trish Stratus’ lackey (which admittedly wasn’t a bad move), to striking out on her own while in an alliance with Shayna Baszler, whom she eliminated last on Monday.
WWE would do well to further establish Stark’s character and show her personality to the fans, but if she and Ripley get the time during the next couple of weeks and then during the PLE, she could accomplish all of that. Stark did a nice job in a backstage promo later in the show when she told Ripley to hold onto the title “nice and tight” until Survivor Series.
No one is holding their breath that Zoey will unseat Rhea, but this still is a pretty good call.
2. ‘WarGames!’
For fans who have been paying attention for the past couple of months, Monday night’s announcement of the men’s WarGames match should have come as no surprise.
The Judgment Day has been embroiled in a battle with several Raw wrestlers consistently for a while now, and wild brawls have punctuated the show several times this fall. It boiled over Monday night when the foursome battled at ringside with Seth Rollins, Sami Zayn, Jey Uso and Cody Rhodes.
All that was missing was the official announcement, which Adam Pearce provided after expressing exasperation at the constant mayhem. It wasn’t on the level of William Regal, but it still fired up the crowd, and that’s really all anyone could ask for here.
Besides that, the match should be fantastic, especially if they find a way to batter Dominik Mysterio for a good while. And there’s the added wrinkle of the World Heavyweight Champion and Money in the Bank briefcase holder being in the same match, which could raise an interesting angle if WWE were so inclined…
1. Babyfaces Doing Babyface Things
For the longest time, WWE was the promotion where babyfaces didn’t act like the virtuous characters one would expect, leaving fans confused and often unable to rally behind the supposed heroes.
That’s why the opening segment on Raw was such a refreshing one for WWE, as the company got things mostly right with World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins and Sami Zayn. Rollins came out and thanked his Crown Jewel opponent Drew McIntyre for giving him a spirited fight and for doing it the right way. He then called out Zayn.
Seth told Sami that he appreciated him chasing off Damian Priest and thwarting his attempted Money in the Bank cash-in. He rewarded that act – even though it wasn’t about protecting Rollins’ title – by offering Zayn a World Heavyweight Championship match whenever he wanted it. Sami tried to be virtuous again in demurring because Rollins is so beat up, and Seth upped the ante by noting that no one in their situation is ever 100%.
It was a game of one-upmanship between two babyfaces just being good guys, and the fans dug it. There was just one quibble: Zayn ultimately called for the match later in the night, which ran counter to his entire argument that he didn’t want to face a champ who was compromised. Considering McIntyre waited several weeks until Crown Jewel, why wouldn’t Sami give Rollins three weeks to heal up and face him at Survivor Series?