6 Ups & 8 Downs From AEW Dark (Oct 13)

14 matches in just under two hours? Exalted One, have mercy...

By Andy H Murray /

AEW

When approaching any episode of AEW Dark, it's important to remember what the web series actually is.

Advertisement

This isn't presented as a Dynamite-calibre broadcast with intertwining storylines, several high-level matches, and TNT's gloss and sheen. It rarely hits a theoretical rating higher than 7/10 because it doesn't aspire to. Sure, Dark serves up many a fun squash, and its more competitive bouts often edge towards television quality, but the brand's primary function is to open doors for wrestlers who aren't making Dynamite every week, provide AEW's less experienced wrestlers with valuable reps, and assess enhancement talents in pseudo tryouts.

To that end, it works. Viewers learn to accept the show's low ceiling and alter their expectations accordingly. Grading it like Dynamite is pointless because you end up holding Dark to a standard it isn't trying to hit, so it's wise to forgive certain flaws - for your own benefit.

Advertisement

Still, the show has a duty to provide something worth your time. It doesn't get a free pass, even as a developmental brand, and 14 matches across close to two hours of largely the same thing? That's too much.

Ricky Starks, Eddie Kingston, The Lucha Brothers, and Darby Allin were among the wrestlers highlighted on this bumper episode. Let's light the overlong fuse...

Advertisement

Downs...

8. The Dark Order vs. Aaron Solow, Angel Fashion & M'Badu

AEW

The Dark Order was represented by John Silver, Alex Reynolds, and Preston Vance here. Silver had his head bandaged up after getting busted open during Brodie Lee's match with Cody last week. A nice touch, particularly as this bout may have been taped before the TNT Title clash.

Advertisement

This was a pure record-padder. The Dark Order unit is talented and Solow is a fun jobber, but there wasn't much meat on the bout's bones and the tags came too thick and fast for anyone to truly standout. Indeed, the finish was the highlight, with Reynolds and Vance hoisting Solow up and Silver diving into his legs, flipping Aaron down for the pinfall.

7. Eddie Kingston vs. Baron Black

AEW

Eddie Kingston took Baron Black on a quick trip down the King's Road in the main event. It was fine, and certainly not bad, but a textbook Dark pseudo squash with the enhancement guy getting a slither of offense in before falling. This time, Black was put away via standing front chancery.

Advertisement

Kingston completionists will enjoy watching 'The Mad King' working his opponent over. Otherwise, skip this.

6. Colt Cabana vs. Griff Garrison

AEW

Evil Uno was overbearing at ringside as Colt Cabana wrestled Griff Garrison. The ongoing storyline is that he is trying to coach Cabana through his matches, sculpting him into a better fit for the Dark Order, with middling success. That was in play here, with Uno constantly encouraging his charge from the ramp.

Advertisement

This story already feels like it's growing long in the tooth. Cabana needs some kind of serious character development before it becomes interesting again, though he was able to score the victory via Billy Goat Curse submission. This came in a match dominated by Uno's presence.

If you're still invested in what's going on with these guys, you probably got more out of the match than your writer.

Advertisement

5. Joey Janela vs. D3

AEW

The highlight of this match was literally D3's wacky Roman headrest almost falling off his head while he made his entrance. Otherwise, this was a basic Dark-style match with several competitive spells, leading towards the inevitable Janela victory.

Advertisement

Again, nothing bad here, but you've seen dozens of these before. Skip.

4. Darby Allin vs. Nick Comoroto

AEW

Comoroto is fresh out of WWE, where he trained in the Performance Center as Nick Ogarelli. He's a big, imposing dude with a great look and dwarfed Darby Allin with his caveman vibes, though his arsenal appears to consist solely of basic big man offense. A shame, as AEW could use another hoss or two, though there wasn't really anything notable about his control segments.

Advertisement

Allin entered a good bumping and selling performance, eventually firing back to take the win via Coffin Drop. Afterwards, he hit the commentary booth and jumped Ricky Starks, brawling until a gang of officials split them up. That story continues.

3. Gunn Club vs. Ryzin & Maxx Stardom

AEW

A Gunn Club squash is a Gunn Club squash is a Gunn Club squash.

Advertisement

Austin is out there getting valuable, necessary experience, while Billy is cutting loose and playing the hits from his peak years. The bouts are fine, but rarely is the fun that father and son are clearly having reflected in the viewing experience.

Stardom at the Quickdraw for the loss. Skip.

Advertisement

2. Red Velvet vs. Elayna Black

AEW

This was Red Velvet's first AEW win, and it appears that the (former?) enhancement talent is growing into a bigger role in Jacksonville. Currently embroiled in a storyline pitting her and Brandi Rhodes against Anna Jay and Tay Conti, there are signs that the promotion plans on doing something with her, and it wouldn't be a huge surprise to see a "Red Velvet is All Elite' banner appear on Twitter before long.

Advertisement

Nonetheless, this was another basic Dark match. Black looks a solid wrestler and is likely worth another shot, though the basic, repetitive layout renders this a pass, particularly as the only storyline development came from Rhodes in the announce booth. There was no sign of Tay or Conti.

1. Brandon Cutler vs. Peter Avalon

AEW

Brandon Cutler and Peter Avalon's last singles match ended in a double countout, which is perfect for their story. These dudes literally cannot win, even one-on-one, so what else would you book other than a double countout? A double disqualification, apparently, which is what we got here.

Advertisement

The first match was good. This one, unfortunately, was overbooked to hell. Avalon jumped Cutler during his entrance then got on the microphone, demanding he be declared the winner because his opponent couldn't answer. This happened twice before we got some actual wrestling, broken up by more bullsh*t in the form of Leva Bates preventing Cutler from using his wacky dice as a weapon, until Cutler hit Avalon with a book while the 'Librarian' blasted him with said dice. Boom, double DQ.

Let's get to the inevitable No DQ match. This story is losing its legs thanks to overly staged stuff like this.

Advertisement

Ups...

6. Lucha Brothers vs. Cezar Bononi & Lee Johnson

AEW

This was worth watching primarily for the performance of Cezar Bononi, who finally showed glimpses of what he might be capable of doing in this, his third AEW outing.

Advertisement

Bononi looked decent against the Lucha Brothers, hossing both around with his significant size and strength advantage. We saw only a few dashes of this, admittedly, but that's more than we've had in past outings and he didn't put a foot wrong, with elite Dark enhancement talent Lee Johnson putting a good shift in as well.

A nasty-looking Bononi Powerslam into the corner was the highlight, though it was Johnson who took the pinfall. From here, it'd be cool to see what Cezar can do in a singles bout.

Advertisement

5. Nyla Rose vs. KiLynn King

AEW

A fired-up KiLynn King promo saw the enhancement wrestler claiming Nyla Rose jumping here from behind made her look like a coward, vowing to stand her ground after proving herself as somebody the former Women's Champion couldn't throw around in their previous bout.

Advertisement

This turned out to be kinda hilarious, really, as King was trucked by Rose despite starting hot. 'The Native Beast' had little trouble aside from a few offensive spurts, beating King up for about a minute before putting her away via Beast Bomb.

The squash was solid - as was Vickie Guerrero's post-match promo. Tired of being put to the side in favour of other wrestlers, Guerrero said Rose wouldn't wrestle again until Hikaru Shida answered her challenge. This makes sense as it feels like Nyla has been number one in the rankings for months.

Advertisement

4. Wardlow vs. Elijah Dean

AEW

Wardlow's squashes are always cool because we don't see a lot of him. There's something of a novelty factor to his work and he isn't even close to becoming oversaturated, meaning all he needs to do his hit the ring, work a couple of his sick power spots, and get out.

Advertisement

That's exactly what he did against Elijah Dean, who was soundly defeated. Wardlow didn't even have to hit the F10 putting him away, instead going to the drop-down corner knee we've seen a few times before, knocking Elijah out in an instant.

Another W for one of the most intriguing prospects in the promotion.

Advertisement

3. Ricky Starks vs. Fuego Del Sol

AEW

Starks feels like a different level of star to everyone else on Dark, and not just because Taz puts him over as one on commentary. There's a different charisma to him. Even in an empty building, he feels ten feet tall, and he was presented as being in a different league to Fuego Del Sol here.

Advertisement

A bullying performance had Starks in complete control for the bulk of it, whether bulling Fuego around the ring, flexing his skill, talking smack, or generally being a d*ck. Sauntering by the announce desk after beating his opponent up on the outside, Starks eventually returned to the ring and won with the Roshambo.

There isn't a universe that exists in which Starks doesn't soon become a massive, massive star in AEW.

Advertisement

2. Matt Sydal vs. Sonny Kiss

AEW

Sonny's pre-match promo saw him call this a chance to show that he is just as adept in singles matches as tags, going up against a generational high-flyer in Matt Sydal. Kiss entered a strong performance. Though he was dropped on his head with what looked like a misjudged Sidewalk Slam, his defensive work was strong, his comebacks well-timed, and his nearfalls believable.

Advertisement

Missing the split leg drop from the second rope proved fatal for 'The Concrete Rose,' who was put away with modified Cobra Clutch soon after. A light, breezy encounter with solid action, and an easy Up on a show like this.

1. Jungle Boy vs. Frankie Kazarian vs. Evil Uno vs. The Blade

AEW

This felt like a hybrid of a standard WWE two-in/two/out Fatal Four Way and one of those wild multi-man scrambles you see on every modern indie card. It was a lot of fun, with fast, fluid exchanges, plenty of shine for everybody, and no real fat, as the wrestlers maximised their minutes in an opener that should probably have headlined.

Advertisement

Evil Uno had the standout performance. One big, heelish moment saw him unravel his wrist tape as a weapon, only for it to be confiscated by the referee. He used this distraction to unravel more tape and finally score the advantage. Whether levelling up with snappy offense or acting the d*ckhead, he put in a good showing.

Jungle Boy ended up pinning The Dark Order man in a moment of quick thinking. A huge brawl broke out afterwards, with The Butcher, other Dark Order Members, Christopher Daniels, and Marko Stunt getting involved, culminating in Luchasaurus wrecking every heel with his big kicks.

Advertisement