6 Ups And 11 Downs From WWE Crown Jewel

An epic disaster: Shane's 'Best in the World,' Brock's champ, Braun's buried.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

WWE held a PPV Friday that was so rotten that you could smell it halfway around the world from wherever it was being held.

Advertisement

Well, we all know where it was being held, but WWE sure as hell wasn’t telling us. It might have been better for the wrestling world if the company’s secrecy about what country had lined their pockets extended to the entire event being kept under wraps, like the tournament in Rio de Janeiro to crown the first Intercontinental Champion.

Crown Jewel was an embarrassment on many levels. It was difficult to watch as wrestlers went through the motions much like they would at a house show with 1,500 locals. Only this time, it was in front of tens of thousands of attendees and broadcast on the WWE Network. Those who watched saw old people dominate the show, with a tag team main event that was longer than all four first-round matches of the World Cup tournament.

Advertisement

Throw in some seriously questionable decision-making regarding the two world titles and a non-wrestler winning a wrestling tournament he wasn’t even entered in, and you’ve got a really bad trainwreck of a show. It’ll be best if this event is forgotten and never spoken of again.

With that said, let’s find out what was modestly decent and what was dismal as hell. Let’s get to it…

Advertisement

Downs...

11. WrestleMania Rollup

WWE.com

It might have been more than a decade ago, but once upon a time, Rey Mysterio versus Randy Orton was two-thirds of a WrestleMania headlining match.

Advertisement

Friday, they were a curtain-jerking five-minute act that ended with a botched backslide rollup.

While you could argue that they were holding back a bit because Mysterio still had further to go in the tournament, it’s ridiculous that they sleepwalked through a five-minute match that could have taken place at any house show. For the opening match of what ostensibly was a PPV.

Advertisement

Sure, both men are exceptional professionals, so the match wasn’t bad by any standard. But if you logged in a few minutes late and missed it, you didn’t miss anything. The post-match beatdown was more newsworthy than the entire bout itself.

Advertisement

10. An Olympic-Sized Dud

WWE.com

There will be some judicious praise of Kurt Angle later, but this item is more about one thing:

Advertisement

Who booked this crap?

Vacationing Raw GM Kurt Angle tricked his way into the World Cup tournament and played up the redemption angle pretty nicely – trying to prove he still had something in the tank, while showing up the man who took his job, Baron Corbin.

Advertisement

So naturally, Angle went out and jobbed in eight minutes to Dolph Ziggler after one Zig-Zag.

Angle’s attempts to prove he still had it were snuffed out in the first round. So why was he even booked for the show? To be a name on the card? To give Ziggler the rub?

Advertisement

9. Where Are We Again?

You had to wonder how WWE would address the entire Saudi Arabia issue, being that they had not referenced the location of Crown Jewel in the weeks leading up to the PPV.

Advertisement

The solution? Painstakingly jump through hoops to avoid mentioning “Saudi Arabia” at any time during the PPV. Whereas at Greatest Royal Rumble WWE aired numerous segments about Saudi Arabia and mentioned it repeatedly, the chyron only identified the location as “Riyadh,” which is Saudi Arabia’s capital.

Even Crown Jewel host Hulk Hogan at one point said he landed here… at Crown Jewel. Big E for his pre-match hype act didn’t name the locale, just said, “Awwwwwwww Crown Jewel!”

Advertisement

Look, there was no good way to address this once WWE decided to go forward with the PPV. It was a lose-lose situation. But to outright ignore the location, going so far as to mention the city the event was being held but not the country… it’s just such a WWE thing to do. Rather than own the reality, they just stuck their collective heads in the sand.

8. Is Now The Best Time?

WWE.com

With everything negative surrounding Crown Jewel, why would you make Hulk Hogan’s first appearance in WWE in more than three years at this show?

Advertisement

The Hulkster made his triumphant return to WWE in Saudi Arabia as “Real American” blared. He certainly wasn’t going to be a national hero there, though Hogan got a decent reaction. His return literally was to deliver a minute-long promo (while presumably trying to avoid saying “Saudi Arabia”) and then go back into the shadows.

Advertisement

It was ridiculous to think that WWE waited until Friday to bring Hogan back into the fold. Just insane.

7. Uninspired First Round

Tournaments by and large are fun and awesome storytelling devices. One-night tournaments often are not. (WrestleMania IV, we’re looking at you.)

Advertisement

Even a one-night tournament involving eight top WWE wrestlers couldn’t avoid the pitfalls of having wrestlers compete multiple times in a night. The first round of the WWE World Cup tourney was an uninspired lot of matches that largely disappointed. As noted elsewhere, you had short matches with out-of-nowhere finishes and very little heat (though the crowd might have something to do with that).

The first round did set the stage for the later rounds, but it certainly was the kind of fodder you would want to largely fast-forward and skip. The idea was solid – fill the card with matches that mean something without having to defend every title or craft extensive storylines for each bout – but it just gave us four matches that felt like Raw filler rather than PPV-worthy contests.

Advertisement

6. Overselling The Drama

Look, Crown Jewel was a turkey, a goose egg, a big flaming pile of poop.

Advertisement

So you’re going to need the announcers to really sell everything that’s happening as the greatest thing that has ever happened in the history of this industry.

But Michael Cole was bordering on Tony Schiavone territory with some of his exclamations Friday. The veteran play-by-play guy constantly referred to everything Shawn Michaels did as “Shade of…!” He sold four AARP members sloughing through the main event and using every smoke and mirror trick they could as the greatest, most historic thing we’ve ever seen.

Advertisement

Truthfully, they could have wrestled a basic, standard tag match with a couple big moments and spots built in, and the match would have been fine. But they opted for more smoke and mirrors. It turned a perfectly decent match into an overdone affair. And Cole’s histrionics didn’t help matters, as his grating commentary just made you want to reach through the TV.

5. Most Midcard Final Possible

WWE.com

Go back and take a close look at the WWE World Cup bracket. Now try to envision a finals between Dolph Ziggler and The Miz for the title of “Best in the World.”

Advertisement

Yeah.

Yes, wrestling is predetermined, and every bit of chastising that’s coming this writer’s way (and speaking as someone who’s a fan of both men), but come on. This is the final matchup for a tournament with Randy Orton, Rey Mysterio, Jeff Hardy and Kurt Angle in it? Two of the least-decorated superstars in the grouping (Bobby Lashley probably has the fewest professional wrestling accolades – at least those recognized by WWE).

Advertisement

It just screamed “Micard!” at you as soon as Dolph won. Both guys are entertaining and good wrestlers, but it makes the “Best in the World” moniker a pretty big joke.

Oh wait, there was a bigger joke to come, and it made this even more of a midcard final.

Advertisement

4. Joe The Bridesmaid

Despite taking AJ Styles to the limit every time they’ve wrestled for the WWE Championship, Samoa Joe came up short again on Friday at Crown Jewel.

Advertisement

It’s a familiar site that is just a headscratcher: Joe is a solid heel who could easily carry the title and be a believable champion to beat all comers. Imagine him fending off Styles, Daniel Bryan, Rusev and Rey Mysterio, as well as other heels who might come at him.

But to have Joe jump into a title match at the 11th hour and lose yet again just hurts him. There’s only so many times you can lose a title bout (especially as a monster heel) that you lose credibility in that role. Joe’s the type who could turn the volume to 11 to get his heat back, but it just seems unnecessary to stick him in this match and then have him lose like that.

Advertisement

That’s not an endorsement for AJ to lose, but for WWE to think beyond just plugging Samoa Joe into the vacant spot on the card.

Advertisement

3. RIP Braun

What the hell was that?

Advertisement

The moment Roman Reigns went down with an unfortunate diagnosis, WWE had a rare opportunity to reheat one of its very few organic stars that fans have gravitated toward due to his impressive feats of strength.

Instead, the company decided to throw its Universal Championship back around the waist of a part-time player who is more focused on returning to UFC than to build a brand in WWE.

Advertisement

Worse yet, Brock Lesnar squashed Braun Strowman. And no matter what they say about Baron Corbin’s belt shot giving Brock the advantage, it was one damn shot with the title. Braun has shrugged off way worse, and instead, we got five F-5s and a new champ – and a burial.

Advertisement

As Randy Orton would say, “Stupid! Stupid! Stupid!”

2. Making A Mockery Of Things

As if a tournament final to crown the “Best in the World” between Dolph Ziggler and The Miz wasn’t campy enough, we got possibly the dumbest outcome possible. Actually, scratch that: We got by far the dumbest outcome possible.

Advertisement

An executive who wasn’t even entered into the tournament won the event.

The Miz got injured during a pre-match brawl (that he started), which should have triggered a forfeit, but SmackDown GM Shane McMahon decided to interject himself into the match and compete on Miz’s behalf. No, he didn’t get the runner-up, Rey Mysterio, or someone else from the SmackDown roster. He inserted himself into the finals – and then he won a squash in about three minutes!

Advertisement

Seriously, Shane won the tournament and took the trophy home. What a bleeping joke. What an absolute bleeping joke.

Advertisement

1. An Embarrassment Every Way You Look At It

There is no easy way to say this: Crown Jewel was a disaster of epic proportions from nearly every angle, except WWE’s wallet.

Advertisement

Aside from the obvious political issues of moving forward, the actual show itself featured horrendous booking, subpar wrestling and long-term damage to one of its few marketable stars.

We saw a legend un-retire for what amounted to a glorified, overproduced house show in an overbooked meaningless tag match. We saw a 48-year-old executive win a tournament he entered in the final round to crown the best wrestler in the world. We saw the full-time, popular superstar lose a title match to the part-time pariah in a squash.

Advertisement

And lastly, we saw WWE too embarrassed by the situation to even reference where in the world they were, even as they boasted about being in Australia last month.

Advertisement

Any one of these would simply merit a down or two and then we’d move on. But taking all of these (and other negatives) into account, we have to put them all here and let it all sink in that this was all on one show.

You seriously can’t make this sh** up.

Advertisement

UPS…

6. Oh Pyro, How We Missed You

You don’t really realize how much you miss the pyro for each wrestler until you see it again.

Advertisement

And that’s what really stood out about Crown Jewel. Nearly all the wrestlers got pyro for their first matches, which really added a little pop to their intro and made the even feel a little more special – even if it was a supersized house show.

Kurt Angle getting his pyro for his intro was particularly cool to see again, as was Rey Mysterio.

Advertisement

It’s understandable why WWE cut it out of its weekly programming – it’s expensive – but that doesn’t mean that we can’t lament its absence and celebrate its (temporary) return.

5. Wrestling CVs

Sometimes, little things can make even what is just a glorified house show tournament feel important.

Advertisement

Before each first-round match of the WWE World Cup Tournament, ring announcer Greg Hamilton rattled off the various accomplishments of each wrestler: titles won, Royal Rumbles won, Triple Crowns and Grand Slams. It provided an air of legitimacy to why each of the eight men were in the tournament.

Even someone like The Miz, who is often dismissed as a solid midcard act, was pumped up with his world, US, and Intercontinental title reigns and being a Grand Slam champion. It wasn’t a huge thing, but it was a really nice little touch.

Advertisement

4. Miz, Rey Step Up 2nd Round

After criticizing how uninspiring the entire first round of the tournament was, it’s only fair to give credit to The Miz and Rey Mysterio for having an entertaining second round match.

Advertisement

Rey might not be able to fly around the ring at the pace he used to a decade or two ago, but he kept things moving really well, playing off of Miz nicely. And to his credit, Miz did a solid job keeping Mysterio down and cutting off his comebacks.

Advertisement

Mysterio was the perfect opponent for Miz – someone smaller and wounded that Miz could believably beat, but also a big enough name that he could crow about it for weeks. And he won cleanly to boot.

3. Rollins, Ziggler Have Another Solid Bout

Some wrestlers have a tremendous amount of chemistry together, while others have none.

Advertisement

Seth Rollins and Dolph Ziggler are somewhere in between, with enough chemistry to consistently have entertaining, even pretty good matches every time. They don’t happen to cross over into “classic” territory, but they certainly will do the job. At Crown Jewel, Ziggler and Rollins battled back and forth, with Ziggler focusing on the neck throughout.

Ziggler turned a Falcon Arrow into a Zig-Zag for a close 2 count, which you could have bought for the finisher. In the end, it was Drew McIntyre paying dividends on a distraction to allow Dolph to hit a superkick (Really? On the show where Shawn Michaels returns?) for the win.

Advertisement

All this being said, these two have wrestled way too much in the past several months, and them taking a vacation from each other would be a good idea.

Advertisement

2. Angle Looks Better Than Ever! (In The Past Year)

One of the announcers’ favorite tropes for more *ahem* established superstars is to talk about how they look “better than ever,” despite being 45+, broken down and well past their prime. It really is insulting how throwing a couple punches suddenly sends the talking heads into hysterics.

Advertisement

But Kurt Angle actually looked better than he had in recent years at Crown Jewel, clearly bulking back up to a wrestling physique that more closely resembled him at his prime. And the Olympic gold medalist also looked crisper in the ring than he had since his limited return to action last year.

If he indeed is gearing up for one final run in the ring, then it looks like he might be able to hold up his end and not look lost out there. Against Dolph Ziggler, Kurt snapped off German suplexes and did some mat wrestling, showing he still has some skills.

Advertisement

It will be interesting to see if we get Angle in some more matches at time wears on, but at least he looked a lot better in the ring than we had seen previously.

1. HBK Sheds Ring Rust

While the match between Shawn Michaels and Triple H versus Undertaker and Kane wasn’t good by conventional standards, it was good to see that if HBK was going to get back in the ring, he didn’t embarrass himself.

Advertisement

Michaels stayed mostly in a safe zone, aside from a top rope elbow and moonsault press to the floor. But he looked fine in his first match in 8-plus years. Yes, it would have been better if he had been that one wrestler who actually hung it up, but if everyone else is going to return after retiring and get PPV paydays (Trish Stratus and Lita, we’re looking at you), then Michaels might as well cash in.

Advertisement

It will be interesting to see if this means that Michaels will compete infrequently again, or if this was a one-time deal and maybe we’ll see him once more at WrestleMania. But for one night, we got to see that Michaels still can go.