6 Ups And 4 Downs From NXT TakeOver: San Antonio

New champs, good wrestling, but bumpy roads exposed for developmental brand.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

After three years of TakeOver specials, NXT was bound to hit a bump in the road.

Advertisement

The little promotion that could, NXT has been the darling of wrestling geeks, a diamond in the rough that is WWE. NXT has been home to independent scene heroes and the proving grounds for homegrown stars. The heavy influence of Vince McMahon is mostly absent, and a more old-school approach favored by the late Dusty Rhodes and Triple H has dominated.

The TakeOver specials have consistently outshined nearly every WWE PPV, with crisp pacing, excellent storylines and fantastic wrestling. But all of this might have come to an end Saturday night, when TakeOver: San Antonio hit the airwaves.

Advertisement

Saturday’s special event was a fun night of wrestling, to be sure, and the matches overall were perfectly fine, but the event simply wasn’t up to par with its predecessors. And with the Royal Rumble PPV looking somewhat solid right now, it could quite possibly outperform NXT’s offering.

TakeOver: San Antonio featured two title changes and some nice moments for the fans who attended or tuned in, but it also highlighted some of the challenges facing NXT as the promotion moves forward.

Advertisement

With that said, let’s take a look at what rose to the occasion and what fell back to Earth…

Downs...

4. Forgetting What New Age Outlaws Taught Us

WWE.com

You know there’s a logic gap big enough to drive a truck through it when you’re practically yelling at the television during a match.

Advertisement

The “Outlaw Rule” might still be in effect, but it certainly didn’t apply in the NXT Women’s Championship fatal fourway match. For those who don’t remember, in 1998, Road Dogg and Billy Gunn pinned each other to win a triple threat tag title match, a loophole that was quickly closed.

However, all four participants in the fatal fourway at TakeOver: San Antonio were technically opponents. Despite Billie Kay and Peyton Royce holding hands and working together the entire match, they were opponents.

Advertisement

So why in the blue hell did neither woman think to pin the other for the title? It was established early on that neither wrestler cared who won the title and that they’d just share it (ala LayCool). With Nikki Cross down and Asuka out on the floor, Peyton could have quickly laid down and let Billie pin her (or vice-versa). New champ(s). Done.

But instead, they went after Asuka, ate a few kicks and the champ defended her title.

Advertisement

3. Women’s Match Gets Shorted

WWE.com

It’s a bad sign when you think you missed half a match and scan back to check, only to find that no, you saw the whole thing.

Advertisement

The fatal fourway between Asuka, Nikki Cross, Peyton Royce and Billie Kay had the potential to be an intriguing bout, with the Australians hanging together and possibly forcing Asuka and Cross to have to team up to take them down. You could have the Aussies dominate the match and get a bunch of near-falls on both women, only to have a miscommunication that leads to their downfall.

Advertisement

Instead, they hid (smart) and tried to pick their spots (kinda smart) and then took out Nikki Cross by putting her through a table (genius). Then they came back to the ring and tried to take out Asuka, only to fall to a series of kicks and lose in short order. Just like that, the match was over. It felt like an entire segment of the match was missing, with Asuka getting beaten from pillar to post before coming back to win.

It was a disappointing performance, and whether it was sent home early because of time, it still was disappointing.

Advertisement

2. Title Pictures Look Hazy

WWE.com

When you look at the NXT roster after all the raids by WWE in the past year, it really looks barren at the moment.

Advertisement

This is something that you can see right away when you look at who would be in the hunt for each of NXT’s titles. Case in point: Who should be next in line for the NXT Women’s Championship? Maybe Ember Moon, but beyond that… perennial loser Liv Morgan? And the NXT Tag Team Championships? The Revival again? TM 61 when they recover from injury?

Advertisement

Even the NXT Championship picture is a little scarce, especially if Samoa Joe is being called up to the main roster. After Shinsuke Nakamura, Bobby Roode could square off against Tye Dillinger, a healthy Hideo Itami, No Way Jose or Oney Lorcan.

That’s not to put these guys down or say that it’s bad to build them up as contenders, but there’s certainly work to be done to get the next group of guys in line. That’s a completely different issue than this one…

Advertisement

1. Hard To Get Invested

WWE.com

One of the biggest criticisms facing NXT in recent months has been how the talent drain has impacted the developmental territory. Obviously, NXT is supposed to exist to supply ready-for-primetime wrestlers for WWE, but the parent company’s latest “raids” have certainly impacted the territory.

Advertisement

Finn Balor, Bayley, Nia Jax, Alexa Bliss, Enzo Amore & Big Cass, Baron Corbin, Apollo Crews and American Alpha are just some of the superstars who were promoted to the main roster in 2016. That’s a pretty big drain on the NXT talent. As a result, we have acts like Andrade “Cien” Almas and Roderick Strong, who put on a solid match at TakeOver: San Antonio, but it’s difficult to be seriously invested in them as wrestlers or the outcome of the match as being significant.

The same could be said about SAnitY, which has an awesome entrance and performers committed to their characters, but aside from the smoke and lighting, and the occasional beatdown, what have they done? Why should we care about them one way or another? This says nothing about the women’s division, with Liv Morgan getting oodles of camera time and next to zero character development.

Advertisement

This isn’t meant to be a huge criticism: NXT is a developmental brand, and it’s supposed to develop these characters, so it’s an ongoing process. But it’s tough to be connected to the performers right now.

UPS…

6. Tye Gets Fired Up

WWE.com

During his run in NXT, Tye Dillinger has become a cult favorite, with fans chanting “10!” at every turn when he’s in the ring. It’s made him one of the bigger stars in the company, despite being little more than a midcard act.

Advertisement

Saturday night at TakeOver, Dillinger got to unleash a little more offense than usual and open things up a bit. He threw Eric Young around, took on all three members of SAnitY at once and had the crowd rallying behind him big time. It looked like he was finally going to put it all together, but ultimately, the numbers game caught up to him.

Advertisement

Dillinger might be on his way out the door of NXT (to bigger and better things), but it was good to see him fire up and throw down in this match. It showed he’s got more than 10 fingers going for him.

5. A Glorious Champion

WWE.com

As great as Shinsuke Nakamura has been as champ, he’s the wrong person to carry the NXT Championship at this point.

Advertisement

Nakamura is lightyears beyond the bulk of the roster in the ring and probably would be an excellent special attraction if he’s not going to get called up to the main roster just yet. Bobby Roode, however, is an excellent choice as a heel champ for others to chase. Even with a gutted roster, his jerky character would elevate just about any challenger, at least in the short term, in fans’ eyes. What fan wouldn’t want to see someone like Oney Lorcan or No Way Jose shut Roode up, even if they have no realistic chance of winning the title?

Advertisement

Roode is a great choice to lead NXT in the coming months, much like Kevin Owens and Samoa Joe were solid heel champs. It’ll be interesting to see if anyone gets elevated (long-term) as a result.

4. Rollins On The Hunt

WWE.com

The NXT TakeOver specials have followed a set pattern since they debuted nearly three years ago: solid might after solid match. There typically is a shortage of other antics during an NXT special event.

Advertisement

Saturday, NXT continued that tradition, with one major change: Seth Rollins. The former NXT and WWE champ stormed the ring and grabbed the mic, declaring that he was taking over NXT until Triple H came out to a huge reaction. Despite being called out on his own turf, Hunter simply gestured to security to help escort Rollins away.

Advertisement

That led to huge boos from the crowd, but it did a hell of a lot to make Rollins into a likable hero chasing after the evil boss, even willing to confront him on his ground. This will probably get replayed a bunch on Raw Monday night.

3. DIY Puts In Work

WWE.com

Johnny Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa certainly earned their paychecks Saturday night. The duo was tasked with the duty of putting over the Authors of Pain in a lengthy and believable match, and they succeeded.

Advertisement

Don’t get it wrong, the Authors had a really good match with DIY, but it was largely due to Gargano and Ciampa selling moves and dishing out offense left and right that really kept the match flowing. DIY used knee strikes, chops, slaps and some tandem offense to keep Akam and Rezar at bay for parts of the match. Ultimately, they folded to their more powerful opponents.

Advertisement

Some will criticize the Authors for being champs despite their relative inexperience and being carried in matches. But sometimes, you’ve got to roll the dice and let the wrestlers learn. DIY did a hell of a job making the Authors look strong Saturday night.

2. Almas And Strong Go 100MPH (Or 160KPH)

WWE.com

Right before the bell rang in the Andrade “Cien” Almas/Roderick Strong match, Corey Graves made the comment that the match could be a show-stealer because both men had chips on their shoulders and something to prove.

Advertisement

Almas and Strong might not have had the best match on the card, but they went full speed from the get-go and didn’t let up for the duration. The match didn’t have a big fight feel, but both men hit each other with some aggressive moves that knocked the other loopy. There were no dead spots in the match because neither took their foot off the gas.

Advertisement

In the end, Strong emerged victorious, but it was good to see two guys who have been largely in the background get to shine for a few minutes on PPV and show the fans exactly what they can do. It made this writer curious to see more of them in action and that hopefully NXT will develop and feature both more.

1. Roode And Nakamura Save The Day

WWE.com

There’s a good reason why Shinsuke Nakamura is called the King of Strong Style. The (now former) NXT champ peppered Bobby Roode with kicks and knee strikes throughout their match, with the Glorious One responding in kind in a hard-hitting title bout.

Advertisement

The two pros had an excellent match that started slowly and built into a frenzy at the end, with Roode countering Nakamura’s mindgames with his own. Bobby didn’t fall for Shinsuke’s tricks and ultimately capitalized on an injured knee to capture the NXT Championship and end Nakamura’s second title reign.

Advertisement

The match had fans freaking out at various points and out of their seats throughout, so that’s all you really need to know. There’s no reason to try to describe the match, just go check it out.