6 Ups And 5 Downs From NXT TakeOver: Chicago
When the crowd chants, 'F*** you' for a heel turn, you're doing something right.
Whenever NXT runs a TakeOver show the night before a WWE PPV, do you think the wrestlers on the main roster get antsy? The developmental brand often sets the bar pretty high for the seasoned wrestlers to match or top, leaving them in an unenviable spot the next night.
TakeOver: Chicago featured five matches that were varying degrees of good, with one of them being purely great. Nothing really dragged, and the two-hour show breezed by, with a truly memorable ending. If you were looking for an enjoyable escape for the evening, you could do a lot worse.
The highest high point of the night had to be the United Kingdom Championship match between Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne, with both men turning in epic performances en route to Dunne defeating Bate to capture the UK title. That match alone is worth the replay, along with a nice performance from Roderick Strong and good showings from Hideo Itami and Bobby Roode.
And we saw a jaw-dropping heel turn that should lead to some high-octane, bitterly personal matches between former best friends. But let’s not spoil that just yet.
Let’s take a look at what scaled the ladder to reach for greatness and what crashed and burned. Let’s get to it…
Downs...
5. AOP Out Of Their League
Let’s note right away that the ladder match for the NXT Tag Team Championships was pretty good, with plenty of fun spots. And we can acknowledge that the Authors of Pain have been involved in a few pretty good matches during their tenure.
However, it also should be noted that a lot of AOP’s good work has come against superior teams like DIY, TM61 and the Revival. They’re capable of being carried to serviceable and even good matches, but it remains to be seen if they can actually wrestle a quality bout on their own. The ladder match was good because of DIY, not because AOP was adding anything super-special. They were the warm bodies following Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano’s lead.
And look, it’s important that they be able to do that, and that’s not a bad thing. But it’s pretty clear at this point that the Authors aren’t going to be leading a tag team revival of their own anytime soon.
4. Ruining The Moment
If you’re going to have longtime tag team partners break up violently, what do you think is the best move? If you answered, “Show crowd shots of fans laughing and smiling,” you could be the next Kevin Dunn protégé.
As Tommaso Ciampa beat the holy hell out of Johnny Gargano at the very end of TakeOver, the camera kept switching to shots of “shocked” fans, except for the fact that several of the fans were half-laughing or busy taking photos with their smartphones. Sure, several had genuine shocked looks, but after the first 30 seconds, the shock was gone. Stick to the drama unfolding or show the larger crowd shots of fans chanting and yelling at Ciampa.
The repeated, rapid cuts to individual fans were ridiculous, jarring and stupid. It’s really sad to think that this is actually being taught as a tactic for filming a PPV.
3. Itami Odd Man Out
NXT did a nice job with its pre-match video showcasing Hideo Itami’s rocky journey with the company, joining the brand with much fanfare two years ago and then getting injured and missing a year-plus, then getting injured again.
The observation was made that a lot of wrestlers bypassed Itami in that time, and he was simply trying to get his footing under him again with this recent return. But after his match Saturday night, you have to wonder if NXT has passed Itami by. His NXT Championship match against Bobby Roode started slow and took a bit to get fans into it, but by the end they were fully invested. Still, Hideo came up short.
This isn’t to say that Itami is a total bust, but it does feel like his best opportunity to excel has elapsed. Sure, that could just be a bad gut feeling, but it’s definitely there.
2. Captain Obvious On Commentary
WWE loves their three-man booths these days, even if it means giving dead weight like Percy Watson a live microphone.
Watson was a middling prospect in FCW/NXT for a few years before being released in 2013. He didn’t do much of note on the independent circuit before returning to NXT as a commentator late last year. And he hasn’t really added much of note in that role either.
During TakeOver Saturday night, Watson contributed observations such as noting that Roderick Strong was moving slowly because he was hurt and that Nikki Cross is “absolutely whacko.” You seriously could have turned his mic off entirely (and he went silent for large stretches anyway) and you wouldn’t notice a loss.
Now, Watson could get better and become a good analyst (NXT is developmental for announcers as well as wrestlers), but he really added as much to TakeOver as static.
1. Asuka Overdone
Have you ever cooked a steak for too long and tried to salvage it with BBQ or Worcestershire sauce? That is what it looks like NXT is trying to do with Asuka’s NXT Women’s Championship title reign.
For nearly 14 months, the Empress of Tomorrow has run roughshod over the NXT women’s division, defeating Emma, Bayley, Nia Jax, Mickie James, Peyton Royce, Billie Kay, Liv Morgan, Ember Moon, and now Nikki Cross and Ruby Riot. NXT has basically painted itself into a proverbial corner, with Asuka defeating all comers and leaving them with no viable challenger to take the title off of her, even though that probably should have happened by now.
Asuka is a great performer, and her new heelish personality helps breathe a little new life into things, but watching the triple threat title match Saturday night, it never felt like Riot or Cross were going to unseat Asuka. The multi-person match felt more like an artificial way to insert doubt into whether she could hold onto her title (the BBQ sauce in the earlier analogy) and to freshen things up.
If Ember Moon is going to unseat Asuka, it’s got to be coming soon, right? Maybe at TakeOver: Brooklyn III?
Ups...
6. Roddy Comes Out Strong
After a really well-done video package on NXT television, Roderick Strong needed to cash in at TakeOver and deliver a performance that continued to rally fans around him – and he succeeded.
Roddy jumped out of the crowd to take out Sanity from the get-go, winning over the fans, and he continued to battle against the odds throughout the match. Strong persevered and pulled out a Strong Backbreaker for the win, becoming one of the first wrestlers to overcome the odds of Sanity (Tye Dillinger did it with the help of a steel cage).
The match wasn’t a classic, but it was a solid opener that continued the momentum built up by the videos, and hopefully it’s a sign that Roddy has a bright future ahead.
5. Building Around Bobby
When he was signed to NXT, it was generally accepted that Bobby Roode was coming to NXT to boost the developmental brand, not to train to join the main roster. Roode was to serve as an established veteran presence to help strengthen NXT. And he’s done just that, now four months into his title reign.
Saturday night, Roode vanquished a member of NXT’s previous “generation,” Hideo Itami, continuing a title reign that could become, well, glorious. Roode carries himself like a star, from his entrance and ring attire to his clothing and promos. He certainly has enough of an aura around him, and his smug attitude makes him the perfect heel champion that everyone wants to see beaten.
If Roode truly is going to call this his NXT and his Glorious Era, then maybe he could use some running buddies to take over the tag team division. But for now, he’s perfectly fine as champ.
4. DIY Goes All Out On Way Out
In what will probably be their last tag team match for a while, DIY let it all hang out Saturday night, leading the Authors of Pain through a pretty good ladder match that featured plenty of awesome moments.
AOP received negative marks earlier for being out of their league, which is deserved, but that also means that DIY earned an “up” for carrying the bigger men to a perfectly fine match that included some great spots, such as Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano splashing Akam and Rezar through ladders, a couple innovative climbing spots, a German suplex off a ladder through a ladder, and Gargano nearly getting decapitated with a ladder.
The match earned a standing ovation from the Chicago faithful, more for DIY’s performance, as no one was happy that AOP defended their titles. It set the stage perfectly for what came later. But as a swansong, this wasn’t too shabby.
3. Nigel Is Music To The Ears
Unlike his broadcast booth compatriot Percy Watson, Nigel McGuinness has been a joy to listen to during NXT programming, and that was on full display Saturday night, particularly during the UK Championship match.
McGuiness partnered with Jim Ross to call the Tyler Bate/Pete Dunne match and they did not disappoint. Nigel constantly added context to the conversation and related the significance of what the title meant and how various moves affected an opponent. Throughout the night, Nigel was insightful and kept the conversation moving while being focused on the action.
In short, he’s better than two-thirds of the announcers WWE currently employs. Can we get him on SmackDown?
2. ‘F*** You Ciampa!’
When you can get that kind of reaction from fans, you know you nailed your heel turn.
Tommaso Ciampa ended his longtime friendship with tag team partner Johnny Gargano Saturday night after DIY lost their NXT Tag Team Championship ladder match to the Authors of Pain. The beaten duo was making their way up the ramp at the end of the PPV when Ciampa turned and slammed Gargano into the lightboard, then proceeded to repeatedly hit running knee-strikes on him.
Ciampa capped it off with a White Noise off the announce table through several tables below, forcing Gargano to be stretchered out of the arena. The turn unfortunately ends one of the best tag teams in all of WWE/NXT, but it sets the stage for an awesome series of matches between the two men.
And putting aside the horrid shots of fans laughing, this turn was almost perfectly executed.
1. ‘Fight Forever!’
Holy hell, the UK Championship match between Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne was an absolute barn-burner.
The two Brits tore into each other with everything in their arsenal, with Bate breaking out a corkscrew 450 splash and deadlifting the Bruiserweight, and Dunne using an X-plex on the apron and a suplex into a powerbomb. The action was too fast and furious to catalog, but let’s just note that the crowd was certainly justified with its repeated “UK! UK! UK!” and “Fight forever!” chants. And when an exhausted Bate and Dunne leaned on each other and kept swinging, it encapsulated everything good about that match.
In the end, it was Dunne with the Bitter End to win the UK Championship and most likely set up a rivalry between he and Bate that could carry the new UK WWE Network program in the early-going.