Last week, WWE put on a quality Raw with good matches, surprises and a hot crowd. Naturally, that effort was rewarded with one of Raws lowest ratings in years. So with ratings in a freefall, WWE on Monday night turned to the one trick the company pony knows authority figures. But does Triple H equal ratings? Well have to wait to find out. In the meantime, Raw was in go-home mode (already) for WWEs next PPV, Payback. We learned the fate of one champion, saw the heart of another, witnessed a burial, watched wrestlers previously buried try to brush off the dirt and saw people still stumped by an old tag team rule. It certainly was an eventful Raw, but nowhere near the level of last weeks performance. (That probably means ratings will go up.) As with many episodes of Raw, there were two hours of good material in here, but unfortunately, Raw is three hours long. That gives us some brutal segments with confusing booking and bad writing. Sadly for the fans who made it through the entire episode of Raw, the ending looked a lot like last week, so unless youre from Cincinnati, you easily could have skipped it. So what rose up and what fell apart? Lets find out how the go-home Raw for Payback broke down.
DOWNS
7. Last Dance
To anyone who thought that Fandangos recent face turn and mini-push would lead to anything it took only 37 seconds for you to get your answer Monday night. The dancing desperado got buried in epic fashion on Raw, losing to perennial jobber Erick Rowan in just over a half-minute. Making matters worse, the announcers immediately began speculating on how quickly Fandango would lose, giving him absolutely no shot and predicting a loss in about 1:30 which then was undercut by two-thirds. This isnt like Fandango going up against Brock Lesnar or even Big Show or Ryback, where you could get away with expecting a quick defeat. He was facing was Erick Rowan, who has spent the past seven months losing on Raw pretty regularly.Adding insult to injury, Fandango got obliterated in a post-match beatdown, with the announcers largely treating him like a nameless face in the crowd. Something says that this guy wont be dancing to the pay window very often in the future.
6. PPV Overload
On the one hand, its nice to see WWE trying to push the Network hard by offering lots of exclusive, original content on it. In addition to the monthly PPVs, they have begun offering wrestling specials to lure in fans. But the move has resulted in an incredible over-saturation almost never seen before in less than a two-month span. Beginning with Extreme Rules on April 27 and wrapping up on May 31, WWE will have held three PPV and a Network special King of the Ring tournament semifinals and finals. Payback will take place on Sunday with a three-week build, and now it was announced Monday that WWE is bringing back the Elimination Chamber PPV at the end of the month, just two weeks after Payback. If you take into account that Money in the Bank is scheduled for June 14, that would make for four PPVs in a seven-week span. That probably has never happened before in WWE history, and thats probably for good reason. Between all of that and Raw and Smackdown, how burned out are fans going to get?
5. Booker Still Confused
Look, this isnt really hard. Booker T made a mistake last week when he said that the Freebird Rule means that all three members of New Day can be in a tag team match at the same time. The unofficial rule actually says that any two of the members of a stable can defend the tag team championships. It was a bad mistake, but one had to assume that Michael P.S. Hayes sat Booker down and explained it to him after Raw went off the air. Problem solved, right? Nope. As Michael Cole laid out the WWE Tag Team Championship match at Payback, Booker chimed in that he believed that New Day would retain the titles because of the Freebird Rule and being able to compete three-on-two. And then no one corrected him. Look, once is bad, but forgivable. Twice is inexcusable. The fact that no one bothered to set the record straight is troubling. It just serves to confuse younger fans whove never heard of the Freebirds. If there is such a rule where a tag team can get a third running buddy and wrestle handicap matches, why doesnt every team do that?
4. Are We Supposed To Cheer Or Boo?
Michael Cole loves to talk about how John Cena always gets a huge reaction from WWE fans. Love him or hate him, everyone has a strong opinion. Unfortunately, his girlfriend and her sister are at the opposite end of the spectrum, barely getting any kind of reaction. The Bella Twins were doing OK as a mean girls-ripoff who made fun of opponents and cheated copiously to keep the Divas Championship around Nikkis waist. A couple weeks ago apparently, WWE realized that with Naomi turning heel, she would be challenging a heel champion, and decided to rectify that. With that, the Bellas suddenly turned face and altered their in-ring tactics to match. The problem is that theyve literally done nothing that would warrant cheering.Then, the announcers took it a step further Monday, noting that Naomi believed she would be champ without Bries interference, and that many fans and observers agree with her. It was weird hearing all three announcers admit that Brie cheated to help Nikki retain her title, yet it was obvious Brie was playing face-in-peril for half the match. Make up your minds, WWE. Are we supposed to boo or cheer? When fans are confused and dont know whether to boo or cheer it rarely works out well.
3. Ziggler Looks Lost
Maybe its the jean jacket with the ripped sleeves and headband ensemble, but Dolph Ziggler looked like a guy who was just trying too hard Monday night. Its really tough to be critical of a guy who many feel has never really been given a chance to succeed, but for whatever reason, Ziggler hasnt really given fans much of a reason to get behind him lately. At one time, it looked like WWE was finally going to give Dolph a bigger role as he stood up to the Authority and then put them away by eliminating three of the five men at Survivor Series, banning the Authority forever. But once they returned five weeks later, it was all downhill for Ziggler.That freefall has included this recent feud with Sheamus, where Dolph is supposedly standing up to a bully, but he instead ends up flat on the mat. Sure, WWE plays up Zigglers whole Never say die attitude, but at this stage in his career, plucky underdog is not the role he should be aspiring to. It would be nice to see him not fighting from underneath constantly. It would be great to be proven wrong and have this just be a bad gut feeling.
2. The MegaParodies
It was only a matter of time before AxelMania met its parody parallel, and we got it Monday night, with Macho Mandow making his debut. Yep, thats Damien Sandow, finally free and out from under the Mizs shadow, standing in Randy Savages shadow. Naturally, they pitted Axel and Sandow against each other. WrestleMania V it was not. In a true example of saying what everyone is thinking, the Ascension came out seconds into this match and broke it up, stating that imitating two relics from the past is a pathetic attempt to jumpstart their flailing careers. Konnor and Viktor pointed out that there is a difference between being laughed with and laughed at. The impersonating duo not only chased off the Ascension, but they will now face the duo on the Payback PPV kickoff show after sharing a MegaPowers-like handshake after thwarting the Ascension.The announcers summed it up perfectly: That was really. something. And once again, its sad to see Damien Sandow still not show his own personality. There was a way for Sandow to emerge from this feud with the Miz and be a much stronger character. Instead, WWE has hit the reset button on Damiens development and had him revert back to impersonating different people. Its very nearly a tragedy.
1. Bryan Surrenders IC Title
Without a doubt, the saddest development Monday night had to be Daniel Bryan relinquishing the Intercontinental Championship and announcing that he still didnt know how long he would be on the shelf. For fans, its déjà vu all over again, with Bryan gaining a major victory at WrestleMania, just to see it all snatched away due to injury. Fans chanted, Thank you Bryan! as if they believed that this was D-Brys in-ring retirement, but really, you cant blame them. Two unknown injuries a year apart does not bode well for the long-term plans and future of a wrestler. That knowledge leaves you with a bad feeling in the pit of your stomach.Personal, selfish feelings aside, this is a smart move for Bryan, putting his personal health first and (hopefully) getting himself in better shape to compete at a high level. You would like to believe that the way in which he surrendered the IC title that it would be treated as a serious wrestling title, but it remains to be seen if WWE can pull that off.
UPS
6. Two-Out-Of-Three Falls
This item gets a tacit thumbs-up for two reasons, one real, one speculative. First up, anytime the WWE Tag Team Championships are defended in a two-out-of-three falls match is an easy positive. It harkens back to the 80s and before, when titles were defended in such a manner, particularly the tag titles. Who can forget seeing the British Bulldogs and Hart Foundation defending the tag championships in those classic 2/3 falls matches on Saturday Nights Main Event? Now, if WWE is smart and really wants to get New Day over as a heel act and extend a bunch of sympathy toward Cesaro and Tyson Kidd then there is a really obvious yet still awesome move that will help: Have New Day use the Freebird Rule to switch competitors between falls. For example, have Big E and Kofi Kingston start the match. Lets say Kofi loses the first fall to Kidd. Xavier Woods then sneaks in behind Kidd as the second fall starts, subs in for Kofi and captures the second fall en route to winning the overall match.Using the fact they have three wrestlers on their team (rather than treating Woods like a manager distracting on the outside) and having him compete like that would give New Day the competitive advantage of a fresh man mid-match and really tick off fans. Its obvious, but it doesnt mean it shouldnt happen.
5. Bray Draws Fans In
Instead of cryptic promos that seem to lead nowhere for weeks on end, perhaps this is what Bray Wyatt should go for right away. Wyatt delivered a more direct promo on Monday night, talking about people wanting to believe in something and not give in to fear. Bray then used Rybacks story of overcoming a shattered ankle as an example of inspiration that fans draw from, sarcastically exclaiming, My hero! Bray then continued on his recent message of being the New Face of Fear, telling children something your parents dont tell you sometimes the bad guy wins. Just like that, it was clear why Wyatt is targeting Ryback. He views the Big Guys story and persona as a positive source of inspiration and hope for fans, and he wants to snuff that out. Its a simple explanation, but its far better than the lengthy, meandering promos we got for weeks.This feud might not be setting the world on fire (far from it), but at least its different than a lot of the others. Its just a shame that it took until the last Raw before Payback to come into focus. It feels like theres more story to tell beforehand. Maybe this is a lesson for the next round of Bray Wyatt promos.
4. Rowan And Harper Reunite
To be honest, this could easily have been a down on the basis that these two should never have been separated in the first place. Also, both men had been losing quite a bit on their own, so why should fans or wrestlers fear them together? That aside, putting Luke Harper and Erick Rowan back together as a tag team accomplishes a couple things: It (re)creates a powerful tag team that could easily dominate the tag scene, providing imposing heel opponents for a face team. It also gives purpose to two wrestlers who were floundering as singles competitors and going nowhere. We already have seen them together and know they play well together, so this should have an instant buy-in from fans. Now, if WWE really wanted to complete the circuit, they could put the duo back with Bray Wyatt to give him two heavies to carry out his edicts again. Even if not, the reformed team will need to find a target soon. Taking turns demolishing Fandango isnt going to cut it week in and week out.
3. Daddys Home
When Triple H uttered those words and compared his Authority stable to his three daughters, it sounded very condescending, but once everyone was in the ring, it was incredible to see everything unfold. Triple H playing the calm yet stern villain trying to keep his volatile team together was interesting to watch. For weeks, weve seen Kane show increasing disdain and now outright hatred for WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins, while Rollins arrogant, smarmy heel act is gold. Seeing them yelling across Triple H while he tried to maintain order only drove the point home that even he cant keep these combustible elements from exploding at some point.The other interesting dynamic is that this showed that there are some dents in the armor of the Authority. Hunter is loyal to Kane despite Kanes disdain for Rollins, and hes obviously committed to Rollins as champs despite his admission that Seth can be annoying at times. Still, having Triple H on Raw brought a somewhat calming influence to the situation for now.
2. A Happy Homecoming For Ambrose
Theres an unwritten rule that whenever WWE television emanates from a wrestlers hometown, he will get a match on TV and typically lose. Booker T. used to lose whenever WWE was in Houston, for example, and Bad News Barrett lose a United States Championship title match in England last month. But occasionally, the hometown boy will have a strong night in front of their devoted fans. Thats exactly what happened with Dean Ambrose Monday night. The Cincinnati fans wasted no time in chanting for Ambrose, nearly derailing the opening segment. Dean would make his way out for the opening match and win a handicap bout against J & J Security. So far, so good.After the main event of Randy Orton versus Seth Rollins broke down, Ambrose and Roman Reigns stormed the ring to clear it out, with Ambrose getting the final attack (on Reigns, no less) to stand tall to close the show. You dont typically see the same guy in a multi-man match standing along at the end of Raw on back-to-back episodes, so this is either foreshadowing something at Payback, or it simply was a nod to the fact Raw was in Ambroses hometown.
1. Cena Can Wrestle
Fans love to chant, You cant wrestle! at John Cena whenever they get a chance, but it really doesnt hold water when you look at his in-ring work, especially lately. Sure, Cena fell into the trappings of a paint-by-numbers style for several years, but he has shown in recent months that he can vary his style and moveset depending on the opponent. Throughout the John Cena U.S. Open Challenge since WrestleMania, Cena has consistently had solid matches, sometimes the best match on Raw. Monday nights bout against Neville was no exception. In wrestling the rookie for 15 minutes, Cena not only made Neville look good by giving him a ton of offense, he was just about ready to possibly lose his title before Rusev interfered which made perfect sense because it preserved the title match for Payback.You cant have a guy lose too many matches early in his career without it hurting him, but this performance by Neville was the kind of thing that shows hes being taken seriously by the company. Cena didnt just overpower him, leaving Adrian to use high-flying moves to gain an advantage. Neville used some mat wrestling and pure strength of his own to take control. Say what you will about Cena dominating the mid-card of WWE, but having solid one-off matches like this help a lot more than Cena running through Curtis Axel or Big Show while talking about winning the WWE World Heavyweight Championship for the 83rd time.