6 Ups And 8 Downs From WWE Greatest Royal Rumble
Great might not be the right word to describe this event.
The Greatest Royal Rumble is in the books, and the results are in: 50 men in a Royal Rumble is just too damn much.
The signature match of the latest WWE special event dragged on and on, with NXT newcomers and tag team wrestlers filling out the ranks, while there was a minimal amount of surprises. We saw no title changes (sorry, spoiler), although we did see Raw Tag Team Champions crowned.
We saw Roman Reigns continue his descension into Lex Luger-dom. Maybe he should adopt the Torture Rack as his finisher. Hopefully, this feud won’t continue.
We saw The Undertaker make an entrance and hobble through a match, forcing people to wonder when WWE will let him retire gracefully. We also saw Triple H and John Cena put together a decent opener that didn’t dazzle, but worked fine.
Sorry, if you were looking for a newsworthy, exciting event, you were disappointed. If you stayed home from work because you thought you’d see a big surprise or history in the making, you wasted a vacation (or sick) day.
The Greatest Royal Rumble was fine as a super house show, but it certainly wasn’t the spectacle WWE built it up to be for weeks. But hey, the company made money from Saudi Arabia, so bully on them.
Let’s find out what worked and what faltered. Let’s get to it…
Downs...
8. A Basic Opener
Normally, a singles match between John Cena and Triple H would be a headliner for most PPVs. But for the Greatest Royal Rumble, it was the curtain-jerker.
That wasn’t a terrible call – get two of your top stars out there first to fire up the crowd – and the match itself wasn’t bad at all, but it was a very basic match between two all-timers. There was no backstory or basis for the match, which isn’t a required thing, other than the fact both were coming off losses at WrestleMania 34.
The match itself was something you’d expect for a house show main event, with Triple H and Cena trading and reversing finishers before Cena turned a crossface into an AA, then hit a slingshot and another AA for the pin.
We’ll count this as a negative if only because the first one-on-one meeting between these two in eight years just seemed a bit flat.
7. What’s The Appeal?
This writer is looking for some help from the readers: What is the appeal of the Bludgeon Brothers?
Harper and Rowan were a pretty good act as part of the Wyatt Family when they came up to the main roster several years ago. Then they were split off stupidly and broken up. Then they reformed, and then they broke up again. Harper has shown a lot of promise as a singles wrestler, as he can move like a much smaller man.
But this latest incarnation has been a bit odd. They’re portrayed as dominant heels, which is fine, but they seem to get almost no reaction. They ran through the field at WrestleMania to win the SmackDown Tag Team Championships, and they demolished the Usos at Greatest Royal Rumble to retain them.
Friday’s match was straightforward and dull, which isn’t a good sign. Something is missing from this act, and they need to figure it out, because when dominant heels are met with crickets, it doesn’t bode well.
6. Jinder Flops Terribly
It really is a shame that Jinder Mahal is a big, fat dud in the ring. He generates pretty good heel heat on the mic and with his presence, but he just can’t back it up when wrestling.
Case in point, Mahal’s United States Championship match against Jeff Hardy was painful to watch. Jinder is a basic wrestler at best, but when he’s off his game, even a basic match can look really bad. And Mahal was definitely off Friday.
It was readily apparent when Hardy went up for Whisper in the Wind and whiffed – and then Jinder fell down as if he had been hit. That was Jackie Gayda levels of bad.
Everyone has a bad night, but Mahal’s world title reign was a flop and he hasn’t gotten much better since then. If he could get his stuff together in the ring, then he could be something more. But right now, uggh.
5. The Undertaker On Wobbly Legs
When will WWE let Mark Calaway rest in peace?
The Undertaker seemingly retired last year at WrestleMania, but he’s now returned three times this year alone: Raw 25, WrestleMania 34 and Greatest Royal Rumble. His “match” at ‘Mania was basically a squash of John Cena where he didn’t have to do much.
But at GRR, ‘Taker battled Rusev in a surprisingly competitive match in which the Bulgarian Brute got far more offensive than you would have thought. And while the match was decent, it definitely appeared like Undertaker was on wobbly legs. At one point early on, he was slugging Rusev in the corner and stumbled backward, holding himself up with the ropes.
This might be an overreaction of sorts, but it definitely seems like ‘Taker is on his last legs in the ring as anything more than a special attraction. The risk here is that at some point, he’s going to fall down, and that’s when the mystique of The Undertaker could also take a fall.
WWE should let ‘Taker bow out gracefully, rather than continuing to ride him.
4. Soooo Looong
“It was excrutiating; It was painful.”
Byron Saxton said a mouthful there. No match should last that long. It was an exercise just to watch the whole thing, to power through the first 35 guys, knowing another 15 were coming. It really was two different matches. The first 35 were mostly jobbers, tag team wrestlers and mid-carders filling space.
At #35, Randy Orton signaled a bit of a shift, although we still had NXT guys no one knew, clumsy Titus O’Neil and Curt Hawkins filling space. But at least we got Braun Strowman, Bobby Lashley, Kevin Owens and Chris Jericho in that grouping too.
Please, never do a 50-man Rumble again, WWE.
3. So Much For Surprises
Pop quiz: Who were the surprise entrants in the Greatest Royal Rumble?
Answer: Babatunde (who?), Dan Matha (who?), Hiroki Sumi (who??) and Hornswoggle (*groan*). At least Roderick Strong and Tucker Knight have been on NXT TV.
Speculation ran wild for weeks, but ultimately, it was pretty much as advertised: 50 men in a Royal Rumble. That’s not a knock on WWE per se, but you’d think with all the hype the company gave this event that there would be something more to it. Even the title matches were baseline bouts.
This isn’t a show that’s going to be remembered years from now, other than the fact that women weren’t allowed to perform or participate in it. It was a show that was better than your average house show or B-PPV, but that was about it.
2. Roman Luger
Once again, Roman Reigns has fallen short.
The Big Dog had another WWE Universal Championship match against Brock Lesnar, and he once again failed to win the title. (We’ll talk about the “controversy” later.) This now is the fourth time Roman has faced Brock for the title (including WM 31), and he’s lost every time. Three of those losses have come during this recent Lesnar reign.
At what point do you just wave the white flag and move on? If Brock isn’t dropping the title, Reigns should move to SmackDown and try to get a fresh start. It doesn’t matter how many F-5s he kicks out of or how many spears he delivers, fans aren’t rallying to Roman.
And having him lose like this in big matches over and over and over just ruins any chance of him ever being accepted as a top guy. There’s a reason “Lex Luger” is also a verb in wrestling jargon.
1. CONTROVERSY: Two Feet Down
Are you f***ing kidding?
Immediately after the crappy ending of the Roman Reigns versus Brock Lesnar match, the announcers started playing up that there was controversy surrounding the finish of the bout, because Roman’s two feet hit the floor before Brock’s did.
So does this mean that Reigns is going to be Raw again, complaining that he’s a victim of a conspiracy to keep him down? Is he going to lobby for – and possibly receive – yet another WWE Universal Championship match?
Vince McMahon, if you want Roman to be your champion, make him your champion. This isn’t building sympathy for him. Unless Reigns is going to turn heel by complaining, it’s time to end this ridiculous storyline.
Ups...
6. Cedric Rebounds
At WrestleMania 34, Cedric Alexander finally won the WWE Cruiserweight Championship by defeating Mustafa Ali during the kickoff show. The match, which should have let it all hang out, was largely a disappointment as the two seemed timid and reserved.
Alexander got a bit of redemption Friday at Greatest Royal Rumble, beating Kalisto in a title match that saw both men flying around the ring, countering each other and basically putting together a more “traditional” cruiserweight match. Kalisto hit a seated springboard Spanish Fly at one point, and Cedric countered a Salida del Sol attempt with the Lumbar Check to retain his title.
Hopefully this is a sign of better things for Alexander, who came into WWE with a ringing endorsement from Triple H at the Cruiserweight Classic back in 2016.
5. Making The List
It was only a short promo, but seeing Chris Jericho back on the mic in WWE was a reminder of just how good he is.
Jericho got paired with Mike Rome, which of course was an opportunity for Y2J to call him “Tom (Phillips),” continuing the joke that has been ongoing for years. Jericho also busted out the List of Jericho, putting Rome on it, then adding the cameraman, sound technician and others before starting to add the other 49 superstars in the Rumble match.
It makes you wish Jericho would teach a master class to the current crop of superstars about how to deliver a memorable, fun promo. It also makes you hope Jericho is back for longer than just one night.
4. Leaving No Doubt
The result wasn’t a surprise, but the manner in which they got there might have been, pleasantly so.
Matt Hardy and Bray Wyatt captured the vacant Raw Tag Team Championships at Greatest Royal Rumble, defeating The Bar. Considering that Sheamus & Cesaro are now on SmackDown, it made perfect sense for Hardy & Wyatt to win the titles. But they did it in convincing fashion.
There was no surprise rollup or distraction finish to protect The Bar. Hardy and Wyatt took out their opponents, with Matt hitting a Twist of Fate on Cesaro to take him out of the match, then Sheamus falling to a Sister Abigail and elevated Twist of Fate.
The match itself wasn’t anything special, but we’ll give this an “up” nod because it was definitive.
3. Countout Not Satisfying, But Appropriate
It’s a shame that AJ Style and Shinsuke Nakamura seemed to be putting together a better match at Greatest Royal Rumble than they had at WrestleMania, because unlike their ‘Mania match, this one did not have a definitive finish.
After an intense battle – which seemingly benefited from Nakamura turning heel via a series of low blows – both men spilled outside and continued to fight, resulting in a double countout. That was a disappointing finish to the match, but it’s one that actually made sense given the rivalry. Styles won cleaning at WM, but Shinsuke had been getting the upper hand lately via low blows.
A clean finish would have not worked as well at this point, and while a DQ by Nakamura would have been fine to continue the storyline, this finish sets them up for another rematch, possibly a falls count anywhere match.
2. The Right Call
As much as Daniel Bryan winning the Greatest Royal Rumble would have been a storybook victory, it was the right move to have Braun Strowman finally win a big match in WWE. (Although how Bryan was tossed was aggravating.)
Strowman has been a force of nature in WWE during the past two years, but his titles consist of a one-day Raw Tag Team Championship run with 10-year-old Nicholas. He has performed impressive feats, but sooner or later, he had to put a signature win under his belt.
Friday, Strowman eliminated 13 men en route to winning a 50-man Royal Rumble. If that isn’t a signature accomplishment, then someone tell everyone what qualifies.
This might be a title win or a regular Rumble win (and WrestleMania championship match), but it is still noteworthy, and it was an impressive performance.
1. Ladder Match Delivers
Midway through the Greatest Royal Rumble event, WWE delivered a high-impact, fast-paced match. To that point, the PPV mostly consisted of solid, if unspectacular matches.
The four-man ladder match for the Intercontinental Championship involved all the elements you expect from that sort of contest: false climbs, tipped ladders, normal moves amplified by using the ladder, etc. It was a pretty entertaining match in which each man actually looked pretty good and appeared like he could win the match.
The highlight came when Finn Balor was just a step away from reaching the title when Seth Rollins springboarded to the ladder and raced to the top to grab the belt away from Finn. It was a finish we don’t see often these days, and because of that, it worked really well, with Rollins looking like a champ rushing to retain, and Balor just getting bested.
Maybe there’s a singles rematch in the cards for these two, which would be just fine.