7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite Grand Slam 2022
Jon Moxley is the king; Saraya makes epic debut; MJF commits the ultimate sin.
Even by his standards, Tony Khan built this f*cker up.
Just to clarify, this is what he is meant to do in his capacity as a wrestling promoter. He was particularly confident ahead of last night's show, claiming on Twitter that he was ready to deliver "The single best live event in New York this entire year". He promised that you won't want to miss Grand Slam. And, in true TK style, he hinted that he has something up his sleeve. The man has so many free agents up there that it's no wonder they call him Big Bicep Tone.
At least, they used to.
Khan was roundly jeered at the Albany tapings, when he was shown onscreen and later hyping up the Rampage taping in the building, because he mismanaged a situation that could drive the exits of CM Punk and or the Elite. And, since this affects virtually every AEW fan, they weren't remotely happy with him. Moreover, because MJF is so charismatic and talented - and went away for a while, which is guaranteed to get a talent more over - those fans might actually believe his anti-Tony Khan rhetoric.
Was Khan overcompensating on Twitter as a defence mechanism - or was Grand Slam truly something special?
Downs...
2. F*ck Finish City
The first three matches of five all ended with chicanery of some sort. All three finishes made sense in the context of the respective stories.
Chris Jericho is the sports entertainer carny sullying the purity of Ring Of Honor. He had to cheat.
The Acclaimed and Swerve In Our Glory first associated as mates. Swerve Strickland then broke the gentlemen's agreement at All Out by targeting Anthony Bowens' suspect knee. In the sequel, Billy Gunn avenged that - and equalised Swerve's attempt to cheat with the boombox - by influencing the outcome, thereby creating scope for another sequel.
PAC cheating to win the competitive, serious match he asked for over two years ago was great character work from a proper bastard.
The issue is that doing this across three consecutive segments detracted from the old AEW ideal that there's no shame whatsoever in clean, hard-fought defeat. Also, it was redundant.
Too much of anything is bad; too much WWE sh*t is inexplicable.
1. A Mis-Step In A Difficult Quest
The idea, and it's f*cked now of course, was to bring back MJF as a heel. CM Punk ruined that by taking all of his heat and material.
Three months' worth!
MJF subsequently manipulated the audience tremendously well and drew jeers across his last two Dynamite appearances. He got his heat back, and plumbed the ugliest depths to do it while still making his promos feel artful and not too cheap.
At Grand Slam, Tony Khan made a mistake, one that can't be excused as a noble failure. Wheeler YUTA should be granted more time to talk, but not in this context. He cut a generic promo that he stumbled through, and MJF ate the poor lad alive. Khan should have seen this coming. MJF instantly felt like the cool, major league star in contrast. This did much to undo the rewarding YUTA push.
This is only a minor 'Down', since flooring Tony Schiavone, as MJF did here, is sacrilege.
Ups...
7. Grand Slam Looks Grand
Last year's Grand Slam was a special occasion. The standing ovation that received the mere reality that the Kenny Omega Vs. Bryan Danielson dream match was happening was an immortal pro wrestling moment.
Once the haze ascended, a less-than-ideal reality crept back in: AEW had lit up the first Grand Slam with a blue hue which, combined with the way in which it was filmed, meant it looked as much like an episode of WWE SmackDown as an epic stadium show.
AEW corrected that strange own goal last night; Arthur Ashe was unmistakably gorgeous, and the director took every opportunity to show off the grand, worked scope of the setting with gratuitous wide shots.
6. Chris Jericho Is An Ageless Wonder
There's an argument to be made that Chris Jericho was the very best wrestler in the world across 2008 and 2009 - he certainly won many fan-voted awards to that effect - and somehow, he's wrestling like it's 2009 in 2022.
This new/old slimmed-down Jericho is yet another revelation; in a career defined by reinvention, this has to be his most extraordinary shift yet. The Le Champion persona was sublime, but the Wizard takes on at least two positive definitions. His ROH World Title win over Claudio Castagnoli was another triumph.
The man has never worked a style designed to draw chants of "This is awesome!", but his work has been so superb this year that he's received more than one chant of "Fight forever". Against Claudio, with an absolutely jaw-dropping midair hurricanrana counter to an avalanche ricola bomb, he did something worthy of a "Holy sh*t!". He didn't need to pull off a stunt to get it, either: he just had to display his timeless brilliance.
The match was initially built around Claudio's attempt to batter Jericho with uppercuts, and he was successful in launching into multiple strikes from creative, strategic positions. One particular flipped evasion was a breathtaking feat of agility. Jericho's own counters were superb. The match, bathed in noise, accelerated into something very special by the finish.
The finish might prove divisive, particularly on a show that was lax in its repetition, but this next evolution of the sports entertainment interloper bit is a savvy one.
5. Everybody Loves The Acclaimed
The Acclaimed Vs. Swerve In Our Glory II wasn't as stunningly great as the original match, in either its craft or its heightened emotion, but it was still a dramatic and by the finish euphoric 15 minutes of pro wrestling television.
Perhaps because the adrenaline was too much to siphon for the hometown challengers, this didn't click in the same instantly magical way that the All Out match did. Throughout, the timing was very slightly off. Certain big moments, like a botched Keith Lee pounce, didn't register as heartbreaking close calls. It was messier than was ideal, but all AEW had to do here was deliver both the correct result and a worthy sequel. That last objective was just about achieved; some of the ideas here were fantastic and Billy Gunn is somehow just as over as he was in 1998.
Keith Lee striking with a flying headscissors early was fantastic. The shocking execution was great, the timing even better: it put him over as insurmountable. Then, when Max Caster hit him with the Brainbuster and narrowly avoided a spectacular moonsault attempt, it was as if he was draining the energy bar of the final boss. In truth, it was probably too rushed to convey that feeling as well as it could have, but the atmosphere was so irresistible - and Swerve Strickland on such immaculate form as a heel - that some not insignificant quibbles really didn't matter in the end.
The Acclaimed brought the necessary fire, heart and sense of struggle, even if it was abbreviated, to earn a reaction that was inevitable even if the match was dire - and it really wasn't.
4. A Bastard's Performance
The timing of PAC's heel chicanery here was fantastic, as was the storytelling in what was a perfect second match. (This was actually their third singles contest, but it played out like a sequel to the joyous Revolution affair because the real sequel didn't maintain that vibe.)
At Revolution 2020, Orange Cassidy outwitted PAC and lulled him into various errors throughout. Here, PAC was wary of making the same mistakes and controlled the match with a brutal precision after studiously avoiding them. PAC didn't strategise for Orange's latest trick, and in a wonderful moment, the commentary team (far better sans Jim Ross, incidentally) didn't expect it either. They popped daft at an inelegant Cassidy getting his legs up with poor, telegraphed timing. The visual was utterly absurd and piss funny for it. It was a ruse that led to an electrifying near-fall and a hailstorm of stunning offence from Cassidy that boasted a top-rope DDT sell from PAC that was borderline NSFW.
In a tremendous story beat, PAC actually received the fight he asked for over two years ago. He couldn't abide it and elected to hit his opponent in the face with a hammer.
A bastard, indeed.
3. Good Match...
...mild crowd reaction.
This is a recurring and bleak theme, but the women deserve immense credit for assembling something very good in places. The action during the ad break was a mess, but only Fite viewers were aware of it.
The actual broadcasted match wasn't quite the smoothest overall, but elements of it were great. These things tend to act as an advert for singles matches as much as a match unto itself, and the super creative and state-of-the-art exchanges between Toni Storm and Athena were exceptional. Serena Deeb was dispatched to pick off various bodies and de-clutter the field with her wince-inducing dragon screw spree. If the idea was to promote an all-action match in which there was zero downtime in which to lose the audience, it didn't quite work to its fullest.
The division has been stigmatised as an afterthought, so there was little heat to begin with, and the layout was probably too ambitious. Dr. Britt Baker got busted open the hard way following a misjudged Athena strength spot. That was not good at all.
Still, Tony Khan has failed, often, to build interest in a women's match - but Storm Vs. Athena should play out in front of a hot crowd when it happens.
2. The Best Debut Of The Year
In the post-match, Jamie Hayter revealed that she was still aligned with Britt Baker, and joined in her attack of Toni Storm. Hayter has developed a strong cult following, and if it seemed strange to not follow through with a full turn, the most effective surprise debut in an age acted as an explanation.
Saraya, the former Paige, generated an eruption of a pop.
The surprise factor no doubt informed it - she was thought permanently retired - but Paige was a veritable trailblazer in WWE. The company does not look what it looks like in 2022 without her contribution to it. The fans in Queens recognised that. It's a massive indictment of AEW that someone needs to act as the catalyst for change in a company that formed after the so-called Women's Revolution, but they do. This felt like a game-changer.
AEW hasn't earned the trust of unqualified optimism, but they'd be absolutely stupid - or, much worse, completely apathetic - not to make the division feel significantly bigger with Saraya at the forefront.
1. Jon Moxley And Bryan Danielson Tear It Up...Eventually
A slow-burner of a match with a safe and steady result, this main event lacked the flash and spectacle one usually expects against a stadium backdrop. The last five minutes however were incandescent; a pyro display in itself. It was a risky layout.
After some WALTER-tier chop exchanges early, the match settled into a slower rhythm and an attritional tone, the story of which was of two men with profound respect for one another both wrestling with apprehension. The first 15 minutes informed the exhilaration of the last five: both men had done such a fantastic and intricate job of putting one another over that the late, breathless surge of near-falls were as unpredictable and as close as the last. In a great spot, with Regal's teachings equalised by both men, Mox drew on the inspiration of an old brother in Seth Rollins to stomp his way to a 2.9 count. Mox is a genius. Here, he displayed it by enhancing the drama of the last stretch by not relying on hollow tropes throughout.
There were a few too many shots of MJF. It was quite clear after the first 19 times that he was "looking on with interest".
An additional quarter star penalty for making the result somewhat obvious - Danielson controlled a great deal of it - and not lingering on Mox's triumph.