7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (January 10 - Results & Review)

Samoa Joe wears the World title VERY well as the vibe returns to All Elite Wrestling in Daily's...

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

Daily's Place - the site of last night's Dynamite and AEW's spiritual home - is magic. If that reads as the statement of an incurable mark, so be it.

Advertisement

It's so bizarre, holding a deep and near-profound nostalgia for the worst period of your life, but it was even more bizarre that AEW was capable of producing a seminal wrestling television programme under the most suboptimal of circumstances. For several months, no paid fans attended that Daily's residency, the purpose of the interactive performance art was defeated entirely, and AEW nonetheless entered an unbeatable streak.

Tony Khan stared at a bleak, empty canvas, the reason that wrestling exists missing from the picture, and saw opportunity. He booked the Young Bucks and the Butcher and the Blade to lay waste to the entire facility in a compelling, creative Falls Count Anywhere brawl. The car park, into which no customers could drive, was instead repurposed as the site of a spectacular Parking Lot Fight, a perfect and seamless blend of brawling, high spots and plunder. It was a fight that used its environment so perfectly that it earned its spectacular Holy s*** moments - and the environment should have been incredibly depressing.

Advertisement

The Daily's Place era of AEW Dynamite was bittersweet, and may not have aged well, but an improbable creative triumph all the same.

Could AEW replicate that on-fire magic last night...?

Advertisement

Downs...

2. A Non-Starter Of A Faction

AEW

The Undisputed Kingdom doesn't feel like a main event concern.

Advertisement

They are fighting a difficult challenge. They are taking the flack for AEW's infuriating sports entertainment misadventure of autumn 2023. They formed in retaliation to MJF. They lack true agency and feel like a contrivance - which is incredibly suboptimal, since the thin reason why they exist, MJF, no longer exists himself. They're now talking about winning championships and taking over and the like, which while generic is good and necessary, but it's all a lot closer to the Firm than the Four Horsemen. They don't feel like a threat, and for the second week in a row, in a promo cut after Roderick Strong beat Bryan Keith, Adam Cole's exercise in over-correction fell flat. His promo was tell-don't-show, near-identical to last week, and the guy is on crutches.

He badly needed a heel masterplan to compensate for the fact that he isn't a physical threat, and "I pretended to be annoyed by Roderick Strong in horrifically lame comedy skits to throw MJF off the scent" was hardly the work of a cerebral genius. The stable isn't a bad idea in theory. Cole has thrived in this role before. Perhaps a few more weeks are needed to disassociate fans from the ruinous trappings of "the Devil".

Advertisement

The troubling thing here, though, is that Cole promised the Undisputed Kingdom aren't going away, and few would be too bothered if they did.

1. Vibe Dampened

AEW

Sammy Guevara Vs. Ricky Starks was something of a disappointment.

Advertisement

Viewers were told of their shared history on the Texas independent scene by the commentary team, but weren't exactly shown it in the ring. This was awkward in certain places, and as good as he is, that isn't an uncommon occurrence in Ricky Starks matches. In a weird moment, Starks broke up a sequence on the apron by randomly walking back into and immediately out of the ring. If the idea was to convey that he'd been knocked so silly he didn't know where he was - and Guevara's chop was hard enough, in fairness - it didn't land. It wasn't registered with a slapstick physicality and nobody takes Guevara seriously as somebody who can mess somebody up even if, again, the chop was actually brutal.

Elsewhere, this veered between decent enough back and forth and cliché. There wasn't much heat to it; it was as if Daily's had already reckoned with the Vince McMahon booking, reconciling the idea that Guevara had to win to make any sense of the upcoming World Tag Team title match at Battle of the Belts. Guevara did win, and the finish wasn't great either. Guevara pinned Starks in a flash. The idea was that either man could have put away the other; it just happened to be Guevara's day. In execution, it felt anticlimactic, from out of nowhere.

Advertisement

In a risible post-match angle, after a handshake that revealed itself to be a ruse, Big Bill beat Guevara down. His facials were fantastic. He enjoys being a villain so, so much. He's class. The fun stopped when Chris Jericho made the save and, to prevent any boos, 'Judas' was played through the ensuing brawl.

This was cowardly and pathetic, consistent with Jericho working Battle of the Belts under the presumed, cynical idea that nobody cares about that event and that the jeers won't sound so loud at the arse-end of a long TV taping.

Advertisement

AEW is trying to keep Jericho around and hide him at the same time, and it reeks as much as this 2019 WWE tag team booking.

Ups...

7. A Quite Fun Eight-Woman Tag

AEW

In the second of two eight-man tags dedicated to the memory of the great Mr. Brodie Lee, Anna Jay, Thunder Rosa, Willow Nightingale, and Kris Statlander defeated Saraya, Ruby Soho, Julia Hart and Skye Blue when - touchingly, appropriately - Anna put Blue away with the Queenslayer.

Advertisement

It doesn't feel great pointing out a minor flaw in a tribute match, but Julia Hart, TBS champion, momentarily forgot she wasn't babyface when she joined the wrong side of the big stereo suplex spot deep into the match. Elsewhere, this was a fun enough party match, although it was a shade inferior to the one promoted earlier in the night. It was also a bit too similar to that match, what with the near-identical pounce spot. Then again, it's always nice watching Willow, who drew a pop with her version of that move, in any context.

Thunder Rosa looked sharp, which was good to see. The whole thing in fact was engineered for a nice, "You love to see it" reaction. It was a fun, knockabout turn-taking multi-man with minimal depth to it, but it broke down well. Every performer was on song timing-wise and in a position to play their role in that sequence, which was quite exciting.

Advertisement

Low-stakes fun, but it actually mattered: Anna Jay gets a shot at Julia Hart on the back of her win.

6. Short And To The Brutal Point

Roderick Strong went over Bryan Keith in just over four minutes. There wasn't much to a match that was principally designed to disassociate fans from the clown that Roddy became last year ahead of an International title show-down with Orange Cassidy. They took turns hitting each other really, really hard before Roddy lulled Keith into a chop exchange before dropping him with End of Heartache. For how long it lasted, though, it was a small plate of "real graps" in the AEW buffet. The physicality was beautifully gnarly.

Advertisement

As mentioned though, the post-match promo did little to elevate the Undisputed Kingdom as a game-changing force.

5. The Young Bucks Return

In the main event post-match (review follows shortly), Tony Schiavone asked Sting who he wanted to face in his retirement bout. The question was seemingly answered for him by the returning Young Bucks who, in a silent stare-down that probably went a bit long, declared their intentions.

Advertisement

If 2021 acts as evidence, and hopefully it does, the rule is: the more offensive the facial hair, the better the Bucks are as obnoxious heels. And they looked, thank Christ, like complete a**holes last night.

This is a great, great idea, incidentally. This incarnation of Sting is a party match specialist, and the Bucks are the best of all-time at that genre. Sting Vs. the Young Bucks in 2024 is as perfect a match as Sting Vs. Ric Flair was in 1988, as perfect as Sting Vs. Vader was in 1992.

Advertisement

The Young Bucks created movement for the best AEW Sting match at Forbidden Door 2022, and barely needed any of the usual shortcuts to get there. Imagine a match between them with shortcuts and a real emotional undercurrent. There is nobody better for his last one.

Nobody.

Advertisement

4. A Very Fun Eight-Man Tag

AEW

This was a very Tony Khan match, but given why it was held, he can be forgiven for leaning on the babyface supergroup trope he rendered charmless throughout 2023.

Advertisement

Adam Copeland, Preston Vance, Orange Cassidy and Dustin Rhodes defeated Lance Archer, Brian Cage and the Gates Of Agony. The basic story saw the Mogul Embassy untrusting of Archer, the outsider - at last, a random squad don't automatically get along for the convenience of a match! - and the faces as a result using their smarts to get past the grunting alpha hoss types whose caveman egos never allowed to get themselves into lockstep.

It was breezy, all-action fun, and while the action itself wasn't prime, spectacular AEW multi-man fare, it was very over in that enchanting building and all of it was timed incredibly well to keep everybody guessing - some achievement, given that there was only ever one result.

Advertisement

There was only ever one finish, too, and AEW nailed it: paying tribute to Mr. Brodie Lee, his protege Preson Vance, who looked determined to impress throughout, smashed Kaun with the Discus lariat for the pin.

3. Samoa Joe Is A Great Champion Already

AEW

There's a good and bad version of everything in wrestling, other than an invisible camera segment, and Samoa Joe's initiation as AEW World champion segued into of all things a compelling promo train.

Advertisement

Joe started his promo with a mission statement: if a prospective challenger wants to step up to him, and they have the winning record and the credentials, he'll mess them up. He will not dignify any challengers who dabble in - what a line this was - "ho-assed" social media activity. Joe wants to put the nonsense that has swarmed the company over the last two years in the past. A lot of people needed to hear that, and Joe articulated with hilarious verbiage and his menacing, cool, world-class delivery.

He was interrupted first by Swerve Strickland, and the mere sight of them sharing the same space felt big. The prospect of two very, very cool wrestlers entering into a major title programme felt refreshing, after the comedy and mystery over the latter part of 2023, and Swerve announced his attentions with ice-cold poise. Hangman Page then announced his intentions to get back into the title picture, and before things went a bit too 2010s Raw, the Mogul Embassy and then Hangman retreated.

Advertisement

This allowed HOOK - complete with a bat signal far less lame than it had any right to be - to square up to Joe to set up their match next week. This was bold, given HOOK's booking over the last 18 months, but he must still have some aura left: the nose-to-nose confrontation felt alluring.

It's new, high-stakes ground for HOOK, and an intriguing stylistic prospect that promises a new tenor to the World title picture.

Advertisement

2. A VINTAGE Dynamite Opener

AEW

Hangman Page Vs. Claudio Castagnoli was a beautiful shoot-out of an opener.

Advertisement

Worked against the Jacksonville skyline and the unbeatable vibe of Daily's, Page was physically outmatched initially by Claudio, the description of whom by Kevin Owens - he's a human horse - remains brilliant in its economy. In the first phase of the match, Hangman sought to win by catching Claudio out with various flash pin attempts before growing in confidence. Page is one of the more intelligent wrestlers in the game - really, of all time - and he used his sharp mind to create an excellent picture-and-picture segue. He took a sip of beer from a ringside fan as Tony Schiavone crowed, nostalgically, about old times. Claudio then grabbed Page and smashed him almost head-first with a press slam over the top rope and onto the ramp. This was no homecoming, but rather a reminder that the work, for a babyface like Page, is never over. The challenges only heighten, literally true in the case of his opponent on the night.

As the modern back-and-forth match often does, Hangman Vs. Claudio evolved into a shoot-out in which both men threw bombs at one another after an exchange of forearms. The execution was snug, the drama and timing terrifying and spectacular - that hurricanrana reversal from the attempted avalanche ricola bomb! - but the unusual, beautiful configuration of the venue elevated the action. The stage stationed right next to the ring was used by Page in what was made to feel like an improvised opportunity to strike Claudio with a moonsault. After more intense back-and-forth, Page won and framed Claudio as a serious threat after a double-barrelled Buckshot salvo.

Advertisement

Very, very good match, one that the intoxicating atmosphere helped broach greatness.

1. A Very Good And Very Dynamite Main Event

AEW

Sting and Darby Allin defeated Konosuke Takeshita and Powerhouse Hobbs in an unhinged main event. It was the best Sting party match in a while - purposefully or otherwise.

Advertisement

In yet another great magic trick in a run overflowing with them, Sting after a walk and brawl sequence draped Hobbs over a flight case, rolling him into a nasty tumble to the concrete floor. Sting can't do much and can increasingly do less and less, and that was a cracking idea for a chaotic slapstick spot. Darby and Takeshita revisited their exquisite psycho chemistry when Take splattered him neck-first with a rolling German suplex by the ring. It was around this time that Sting looked to be in real trouble. The ref looked nervous, commentary sounded nervous. He got back into it, after a bleak vibe-wrecker of a cameo from Ric Flair, when hitting Take and Hobbs with a pair of Stinger splashes. The spring and impact isn't what it was even two years ago, but the emotional weight will always land. A scary, anxiety-inducing layer of drama is drama all the same.

Just when you thought he couldn't do his signature Holy S*** moment, after Darby took Takeshita out with a demented Coffin drop from the top of the set, Sting walked Hobbs along the concrete seating area and smashed him through two tables erected by the heels earlier in the match with a Scorpion Death Drop. This was a great spot, even better than the Darby Special in which he was thrown and spun like a rag in a washing machine at the same insane time by the two hoss heel monsters.

Advertisement

A vintage, expertly laid-out Sting party match - even if you'd be happy if the next one is the last.