7 Wrestling Gimmicks WWE Should Recycle

1% of the time, it works every time.

By Michael Sidgwick /

Very little in wrestling is novel.

Advertisement

Take James Ellsworth. The elevated jobber trope is a classic wrestling staple, which WWE has previously used to stellar effect with the improbable rise of Barry Horowitz in the mid-nineties. Tyler Breeze is currently channelling Rick Martel and the Narcissist (albeit with zero support from the creative team). Braun Strowman is the latest towering monster to emerge from the production line of WWE's patented monster factory.

More glorious wrestling templates are ripe for reissue. On this week's RAW, Seth Rollins referred to Chris Jericho as "Sparklecrotch", positioning him as the umpteenth talent to adopt John Cena's unfunny diss merchant shtick. It is a derivative, counterproductive and illogical development. Shockingly, given that the same RAW staffer probably penned that line, he is now tonally identical to Dean Ambrose - the man who just months ago was his diametric opposite.

To put an end to the monotony, WWE should, as my man Jim Cornette via Kenny Bolin puts it, "fire the f*ckin' writers!" But, since that it is never going to happen, let's instead daydream over the glorious traditions WWE would be well advised to exhume...

7. The Maniac With No Regard For His Own Safety

The PG era makes such a resuscitation difficult, but if part-time non-wrestler Shane McMahon is allowed to launch himself from the top of the Cell to get himself over, so too should a willing full-time roster member. Though, perhaps not Charlotte...

Advertisement

50/50 booking remains a critical problem for WWE. The Clash of Champions Chris Jericho Vs. Sami Zayn match, good as it was, may as well not have happened. Both men are, more or less, in the same position. Why should we care about their progression, when the creative team doesn't?

Implementing a Tommy Dreamer-esque character - one who is as equally willing to lose as they are to maim themselves in the process of doing so - would provide an emerging WWE talent with a leaving, breathing, sympathetic barrier through which to smash en route to the top of the card.

This man (or woman - that division, too, needs a hierarchy) wouldn't have to go to lunatic lengths to make the character work. The essence, not the extent, is all that would be required - think more Spike Dudley than Mick Foley (5:49).

More long-term, their status as pitiable punching bag would lend itself well to a push based on audience sentiment months - or even years - down the line.

6. The 1% Percent

In these times of austerity and widespread political uncertainty, it would be remiss of WWE not to position one of their stars in a guaranteed heat-seeker of a heel role. The mega-rich arch villain is so detestable that it's a wonder WWE doesn't deploy them more frequently. There's something about someone with money - especially cash that's flaunted and or barely earned - that riles people up into a frenzy.

Advertisement

To their credit, WWE did try to revive the trope by literally wheeling out Alberto Del Rio in a fleet of luxury cars - but without the illusion of kayfabe which so benefitted Ted DiBiase, it was altogether more difficult to suspend disbelief.

Fans would be more willing to believe in a character who has already reached a - and been seduced by his - massively monied position.

Enter Roman Reigns. Already a loathed beneficiary of nepotism, the man is practically begging to be re-contextualised into a man who would sneer at such supplication. He already occupies the 1% bracket, in a way; as a Vince McMahon pet project, he breathes rarified air. Why not press the issue by flaunting his wealth, as well as his status, in the face of fans?

Fans don't need another reason to hate Reigns - but a DiBiase/Drew McIntyre hybrid is, if you'll forgive the pun, money.

5. The Zeitgeist-Grabber

When DX crotch-chopped their way across the WWF in 1997, it was a revelation. Not only were they almost single-handedly raising the Federation's TV Parental Guideline rating, they did so by tapping into the mainstream pulse. With the advent of nu-metal and the back-in-vogue gross-out gag, obnoxiousness and puerility was the order of the day. Triple H and Shawn Michaels were ahead of the curve. No act in WWE comes close to similarly capturing the imagination of the casual audience.

Advertisement

Sasha Banks in NXT was the exception last year - adopting the language and iconography of urban music, she was, to borrow the nomenclature, on fleek, as she made her entrance at TakeOver: Brooklyn. Upon her main roster promotion, when she was eventually featured prominently, her identifiable traits were rounded off at the edges.

It's ironic; WWE has long been desperate in their attempts to court an uncaring mainstream media, but their transparence holds them back. Instead, by embracing fashion (admittedly difficult for an out-of-touch Vince McMahon), they could attract the fans whose would-be, newfound love of the product would compel the media to take notice.

They go with the trend - WWE have been unsuccessfully going the long way 'round for years now.

4. The Everyman

It is a credit to the wilful obstruction placed above Dusty Rhodes' head that he made his retooled character work to the extent it did in the WWF. Fans took him to their bosom, despite his ridiculous polka-dotted garb, because he was so obviously, thrillingly, one of their own.

Advertisement

There's a reason football fans prefer a hometown hero over a more skilful foreign import. Wish fulfilment is a major component behind the success of both sport and culture - a line WWE claim to blur.

WWE - or, more accurately, NXT - did almost transpose this sentiment with their handling of the TJ Perkins character during the Cruiserweight Classic - which, incidentally, feels like it happened a lifetime ago. Drawing on his real-life backstory of homelessness, fans identified with Perkins because they could relate to his plight. It's perhaps no coincidence, then, that they readily accepted TNA cast-off Perkins as tournament winner ahead of more the more hyped and exotic field.

However, as of last night's RAW, he became yet another zing merchant. As Drew Gulak - who, of course, was suspiciously just off-camera - sidled up to him, Perkins poked fun at his medieval-looking outfit, asking whether Tony Nese was his knight in shining armour. In one moment, Perkins made the transition from a relatable avatar for the common man to a cookie cutter WWE (c) babyface.

Instead of toying with a proven formula, WWE should revert back to it.

3. The Intermittent Avenger

In late nineties WCW, Sting, irate at the state of his beloved, infiltrated company, refashioned himself as a lone wolf - a "free agent", as he put it.

Advertisement

Turning his back on the company he bled for, Sting instead promised to "pop in from time to time". When he did so, unadvertised, it was thrilling. It is a testament to the power of the character that fans wanted him to go literally batsh*t crazy over the hottest, must-see act in wrestling at the time - the nWo.

The payoff was nonexistent - we can thank Hulk Hogan's inflated ego for that - but for a solid year or so, WCW, so over-the-top elsewhere, preserved the mystique of the Sting character by deploying him with admirable restraint.

WWE in 2016 is a beast rendered dull through excruciating overexposure. Sometimes it's hard to maintain perspective. Tyler Black is currently feuding with Kevin Steen over a top-tier WWE title. Awful writing aside, that is a thoroughly wonderful development. But, sandwiched between interminable dross, it's hard to muster up the requisite enthusiasm.

Reinstalling the intermittent avenger trope would furnish weekly programming with a desperately-needed air of unpredictably. Fans would be more inclined to sit through their weekly dose of Titus O'Neill if, say, a newly-heel Dean Ambrose lived up to his unhinged moniker and Joker comparison, lighting up WWE just to see it burn.

2. The Main Event Heel Stable

The glorious aberration of The Shield aside, WWE's form with stables has been inconsistent at best in recent years.

Advertisement

3MB and the Social Outcasts were harmless, but elsewhere, the League of Nations were a total chore to sit through. Blatantly thrown together in a fit of desperation, their modus operandi was nonexistent. They preached halfhearted anti-American sentiments - and while they feuded with American Roman Reigns, the man hardly professed his patriotism.

A great main event heel stable - like the Four Horsemen and Evolution - gifts bookers/writers with years' worth of engaging - and tested - storylines. They possess a numbers advantage of their babyface foes, imbuing rivalries with psychologically-sound heat and, and in the case of the ubiquitous beat-down, genuine emotion. Their dominance over the company lends it winning continuity, and presents a deluge of multi-man tag and handicap affairs. With a dominant faction at the heart of a company, programming writes itself.

And, just as the act reaches its apex, an underling, who has learned under the on and offscreen tutelage of their mentors, is afforded a gilt-edged opportunity to enter a proven (and much-anticipated) main event series and emerge from it as a star.

Enough time has passed since the days of Evolution (brief 2014 reformation not withstanding) - let's hope there is fire where there's smoke.

1. The Mike Bennett

Mike 'The Prodigy' Bennett's Ring Of Honor persona was an enterprising work of genius. A sports entertainer in a straight-laced wrestling world, his intentionally anachronistic persona was an astute harbinger of heat. Hardcore ROH fans hated him because he was the enemy incarnate.

Advertisement

A straight subversion wouldn't quite work - to the widespread audience, who increasingly share a similar ethos to the taste-making ROH devotees, a plain wrestler in a sports entertainment world would probably become a babyface. It would cast a counterproductive shadow over the rest of the roster.

That said, this would be one of the few occasions on which WWE's patented Flanderisation would actually work. Creating a chickensh*t heel, afraid of the plethora and overabundance of gimmick matches, would make it that much more cathartic when he was contrived into wrestling one.

Moreover, a steadfast refusal to engage in a fifteen minute promo - instead, our wrestler could spend that time simply warming up in the ring - would raise the hackles of the audience, who would go wild in their support of the man who would batter him and rescue them from boredom.

WWE has a dubious record with postmodernism (see: The Authority), but variety, for better or worse (see: The Boogeyman) livens up wrestling.

Advertisement