8 Match Star Ratings For WWE Royal Rumble 2020

Uneven undercard, but what really mattered was unbelievably great.

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE had much to accomplish at the 2020 Royal Rumble, particularly since, for reasons hard to place - the lack of a true, ascending star, no imminent returns from part-time megastars? - it didn't much feel like WrestleMania season yesterday.

Advertisement

WWE had to heat Becky Lynch back up. Her big, brash talk hadn't landed as well as it had in 2018, and her crisis in confidence schtick, well-intentioned as a babyface - she should want to avenge that loss - veered too far in the other direction. She didn't feel like Becky Lynch, and she didn't feel like Becky Lynch when she was being Becky Lynch. This time last year, the Women's division was on fire. This year, ahead of Royal Rumble weekend, just five women were announced for the titular match. This was pathetic, and sad. Were they not worth promoting?

The Fiend needed a convincing, and more importantly over match. Bray Wyatt has engineered a cult following online, more than he ever did as an actual cult leader, but then the bell rings, and if it's only subjectively awful, it is objectively quiet. No Fiend match has gotten over. That is a fact.

WWE also had to pay off the very intriguing Brock Lesnar hook with a satisfying elimination spot that built, if not a breakout star, then a compelling WrestleMania 36 match.

Did WWE accomplish any of this...?

8. KICKOFF: Shorty G Vs. Sheamus

A broad story told in a way that wasn't particularly compelling, this was a disappointment, but perhaps one excused by Sheamus' ring rust and its position on the card.

Advertisement

Sheamus is taller and stronger, Shorty G is shorter and pluckier, and this dynamic was explored early when Sheamus continually threw Shorty to the canvas, with a thud, in exchanges fought at a glacial pace. This didn't work in generating a reaction from the crowd; the palpable lack of intensity made that power boring, and that guile all but impotent. This was a Kickoff match, and was wrestled in that gear as a result, but without Sheamus clubbing Shorty with his trademark stiffness, they failed to orchestrate and real sense of peril or drama early.

The hardway blood that emerged from Shorty's ear seems to undermine that take, but the sight of blood usually extracts some sort of reaction from the crowd. It didn't here. By the time the stiffness intensified, the pace never picked up to unglue the crowd. It was almost pointlessly painful.

Quintessentially solid, plodding WWE fare, this was a dire night for the returning Superstars on SmackDown. At least John Morrison had an easier shift.

Star Rating: ★★¾

7. KICKOFF: Andrade Vs. Humberto Carillo - United States Championship Match

There is a clear edict expressed to the talent working these absolutely pointless Kickoff shows: slow it down, don't get too much sh*t in, don't go too long, ease the crowd into it, go home.

Advertisement

The panel chatter is inane. Nobody has ever said anything insightful. There's a perverse bemusement to be had at times, but that's about it. What should have proved welcome reprieve did not; weirdly, since this was set up by a Ladder match and an injury angle, this badly lacked in heat, intensity and energy.

After a hot enough start, Andrade and Carillo laboured through a contrived and tentative lucha exchange to set up a fairly bizarre, immersion-breaking spot. Andrade purposefully ducked Carillo's dive attempt. He saw him modify his movement into a slide, and was still perplexed when he saw that Carillo hadn't...stopped still? on the canvas. It was weird, and Carillo failed quite badly to project the theme of disrespect with his body language. Andrade, for all of his exhilarating work, is guilty of the odd gap in logic. Lucha-adjacent in style, in-house WWE in pace and structure, and met with a mild audience reaction, this was a real disappointment for which internal policy wasn't exclusively at fault.

They worked a far better effort at TLC's Kickoff, and had more to work from, given the recent, profiled events of Monday Night RAW.

Star Rating: ★★½

6. Roman Reigns Vs. King Corbin - Falls Count Anywhere Match

In what was genuinely quite an impressive achievement, Roman Reigns and King Corbin worked a 21:18 match that actually felt longer than the two Rumble matches combined.

Advertisement

The layout was dire, and the action was nowhere near intense nor interesting enough to make up for it. It was every weapons-based WWE gimmick match you've ever seen, fought with a flat turn-taking structure and methodical pace that betrayed the purpose of a pay-per-view opener. It was especially disheartening because, on a night on which WWE re-learned so many valuable lessons from the past, whichever agent mapped this out learned not a thing from just last month's similarly drab TLC bore.

A hot finish was at least tacked on to the last five minutes, at least five minutes too late, in which Corbin' latest crew of heel associates assaulted Roman Reigns. The comeback spot facilitated by the Usos was exciting, and at last made enterprising use of the Falls Count Anywhere stip, following which Reigns avenged the storyline humiliation in mildly, mildly amusing comedy set-pieces.

It felt like an entertaining, only-in-WWE spectacle by the finish, but by Christ did it take an eternity to get there.

Star Rating: ★★

5. Women's Royal Rumble Match

In which WWE extracted so much from such minimal/abused resources.

Advertisement

In spite of a badly fading main roster Women's division and almost comically bad build, WWE relied on the women of NXT and faces from yesteryear to obscure this and deliver a very good - but likely controversial - Royal Rumble match.

Considerably better than last year's broadly comedic and overlong misfire, this was far more economical. Last year, Ember Moon, Natalya, and Charlotte Flair all entered 50+ minute stints. None got particularly over, because as a match it was flabby and inconsequential, but Bianca Belair impressed in a powerhouse performance in which she broke the record for most eliminations in a Women's Rumble match. This was tied by Shayna Baszler's blitzkrieg cameo, which sadly was just that. Candice LeRae looked excellent in her cameo, and Naomi's interpretation of the creative elimination save might be the most impressive yet. The core strength required to cling to the barricade in the manner she did - and the tiny gap she left between her feet and the mats - rendered this a superbly athletic spot of agonising drama.

The match as a whole never meandered, advanced future storylines, called back to fond memories of yesteryear, created an advertisement of a bright future with its various interactions, and generally had no right to be as effective and over as it was.

Star Rating: ★★★¾

4. Bayley Vs. Lacey Evans - SmackDown Women's Championship Match

An uneven match, it at least evidenced that the decision to turn Lacey was the correct one; she's still far, far from complete as a pro wrestler, but her raw, impressive athleticism - witnessed early with a nice, vaulting elbow drop - is more engaging than watching her work a basic hold in the customary, limited WWE heel vein.

Advertisement

Bayley is more proficient, obviously, but isn't interesting as a heel, and her heat spot wasn't interesting nor particularly convincing. She suckered Lacey into it by feigning a knee injury, grunted as she threw some strikes, shouted at somebody or other at ringside, and ground down the pace to very little reaction. The inevitable chinlock happened, and it was somehow worse than boring, because, following agent instructions, she shook her head from side to side as if to display anxiety at the show of support. It was largely silent in the stadium, highlighting what a patterned and ho-hum match this was.

It was also repetitive; Bayley applied three chinlocks in as many minutes. Comeback, cut-off, mimicked pose taunt, missed move, feeding the real comeback; this was the sort of match an agent phones in deep into RAW's second hour.

Heel grabs the tights, "wins" indecisively as rematch pretext, few if any react.

End scene.

Star Rating: ★★

3. The Fiend Vs. Daniel Bryan - Universal Championship Strap Match

The Fiend is not to your writer's subjective tastes. This particular Fiend match drew a relatively strong crowd reaction, and was well-worked in its own specific, divisive context, and it was not drenched in that putrid, migraine-inducing red light.

Advertisement

This is a way of saying that it worked for others, just not for me personally, in a bid to remain objective.

The problem with the Fiend is a profound psychological gap that renders most of the story beats arbitrary and difficult to invest in. Unlike other monsters - the stomach of Brock Lesnar, the slow pace of the Big Show et al. - with the possible exception of his testicles, there is no definable weak spot to the Fiend's game that one can detect as a shift in momentum, thus undermining the babyface comeback. There's no sense that he can be overcome, if the babyface is intelligent and resilient enough. It's essentially hopeless, and if it is the mask, as was possibly alluded to here, what happens when it's removed? Is...is that it? That is a Shyamalan twist, if indeed it is the case.

At least, with that red light not bearing down, the crowd was able to register the horrendous welts over Bryan's body, which added a layer of realism and humanity to a spectacle that is ordinarily too cartoonish to take seriously. The horror-movie-in-a-wrestling-ring bit is inherently farcical, but the decision to go for torture-porn as the sub-genre was effective enough.

Bryan, being a genius, actually contrived to make this halfway-realistic with his expert sense of timing and snug execution. But his clever strategy, of pulling the Fiend into positions of harm, ultimately held no weight. The match was at its best when it most resembled a wrestling match - Bryan's babyface fire was awesome at points - but, in the end, the Fiend, unaffected, no-sold the strap he'd sold for 10 minutes and just simply won.

Star Rating: ★★¾

2. Becky Lynch Vs. Asuka - RAW Women's Championship Match

This felt flat for a long old time, through its placement on the card, only-solid build, whatever: there was little in the way of graduating intensity nor the big fight feel that elevated last year's original.

Advertisement

A good, almost old-fashioned WWE match in that the bumps mostly served the methodically-paced story, the most frightening was very effective. Asuka took an absolutely wicked face-first bump from the apron to ringside, but per the wider storyline, Becky Lynch had to reach these lengths to put the Empress away. Asuka had been built as a killer who had her number. This wasn't gratuitous; it was necessary.

They got there in the end, and that's the lede here; this was a very polished worker's match boasting a fabulous finish at which the whole thing peaked consistently with the thrust of the storyline. Proper babyface catharsis fused with idiosyncratically wonderful pro wrestling theatre, the sight of Asuka's mist spraying impotently into the ether paid off her heel work and Becky's ring general intelligence with gorgeous GIF material.

The match was forgettable, the finish exciting, memorable and effective; this is what they talk about when they talk about "learning how to work".

Star Rating: ★★★½

1. Men's Royal Rumble Match

An absolutely glorious, pulsating, deeply thought-out and fully committed triumph of a Royal Rumble match, this was so incredible and stirring that it almost singlehandedly restored faith in WWE's creative process and built rapt anticipation for WrestleMania. It was a double-barrelled blast of a masterstroke.

Advertisement

Brock Lesnar was so terrifying in the opening sequence that his assault of Elias looked like something from a wildlife documentary. From there, the expected structure - Lesnar kills your favourites to piss you off, before a hero emerges to exact retribution - played out to perfection. Gruesome (Kofi Kingston's murder); hilarious (his turn on Shelton Benjamin); ultimately rewarding (his elimination to a fresh, ascendant star): this was a stupendous bit of business.

It was so inspired. It was no accident, that WWE selected cult online favourites in Cesaro and Shinsuke Nakamura for this abattoir scene: the idea was to intensify the loathing of the crowd, in order for them to rally behind Drew, and they did.

Edge's return was a euphoric, all-timer of a WWE 'Moment', but there was far more substance to it than that. His interplay with AJ Styles and Randy Orton was excellent, and built two matches in the medium and long-term. His elimination of the Viper was classic, intelligent babyface work, and the improvised camaraderie they shared felt genuinely vital. The events of the finish were germane to plot developments on RAW; the last-gasp drama was driven by expert, manipulative tension; several stories were advanced or teased: this was a classic Rumble match crafted by an organisation that, in stunning contrast to the idiotic chaos of several months ago, seems to have grasped what to do and when to do it.

This, coupled with 2018's stunner and last year's more workmanlike success, has put a definitive end to the Royal Rumble's period of disastrous malaise.

Ultimately, with Royal Rumble 2020, the titular matches of which were the most important, WWE pulled off a triumph of a show that couldn't have been more perfectly timed. People were tentatively starting to believe again, and this PPV repaid that faith as a minimum.

Star Rating: ★★★★½

Advertisement