8 Times Vince McMahon Regretted Huge WWE Contracts
Because buyer's remorse is a very real thing.
It was only last month that it was made public just how much WWE's current top earners were taking home on an annual basis. Leading the way on that front, of course, was Brock Lesnar.
With a $10 million salary, Paul Heyman's Beast edges out the likes of Roman Reigns ($5 million), Randy Orton ($4.1 million), and Seth Rollins ($4 million) when it comes to the highest paid talents under a WWE contract. And for the first time ever, a purely on-screen female talent was listed amongst the company's top earners as Becky Lynch and her $3.1 million contract saw her in sixth place amongst WWE's high rollers.
Whether those names are worth their respective salaries, that's an argument for another day. That said, Vince McMahon and WWE have been left regretting lucrative contracts at so many points over the decades. Obviously, that regret can be down to many different reasons - be it a wrestler's inability to perform as expected, a sh*tty attitude, extreme injury issues, or outright offering someone way more money than ever realistically made sense.
Taking all of those factors into account, then...
8. Ultimate Warrior
For those who grew up watching him on their screens, there really was no presence quite like the Ultimate Warrior. But for those same facepaint-adorned, tassle-wearing kids of the '80s and '90s, there was the realisation in later life that Warrior was a racist, homophobic, generally xenophobic false hero.
Zeroing back in on the point of this article, the contract that Vince McMahon would've regretted the most when dealing with Warrior was the deal that the Ultimate One was signed to back in 1996.
Having spent the best part of four years out of the company, Warrior returned to action with a squash match victory over Hunter Hearst Helmsley at WrestleMania XII. McMahon truly hoped to spearhead his attack on WCW with Warrior front-and-centre in fresh match-ups against the likes of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels, and so Vince agreed to pay Warrior a $1 million salary, allow him to work just 14 shows a month, and pay the Parts Unknown native an additional $2,500 for each show he attended.
Of course, Warrior being Warrior, Vince was soon left to rue his decision to bring back the former WWF Champion. Barely four months later, Warrior was gone from the company for no-showing numerous events.
Still, bizarrely, McMahon would again reach out and offer Warrior a five-year contract the following year - albeit on lesser base pay.
7. Mark Henry
These days, Mark Henry is a WWE Hall of Famer and a one-time World Heavyweight Champion beloved for his ass-kicking Hall of Pain days. But for a spell there, Vince McMahon must have had a huge sense of buyer's remorse over the initial contract he'd signed the World's Most Strongest Man to.
Having competed at the 1996 Olympic Games, Henry was snapped up by the then-WWF. An established, successful athlete, making the jump to professional wrestling? That's something that's been commonplace in WWE and across the wrestling business for decades. While McMahon taking a chance on Mark Henry was no major surprise, what was surprising was the contract given to the hoss-like strong rookie.
In an unprecedented move, Henry was signed to a whopping ten-year deal worth a guaranteed $250,000 per year at a time when guaranteed money wasn't commonplace in the WWF. For a rookie with zero wrestling experience, this was a truly huge deal - and one that irked many of those on the WWF roster at the time.
What made this worse for McMahon for a spell, is that Mark Henry just didn't click with the business for several years. Initially too green for the role he was put in, it looked like taking such a punt on the Olympian was a foolish move from the company. Still, they were tied in for ten years, regardless.
Fortunately, Henry finally found his groove and would go on to become one of the modern-day great powerhouse performers.
6. The Club
Just to clarify, yes, the tandem of Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows are one of the very best tag teams in the world. With their tag run in New Japan Pro Wrestling as part of The Bullet Club, Anderson and Gallows put themselves on the map as major players in the tag team game.
The reason for The Club's inclusion here has zero to do with the pair's work or talent, but more to do with how Vince McMahon must look back in frustration at the most recent WWE contracts signed by Machine Gun and Doc.
Ever since All Elite Wrestling started to become a reality, we've seen how WWE has desperately tried to get any and all talents to sign new long-term contracts in an attempt to stop said stars from signing with this burgeoning rival promotion. And what better way to convince people to tie themselves down to lengthy deals than by offering them a massive wedge of cash?
In the case of The Club, Anderson and Gallows were rightfully frustrated with how they'd been used during so much of these past few years, and thus they were reportedly looking to refuse any WWE contract extension and instead were keen to explore what other options are out there. Well, that was until WWE offered them a staggering $750,000 basic salary apiece last year.
Seeing such Scrooge McDuck levels of moolah did indeed convince this tag pairing to re-sign with WWE. And upon their recent WWE release on April 15, it seems that Anderson and Gallows would've had quite the golden handshake upon being let out of their hefty contracts.
5. Sin Cara
Back when Mistico signed with WWE in 2011, it was seen as a genuinely big deal for the company. A Triple H signing, this CMLL standout had long been viewed as one of the best in-ring talents in the world, and now WWE had secured a signing viewed by many as the heir apparent to Rey Mysteiro Jr.
Mistico had already had several opportunities to sign with WWE, yet he would always ultimately turn down the advances of Vince McMahon's sports entertainment juggernaut. That was until he became unhappy in CMLL in 2010, and then the shiny promised land of World Wrestling Entertainment became a much more appealing prospect for the real-life Luis Uribe.
Much was made of Mistico's signing, with WWE holding a press release to welcome this major Mexican name. While the salary specifics of Mistico's signing were never revealed, it's believed that this marque signing was tied down to an extremely lucrative multi-year deal. Unfortunately for WWE though, it soon became apparent that this signing was to be a dud.
Taking on the new mantle of Sin Cara, a botch-laced debut match against Primo Colon was the first warning sign for WWE. Several uninspired, average-at-best matches followed for Sin Cara before he would be suspended for failing a wellness test, then was put on the shelf with a lengthy knee injury.
Uribe's last match in WWE came in October 2013, with the Hunico taking over the Sin Cara role as Uribe returned to CMLL and cemented his spot as one of WWE's most frustrating big-name signings in history.
4. Rob Gronkowski
To paraphrase Randy Savage, Rob Gronkowski's WWE career appears to be nothing more than a cup of coffee in the big time.
Having signed a contract with WWE back in March of this year, many wrestling fans were wincing at the prospect of seeing Gronk as a semi-regular presence on WWE TV over the next couple of years. Thankfully, the legendary NFL tight end was with the company for barely a month before deciding that he wanted to return to the football field with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
The final figure on Gronkowski's WWE contract was never officially revealed, although Dave Meltzer had previously suggested that Gronk would be on a similar salary as Ronda Rousey to work a schedule more akin to Brock Lesnar. That means approximately $5 million for a handful of matches each year.
Given how it was Gronkowski's call to scrap this contract, WWE has likely not been hit too hard in the pocket by any of this. The regret for the company here, mind, is more than they'd put so much time, effort, and financial commitment into securing the signature of Rob Gronkowski, only to see Gronk walk away from that deal merely weeks into it.
3. Big Show
Upon snatching Paul Wight from WCW in 1999, Vince McMahon must've thought he had hit the jackpot.
A legitimate giant with impressive movement and athleticism, Wight is the sort of monster performer who Vinny Mac famously gets tight in the pants over. And thus, McMahon signed Wight to a ten-year deal worth just shy of $1 million a year basic salary and turned him into the Big Show.
There's no doubting that Paul Wight will one day end up in the WWE Hall of Fame, with the four-time WWE Champion going on to be revered as one of the very best giants that the business has seen. The thing is, Vince must've spent so many of Big Show's early WWE career tearing his hair out about the contract he'd signed Wight to.
In recent years, Big Show has been brutally honest about just how green he was during the formative years of his WWE career. And McMahon was quick to realise that, with Show soon paired with the Undertaker in a move designed to teach the former WCW World Heavyweight Champion how to make the most of his unique attributes.
Still, weight issues and attitude problems saw Big Show on and off main WWE TV over the first few years of his time with the company, and the company went as far as to send him to developmental territory Ohio Valley Wrestling for a spell. Even when he was featured on WWE programming during those years, he was often utilised as a midcard comedic character who was far from the $1 million-per-year main event act Vince McMahon thought he was getting.
2. Kevin Nash
The amount of money Kevin Nash made during the heady heights of WCW's peak is the stuff of legend. If various reports over the years are to be believed, Nash had a unique contract that saw his pay instantly bumped up should anyone sign for the company on more money than he was earning. As such, there was a spell of time where Big Sexy was taking home over $1.5 million a year.
Upon returning to the World Wrestling Federation in 2002 as Vince McMahon brought in the nWo, Nash was given a deal for an annual downside guarantee of $700,000. But, as became a running joke with Big Daddy Cool, that run with the company saw Nash as forever being one match away from an injury.
After only a month back with McMahon's company, Nash was put on the shelf with a bicep injury. Upon returning, the multiple-time World Champion was instantly faced with another spell on the sidelines - this time a quadriceps tear rending Nash out of action for nine months.
By the time all was said and done with this particular Kevin Nash run in WWE, the former Diesel competed in just 17 TV matches across an 18-month spell - with only a handful of those being singles contests. Even after departing the company following SummerSlam 2003, Nash was soon forced to undergo neck surgery as the wear and tear on his body continued to make itself known.
1. Bret Hart
Arguably the most famous contract negotiations in the history of professional wrestling - largely because so much of it was showcased in the Wrestling with Shadows documentary - is the situation involving Bret Hart back in 1996.
At this point in time, Hart was the best wrestler on the planet - sorry Shawn fans - and was one of Vince McMahon's most loyal of soldiers. Whereas so many former WWF mainstays were now competing for Ted Turner's WCW, the Hitman was happy to stay with the World Wrestling Federation. So happy, October 21, 1996 saw Bret sign a mammoth 20-year deal to remain with the company.
With the green, green pastures of WCW waving ludicrous amounts of money at Hart, he instead opted to take the lesser amount of a reported $1 million a year to stay with the organisation for whom he'd worked since 1984. That salary would reduce once Hart's in-ring days were over, and Bret would then transition to becoming a backstage producer for the WWF.
Fast forward to mid-1997, and the WWF was well and truly getting its ass handed to them by an Eric Bischoff-driven WCW product. As such, times were hard for the company - to the extent that there was a genuine threat of WWF going out of business.
For McMahon, he saw Bret Hart's salary as a major headache, and thus encouraged the Excellence of Execution to open dialogue with WCW to see if their previous offer was on the table. Not only was that offer - a supposed $9 million over three years - still on the table, but Vince even helped Hart negotiate with WCW so that McMahon could get out of the 20-year deal he'd agreed with Bret.