8 Ups & 6 Downs From Triple H's WWE (So Far)
A report card for Triple H's first quarter as WWE's new 'King Of Kings'
There are big wins and easy wins when booking pro wrestling, and it's pointless to reward Triple H for the latter kind.
For the longest time, WWE was no longer analytically comparable with any other wrestling company, which is perhaps what Vince McMahon had been aiming for from the day he classified it as Sports Entertainment to try and save on tax in certain states. Comparisons he'd previously made to Seinfeld in the 90s and Sopranos in 2000s (which for somebody that typically aimed low, were both enormous and preposterous missed swings in the opposite direction) were reminders that WWE's competition was mainstream television rather WCW, TNA or AEW.
This might still be the case with Paul Levesque, but he's spent enough time over the years telling us that he g*ddamn loves this business, pal, and some more of it showing us when NXT was genuinely the hottest product in pro wrestling. To this end, the second his father-in-law resigned in disgrace, Triple H allowed wrestlers to say wrestling again and several people with only one name were given a second one back.
But these were the aforementioned easy wins. On the eve of Hunter's first traditionally-crucial Survivor Series-to-WrestleMania run, how many big ones has he extracted from a fascinating and wholly unexpected summer season? And what of the big Ls for the man infamously immune to taking them?
Downs…
6. Baron Corbin & JBL
Things looked bleak for Baron Corbin in the initial stages of Triple H's formal takeover, but a formulaic loss to Ricochet in July already seems like a smoother path than the one he's since been sent on.
Linking arms with JBL in what's presumably supposed to scan as a natural alliance has drastically lowered the former "King"'s stock. Switching "Baron" for "Happy" wasn't the daftest decision, but Corbin's charm was his ability to lean much harder into his obnoxious side than just about anybody else on the roster.
Pairing him with a man that parlayed that specific skill all the way to a World Title reign and Hall Of Fame spot does the opposite of enhancing Corbin's status, and 'The Game's broad insistence on longer matches won't help.
5. Karrion Kross Vs Drew McIntyre
Boring matches, botched spots and a renewed sinking feeling around a returning star have already rendered the Karrion Kross/Drew McIntyre feud one of the early bust of the Triple H era.
Kross was one of the first to make a return, coming in at the very highest level during 'The Scottish Warrior's feud with Roman Reigns. Having then been forced to take a back seat until all that concluded, he then failed to cleanly defeat McIntyre at both Extreme Rules and Crown Jewel. The latter was a defeat, even though the former NXT Champion will likely crow about not being pinned or submitted just to claim an ill-gotten rubber match.
Almost the whole thing has sucked, and while 'The Game' wisely dropped the black-and-white camera effect over Kross' beatdowns after only a week, it's a shame he didn't park this completely and try something a bit more committed with his pet project.
4. Johnny Gargano, The Miz & Dexter Lumis
A bad storyline made worse by the personnel swallowed into its maw, the Johnny Gargano/Miz/Dexter Lumis bullsh*t triangle could be stacked up next to the likes of the Dawn Marie/Al Wilson/Torrie Wilson nonsense from Paul Heyman's SmackDown Six era if the rest of Raw came even remotely close to producing that level of consistent quality. Triple H should know all about that - he was destroying the red brand as its World Champion in opposition at the time.
As it doesn't though, it instead exists as a monument to 'The Game' having the capacity to make bad choices and see them through rather than rectifying them before it's too late. Lumis and Miz' feud being predicated on 'The A-Lister's influencer paranoia is stupid and riddled with plot-holes, and Gargano's casting as the whistle-blowing bastardised Columbo character is nightmarish.
And that specific issue isn't isolated to Gargano...
3. Terrible, Terrible Babyfaces
Triple H has got a significant problem with what he thinks is a relatable babyface attribute.
On a recent SmackDown, Madcap Moss and Ricochet were doing a wholly unconvincing job of bantering off Sami Zayn about his Bloodline role before Solo Sikoa burst into shot and smashed them half to death. Never mind the eventual match - they effectively lost a backstage segment that started with them lauding an advantage (!) over a lone villain. This isn't an isolated incident with Ricochet in particular either - the former NXT North American Champion has been featured more, but it's been in a losing capacity and following on from promo segments that do him more harm than good.
Elsewhere, Mustafa Ali has been traded to SmackDown after getting wrecked by Bobby Lashley just weeks into a now-aborted series with Seth Rollins. Then there's the aforementioned current state of Johnny Gargano (even when he's not dancing on the announce table in a cowboy hat) and the bulk of the blue brand's women's division there to cheesily grin until Shayna Baszler knees their nose into space.
There are some beloved characters within WWE at the moment, but Paul Levesque should assess what's gotten the likes of Sami Zayn and Seth Rollins over this time around rather than forcing risible humour, fake jock energy and happy-to-be-there-giddiness on the rest of the rank-and-file.
3. Damage CTRL
The obvious potential of Damage CTRL was clear from the moment the group shockingly came together at SummerSlam.
Bayley's return after over a year away (and longer still without a crowd to bounce off) was greeted with the rapturous ovation it deserved, while Dakota Kai's return to the company alongside NXT call-up Iyo Sky, promised a host of decent matches (at a minimum) with instant babyface rivals Bianca Belair and Becky Lynch.
An injury to Lynch was credited to the group and pulled in Asuka and Alexa Bliss as Belair's new accomplices, but there's been a distinct lack of actual booking to go along with actual matches. Coupled with too many of said outings not really being good enough to speak for themselves and Bayley's promos amounting to copy about "control" et al best left on the cutting room floor, and the whole stable has scanned as a noble failure.
WarGames should spell their biggest defeat yet - and ideally will be the end of the group completely.
2. Uncle Howdy
The build to Bray Wyatt's return was exceptional - more on that later - but several weeks on from an ear-shattering Extreme Rules return and what exactly is different from one of his last failed stints?
Wyatt's cutting good promos at present, but the entire act is badly undermined by an Uncle Howdy masked man telling him to do terrible things...which has a lot of Fiend energy about it, no? A bang average series of matches with LA Knight awaits as his first feud too, which is a step up from a rivalry with the TitanTron but honestly not by much. And at least whatever the hell's behind that mask can't banter him clean into the sun like the former Max Dupri might.
Early days, of course. But that's what this entire thing is covering, and when has a rough start ever ended well for the 'Eater Of Worlds'.
1. The Comebacks
Not all of them have gone badly, but the ones that have have tanked, and the novelty of having certain people back around has worn off so quickly that Triple H has found himself accused of the same pop-chasing problem Tony Khan had during his own 2021/22 hiring spree.
It's fair to say that WWE had thinned out its numbers way too aggressively in sweeping releases between 2020 and this year's post-WrestleMania cuts, but Nick Khan's spreadsheet massaging wasn't just about widening the margins between the nominal losses and enormous gains. The roster was bloated thanks to aggressive warehousing of talent in 2018 and 2019 as New Japan Pro Wrestling and later All Elite Wrestling made clear gains in markets that had been sewn up by a monopoly for nearly two decades.
All of this is to say there's a right and a wrong way to do everything in wrestling, and when even Paul Levesque's booking is making it look like the return of Hit Row was a mistake, it's safe to suggest a little more caution should have been exerted...
Ups…
8. The Comebacks
...but there have been some subjective success stories.
As noted elsewhere in this article, Damage CTRL's failure in particular could be classified as "noble" without scanning as generous. As a group, they were given big wins and Tag Team Titles even if the rest of the booking was hollow. This was as big a commitment as any from WWE that the three are priority players.
Braun Strowman and Bray Wyatt were ludicrous releases in the first place considering their obvious popularity, Johnny Gargano and Candice LeRae felt like big gets considering what must have been quite appealing about life on the other side of the divide, The Good Brothers are spectacular patter, and Emma might have more than her comeback loss to Ronda Rousey suggested.
Not all of them have been booked brilliantly as of yet, but none of them represent returns so egregious that the end point has been lost to an unexpected talent arms race.
7. Seth Rollins' Babyface Turn
Might this be the time a Seth Rollins babyface turn actually clicks?
The (as-of-writing) United States Champion has entered one of the best in-ring years of his career in 2022, working critically acclaimed programmes alongside Kevin Owens and against Cody Rhodes and Matt Riddle, and has approached his preposterous 'Visionary Of Drip' gimmick with such conviction that fans have fallen in love all over again.
Perhaps learning from the mistakes he made trying to do it in kayfabe several years earlier, Triple H has nurtured this well as WWE's creative chief. The switch happened gradually enough that it was almost imperceptible, and - crucially - Rollins hasn't really changed his gimmick to go alongside it. His offence getting jacked all the way back to his dazzling best doesn't hurt either.
Additional to all of that, it's perhaps no coincidence that the latest unlikely twist in a unique tenure has coincided with the belt currently slung over his shoulder too...
6. Gunther
This was already going better than anybody could have expected before Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace, but Gunther's time on the main roster - and particularly as Intercontinental Champion - since Triple H took over has yielded WWE's best match of the year, several supremely strong television encounters, and splinter feuds with Imperium that have gotten others over as some of the biggest babyfaces on SmackDown.
It's a tremendously impressive CV made even better by what might have been had McMahon not been given the heave-ho. Rumours swirled of a rote anti-America gimmick coming the titleholder's way, which speaks to the short-terminism that had cursed the company and countless talents for years.
It's not to say Gunther couldn't have rolled with these specific new punches, but it's far more satisfying to see him not have to. The thriving SmackDown star has elevated the status of the secondary strap beyond anything it's been in years - doing the all-important show-not-tell trick about five thousand Intercontinental Champions failed to do before him.
5. The Theoretical WrestleMania Card
It's Road To Road To WrestleMania season!
Survivor Series used to mark the first clues of what to potentially expect from a company with the capacity to book approximately six months ahead for their biggest event of the year. After decades of disrepair, Triple H has moved to make this one of his first fixes.
On the November 7th edition of Monday Night Raw, most-over-women-on-the-show Bianca Belair and Rhea Ripley briefly crossed paths and locked eyes, despite not currently feuding with each other. Seven days, the latter volunteered herself for a WarGames match against a team captained by the former. That die has been cast, but thrillingly, it's for later rather than now - on the same evening, a replay of The Judgement Day's brutal attack on Beth Phoenix was aired, reminding audiences that Ripley had 'The Glamazon' has her most pressing concern.
Meanwhile, multiple Kevin Owens/Sami Zayn spots have been fan-cast into the men's equivalent match at Survivor Series. The Royal Rumble will carry the buzz of potential returns for earnestly beloved babyfaces Becky Lynch and Cody Rhodes, Rey Mysterio forced through a separation from his own son with a move to SmackDown but he can't compete with a calendar, and Gunther being toppled as SmackDown's secondary Big Bad seems like something perfectly placed for the 'Show Of Shows'. All of this without considering the possible in-ring inclusion of Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock.
Not every story is hitting right now, but it's the above that should inform some optimism - the biggest possible picture is being considered.
4. White Rabbit
Since rebranded as the "White Rabbit Project" because everything needs a f*cking brand and corporate capitalism is designed to gobble up your sense of fun and charge you for the spew it regurgitates, the Bray Wyatt return was a multifarious success for WWE and a great example of Triple H following the mantra set by the man that smashed his throne and Doing The Work.
People clocked on that - by virtue of its weirdness - the QR codes and videos they led to were related a returning Bray Wyatt, with the White Rabbit motif working perfectly as the thing to keep following even if a genuine Wonderland couldn't possibly await. Internet sleuths had a blast decoding various clues that were less about who it was but more how it tied to prior Wyatt lore.
An initial tease of September 23rd generated a monster number for the SmackDown on that date (peaking, brilliantly, at 9:23pm) and reactions for Wyatt's Extreme Rules return were some of the loudest of the year. It might never live up to the hype (again), but the hype itself was a campaign for the ages.
3. Clash At The Castle
Despite Triple H spending years on the grift that SummerSlam 1992 was a fiscal failure, he sure understood the importance of making September's Clash At The Castle a WWE premium live event for the ages. Even if it was just to zoom and enhance on the praise he'd been receiving for his work since taking over two months earlier.
Riding a wave of that optimism and mixing in the excitement and enthusiasm of the Cardiff/UK crowd buzzing for the first event of this nature in 30 years, the show was a work of unqualified excellence.
A tight and supremely well-paced card offered the probable WWE match of the year in Sheamus Vs Gunther, an exceptional and nerve-jangling main event between Roman Reigns and Drew McIntyre, Damage CTRL's finest hour in a killer six-woman opener, and what turned out to be the creative and critical peak of Seth Rollins and Matt Riddle's spirited summer series.
Every visual was better than the last, Cardiff city centre buzzed with WWE's curated vibe all weekend, and echoes from Edge's pop and Dominik Mysterio's heel turn can still be felt in and around the South Wales Valleys to this day.
2. The Judgment Day
There could only be one viable #1 entry in this list of ups, but nobody could have predicted what specific type of Number Two The Judgment Day would be classified as as 2022 drew to a close.
For the longest time set to be one of the most appalling entries in Edge's career, his makeshift goth group has instead morphed into one of Monday Night Raw's most entertaining heel stables in years. An absolute unashamed pack of bastards, the group needed to get 'The Rated-R Superstar' out to kickstart their conversion and recruit Dominik Mysterio to complete it. The summer (and ongoing) feud with the former leader got the whole thing over the line too - the closing moments of the Extreme Rules "I Quit" outing pitting the Hall Of Famer and his wife Beth Phoenix against Bálor and Ripley were some of the loudest in WWE all year.
Memes on the reg whenever just about anything goes their way, the four are as definable now as individuals as they've all ever been on the main roster, yet blend so impossibly well as a group that it's tricky to imagine how they ever functioned before. Ripley and Mysterio are surefire safe bets for the WrestleMania, Finn Bálor is as convincing running the rule over this rabble as he was in Bullet Club and Damian Priest looks like he's perfecting the role he was born to play.
Triple H knowing exactly how to advise people to be a*sholes in stables. Whodathunkit?
1. The Bloodline
It's the story that has thrown the wildest and most unpredictable spanner into WWE's WrestleMania works.
It's the plotting so good you want to be in the building when it unfolds.
It's the performance level so sublime that it draws gushing praise from almost every corner of the wrestling commentariat no matter how hard it is to form consensus in the age of monoculture.
It's - at long f*cking last - something actually worthy of Roman Reigns exceptionally deliberate pacing, menace and fear-mongering after months of his Uso gaslighting running on fumes.
Sami Zayn was the missing ingredient, but it can't go underestimated how superb the rest of The Bloodline have been bouncing off him and risking the integrity of the act by selling so much for it. "Being Ucey" is now the best thing anybody in WWE can be, Zayn himself will fall heartbreakingly short before somebody topples Roman's empire, and the sprawling stories (and instantly iconic conversations about t-shirts) that have already spun out of the unit since the summer has etched the group into company history.