8 Wrestlers The Rock Couldn't Get Over

Know your role.

By Michael Sidgwick /

With an act like The Rock, this was never going to reach the traditional WhatCulture 10.

Advertisement

Perhaps the most selfless main event talent ever - he came up at a far more cutthroat time, in which the scope for politicking was vast - The Rock took a more carefree approach to his career than his fellow Mount Rushmore legends Hulk Hogan and Steve Austin. Perhaps he was secure enough in his unbreakably cool aura that he knew he was bulletproof.

Rock did wonders for Kurt Angle in 2000. Angle, always a great wrestler underneath the dorky veneer, never looked more like a legitimate threat when applying the Ankle Lock to Rock at No Mercy. Rock sold it as if Angle was ripping the tendons from his bones. Rock put Brock Lesnar over cleanly with no complaints at SummerSlam 2002 in what was a competitive but decisive passing of the torch.

Even the lowly Hurricane benefited from his association with the altruistic Hollywood Rock in early 2003. Their fondly-remembered RAW match was so much better than it had any right to be because Rock actually took him seriously.

It's not so much that Rock wouldn't put the following eight men over - mostly - it's that he couldn't...

8. Roman Reigns

If only wrestling was as easy as Vince McMahon thought it would be at the 2015 Royal Rumble.

Advertisement

The finish to the titular match wasn't quite as harebrained as it appeared on the surface, but it was perhaps even more irritating. McMahon was aware that The Big Show and Kane were personae non gratae amongst the fandom, and dispatched them to kill our darlings, in slow motion, in the hope that anybody - even Roman Reigns - would get cheered for vanquishing them.

McMahon knew the transparency of this approach, so added a further layer of window dressing by sending The Rock out there to come to Roman's rescue. The deathly quiet swelled to a pop as Rock laid waste to the dinosaurs - but the excitement dissipated the second he raised Roman's hand in victory. This contrived endorsement fell brutally flat - so much so that even Rock, by this point a trained Hollywood actor, involuntarily let the mask slip. The cucumber-cool Rock was so shaken that his expression of shock - even insecurity - underlined the folly. He almost looked concerned for his own brand.

McMahon was aware of the sentiment; he just couldn't help himself.

7. Rikishi

"I did it for The Rock."

Advertisement

A rare Chris Kreski misstep, the Rikishi hit-and-run reveal was such a retcon, and such a senseless killing of a made man with a visible ceiling, that even The Rock had little chance of transferring his star dust to the programme.

The racially-charged premise rang hollow. Rikishi's desperate "island boys!" protests sounded stupid at the time - the WWF Heavyweight Title was draped over The Rock's shoulder as Rikishi delivered his infamously monotone promo - and in retrospect, The Rock was a made man by Survivor Series 1999, and was even hand-chosen by Vince McMahon as the corporate face of the company at the same event in 1998. The plot hole was almost as gigantic as Rikishi's explanation was wooden - and in parroting those six words back to him, The Rock sealed Rikishi's fate.

His "I-did-it-for-da-Rock!" impersonation was far more exaggerated than Rikishi's original promo, but it was such a deep, deep cut that Rikishi was instantly stigmatised as a spectacularly unthreatening heel worthy only of derisive laughter. It was too effective a diss. It's now a meme.

Rikishi had no hope in hell of salvaging himself from that assassination; their Survivor Series 2000 blowoff was a midcard attraction in both card placement and atmosphere, much as Rock was game.

6. Goldberg

The Rock probably would have signed off on a sudden squash, had Vince McMahon asked. You get the distinct impression that he did not, on the evidence of the Backlash 2003 main event.

Advertisement

The Rock's pre-bell work was good, and all the better for its subtlety. Rock was more hyperactive and anxious than usual in his pre-match promo, and he stalled with a definite cowardice prior to getting in the ring. As soon as the bell sounded, though, whether through the preordained layout or the massaged perception that WCW guys were a notch below the WWE stars, Goldberg was normalised as a typical WWE babyface over the course of 13 minutes thoroughly lacking in electric dynamism for which Goldberg was known.

A missed Spear spot, itself too broadly comedic, begat a protracted Sharpshooter sequence, which sapped the enthusiasm from the crowd. Partisan WWE, they weren't falling for this sympathy ploy. Goldberg needed all the help he could get to get over, but not the support of the crowd.

The old WCW dynamic, in which the crowd needed Goldberg to annihilate the old guard more than he needed them to do it, was subverted and, in turn, diluted.

5. Faarooq

The net result of The Rock's 1998 feud with Faarooq wasn't to get both men over; this was penned specifically to remove Rock from the Nation of Domination and rid him of its midcard stigma. The writing was phenomenal, but in what was something of an omen, Rock was so bloody entertaining as an arrogant blowhard that it was impossible not to fall for him charm. Presenting the rest of the Nation with Rolex watches, and Faarooq with a framed portrait of himself, was almost psychotic in its hubris.

Advertisement

Faarooq's character work was good, too, if thoroughly dwarfed in comparison; his facial expression when presented with what was essentially dog sh*t in a paper bag was classic - itself an omen of the no-nonsense badass he'd become as one part of the winning APA act.

In its own strange way, despite how dire the Over The Edge climax was, The Rock Vs. Faarooq programme was quietly significant for Rock, at least; by utterly overshadowing and drawing more cheers than babyface Faarooq in the heel role, he had at last subverted entirely the blue chipper Rocky Maivia character.

The Rock wasn't just an over heel now; he was a megastar in waiting.

4. Billy Gunn

Billy Gunn was never cut out for major singles stardom, immensely popular though he was as one half of the New Age Outlaws.

Advertisement

Early Attitude Era undercards were putrid, pre-Kurt Angle, Chris Jericho and the Radicalz - and so, given his ability to get over and his McMahon-friendly physique, Billy - renamed 'Mr. Ass' in what was nominative determinism at its purest - was awarded a litmus test with The Rock at SummerSlam 1999. The major platform spoke volumes of the company's belief in Billy.

Rock was a man of the people, and he expressed the sentiments of the people - but his pre-match words were spoken with so much truth behind them that the platform crumbled, weeks in advance. "My name is Billy," said The Rock in a prayer-framed promo too effective for its own good. "And I just won King of the Ring. But there's one problem - everybody still thinks that I absolutely suck!"

The SummerSlam match wasn't a peak SuperCena burial, but it was almost completely mundane, saved only by the searing heat generated solely by Rock's mega star power.

Billy, placed in the driver's seat, was ejected to the back - in so small part because a far superior performer act had already assumed the front seat...

3. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho's 9 August 1999 introduction was one of all time great wrestling debuts; after interrupting a Rock promo and running through his class list of catchphrases, Rock responded by subverting Y2J's nickname with a KY jelly boot-up-the-ass threat.

Advertisement

The Rock couldn't get Chris Jericho over because, ultimately, this awesome interaction led nowhere in the short term. The Rock's SummerSlam bout with Mr. Ass went ahead as scheduled, and Jericho was quickly sidelined into a forgettable and regrettable midcard programme with a fading X-Pac. It took an age for Jericho to ascend to the main event promised land...if he was ever truly considered part of that Attitude Era class; comprehensively overshadowed by The Rock and Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania X8, he was already stigmatised as an also-ran through empty victories over his old verbal sparring partner at Vengeance '01 and Royal Rumble '02. Very good though they both were, there was never any doubt that Rock was the far bigger star.

Jericho eventually did reach that summit, in 2008 - but nobody, even The Rock in full selfless selling mode, was able to convince fans that Y2J really was an Undisputed headliner at the turn of his own millennium.

2. The Big Show

The man who would eventually come to be known as 'The Big Show' didn't arrive in the WWF in fantastic shape.

Advertisement

Grossly entitled at the beginning of his WCW career, the lax company culture converged with the Giant's own indiscipline and settled on his stomach; the lean hoss once capable of a moonsault had slowed down and fattened up by 1999. Many were optimistic that, in the more professional WWF landscape and under the strict provision of legendary macrophile Vince McMahon, Paul Wight would rediscover his drive. He did not. His first year contributed much to the creative horror show that was 1999, and Rock did much to yank the paddle away from him.

Rock, incensed at Show's insistence that he'd "singlehandedly" secured the WWF Title for The Rock shortly after his debut, described Show as an "overgrown, 500 pound bag of monkey cr*p".

We were firmly in the cutthroat Attitude Era diss culture at this point, and the line was pre-approved and/or scripted on his behalf - but the cut was so deep that Show essentially bled out. Rock, while selfless in the ring, was also too truthful on other occasions. The various machinations on the Road to WrestleMania 2000 threatened (in storylines) a Triple H vs. Big Show main event.

"If WrestleMania is going to be Triple H Vs. The Big Show," Rock reasoned, "then WrestleMania is going to absolutely suck."

Instantly, yet more soil fell over the poor sod's head.

1. The British Bulldog

The British Bulldog arrived back in the WWF a shadow of his former self; his back mangled on the Warrior's trapdoor in WCW, he was unrecognisable from the big-bumping powerhouse of yore - a condition reflected sartorially with a pair of baggy blue denims. Recast as a street tough brawler to conceal his fading technical game and strapped-up knees, the 1999 Bulldog vintage was all a bit depressing - so much so that even the uplifting Rock babyface act could not get a thing out of him in their mini-programme. Rock's frustration was our anguish.

Advertisement

It was hard to watch; knowing what we did about the Bulldog's condition meant that every single bump he took evoked feelings of anxiety. Escapism was impossible; the grim reality of his situation was etched all over his pained face. That he felt compelled to come back into the WWF fold, after the events of the Montreal Screwjob and the death of Owen Hart, compounded everything: he probably didn't even want to do what he was incapable of doing.

It was hard to watch before Rock Rock Bottomed Davey Boy on a platter of a dog sh*t - the last memorable moment of a career that once lifted an entire nation.

Advertisement