9 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Dynamite (31 Aug)

Jon Moxley and CM Punk set sights on All Out, Omega vs. Ospreay finally happens, and more.

By Andy H Murray /

AEW

All Elite Wrestling left itself in the unusual position of being without a pay-per-view main event four days before the show heading into last night's Dynamite, but somehow answered the headlining question with style.

Advertisement

The situation was made trickier by Tony Khan's own choices. Putting CM Punk vs. Jon Moxley on television was a bold marketing choice when that match appeared set to sell one of AEW's biggest shows of the year. Still relying on it to sell All Out 2022 11 days after a divisive, three-minute mauling is even bolder. Time will tell if this tactic pays off - the proof will be in the buys - but the pay-per-view main event is probably what you thought it was going to be.

This was a strong All Out go-home show that lived up to Khan's claims after the AEW founder and CEO promised an eventful night during his media rounds. Dynamite hosted All Out matches being made, a return, the World Trios Championship Tournament's advancement, hot promos, and more.

Advertisement

Nothing quite hit the promotion's weekly television peak, but with Moxley, Punk, Kenny Omega, Will Ospreay, Chris Jericho, and hordes more on the lineup, AEW packed its night with stars. There's no denying the genuine effort at hooking television viewers into throwing their hard-earned fifty bucks at All Out.

Let's light the fuse...

Advertisement

Downs...

1. An Ill-Fitting Return

AEW

W. Morrissey is deserving of the nice things that have happened to him over the past year or so. The former Big Cass endured some rough personal times before showing up in IMPACT Wrestling in 2021, enjoying a healthy monster run in the Anthem-helmed promotion before dipping out this June. Now, three months after guest-starring opposite Wardlow prior to Double Or Nothing, he is back in AEW, having flattened the Wingmen last night.

Advertisement

It was an angle, unfortunately, that fell flat. The Wingmen are effective jobbers but not over to the extent that live crowds are going to beg for somebody to come out and kick their asses when they try to hijack the show, which was the goal here. Thus, Morrissey emerged to what sounded like a flat reaction, though his run of Chokeslams and Big Boots on Cezar Bononi, Peter Avalon, JD Drake, and Ryan Nemeth at least looked good.

Stokely Hathaway continued building his group of wrestlers as part of this, handing Morrissey a business card after observing the destruction. On their way out, Morrissey and Stoke refused to answer Tony Schiavone, who asked what was going on.

Advertisement

This, too, does little to inspire investment. Stokely has thus far focused on male wrestlers who aren't over with live crowds. While this can absolutely change in time, it makes for an uninspired start to AEW life for Morrissey.

Ups...

9. FTR & Wardlow Tune Up

AEW/Scott Leish

FTR and Wardlow's squash of a crew of jobbers was a perfectly acceptable tune-up for All Out, where they'll face Jay Lethal and the Motor City Machine Guns.

Advertisement

The former Pinnacle men got the job done with minimal resistance from their opponents. In the end, Vic Capri was pinned after Wardlow conducted a two-Powerbomb Symphony for the Chicago crowd, showcasing his enduring overness.

A more substantial build would have been good for this pay-per-view match. Specifically, an in-arena appearance from Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin, neither of whom have featured on AEW programming yet, would've added extra juice to a match that looks exciting on paper, but lacking in story.

Advertisement

Nonetheless, a good, effective television squash for the good guys.

8. Here We Go, Hangman

AEW

Many a pundit predicted 'Hangman' Adam Page's insertion into the Trios World Championship Tournament when he spurned The Young Bucks in favour of supporting The Dark Order through the completion, leading to a gut-wrenching final showdown with The Elite at All Out - and here we are.

Advertisement

Page came into the tournament last night. With Ten injured last week and substitute Evil Uno knocked loopy in a backstage segment with Andrade El Idolo and Jose the Assistant, 'Hangman' stepped up to partner John Silver and Alex Reynolds, who seemed resigned to going it alone.

Speaking of Reynolds, his fantastic new beard gets a supplemental Up. That's how this column works.

Advertisement

It was always a case of when, not if AEW would put Page in the tournament. Now, his long-term storyline with The Elite continues when he inevitably meets Kenny Omega and The Bucks at All Out in a showdown AEW diehards will unquestionably lap up.

7. A Little Brief, But...

AEW

The Jungle Boy/Christian Cage sitdown could have benefitted from a longer runtime. Jim Ross is fantastic at mediating and hosting these things, so why limit him to such a condensed space? Give it a little longer and all three would have crushed it.

Advertisement

Similarly, AEW could learn a lesson in structuring from how this feud has been positioned over the past couple of weeks. That's twice in a row that the Cage/Jungle Boy offerings have gone down after something involved CM Punk and Jon Moxley. It feels like a comedown.

But.

Advertisement

BUT.

What we got here was very, very strong. Cage was his usual horrible self, promising to make Jungle Boy a 25-year-old has-been at All Out. His opponent, meanwhile, spoke with a new level of gravitas, referencing his departed father and all of Christian's below-the-belt barbs and personal insults in promising not to wrestle Cage as Jungle Boy, but fight him as Jack Perry.

Advertisement

Jack spoke with conviction, which isn't something he has always been able to do, and this felt like a step forward for him. He can't be Jungle Boy forever. One day, Jack Perry has to come to life - and we will look back on segments like this as bridges from one era to another.

6. Shida Scores Pin Before All Out

Forgetting the sandbagging allegations for a moment, the protagonists of AEW's women's division beat the sh*t out of each other these days.

These matches are often stiff, nasty, and intense, which is to their benefit. Physicality is often an effective substitute in a division where crowd investment isn't always at a high, at no fault of the performers. Here, Toni Storm, Hikaru Shida, Britt Baker, and Jamie Hayter threw leather at each other in a tight, hard-hitting tag team match to preview All Out's Women's World Title fight.

Advertisement

Shida looked particularly motivated here, not only throwing herself at her opponents with full-bodied vigour but continually playing to the crowd as well, trying to raise their fire to her level. She would make a fine new champion should AEW choose to go back down that route. Hayter, meanwhile, continues to be one of the most well-rounded workers in the company. Perhaps informed by her experiences in Japan and the UK, her powerhouse style feels distinct in this division. A pay-per-view win would also open interesting storytelling possibilities with Baker. Don't rule it out.

Hikaru took the pre-PPV advantage, pinning Britt after nailing the Katana. This followed an awesome Storm sequence where she destroyed Baker with the hip attack then slid out of the ring, hopped from the apron, and DDT's Hayter, all in one fluid motion.

Advertisement

5. Wheeler Yuta Qualifies For Casino

AEW

Wheeler YUTA triumphed in a preview for All Out's Casino Ladder Match, besting Dante Martin, Rey Fenix, and Rush in a match that absolutely flew by.

Advertisement

The bout was pretty much what you'd expect from its participants. All popcorn and fireworks, it prioritised fast-flowing excitement above all else, even if Rush and Yuta aren't traditional flyers. Nonetheless, both got involved in the general theme. Rush dived onto a pile of humanity where often he would fake out, while Yuta, a prodigious athlete himself, was a game flyer and counter wrestler simultaneously. His win came via Seatbelt on Dante.

Martin and Fenix provided most of the highlights in a bout fought entirely in sixth gear, working at least a couple of frankly inhuman counter sequences. Particularly impressive was Martin somehow countering a Gory Special into what looked like a Code Red. One day, when the rest of the pieces come together, Dante is going to marry intangibles to his outrageous in-ring capabilities and make himself a megastar.

Advertisement

4. Bryan Bests Jake

AEW

Jake Hager is a wrestler best used sparingly. While effective in short bursts, he lacks the aura and intensity demanded by his role, which gets exposed in longer, more gruelling matches. He is big, strong, and looks good but does little to pull you in on a visceral level. Compare his work on top to that of Lance Archer and the differences are stark.

Advertisement

Fortunately, he was in the ring with a wrestling savant last night, falling to Bryan Danielson in a well-worked battle largely dominated by the Jericho Appreciation Society's enforcer.

Danielson started the match by attempting to circle around Hager while taking potshots, chipping away at the big tree. This gameplan fell short when Jake got hold of him and started pummelling. Following this was a long heat sequence that lagged towards the end, though the craft of Danielson shone through. Having had his lower back worked over (effectively softening him up for the Walls of Jericho at All Out), Danielson found an opening when Hager preoccupied himself with the referee. Bryan chipped away at Hager's remaining defences, combated his brute force with smarts, and eventually won via Busaiku Knee Kick.

Advertisement

The Chris Jericho/Daniel Garcia relationship was given new wrinkles, too. The pupil apologised to the master for prior transgressions early on, pledging his allegation to the JAS. Later, when Jericho attempted to swing a chair at Danielson, Garcia saved his hero, accidentally making Jericho susceptible to a Busaiku in the process.

3. The Heart & Soul Of It All

AEW

How do you solve a problem like an empty pay-per-view main event? If you're Jon Moxley, you pen an open contract and leave it in the ring.

Advertisement

Moxley leaving said contract on the mat and leaving his All Out to fate shows the pure badassery of the man. He can say he will defend the belt against any opponent at any time all he wants but it doesn't mean anything if he doesn't live it. Here, he lived it. Anybody from Peter Avalon to Kazuchika Okada could have conceivably inked that contract, let alone CM Punk via Ace Steel. The AEW World Champion didn't give a f*ck either way.

That's a franchise player.

Advertisement

Preceding this was a typically excellent promo from the World Champion, who is fully committed to playing the heel in Chicago. As he should be. Punk's injury-driven loss last week was to set him up as the ultimate babyface in his hometown. Here, Moxley ripped into his weaknesses, showing no sympathy or remorse for a man whose ego and body were too fragile to compete with him, and his mind and spirit too weak.

2. The Elite Advance In Trios Tournament

AEW

Chances are strong that unless you wanted a match completely at odds with its participants' ongoing storylines and who they are as performers, you got everything you expected from The Elite vs. United Empire.

Advertisement

This was a fabulous main event to close a very good go-home show and advance the Trios World Championship Tournament. Aesthetically, it was an all-out crowd popper rife with great exchanges between some of the best wrestlers in the world. The two sides' interplay was fantastic. These guys wrestled like they've been facing each other all their lives, crafting something marvellous from their instant chemistry, with well-timed cut-offs, counters and transitions creating great drama at all the right moments.

Going deeper than that, the ongoing tensions between Will Ospreay and Kenny Omega were paid off without giving too much away. The duo started in the ring together and provided some of the most thrilling sequences. Will somehow landing on his feet from an attempt Snapdragon was the most gasp-worthy of these, but their work together did much to whet the appetite for a future singles bout.

Advertisement

Omega's recovering body remains a key story, too. His torso was finally exposed as United Empire tore his rashguard away and inflicted brutal punishment upon his taped shoulder and wrapped torso. The bot was lower on deliberate flubs, as it should have been, because Kenny is getting stronger as he shakes the rust away. Nonetheless, his physical state gives his opponents several massive targets, which will be interesting when he inevitably faces off with the moralistic Adam Page at All Out.

1. This Is Chicago

AEW

Look, this was a two-month storyline crammed into a single week. Consider that a supplemental Down. CM Punk's journey from the Jon Moxley defeat to getting himself physically and mentally ready to face the Wrestler of the Year again would have hit harder had it been given those additional steps, ideally with Punk disappearing for the first few weeks to ponder his future.

Advertisement

But good grief. If you weren't hooked by what happened when Punk poured his soul out in the ring and Ace Steel slapped it back into him, you might want to check yours hasn't already left your body.

Punk was despondent. Mopy and upset, he spoke of letting Chicago, his fans, and himself down, breaking up several times in what initially sounded like a retirement promo. Steel, who grabbed the contract from Jon Moxley earlier, set him straight. A great, fired-up rant from Punk's lifelong friend got the blood flowing. Steel literally smacked the life back into Punk, dropping a hard eff-you-see-kay on national television in one of the year's best promos, which served as a pitch for the now-former World Champion to hit the home run from his Chicago faithful.

Advertisement

Punk signed the match contract up in the bleachers, surrounded by his people. From lemons, he, Moxley, and Steel made delicious lemons last night.

And Steel was an inspired choice. His appearance was a nice easter egg for anyone who was there for the Second City Saints in ROH, but that it was contextualised by Ace himself and the announcers would've helped those who weren't around in 2002, too.

Advertisement