9 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (27 Oct)

MJF is your worst best friend, FTR seal Tag Team of the Year, the Elite are...back?

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

The build to and hype surrounding this week's Dynamite was uneven.

Advertisement

Much intrigue surrounded Claudio Castagnoli and Wheeler YUTA Vs. Chris Jericho and Daniel Garcia and, more specifically, the respective directions of the two apprentices. Were fans allowed to bond with Daniel Garcia for no reason? Is Bryan Danielson's insistence that he could still one day become the greatest wrestler alive act as the catalyst for YUTA to turn? Will Danielson turn alongside Garcia, since it was Mox, eternal babyface, who was tested by the bloodied upstart in the first place?

The pre-tape that built Mox's own match, against Penta El Zero Miedo, was atrocious. The gag at the end was amusing enough, but the idea that Penta just happened to be walking around Daily's Place (after a show on which he wasn't booked) and was magically summoned by the words "zero fear" was beyond contrived. It wasn't even sub-WWE; it was even more stupidly convenient than that.

Advertisement

Riho Vs. Jamie Hayter I was fantastic, if bleak in how quiet it was. The second match promised even more, since Hayter is adjacent to a sensation now. FTR Vs. Swerve In our Glory was hard to predict, promising much drama: FTR had two separate tag teams taunting them from afar, whereas SIOG are always on the verge of the split. This was deft, big picture booking from Tony Khan. A flash of the old magic.

Was the show itself magic, or...?

Advertisement

Downs...

2. A Minor Plot Hole...Maybe

AEW

More on the show-closing angle later, but as deftly-plotted as it was, a certain logic was amiss: where were Eddie Kingston and Ortiz?

Advertisement

Both men have aligned with the Blackpool Combat Club throughout this long-term story, and Kingston in particular is very close to Mox onscreen and in reality. It's not as if they'd have equalised the numbers game, either, ruining the heft of the beat-down. In that situation, the badass gang of babyfaces should always come out on top - but that wasn't the situation here.

Eddie Kingston was interviewed by Renee Pacquette moments earlier, and was clearly not in the mood. He actively said the words "I don't need help", which might indicate that he doesn't want to help anybody else. He might be in a solitary headspace, one in which he deserts his friends because he doesn't think he can do anything of value for them. He's been there before.

Advertisement

Critiquing an episodic TV show that literally never ends is difficult. This 'Down' may well reveal itself to be a 'Up', but his absence from the Firm's beat-down of Jon Moxley scanned as a narrative convenience.

1. The Most Pedantic Of Downs

AEW

In another criticism that is probably pedantic, about the only aspect of Dynamite preventing it from reaching the top-tier pantheon of classics is that, particularly so close to Full Gear, there was too much emphasis on in-ring action. It felt more like a suffixed special - a Beach Break or a Fyter Fest - than a show that went full-tilt demanding your PPV dollars. It was lacking in angles and promos, and the pay-per-view card does not look any clearer.

Advertisement

In what was only very slightly less than ideal, the in-ring action peaked in the first two matches, which were superb. The last two matches, while good, could not follow - which was all the more reason for Khan to work under the promo/angle/match trifecta with which the best top-tier Dynamites soar. This probably is pedantic, but AEW should be held to the highest possible standard.

At its best, it is the best.

Advertisement

Ups...

9. AEW Remains The Premier Storytelling Promotion

AEW

The ongoing Blackpool Combat Club Vs. Jericho Appreciation Society programme is a strange one to unpack. It peaked at Double Or Nothing all the way back in May, although Blood & Guts was a worthy if flawed hero's redemption. Now, it is simultaneously dragging on too long and worthy, compelling storytelling.

Advertisement

This was a fantastic advancement of it, one that made a mockery of recent criticisms not necessarily made in bad faith. Tony Khan's booking has fallen across 2022, but the character work here was robust in its logic and made for a scintillating tag team match. Claudio Castagnoli was pissed off because Chris Jericho cheated him out of the ROH World title. Wheeler YUTA was pissed off because he is considered, by his hero, to be inferior to his career rival.

Working under this character motive, both men delivered a complete blast of catharsis in a stupendous babyface showing. YUTA brought the fire and Claudio the superhuman magic in a vengeful, furious performance. Chris Jericho, incidentally, remains the most underrated tag team wrestler ever. Just when you thought the 'systematic cheating" bit was starting to take the piss, the heels eat sh*t in the most entertaining way imaginable.

Advertisement

Maybe the booking hasn't quite fallen off after all.

8. Small, Beautiful Details

AEW

Of course, more than one backstage interview was interrupted later on the broadcast - it was an episode of AEW Dynamite - but a lot of signature AEW detail informed the show-closing angle. Bryan Danielson was interviewed near the Dusty position, where he was preparing for his match against Sammy Guevara (which really should have followed, but alas). He was confronted by a hot Wheeler YUTA, walking back from the ring, who all but said "Follow that, motherf*cker" in a cracking promo miles better than his work opposite MJF.

Advertisement

AEW finally engineered an interruption that felt halfway organic - although, again, it would have made far more sense for the Danielson Vs. Sammy Guevara match to happen there and then.

Still, this led to the team meeting, which allowed the Firm to barricade the BCC in their locker room in order to beat Mox down in an effective heat angle that didn't blur into yet another stable brawl.

Advertisement

7. The Elite Tease

AEW

The idea of a rested Elite returning to their promotion with something enormous to prove - that they are more valuable to it than CM Punk - has phenomenal potential. These three men are motivated to be the absolute best, and this is the stiffest challenge they've faced since December 2019. They came through that two months later by working the best tag team match of all time.

Advertisement

What might follow now could and should be incredible.

Their being erased was acknowledged in the short vignette too, which is fascinating. This is the first time the Elite have been directly acknowledged on TV since All Out, and it would appear that they aren’t just going to simply reappear out of nowhere, which would be flat and insulting and cast a shadow on their return.

Advertisement

6. Pulsating Drama

AEW

Three probable outcomes hung over FTR Vs. Swerve In Our Glory:

Advertisement

1) The Gunn Club make their presence felt, and interfere.

2) The Kingdom make their presence felt, and interfere.

Advertisement

3) Swerve and Keith split, definitively, after one last crucial miscommunication.

The overlapping plotting of a stronger tag team division than Tony Khan has booked all year created a super-dramatic backdrop for what was a tremendous match in and of itself. Even with a clean result not amongst the most likely finishes, the action was so well plotted and timed that the fans bought the hailstorm of near-falls late.

Advertisement

Treating Keith Lee like a big man in a manner of which New Generation Bret Hart would be proud, it took FTR several failed attempts to hoist him up for the Big Rig - and when they finally did, the crowd bought it as the finish. The sheer endeavour had to be rewarded, but it wasn't: with expert timing, Swerve, on great form throughout beyond one awkward misstep, pulled Dax Harwood out of the ring at the last second. The drama was pulsating by the finish, but the work throughout was glorious.

Keith Lee's double leapfrog was one of those only-in-wrestling moments so good that you all probably went a bit apesh*t in your living room.

Advertisement

5. MJF Is Still On Fire

AEW

The tease of a babyface MJF remains incredible, even if it's part of an elaborate ruse. He is a snake, after all, of which he constantly reminds the audience.

Advertisement

It was thought MJF could never turn face for two key reasons: he is too good in the heel role, generating an impossible, earnest strain of heat in the modern age, and he's a sociopath to his bones. The idea of him simply becoming good is not so much character development but a retcon impossible to take seriously.

His spin on it however is typical of his budding genius: he is the mate you have who will banter you off into oblivion, but is so funny that you never begrudge him for it. His promo was consistent with that; he had the audience laughing along with his insults.

Advertisement

It's his second megastar act at just 26 - if it's actually happening...

4. More Earned Babyface Catharsis

AEW

Bryan Danielson Vs. Sammy Guevara was a very, very good match with a fabulous, sickos-friendly dynamic.

Advertisement

The eternally beloved sh*t-kicking technical virtuoso hero beat the hell out of the cocky flashy high-flyer in a match loaded with brutal and cathartic counters. Excitement flowed into fist-pumping sequences of a smug d*ckhead eating sh*t, and while certain sequences were contrived and a smidge sloppy - all the more glaring in a Danielson match - the emotion elicited from an inspired bit of matchmaking on the part of Tony Khan elevated it. Sammy Guevara, being so detestable, is practically underrated at this point.

The height he managed on an Asai moonsault was outrageous even by the standards of a modern athlete. It wasn't just showing off, either: he needed to be at his spectacular best to inform the drama and stand a credible chance of slaying the Dragon by using a form at which he is superior. In the end, Danielson won, and in what is something of an indictment of his run in 2022, he needed the victory.

Advertisement

It wasn't the best match Danielson has worked in AEW, but the crowd were red-hot for it at various points and it was as necessary as it was good.

3. Is...Is The AEW Women's Division Good Now?

AEW

Jamie Hayter Vs. Riho told a simple, absorbing story and executed it tremendously well.

Advertisement

The crowd weren't red-hot for all of it, which was a shame - this week really felt like it was set to buck a bleak trend - but Hayter was at least received as a star during her entrance and the crowd popped big for her win. This, then, was another small, vital step in repairing a division that has quietly excelled over the last two months. On Dynamite, anyway.

The match was premised on Hayter boasting a death blow of a lariat, if only she could hit it. She failed to do so on several occasions when Riho used her speed and wit to evade into several, super-close pinning combinations and incredulous big bomb moves. Watching Riho power up in such a way is always a joy, and Hayter is one of the best bumpers in the entire company irrespective of gender.

Advertisement

They explored a gorgeous dynamic very well, even if they have something better in them, but whatever happened to Paul Turner tightening up the officiating?

Tony Khan made a rod for his own back there.

Advertisement

2. Mox Vs. Penta Just About Delivers

AEW

This was one of Jon Moxley's weaker 2022 matches in truth, but it wasn't actively bad. It was however slightly disappointing, but still good enough to warrant an 'Up'. If the signature WhatCulture review format was titled 'Ups, Downs & In-Betweens', this might have fallen under the latter category.

Advertisement

The match was made, presumably, as a result of the hype generated by Penta El Zero Miedo's recent blood-soaked exploits in AAA. It was hardly made after a patiently booked winning streak allowing Penta to contend for the belt. The Championship Eliminator gimmick should have been used here.

The visual of Penta holding up Villano IV's mask was both instantly iconic and promised a similar, claret-drenched Mox signature here. It didn't happen; instead, Mox and Penta worked a solid match highlighted by an inventive DDT spot on the steel stairs, which looked ugly in the best possible way, and a 2.99 Mox kick-out of which Kurt Angle and Kazuchika Okada would be jealous. It was thought for a brief moment that Penta had won the AEW World title. That is some accomplishment, even if the match on the whole was not.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, this bordered on tepid, which is bizarre given how fantastic both men are at the ultra-heated brawl.

1. A Twist In The Tale

AEW

A conditional 'Up' here, since the storyline has yet to conclude. If this is all an elaborate ruse on the part of MJF, and he remains aligned with Stokely Hathaway, there's a suboptimal Aces & Eights quality to it - i.e., making daft and illogical creative decisions purely to obscure the revelation.

Advertisement

In a thoughtful twist, the Firm locked the BCC in their dressing room, enabling Mox to take a beating with no comeback (even if he has previously been aligned with Kingston and Ortiz and, more loosely, Darby Allin and the Lucha Bros.)

It was effective stuff. W.Morrissey looked like a monster, as did Ethan Page, where Lee Moriarty and the Gunn Club played the role of annoying insects. Then, MJF ran in for the save to deepen the mystery of whether he's actually turning. If nothing else, this was very effective in teasing out the mystery and dropping an unpredictable hook over the coming weeks.

Advertisement

Overall, some tiresome tropes notwithstanding - Orange Cassidy volunteering to defend his title in a three-way via interrupted backstage segment, f*ck's sake - this was a stellar and what's more, very promising episode of Dynamite.