9 Ups And 3 Downs From WWE NXT Takeover: Brooklyn

Good luck topping this, SummerSlam.

By Scott Carlson /

NXT effectively threw the gauntlet down at the WWE main roster€™s collective feet Saturday night, blowing away more than 15,500 in attendance and daring WWE to do better at SummerSlam. NXT Takeover: Brooklyn was the first NXT special event to take place outside of Full Sail University, effectively taking the developmental territory€™s show on the road. After performing and broadcasting in front of a crowd of several hundred, the NXT stars showed that multiplying the crowd several times over did not give anyone a case of the butterflies. Each of the six matches hit on all cylinders, providing fans with an incredible PPV that didn€™t just raise the bar for WWE at SummerSlam, it launched the bar into the stratosphere. Takeover saw two titles change hands and two NXT debuts: one a Japanese legend, another a young superstar of the future. Neither man disappointed. It was difficult to find anything bad or even really critical to say about the event itself. Everything was tightly packed into two hours-plus, but nothing felt rushed. The show was great fun for anyone who tuned in, and it€™s completely worth it if you missed it to catch it ASAP. Smart booking, quality wrestling, a hot crowd€ you€™d almost forget this was still a WWE show. So what scaled the ladder and what came plummeting back to Earth? Let€™s get to it€

Advertisement

Downs€

3. Triple Me

It€™s hard to openly criticize Triple H for being proud of what he€™s doing with NXT and the work the wrestlers, trainers and staff are putting into the product. He very clearly has a lot of pride in what€™s happening down in Florida. But opening the PPV in the ring and talking up how the fans have turned WWE€™s developmental program into a bona fide brand just runs counter to everything else we see about Triple H the character. Is he supposed to have two separate personas: the proud NXT father and the ruthless WWE Authority head? If Hunter was on Raw bringing NXT stars up to join the Authority€™s ranks (picture Baron Corbin becoming an enforcer for them), then that would be one thing. But he€™s not.Again, it€™s tough to say this is a negative, but it just feels self-serving more than anything. If you want to be proud of NXT and boast about it, then it should carry over consistently with your WWE persona. We shouldn€™t haven€™t to actively separate the two. Kevin Owens doesn€™t play two different characters between NXT and WWE; neither should Triple H.

2. Starting Off In A Hole

This is actually a strike against WWE because it€™s about to become a victim of its own success. NXT Takeover: Brooklyn was damn good, so good that it€™s going to be nigh impossible to top. And that in itself is a negative. It€™s like your varsity team being outperformed by the junior varsity squad. Takeover was a two-hour (plus a few minutes overrun) event that delivered six matches and never felt dull, not even for a minute. SummerSlam is booked to be twice as long with 10 matches, and while several of the bouts look great on paper, what are the odds that the PPV will stack up with this one? Sad to say, the answer is, €œNot very good odds.€ That€™s not to say that WWE should stop putting on NXT specials €“ quite the opposite. WWE needs to learn from what made Takeover: Brooklyn special and try to replicate that. Putting NXT and WWE special events on back-to-back days like this will only make the contrasts more stark, until WWE wises up with its own PPVs.

1. Technical Difficulties

Maybe your feed for NXT Takeover: Brooklyn was spotless, a perfect HD heaven of developmental wrestling. But this household€™s feel was spotty at best, buffering repeatedly and the quality dropping from HD to standard definition at random points. And it looks like the issue wasn€™t limited to just one household. On the WWE Network€™s Facebook page, several users complained of buffering issues, fuzzy picture and even being booted from the show and back to the main menu. Several people pointed out that they have been subscribers since the beginning of the Network and are tired of these problems. Transmission issues with the WWE Network have cropped up periodically for the 18-month-old service, and it doesn€™t help with subscription woes if those who have been there since the beginning are throwing their hands up in the air. After more than a year, WWE should have the bugs worked out. There are bound to be problems from time to time, but it€™s truthfully unacceptable at this point. All you€™re doing is p***ing off your most dedicated fans. If the issues persist with SummerSlam Sunday after billing it as the WrestleMania of the summer, WWE could find themselves with the kind of press they certainly don€™t want.

Ups...

9. If You Will

Ten-bell salutes are nice, but WWE figured out a great way to honor the late €œAmerican Dream€ Dusty Rhodes, announcing Saturday a month-long tag team tournament that will begin in September. WWE.com bills it as €œfeatur(ing) the best of NXT€™s past, present and future, duking it out for tag team supremacy, with the finals taking place at the next NXT TakeOver, live on WWE Network on Wednesday, Oct. 7.€ There€™s no word on whether this will be a number one contender€™s tournament for the NXT Tag Team Championships that the Vaudevillains just won, whether the champs will put their titles up as part of the tourney, or if this is just for bragging rights. Regardless, if done well, this could be a classy, smart way to honor Rhodes, who worked hard with the young NXT talent to get them ready for the big time.

8. Even The Jobbers Have Personalities

Anyone who has watched NXT for a few months knows that Tye Dillinger is largely used as enhancement talent, a guy who comes out and makes his opponents look good before laying down. He very easily could eke out an existence on the roster as a jobber, but Dillinger has managed to roll out a new persona that could work really well: The Perfect 10. Sure, it€™s cheesy, with Dillinger sporting a €œ10€ shaved into the back of his hair and flashing all 10 fingers repeatedly to lead fans in a €œ10€ chant after performing a move, such as a leapfrog and cartwheel to avoid a corner charge. But it€™s something. Tye even pulled out the old Barry Horowitz self-congratulatory pat on the back, which if intentional is even more awesome. Jobbers certainly have a role in professional wrestling. One of the criticisms leveled against WWE today is that most matches on Raw are guys trading wins. If you use enhancement talent every now and again, you can give guys face time and not have another €œname€ guy be a sacrificial lamb. Giving guys like Dillinger a personality €“ however cheesy it might be €“ is a fun way to add some depth. And besides, who doesn€™t want to simultaneously boo an arrogant jobber and chant €œ10€ along with him?

7. A Thunderous Debut

It€™s rare that you will ever see a €œdebut€ for a 50-year-old wrestler, but that€™s exactly what happened Saturday when Jushin Thunder Liger competed in his first WWE match as part of NXT Takeover. A 30-year ring veteran, Liger is best-known for his work in Japan but had competed in the United States with WCW, Ring of Honor and TNA, but never WWE. Tyler Breeze had the unenviable task of playing second fiddle to the Japanese legend, but he not only held his own, he pulled out a couple innovative moves during the opening contest. Breeze is a guy who probably won€™t be main-eventing WrestleMania, but he showed that he deserves a spot on the main roster when the opportunity is right.Liger managed to hit enough signature spots to keep the crowd cheering along. If this truly was a one-shot deal, then it was a treat for the fans. But as legendary as Jushin Liger is, NXT is supposed to be about the future, and hopefully this performance will lead to bigger and better things for Breeze.

6. Hug It Out

Some will say that the extracurriculars after the NXT Women€™s Championship match was a huge break of character and protocol. If you missed it, Sasha Banks re-entered the ring moments after losing her title to Bayley. The new champ already was celebrating with Charlotte and Becky Lynch. Banks walked over and hugged her bitter rivals, the four embracing and raising each other€™s arms. If you were watching for the first time, you€™d be hard-pressed to realize that they aren€™t supposed to like each other. But to those who think this is a €œdown,€ you€™re flat wrong. Mutual respect is something that even heels can show to their opponents. It doesn€™t have to be face-versus-face matches where there€™s a respect handshake or hug afterward.There€™s no rule, written or otherwise, that says a villain can€™t respect their opponent. If anything, it helps a character be more complete. Banks showing respect doesn€™t €œexpose the business€ or any foolishness like that. It shows that she€™s not a one-dimensional heel. Yes, there are bad guys who would never shake their opponent€™s hand (Kevin Owens immediately comes to mind), but that doesn€™t mean no one can. Besides all of that, this was a pure, emotional moment, something WWE couldn€™t manufacture on its best day. That makes it even more special.

5. End Of Days For Corbin

If this were the WWE main roster, the indy darling probably would have lost clean to the homegrown talent. Instead, we saw Samoa Joe submit Baron Corbin in the middle of the ring after a bruising, hard-hitting match. And it was the right result. Corbin has been dominant in NXT for some time now, winning nearly every match he€™s wrestled in mere seconds. While those repeated squashes look impressive, they do nothing to help Corbin prepare for life on the main roster. NXT is, after all, a developmental territory, and its purpose is to get wrestlers ready to compete in WWE proper. Beating a bunch of jobbers in 20 seconds doesn€™t prepare you to have a 10-minute match on Monday Night Raw.By matching up against Samoa Joe, Corbin was forced to expand his arsenal and go toe-to-toe with a ring veteran. Joe certainly wasn€™t going to make Baron look bad €“ quite the opposite. While their match wasn€™t a classic, it was a good hard-hitting affair that showed that Corbin can do more than hit his finisher. He€™s got work to do, but if he continues matching up against Samoa Joe, it should help him. And that€™s exactly what developmental is for.

4. A Colorful Payoff

Say what you will about the NXT Tag Team Championship reign of Blake and Murphy, but the unlikely champs have served to greatly boost the profile of Alexa Bliss, who has gone from a smiling pixie to a snarling vixen in just a couple short months. Bliss€™ role as the champs€™ secret weapon has been well-established, leaving challengers the Vaudevillains with the task of finding someone to neutralize her, and they succeeded in delivering a great payoff that was a direct nod to the NXT fans: Blue Pants.For those unfamiliar, Blue Pants is indy wrestler Leva Bates, who mostly serves as enhancement talent in NXT. However, she€™s gained quite a following down in Florida, going far beyond what you might expect for a jobber. (Imagine Barry Horowitz getting Daniel Bryan-like reactions.) Blue Pants managed to counter Alexa Bliss, and the Vaudevillains managed to capture the tag titles, paying off the storyline perfectly.

3. Apollo Gets Star-Struck

NXT Takeover: Brooklyn took place in front of the largest crowd the developmental territory has performed before, nearly 16,000 people. That, and the fact it was his first NXT match made it doubly cool when Apollo Crews took a couple moments to take in the crowd at the Barclay Center Saturday night. Crews stopped on the ramp, put his hand over his eyes and scanned the crowd and said loud enough for the mics to pick up, €œThat€™s a lot of people!€ He then flipped a switch and stalked to the ring, and proceeded to deliver an impressive debut, defeating Tye Dillinger in a match in which the result was never in doubt. Crews certainly looks like he can be a major star for WWE in the future. He has a carved-out-of-granite physique, impressive strength and even more impressive agility. His gorilla press drop/standing moonsault combo finisher showed off both of those traits perfectly. It€™s exactly the kind of debut you€™d want from a highly touted performer.

2. The Demon Climbs Out Of The Depths

How many one-on-one ladder matches do you think there have been in WWE history? Dozens? Just when you think you€™ve seen everything in a match, Kevin Owens and Finn Balor came along Saturday night and managed to deliver a fresh matchup with innovative spots. Instead of relying on the ladder for the bulk of the match, neither man was able to get his hands on a ladder until several minutes into the match, and even then the ladders only factored into a portion of the match, avoiding the cliché of multiple slow climbs up the ladder. Balor channeled his inner Jeff Hardy, hitting a Coup de Grace from the top of the ladder onto a prone Owens. That turned out to be enough to KO Owens and allow Finn to retrieve the title.Like the co-main event, this match easily could be dropped onto Sunday€™s SummerSlam broadcast and it wouldn€™t look one bit out of place. That€™s a very good sign for the future.

1. Fight Like A Girl

Another NXT Takeover special, another show-stealing performance from the NXT women. It€™s beginning to become old hat, as the women completely overshadow everything happening at the main roster level. Even though Sasha Banks, who lost her NXT Women€™s Championship to Bayley Saturday, is on the WWE roster with several other NXT women, her match with Bayley blew away anything that has been on television since the Divas Revolution started. That€™s not a knock against the women in WWE, but a compliment to Sasha and Bayley.The two women unloaded on each other, with Banks talking trash and hitting a somersault plancha to the floor on Bayley after ruthlessly trying to re-break her hand. They fought over a crossface, and they battled on the top rope multiple times. Bayley pulled off a top rope reverse hurricanrana before nailing a Bayley-to-Belly for the title. Watch this match and try to find a flaw with it. This underdog story had a wonderful ending and it showed exactly what the women in NXT (and now WWE) are capable of.