WWE Hell in a Cell is one week away and we have blockbuster matchup in the main event to look forward too. The Undertaker battles Brock Lesnar in a Hell in a Cell match, capping off their recent series that began with the conquering of The Streak at WrestleMania 30. Undertaker made a surprising non-WrestleMania season return to WWE to challenge Lesnar to a match at SummerSlam. It turned out to be a great bout with a controversial ending. Considering their third encounter was at one point rumored to take place at next year's WrestleMania, this is a highly anticipated matchup. Time will tell how this upcoming encounter between these two legends stacks up against the previous Hell in a Cell main events. In the meantime, the 6 matches that have closed out this event since its beginning in 2009 are here to recap and rank...
Advertisement
6. Kane vs. The Undertaker (2010)
In the build up to this match, World Heavyweight Champion Kane was positioned as the more dominant of the two brothers. The Undertaker needed something dramatic to turn the momentum to his side and he got exactly that with the return of Paul Bearer. It might be cheesy storytelling but it's still pretty amusing to go back and watch Bearer emerge from a casket on a SmackDown to the horror of Kane. Dallas was extremely quiet as they witnessed Kane repeatedly target Undertaker's leg. There were a few moments where these two traded punches that engaged the crowd, but most of this match was just boring and slow. After Kane struck the referee, the Cell door was opened, giving Paul Bearer a chance to enter the structure. He had a strange role in the final moments of this match as he turned on The Undertaker and emitted a not-so-blinding light out of the urn he was carrying. Kane finished his brother off by striking him with the urn and hitting a couple of chokeslams. There was definitely a story of betrayal that unfolded here, but it wasn't told effectively. The World Heavyweight Championship stayed with Kane as the worst main event in Hell in a Cell history closed out.
5. CM Punk vs Ryback (2012)
Ryback was pretty fresh into his current run at this stage, mostly defeating lower card guys to look like a monster. This challenge against CM Punk for the WWE Championship would serve as his first real extended bout against a top level guy. The general flow of this match involved CM Punk trying to evade Ryback's offense. They did a good job of making The Big Guy to be a legitimate contender here and the crowd bought into it. Brad Maddox (remember him?) was the guest referee and played a role in the final moments of this match. Ryback had this won with a Meathook clothesline and then was ready to give a Shell Shock. Brad stood in front of Ryback to stop him and then gave him a low blow. Punk did a rollup while Brad fast-counted to save this match for the champion. Postmatch, Ryback had his revenge as he pummeled Maddox, throwing him into the cage from inside the ring. He then chased Punk onto the top of the Cell and gave him a Shell Shock from those heights to close out the event. If you include the fun that happened after the match ended, this was a pretty enjoyable contest. Ryback actually looked like he belonged opposite the champion and it was overall entertaining. There would be better matches to main event Hell in a Cell, but this one deserves credit.
4. Shawn Michaels & Triple H vs. Cody Rhodes & Ted Dibiase (2009)
This was a battle of the present versus the future as Triple H and Shawn Michaels of Degeneration-X took on Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase of The Legacy. Just because WWE doesn't let current Hell in a cell matches achieve the levels of brutality of the pre-PG era, that doesn't mean they can't be wildly entertaining with some elements of chaos. An extended sequence of brawling around the ring and in the crowd took place before the match, setting a chaotic tone for these four guys. When the match finally started, Cody and Ted were at a 2 on 1 advantage because they locked Triple H out of the Cell. This told a good story of them having the unfair advantage, but the biggest knock on this match is it took probably way too long before Triple H used bolt cutters to get back inside. D-X turned the odds in their favor as they locked DiBiase out of the Cell to finish off Cody Rhodes. They did a pretty sick spot where Shawn dropped the elbow off the top rope onto Cody, whose head was wedged inside a steel chair. The finish came about when Shawn gave Sweet Chin Music to Rhodes while Hunter simultaneously nailed him with the sledgehammer. D-X won this match that started off very hot and had a few great moments along the way.
3. Randy Orton vs. Daniel Bryan (2013)
Heading into SummerSlam 2013, it looked like Daniel Bryan's time had come. John Cena was on the way out to tend to surgery on his elbow and Bryan was emerging as the most over guy in the company. Then, Randy Orton cashed in his MITB briefcase which kicked off a sobering few months in which it would be realized that WWE wasn't as sold on Bryan as the fans were. This Hell in a Cell Main Event was the last match in their series. There was a lot to like about this match because Randy Orton and Daniel Bryan mesh well together. They used the ring steps and chairs well and Bryan showcased his usual babyface hot spots. Randy even performed a Superplex on Daniel onto a pile of chairs in the middle of the ring. It was the ending that soured this one. Special guest referee Shawn Michaels became involved after Triple H and Randy Orton verbally harassed him a few times. Hunter received a running knee strike from Daniel, which set up a Sweet Chin Music by Shawn against his former pupil. Daniel Bryan got revenge against Shawn the next night on Raw, putting him in the Yes Lock. It would've been amazing if the interference was for the purpose of seeting up a match between the two, but Michaels later recounted that "there were never any plans to have a match with Bryan." Bummer. The mishandling of Daniel Bryan's booking during this match and this time in general was a big missed opportunity for WWE. Luckily, they'd learn their lesson thanks to overwhelming fan support and reinsert him into the title scene by WrestleMania season.
2. John Cena vs. Alberto Del Rio vs. CM Punk (2011)
This was an interesting time for the WWE Championship. John Cena was the champ going into this match while CM Punk and Alberto Del Rio had won it in previous months. For context, CM Punk's memorable Pipebomb promo was several months prior as well. No one wrestler was booked as an exceptionally dominant or weak competitor in this Hell in a Cell match. The action was back and forth and they kept the attention of the audience well. There was also nice uses of weaponry, such as when Del Rio back suplexed Cena onto a chair that ever so slowly collapsed under his limp body. Ricardo Rodriguez was able to get the Cell door open which then prompted Cena to go after him and administer an AA to him on the outside. Del Rio capitalized on this and locked Cena out of the steel structure. This left Del Rio and Punk alone for a one-on-one sequence to finish out the match. Alberto used a steel pipe to his advantage, including to strike the ribs of Punk while he attempted his GTS. Del Rio pinned Punk to win the match and the WWE Championship. The fun continued after the match as The Miz and R-Truth entered the ring while the Cell was briefly raised for an attack on the three match competitors, the refs, and even a couple of camera guys. They were arrested as Triple H acted all mad at them - it was an exciting element to top off an already good match. Some might dispute this one being ranked higher than the Orton vs. Bryan bout from 2013, but it was a close call for me. Even though Cena was baited into leaving the Cell and was locked out for the final moments, the ending in this one lacked the overbooking of the 2013 main event. That was what ranked this one higher for this list.
1. Seth Rollins vs. Dean Ambrose
This is the most recent match on this list, so the backstory should be pretty familiar. It's a shame that Dean Ambrose's character doesn't stay continuously bitter about being betrayed by Seth Rollins, because that's when he's at his most interesting. The first chapter of this match was super exciting because of the brawling on top of the Cell and the eventual double table break when they fell off the side in tandem. They both were in the process of being stretchered out when Ambrose got a second wind and went after Rollins. More fun ensued inside the ring when the match actually started. There were several table breaks outside the ring and a suplex onto a pile of chairs. It looked like there would be some retribution for Dean when he pulled out some cinderblocks and was going to do a Curb Stomp of his own onto Seth. It would've been nice if there was a finish to this that was satisfying enough for this highly emotional feud, but it just wasn't meant to be. The lights went dim and a hologram was shown in the smoke of a lantern in the middle of the ring. This set up an attack against Dean by Bray Wyatt. Rollins took advantage of the attack and pinned Ambrose for the win. Despite the finish, all of the action that preceded it was stellar. There were dangerous spots and tons of emotion, making this the best main event to ever cap off a Hell in a Cell card.