Booking NXT TakeOver: New Jersey - 10 Matches That Could Happen
Dreaming up dream matches.
NXT is better than the main roster, and that is a fact.
The black and yellow brand has gone from developmental to one of the hottest wrestling promotions in the world over the last six years, and it continues to get stronger with every year that passes.
NXT TakeOvers are now more hotly anticipated that anything put on by the main show, and this is never truer than over WrestleMania weekend.
The last three TakeOvers to take place over WrestleMania weekend - Dallas, Orlando and New Orleans - have given us some incredible matches. Shinsuke Nakamura vs Sami Zayn. The Revival vs #DIY vs The Authors of Pain. Johnny Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa. These are just a few examples of what to expect when NXT takes over a WrestleMania Saturday.
What matches will follow in this legendary legacy?
We'll have to wait and see, but, in the meantime, it's always fun to fantasy book, so allow us to let our imaginations run away with themselves and book 10 possible matches for the biggest NXT show of 2019.
These matches are all based on existing storylines, championships and stars' positions in NXT. Some liberties have been taken in few of them, but this is pro wrestling, and if you can't take liberties with that, where can you...?
10. Adam Cole Vs Punishment Martinez
A tasty prospect for any Ring Of Honor fan.
Punishment Martinez, a former ROH TV Champion, is yet to debut on NXT TV, but he has appeared on a few house shows, which can only mean his official debut is coming very soon.
The 6ft 6in monster is an absolute beast in the ring, combining incredible power and strength with insane speed and agility. When he does make an appearance on NXT TV, it's should be in a big way - and what bigger way than in a storyline with the brand's hottest faction?
The Undisputed Era's whole shtick is that they're all former ROH guys in NXT. Punishment Martinez fits this bill perfectly. The Era could attempt to recruit him, even doing it successfully for a few months, before Martinez rejects their ways and establishes himself as a hero to Adam Cole's villain.
Both men are excellent workers and would put on an excellent match. Throw in a top notch storyline and this is a great way to introduce the NXT Universe to Punishment, even more so if he beats Cole.
A chance to give Martinez the push he deserves, and perhaps a fitting way to call The Era up to the main roster, this storyline would give TakeOver: New Jersey a hot blood feud and an amazing match.
9. The Undisputed Era Vs Matt Riddle And Keith Lee For The NXT Tag Team Championships
Disclaimer: The Undisputed Era feature in a lot of these, but only because they're the best. Reminder that this isn't a prediction for the entire card, as awesome as Cole pulling double duty may read, bay-bay bay-bay.
Roderick Strong and Kyle O'Reilly are amazing as NXT Tag Team Champions, but their reign must come to an end at some point. If they have to lose the belts, then they may as well lose them to some new faces - and inarguably, the two biggest new faces in NXT are "Limitless" Keith Lee and "The King of Bros" Matt Riddle.
Riddle and Lee have been presented as a bit of a package on NXT TV thus far, so why not just go whole hog and pair the two up? It would be an interesting dynamic for sure, especially as the two have a lot of potential as singles stars, which could be used to create tension between the team.
The NXT Tag Team Championships have always produced great matches at TakeOvers, and this one would be no exception. All four men are amazing workers and incredible match constructors, so this would be a truly memorable tag match and a great chance to give Matt and Keith a spotlight away from the already-crowded men's singles division.
Equally, if you don't like this idea, then we could always have...
8. Matt Riddle Vs Keith Lee
Some people just want to watch friends fight, and that is sickening. But damn, this would be a great match.
As mentioned, Lee and Riddle have been shown to have a sort of partnership in NXT so far, but that could easily change with a little heel turn.
Lee could be jealous of Riddle receiving more attention than him (Riddle's already had a TakeOver match, despite arriving after Lee did) and turn on The King of Bros, maybe costing him a title match or something like that.
Lee and Riddle have a history of great matches on the indies and could easily replicate this in NXT. Both men are amazing in the ring and have such conflicting styles that a match between the two would tear up any arena, anywhere, any time.
If you wanted to, this could be set up as a #1 Contenders match for the NXT Championship. Equally, it's not a bad idea to just have the two fight in a good ol' fashioned blood feud.
7. The Undisputed Era Vs War Raiders For The NXT Tag Team Championships
This is a match that is guaranteed to happen again at some point, and it's definitely worthy of taking place on the biggest stage in NXT.
Hanson and Rowe, formerly known as War Machine outside of WWE, have had The Undisputed Era's number these past few months, most recently helping to defeat them in a War Games match at the most recent TakeOver. The Modern Day Vikings are basically #1 Contenders to the NXT Tag Titles, so it's just a matter of time before we see them face off against O'Reilly and Strong.
This could easily be a second clash between these two teams. Perhaps The Era could retain against War Raiders over the Royal Rumble weekend through nefarious means, and a rematch could take place in New Jersey with Hanson and Rowe finally capturing the gold.
If this was the case, it might be nice to have this match have a stipulation - maybe a hardcore match or perhaps the second-ever tag team ladder match in NXT.
Stip or not, this is going to be one hell of a match when it does happen, and the War Raiders are popular enough for a title win to take place on such a big stage. You really think anyone is going to boo these guys?
They're all too scared.
6. The Undisputed Era Vs #DIY For The NXT Tag Team Championships
This is easily the most intriguing and complex idea on this list.
Tommasso Ciampa is currently your NXT Champion and, to put it lightly, a bit of a douche. As for Johnny Gargano, well, he's gone off the deep end, believing his acts of evil are actually heroic.
This presents an interesting scenario for the former NXT Tag Team Champions and, if rumours are true, as they both now seem to be on the dark side. If certain rumours are true, one of NXT's most popular tag teams could be getting back together, but not how you remember them.
Let me explain how this could work. Ciampa loses his NXT Championship, and is furious. To try and win a title back, he goes to his old pal, Johnny, and persuades him to reunite #DIY. Perhaps the two could win the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, earning them a Tag Team title match in New Jersey.
The match itself would appear to be heel vs heel, but the main story of the bout would be Johnny confronting his demons and finally scoring his revenge on Ciampa.
Ciampa could cheat in this match and have the belts won, when Johnny snaps out of his dark spell and blasts Ciampa with a superkick, leaving him lying in the ring. The Era retain the tag titles and Johnny gets his revenge on Ciampa, denying him the gold and leaving NXT to go up to the main roster with the fans back on his side.
Yes, this would work better with a face team as champions, but there isn't really enough time to take the belts off of The Era and establish new champions in their place. Also, Kyle O'Reilly, Roderick Strong, Tommasso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano in one match together?
You'd be mad to turn that down.
5. Shayna Baszler vs Toni Storm for the NXT Women's Championship
The Mae Young Classic has done wonders for NXT's Women's Division, and the winner of this year's tournament could be the next example of this.
Toni Storm won the Mae Young Classic this year at Evolution to cap off an amazing run of matches in the tournament. Last year's winner, Kairi Sane, went onto become NXT Women's Champion, so Toni could very easily follow in her footsteps.
Toni and Shayna would have an excellent match and their in-ring styles would clash perfectly. Toni is such a loveable babyface, and Shayna such a despicable heel, that the story possibilities are endless.
If Shayna - alongside her Horsewomen buddies, Marina Shafir and Jessamyn Duke - is on her way up to the main roster soon, then you'll need a top babyface to replace her as NXT Women's Champion. Toni Storm definitely fits that bill and is definitely ready for the top spot in NXT.
However, the only issue with this is that Toni Storm is currently tied up in NXT UK. If WWE do want to keep her in that brand - despite the fact she's from New Zealand (!) - then we may need another Mae Young Classic finalist to take down Shayna...
4. Shayna Baszler Vs Io Shirai For The NXT Women's Championship
Io Shirai is an absolute legend of Japanese wrestling.
The biggest star in the history of the Stardom promotion, Shirai is easily one of the most decorated female wrestlers in Japanese history, and when she turned up in WWE for this year's Mae Young Classic, it was great news for everyone.
Shirai has already made her presence felt in NXT, coming to the aid of Kairi Sane in her TakeOver: WarGames match against Baszler. It's clear from this that NXT want to throw her into the mix for the Women's Championship and they have plenty of time to tell that story in the build up to TakeOver: New Jersey.
Io Shirai has all the tools to lead NXT's Women's Division into a new era alongside the likes of Storm, Dakota Kai, Bianca Belair, Mia Yim and many, many more.
On the obverse, Baszler is clearly not long for NXT, as WWE will be keen to unite her and the rest of the Horsewomen with Ronda Rousey on Raw. The time to take the belt off of her is soon and, whether it be Storm or Shirai, NXT have plenty of contenders to take her place.
3. Another Six Man Ladder Match For The NXT North American Championship
It worked last year, so why not do it again?
At NXT TakeOver: New Orleans, Adam Cole made history by becoming the first ever NXT North American Champion by outlasting The Velveteen Dream, Ricochet, EC3, Lars Sullivan and Killian Dane in an epic, 5 Star-Rated ladder match.
NXT is so busy with top stars right now, so getting them all on the card for TakeOver is becoming increasing difficult. You just have to look at where EC3 is now to see that.
Another multi-man ladder match, with multiple interweaving storylines, could be a nice excuse to get multiple people onto this card, as well as putting on an insane match in the process.
Ricochet would have to make an appearance as the champion and Velveteen Dream is very hot right now, but not quite ready for the NXT Championship yet, so he's in too. As mentioned earlier, Matt Riddle and Keith Lee could have a storyline very soon, so why not them let them shine in this match too?
Punishment Martinez could also be debuted in this match to fill the big man role and an unheralded surprise proposition like Jackson Ryker could be built up to fill the final role.
Whilst this might dilute the power of last year's ladder match, that match went so well that this the hype for a sequel would be off the scale. However, if you wanted to go down a more tradition route for the North American Championship, there's a ready-made feud for that already.
2. Ricochet Vs Pete Dunne For The NXT North American Championship
This has been building for months now. It would be ludicrous for NXT not to pull the trigger on this match.
Pete Dunne and Ricochet are easily two of the most over stars in NXT today. Ricochet is the high-flying North American champion, whilst Dunne is the hard-hitting, longest-reigning champion of the modern era, notching up over 550 days as United Kingdom Champion.
The two have shared an uneasy alliance on NXT for some time now. It's clear that they both want the other's belt, but they have been forced to team up to fend off The Undisputed Era, culminating in a brilliant War Games match where both Dunne and Ricochet pinned Adam Cole to pick up the win.
Pete Dunne needs to lose the United Kingdom Championship soon so he can become a fully fledged member of the NXT roster. Once he does, then a feud with Ricochet over the North American Championship is right there waiting for him.
The two have fought in singles matches before, but never to a definitive winner, so there's plenty of history to build on when New Jersey comes around. You wouldn't need to turn either of them heel; just have both men fuelled by a desire to win and let their in-ring magic tell the story.
No matter the outcome, Dunne vs Ricochet is a match made in heaven - and the fact its been building for the better part of a year will make it even more satisfying when the two finally lock horns.
1. Tommaso Ciampa Vs Johnny Gargano Vs Aleister Black For The NXT Championship
Better late than never.
When Aleister Black injured his groin and was removed from the NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn 4 card, it was a real disappointment.
The planned match of Black taking on Johnny Gargano and Tommasso Ciampa for Ciampa's NXT Championship was in ruins, and hastily changed to a Last Man Standing match between Gargano and Ciampa. Whilst this match was good, we all knew that Black would have definitely added something special to the mix. Luckily, now that Black is back, we may get the chance to finally see this match.
Black returned to NXT with a vengeance, not just against Ciampa for taking his title, but against Johnny for the kayfabe attack that took him out of Brooklyn. The narrative threads are all still there for all three men and, with the right build, the triple threat match could happen - and it will be even better than it was going to be at Brooklyn.
Black's desire for revenge, Johnny's shades of grey character, Ciampa's twisted heel persona, of all these little nuances would come together in a truly epic match in New Jersey, not least because the fans would have been waiting nearly six months to get it.
Who knows, maybe this is how you start a heel #DIY, with Johnny turning on Black in the match to help Ciampa retain the title. There are so many possibilities with this match that it practically has to happen, so why not let it happen on the biggest stage of them all?