Casting WWE Montreal Screwjob Movie

Kylo Ren is Bret Hart. Why not?

By Jack Pooley /

WWE/Kansas City Star

There's perhaps no event in the history of modern professional wrestling as iconic, infamous and unforgettable as the Montreal Screwjob.

Advertisement

On November 9, 1997 at that year's Survivor Series pay-per-view, Vince McMahon schemed with Shawn Michaels and others to change the outcome of Michaels' main event WWF Title match against Bret Hart.

Despite Hart never submitting, McMahon instructed referee Earl Hebner to ring the bell, ruling the match in HBK's favour while viewers were left utterly baffled at what happened. If you watched it live, you'll probably never forget it.

Advertisement

Over 20 years later, the Screwjob remains one of the most fascinating and fiercely debated aspects of WWE lore, and it goes without saying there's room for this to be adapted into a stunning feature film.

While there's no Screwjob movie on the horizon at the moment, just imagine if someone gave it The Social Network treatment. With the right writer and director, it could certainly entice a prestige cast and shed incredible new light on one of wrestling's most enduring all-time scandals.

Advertisement

With that in mind, it's time to lay out our dream casting for all the Screwjob's key players...

14. Bill Hader - Jim Cornette

WWE/HBO

If we take Jim Cornette at his word, then he inadvertently suggested the concept of a Screwjob finish to Vince McMahon in the first place.

Advertisement

As Bret was willing to drop the strap to anyone but Michaels, Cornette pitched the idea of Ken Shamrock double-crossing Hart for the title, which reportedly gave Vince the lightbulb inspiration for what eventually became the Screwjob. Cornette was also spotted meeting with Vince and others the night before Survivor Series, seeming to confirm his involvement.

As for who could play him? It's not easy to replicate Cornette's eccentric motor-mouth shtick, but one suspects Bill Hader could do a fantastic job.

Advertisement

In addition to bearing a decent resemblance to Cornette, he's proven he can play both broadly over-the-top and intensely agitated. Plus, his recent Emmy win for Best Comedy Actor bolsters his status as a true prestige talent. Perfect.

13. Hugh Jackman - Vince McMahon

WWE

What would the Montreal Screwjob be without the man who orchestrated it all, Vince McMahon? The event was a major turning point for the WWE's chairman, prompting him to reinvent himself as the now-iconic Mr. McMahon villain, and legitimately becoming one of the Attitude Era's all-time greatest heels in the process.

Advertisement

The actor playing a 52-year-old McMahon needs to have a dapper appearance but also be capable of more calculated viciousness, as evidenced by the Machiavellian nature of McMahon's underhanded plot.

Who better than Hugh Jackman? We've seen numerous times that the X-Men star can fill out a suit nicely, and his recent role in The Greatest Showman demonstrated his ability to play an enterprising businessman with dubious ethics (even though the film itself downplayed this fact).

Advertisement

Plus, the role won't require Jackman to get back into Wolverine shape, which he'll most likely be eternally grateful for.

12. Holt McCallany - Pat Patterson

WWE/Warner Bros. Pictures

Vince McMahon's right-hand man Pat Patterson was the chief agent for the main event, and though there's fiercely conflicting word on his involvement in the Screwjob, Patterson claims he had no idea Bret was going to drop the title.

Advertisement

After Hart punched out McMahon backstage following the match, Patterson says he tearfully offered up his own face for an extra hit (which Bret refused).

Patterson is of course an industry vet, and to play a man of such seasoned authority, an actor with a real heft and screen presence is required. Enter Holt McCallany, the terrific star of Netflix's Mindhunter, whose piercing gaze and physically involved acting will ensure he steals the show every opportunity he gets.

Advertisement

In addition to being almost exactly the same age that Patterson was during the Screwjob, one suspects he won't struggle to replicate the man's distinctive French-Canadian accent.

11. Chris Hemsworth - Triple H

WWE

Triple H was at ground zero during the Screwjob, having escorted his D-Generation X partner Shawn Michaels to the ring and, depending on which reports you believe, possibly having an intimate knowledge of the events that subsequently took place.

Advertisement

Trips was accosted post-match by Bret's wife Julie and, along with HBK, was also harassed by fans outside of the arena and at his hotel. The Screwjob also occurred briefly before Triple H's career skyrocketed, with D-X becoming fast fan favourites in 1998 followed by his ascent to main-eventer status the very next year.

There is one actor who is all-too-frequently compared to Triple H, largely due to their long, flowing locks (formerly in Trips' case) and their love of giant hammers.

Advertisement

Thor himself, Chris Hemsworth, is admittedly a little older than Trips was during the Screwjob - he's 35, Trips was 28 - but he can still convincingly pass for his late-twenties, and honestly, would most fans even know that Triple H was so young at the time?

Hemsworth has the look down pat, he's obviously got the physique to play a wrestler and he can pull off a passable American accent, so this one's a slam dunk.

Advertisement

10. David Harbour - Bruce Prichard

WWE.com

Bruce Prichard was a member of Vince McMahon's "brain trust" when planning the finish to the main event, but according to his own testimony, he was as shocked at the end result as anyone else.

Advertisement

He was working the Gorilla position for the match and apparently assumed the finish was a botch, leaving him frantically communicating with both ringside and the TV truck to figure out what happened. This is all while Davey Boy Smith, Owen Hart and company were still waiting to be given their cue to head to the ring.

If he was about 15 years younger, Tim Robbins would've been absolutely perfect for this role, but instead we'll defer to one of TV's hottest rising stars right now: Stranger Things' David Harbour.

Advertisement

He's a few years older than Prichard was in 1997, but he's got an undeniably schlubby quality to him that fits the popular perception of Prichard perfectly. One can't imagine his Texan accent will be much of a stretch for the Emmy-nominated actor either.

9. Margot Robbie - Sunny

WWE

Though Tammy Lynn Sytch aka Sunny didn't have any direct involvement with the Screwjob, she was intimately involved with both Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels around the time of the incident.

Advertisement

Sytch had been in a nine-month relationship with Michaels, and a few months prior to Survivor Series a fight broke out backstage between Michaels and Hart after the former accused the latter of having an affair with Sunny. Sunny, for her part, insists she and Hart were just close friends.

Though Sunny would only have a small role in the film, she's got such a distinctive look and personality that we can't just defer to any attractive blonde woman for the part.

Advertisement

Margot Robbie's Oscar-nominated turn in I, Tonya last year proved she could play a truly multi-faceted character, both sweet and gorgeous but also calculated and conniving.

It really wouldn't take much work at all to make her convincingly resemble Sunny, and we know how spot-on her American accent is, so she's the only actress who really even merits much consideration.

Advertisement

8. Aaron Taylor-Johnson - Shawn Michaels

WWE

Casting Bret Hart's opponent, Shawn Michaels, is one of the tougher aspects of this potential movie, if only because HBK was such a singular entity at this point in his career, and brought such a particular brand of d*ckishness to the table.

Advertisement

Michaels is one of the few people 100% confirmed to be in on the Screwjob alongside Vince himself, despite his initial firm denial. The fallout resulted in the already-controversial Michaels being vilified by a huge portion of the fanbase for years.

It takes a special type of cinematic douchebag to pull off such an exuberant "character", and given his slew of performances playing smug, cocky a**holes, Aaron Taylor-Johnson feels like the right fit.

Advertisement

His performances in Savages and Nocturnal Animals are proof perfect of his suitability for the role, while Kick-Ass and Avengers: Age of Ultron make it clear he'd have zero problem getting into wiry fighting shape.

7. Clark Gregg - Earl Hebner

WWE/Marvel

Referee Earl Hebner's exact involvement in the Screwjob still remains murky to this day: Bret claims he swore on his kids' lives that nothing fishy was going to happen, while Hebner insists he was only informed of the new match finish mere minutes before it concluded, and others attest he was told earlier in the day.

Advertisement

Whatever the truth, Hebner's role in that night's fateful events made him a divisive figure for the remainder of his WWE tenure. The actor playing him needs to bring a subdued yet animated quality to the table, and not be so famous that they'd distract from the more effusive major roles.

Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.'s Clark Gregg feels right here. He's a little older than Hebner was at the time but he can certainly pass for younger, and he's proven he can play both dramatic and comedic roles equally well, so whatever the movie's tone would end up being, he'd surely rise to the occasion.

Advertisement

6. Gina Carano - Chyna

WWE/Grindstone

Chyna didn't have a huge role in the outcome of the Screwjob, but she was of course HBK's D-X teammate, and she was supposed to be involved in the originally planned scuffle with Hart Foundation members which would lead to a no contest finish.

Advertisement

Chyna is probably the single most challenging role to cast in the entire movie, because there are hardly any known actresses who can replicate her incredible late-90s physique, to say nothing of her chiselled facial features.

MMA fighter-turned-actress Gina Carano may seem too conventionally attractive to play Chyna of this period, but if she's deprived of make-up, she's certainly got the ludicrous physique to match.

Advertisement

Plus, when Carano was shooting her role in Deadpool, a cut gag from the movie saw Ryan Reynolds compare her to Chyna. So, there you have it.

5. Adam Driver - Bret Hart

WWE/Kansas City Star

And now we have the role that would single-handedly make or break the movie: the "target" of the Screwjob himself, Bret "The Hitman" Hart.

Advertisement

Given the major emotional turmoil Hart was put through during the Screwjob and its fallout, the part requires an actor with tremendous emotional range, who can vacillate between palpable rage and more smouldering, contained anguish.

And who, really, is a better fit than rising star Adam Driver? He's got a similar facial structure to Bret, his shirtless scene in Star Wars: The Last Jedi proved he could get into great shape, and he's got a knack for playing things subtle while hinting at far more going on behind the eyes. Much like Bret, he's also handsome and likeable, yet not overly extroverted or animated.

Advertisement

It's incredibly easy to picture him wearing the Hitman glasses and filling out Hart's attire perfectly.

4. Paddy McGuinness - Davey Boy Smith

WWE/Blacknet

The British Bulldog is without question one of the toughest roles to cast, because in addition to having an absolutely mind-boggling physique, he sported an extremely unique accent shaped by both his youth spent in Manchester and his adult life in the U.S.

Advertisement

We're going with a bold one here: Irish comedian, actor and presenter Paddy McGuinness. The guy has a knack for a wide range of accents as proven in his TV work, yet the fact he's also a bit daft and rough around the edges could actually help him convincingly portray Davey Boy's penchant for stiff, incoherent promos.

His body is an undeniable sticking point, sure, but in recent times McGuinness has aptly demonstrated that he can get into fighting shape, so with one of those famed Hollywood training regimes he could probably achieve some surprisingly convincing results.

Advertisement

3. Channing Tatum - Owen Hart

WWE/Cosmopolitan

Though your first reaction might be to groan at this pick, just think about it for a moment.

Advertisement

Like the late, great King of Harts, Channing Tatum is a natural joker, and considering he demonstrated terrific chemistry with Adam Driver in last year's Logan Lucky - where they also played screen brothers - there's no reason they can't light up the screen together here.

While Tatum is already quite a bit older than Owen was in 1997 and he doesn't immediately appear younger than Adam Driver, the aforementioned prior chemistry with Driver, Tatum's absurd athleticism and his brilliant prior work playing a wrestler in Foxcatcher make him a convincing fit all the same.

Advertisement

The "I can't take Channing Tatum seriously" excuse died years ago, so it's easy to imagine him bringing plenty of compassion to the table while playing one of the most beloved talents in the history of the industry.

2. Jaime Pressly - Julie Hart

WWE/Closer

Bret's wife Julie Hart is best remembered by most fans for fearlessly chewing out Triple H immediately following the Screwjob, as featured in the brilliant documentary Wrestling with Shadows.

Advertisement

In more recent years following her divorce from Bret, she published a book on her experiences of being a wrestler's wife, focused on her struggle to raise the family while Bret sought success all over the world.

In the book she claims the Screwjob had a profound effect on their already fraught marriage, and if the movie's going to accurately capture the Hitman's mindset, it'd be criminal not to feature Julie in some form.

Advertisement

The actress in question needs to be attractive and assertive in their probable cameo appearance. Considering she's also a former model much like Julie and certainly has the moxie to play the part, Jaime Pressly feels right.

She's not famous enough to be a distraction in a smaller part, but she's a tried-and-tested talent with striking looks to match.

Advertisement

1. Michael Shannon - Jim Neidhart

WWE/Parade

And finally, we have another tough-to-cast role, if only because the late, great Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart is such a uniquely intense personality with a distinctly stocky physique.

Advertisement

Michael Shannon's penchant for fiery performances that explode out of nowhere ensure he'd be able to effortlessly embody the spirit of the man.

He admittedly might be a tad too famous for such a small role and some liberties may have to be taken when it comes to Neidhart's bulky frame, but in the very least Shannon could get muscular with enough prep time.

Advertisement

And if we're being totally honest, we really just want to see Michael Shannon screaming maniacally with a ginger goatee. Make it happen, Hollywood.

What do you make of these casting picks? Got any of your own? Shout them out in the comments!

Advertisement