EVERY Wrestling Gimmick Match Ranked From Worst To Best

From the seminal to the disastrous: what is the BEST wrestling gimmick match, and the dirt worst?

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE.com

A quick note on the criteria: this shouldn't be too impenetrable nor daunting a read, and you'll only click through as many slides here as you ordinarily would - but it should be comprehensive.

Advertisement

As such, some stipulation matches will be collected under one banner - Reduced Clothing, for example. Nobody wants an in-depth analysis on the subtle intricacies that separate the Evening Gown and Bra & Panties matches, other than, of course, Jerry Lawler.

Conversely, some stipulations under the same purview should (and will) be reviewed separately. The aim is to catalogue each stipulation in an attempt to determine which types have endured and why, which should be abandoned, tweaked or brought back. It should prove interesting to compare something like the NXT WarGames reboot versus the slightly more traditional AEW Blood & Guts attraction - or whether, for that matter, another promotion exhumed the NWA/WCW centrepiece and did something better with it.

Advertisement

Also, because an exhaustive list would be legitimately impossible to compile, certain unknown or entirely forgotten matches can't be included - and something like the shindie 'Pools of F*ckery' or TNA's 'Hard Ten' won't be here, either. The idea is to spark some debate and provide an in-depth long read on a quiet night, not make you wade through every last bit of wrestling bullsh*t for the sake of retention.

Although, it wouldn't be very fun to ignore some of the more memorably silly matches, so the daftest and maddest will be ranked.

Advertisement

OK, let's go...

83. Reduced Clothing

WWE

This covers your Evening Gown and Bra & Panties matches and the like. Gross. If you insist on molesting yourself, do it to content made by 100% willing participants.

Advertisement

82. Substance

WWE.com

The 'Substance' match is ironically named on Wikipedia, since it is invariably a very shallow affair designed to build either to a slapstick spot or an ugly excuse for Jerry Lawler to rip it clean off. The former saw Hunter Hearst Helmsley get slopped in pig sh*t by Phineas Godwinn; the latter was presented regularly, in "mud" and "gravy" and the like, in a misogynistic exercise to titillate the lads. Every version of this match ever was awful.

81. Non-Wrestling

WWE.com

This entry covers your matches that involve wrestlers but are not in fact wrestling matches. No, this doesn't cover your average NXT match, but rather worked sumo matches, boxing matches, arm wrestling matches and the like. They are all, every last one of them, irredeemably sh*te: object-defeating exercises that present an exponentially worse version of a sport to a set of fans that aren't even interested in the good version of said sport.

Advertisement

80. Blindfold

WWE.com

A deep sea lobster could see through those things, the slapstick comedy is often as a brutal as a "missed" Shane McMahon punch, and while there's always the chance that the blindfolds might slip off, schadenfreude is the absolute most you can hope for in terms of entertainment value. Otherwise, it's very much in the genre of "you'd rather you family walked in on you watching depraved smut".

79. Object On A Pole

WWE.com

Beloved by Vince Russo, who booked one every other week, they were all abysmal. Unless there's an attendant risk of a spectacular bump from a ladder, nobody wants to watch a wrestler climb for an excruciating period of time - especially when they're retrieving something like a bottle of viagra or a bottle of champagne. Trivial, unexciting, a boring exercise in low-stakes anti-drama, that Russo was allowed to work for as long as he did is as profound a failing of humankind as the state of the ozone layer.

Advertisement

78. Trading Places

WWE

Promoted a few times by WWE in the 2000s, the Trading Places match saw each wrestler dress up as the other. A thinly-veiled excuse for the worst comedy you'll ever see, because Goldust was involved in one of them, it was also a thinly-veiled excuse for homophobia - the William Regal character was appalled at the idea of cosplaying as him. An alternate, clunky name for the stip is the 'This Sort Of Sh*te Ultimately Led To The Formation Of AEW' match.

77. Strange Bedfellows

WWE

What was once an excuse to do unique, frivolous matches on TV - this guy is teaming with their fiercest rival, whoa! - actually became one of WWE's key storyline drivers during far too many WrestleMania seasons. The whole Can They Co-Exist? b*llocks remains WWE's biggest insult to the intelligence. They think you are stupid. They really hate you. They wouldn't trust you to tie your shoelaces without Michael Cole screaming "This bunny ear should have a long tail!"

Advertisement

76. Move

WWE

A relic, thankfully, this entry covers the matches that can only be won by using a particular manoeuvre - the powerbomb, more often not. WCW promoted such a match between Sid and Kevin Nash, where WWE - who of course were better than those yokels who went out of business - booked equally dismal Last Ride matches between the Undertaker and JBL and the Undertaker Vs. Mr. Kennedy. The matches were never any good, and surely, the last thing you want to do is give JBL less to do in a wrestling ring. As broad and as boring as drama gets.

CONT'D...

Advertisement

75. Flag/Anthem

WWE

Refers to the original or the even more jingoistic 'Anthem' update, in which the loser was punished by listening to the national anthem of the victor, the Flag match was cycled out of fashion when nationalism no longer drove pro wrestling narrative (despite Vince McMahon's best, most inexplicable efforts). Never any good, the Flag match was yet another woefully one-dimensional storytelling vehicle that stood no chance whatsoever of being as good as a match held under traditional rules. It lacked the lurid, violent appeal that justifies not doing a straight singles, too. Better left in the past (like Vince McMahon!).

Advertisement

74. Taipei Death

WWE Network

Shocking then, an historical curio now, the Ian Vs. Axl Rotten Taipei Death Match - in which the brothers taped their fists with glass before shredding one another apart - really wasn't good. It was mesmerising in its own way, but violence has turned the audience into depraved unethical monsters in countless better matches before and since.

73. One-Sided Rules

WWE

This match type basically covers all instances in which the rules benefit just one of the participants. The most famous and indeed dreadful example was promoted at WrestleMania 25, when the rules benefitted Randy Orton, who, despite invading his home, would capture the WWE title from Triple H were he to have been counted out or disqualified. Not too dissimilarly, at the Horror Show At Extreme Rules, Dolph Ziggler couldn't be disqualified, but Drew McIntyre could. These matches are often bad. The storytelling is prohibitive and one-dimensional, adhering strictly to one beat, and the acting of inner turmoil on the part of the disadvantaged wrestler is usually poor.

Advertisement

72. Empty Arena

AEW

Look, Terry Funk and Jerry Lawler did a great one once, and Lance Russell was incredible at selling the eerie disquiet, but it was a miracle. A unicorn. An Empty Arena match defies the point of wrestling, that incredible cacophony of noise and huge swell of emotion, and, in a "post"-pandemic world, it should never be revisited ever again until it absolutely has to. Jake Hager going half an hour in front of nobody: nobody else wants that feeling restored, either.

71. Holiday-Themed Street Fight

WWE.com

The Trick Or Treat Street Fight and Miracle on 34th Street Fight are annual, risible affairs in WWE. Everybody has a spooky tradition as the air frosts in October. Would it even be Halloween without an annual viewing of The Shining, a blast through Resident Evil 4, or watching a WWE midcard act get their head stuck in a pumpkin in a sh*te match?

Advertisement

Invariably lame, it must be awful taking a real kendo stick-assisted beating just for virtually everybody watching to roll their eyes. The Christmas variation is even worse - a woeful reminder that wrestling should but never will take a day off for once.

70. Scaffold

WWE Network

The Scaffold match died a quiet death for a reason. It enforced a sort of anti-action, in that the wrestlers had to tentatively walk at a very dangerous height, naturally more concerned with saving themselves than harming their opponents. The idea was to either capture a flag or throw your opponent to the floor. The bumps never looked all that great, unless there was an enormous stack of tables underneath the launching point, and since the more famous battles predated ECW, those matches were almost invariably not great either. A sense of danger was palpable, yes, but not of a particularly exciting stripe.

Advertisement

69. Punishment

WWE.com

Since the body of the match exists only as pretext for some daft comedy angle or other, in the 'Punishment' stip - Crybaby, Kiss My Foot, Kiss My Ass - the action itself is hardly great. You put your working boots on the night of WrestleMania; you don't fizz about bumping all over the shop if, for example, you're the 123 Kid and your job is to throw a tantrum after you job to Scott Hall. Risible as the post-match was, the In Your House: Rage In The Cage match itself was good, but only because it was impossible in that era for Sean Waltman to work an actively bad or even mediocre match. It was still his worst feature match of the era, however.

68. Three Strikes

AEW

A match in which a wrestler must earn three specific types of victory before ultimately being declared the winner, it's a rarity for a reason: it's a bit much, and unless you're Shingo Takagi, you probably aren't talented enough to enthral fans for the duration.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

67. Eye For An Eye

WWE.com

In AEW, the Eye For An Eye match was a subplot of surprising emotional weight pitting Jon Moxley - blinded by Chris Jericho - against Santana - blinded by Mox in retaliation. What Mox and the viewers didn't know, in a shock twist, is that Santana's father had succumbed to blindness. Pathos! In a Chris Jericho programme!

Advertisement

In WWE, Seth Rollins defeated Rey Mysterio by literally extracting his eye. This didn't happen - Rollins extracted a cue ball with a dot on it - but you were expected to think that he did.

So about a 50% success rate, then.

Advertisement

66. Beat The Clock

WWE Network

This should work - sudden death urgency and injury time are terrifyingly dramatic when your sports team is involved - but all too often in WWE, the trope exists as an easy way of building a midcard title challenger. The urgency should be off the charts as the seconds recede, and the favourite is in real danger of a shocking loss, but when has it truly felt like that? The promotion has never once worked that "buzzer-beater" feeling.

65. Special Guest Referee

WWE.com

The logic behind the Special Guest Referee match is chronically wrestling brained.

Advertisement

The experienced specialist keeps making blunders, so let's resolve that by replacing them with a complete amateur with a preexisting grudge with one of the competitors!

A good referee is invisible. The bad Special Guest Referee is guaranteed to affect the action and mess up the finish. Done very well at SummerSlam 1997, ever since, the Guest Ref was a woeful contrivance that V-Triggers the intelligence. Mark Briscoe only got away with it because the man can do anything, and Shawn Michaels was astonishing in the role, but it's an inherently dumb one.

Advertisement

64. No Count-Outs

AEW

The No Count-Out genre covers either the match between Sable and Stephanie McMahon at WWE Vengeance 2003 or every AEW match ever promoted. As such, it's probably the most uneven stip in wrestling history. The former was rotten, and the best AEW matches are up there with the greatest wrestling experiences ever felt.

63. Lumberjack

WWE.com

An antique of a stip, it's fundamentally very silly and feels more boring than ever, now that the vast majority of wrestlers have forgotten how to work a match without a spot on the apron. The idea that heel wrestlers are automatically driven to punch any old babyface they can get their hands is the most stupid conceit ever. Pitifully one-dimensional character "work", mediocre action, a match towards which everybody rolls their eyes: it's miraculous that Wardlow and Luchasaurus somehow did a great job with it back in 2020.

Advertisement

62. One Weapon

WWE.com

Just have a No DQ-type match and be done with it because, unless the weapon of choice is a ladder or table, it's probably not very good. A 'Chairs' match, for example, is a concept as daft as it is boring. A wrestler obediently using just one weapon defeats the object of a hateful brawl that one doesn't win but survives, and the repetitive structure of such a match betrays also the point of a plunder brawl: to use various shortcuts, plural, to open up different avenues of action. A gimmick match in the regular and pejorative sense used mostly to pad out the undercard of a PPV that, by scheduling its heated and uncontainable conflict, also defeats the object: the Chairs match stinks!

61. Spin The Wheel, Make The Deal

WWE.com

This entry, covering the various standards and one-offs "randomly" selected at WCW or NXT Halloween Havoc events, ranks low because nostalgia is deceptive. A violent plunder match should mean something - otherwise, why waste your bump card? - and since the appeal of Halloween Havoc lies mostly in the set design, wrestlers hurting one another against the backdrop of an inflatable pumpkin seems pointless. Fun!

Advertisement

But pointless.

60. Battle Royale Variations

WWE

Much like the Royal Rumble, many have failed to imitate a format that has endured for as long as it has for a reason: when done well, it's a gloriously simple and complete thing. The Bunkhouse Stampede matches were fun enough in the days of JCP, but WCW's Battlebowl - in which the idea was to throw the field into a second ring - reeked of doing sh*t just to do it.

Advertisement

On that, Vince Russo was so stupid that he booked a Reverse Battle Royale without grasping that it, logically, was a running race. In trying to do anything different to the wrestling he detested, he made himself look like a complete moron.

CONT'D...

Advertisement

59. Cinematic

AEW

A way for Tony Khan and Vince McMahon to promote something during the pandemic that wasn't bittersweet empty arena wrestling - or, alternatively, a way for Matt Hardy to not have to move - the Cinematic match was always a compromise. The original Stadium Stampede was fantastic - a spectacle, somehow, a very funny and moving story that was also deliriously inventive and at times incredibly violent - Khan grasped the "match" part of "cinematic match". Hangman Page in particular went absolutely apesh*t in that bar scene. WWE meanwhile never got the "match" bit, though the Bray Wyatt Vs. John Cena Firefly Fun House match was as bold and artful as anything the promotion has ever booked - a surreal journey into the flawed psyche of its PG babyface. Everything else they did in the parameters of the form was truly diabolical.

Advertisement

58. Lesser Steel Cage Variations

WWE.com

Remember when JBL and the Big Show worked a Barbed Wire Cage match? With barely any flesh-ripping gore? A terrible match on a terrible show - No Way Out 2005 - WWE seemed to promote it knowing full well that even a regular Steel Cage match couldn't polish that turd. Instead, the more lurid-sounding stip was tacked onto it in a very transparent bid to put a couple of interesting words together (where two interesting wrestlers had not been paired together). Again, the cage (while bastardised by WWE) is perfect as is when done well. Virtually every attempt to tweak it is mostly convoluted and driven by desperation on the part of a promoter who, unable to get the basics right, mistakenly believes that over-gimmicking is the way to go (Dixieland). That, or the cage is a penis extension for Hulk Hogan (Doomsday). As you'll discover, one promoter, inspired by the Last Battle of Atlanta, actually did improve upon the traditional cage match.

57. First Blood / Sadistic Madness

WWE.com

The First Blood match is a bit of a risk, one that lends it a certain anxious vibe removed from the intended drama: what if a wrestlers draws blood the hard way? It has to "count' - the commentators can hardly explain that only predetermined cuts to the forehead are allowed - so the match already risks being incredibly stupid. WCW promoted the dumbest one ever, at Uncensored '99, when Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair just started blading because, like the scorpion feasting on the frog, they were such inveterate carnies desperate for a reaction that they didn't know any better. You should be baying for blood - not hoping that it doesn't leak out.

Advertisement

The First Blood match is the sort of thing that sounds incredibly cool in the mind of a 14 year-old - like Spineshank, or Vince Russo.

56. Handicap

AEW

Mostly used as a TV device - babyfaces must face a series of obstacles to earn their big redemptive moment - the handicap match by design isn't a great, climactic affair worth paying hard-earned money for. It is also - by design - a one-dimensional match with minimal scope with which the babyface can do anything interesting, since it only makes sense for them to sell and sell and sell before the comeback. All that said, a great wrestler can elevate anything they are tasked with. During his early ascension in AEW, Darby Allin tagging himself in against Le Sex Gods was a memorable bit of defiant, badass body language that further got him over as a potential babyface superstar.

Advertisement

55. Casino Battle Royale

AEW

A more famous variation of the Rumble than most of the imitators, the Casino Battle Royale warrants its own entry accordingly - but it's more of the same copy. The match can't rip off the Rumble beat-for-beat, and since there is no improving on perfection, what's left is an overthought and unnecessary update. It's a very Tony Khan match; just as he can somehow concentrate on at least three high-level occupations, he is the only person with the ability to track the four wrestlers enter at once gimmick. Everybody else watches on as the unfocused device plays out and no one wrestler really gets the pop and shine of entering the field. Marred by a gambling motif for the sake of it, the Casino Battle Royale never once worked. MJF was very funny in the first one, mind.

54. Punjabi Prison

WWE.com

A bespoke vehicle for the Great Khali was never going to be any good, but making the poor bloke climb two separate walls felt more like a rib than anything. On one level, the stip was a catastrophically stupid idea - it was dogless Kennel From Hell match, for all intents and purposes, and the one and only version of that was infamously awful - but on another level, sorry, the structure looked awesome in a silly B-movie way and the Undertaker using a rope to hit the Big Show with a dropkick kicked ass. Both bad and so-bad-it's-good. Mostly bad.

Advertisement

53. Three Stages Of Hell

WWE.com

Two or even three gimmick matches for the price of one, Three Stages of Hell is that rarest of things: a Vince Russo-pilled exercise in excess that can actually be great. Steve Austin and Triple H proved as much at No Way Out 2001, but elsewhere, it's probably more accurate to describe that specific match as a rule-proving exception to the fact that the gimmick is bad. Nobody else did anywhere near as good a job with it. Triple H and Shawn Michaels went very masturbatory at Armageddon 2002, and the NXT backlash began when Adam Cole and Johnny Gargano scrambled all too desperately for critical acclaim in a match, at TakeOver: Toronto 2019, that was way, way too much.

52. Inferno

WWE.com

It's impossible to do much beyond basic sequences of power moves - you can't make the flames dance with a technical chess battle on the mat, and you'd be fool to attempt a springboard with fire mere inches away from the ropes - but if a gimmick match is strong enough to make a match between the Undertaker and Kane halfway compelling to watch, it can't be all bad. WWE's version was an excuse to make fans react in much the same way as children do at a fireworks display; in Puerto Rico and FMW, the match was once so barbaric and dangerous that you'll never see its like ever again. You have not lived until you've seen Atsushi Onita escape what he sells as near-certain death, as the ring practically melts underneath the heat, only for the Sheik to throw a fireball in his face.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

51. Gauntlet

WWE.com

Done well at times - the match that crowned a #1 contender for the AEW World Tag Team titles ahead of All Out 2020 was both exquisite use of the rankings system and a genius exercise in making you want to pay for the first sequence between the Young Bucks and FTR - the Gauntlet mostly functions to pad out TV time on Raw. In principle, it's a good means with which to get an underdog babyface over, but in reality, the match is often just a slog. Every criticism aimed at the Iron Man match - that much of it doesn't count - should instead be aimed at this excuse to give the writing team a break.

Advertisement

50. Royal Rumble Variations

Lucha Underground

It's easy to see why a promoter would attempt to emulate the magic of the Royal Rumble, but Pat Patterson perfected it. There's no improving on the formula of the match, even if the action itself is possibly overdue a 21st century update. The NJPW 'Ranbo' is a cherished Wrestle Kingdom institution, but only because you often see a mad name entering and as a result of the generally loose, shrugging way in which it is worked. It's a bit of fun that works as an exercise in contrast. MLW and Lucha Underground both promoted variations in which the match can be won via pinfall and submission, but both operated as an excuse to do one, because again, why wouldn't you try?

In the '80s, every ageing rock star started pissing about with synthesisers in a bid to stay relevant. They felt they had to. Nonetheless, the odd fun song emerged from this cynical period. This analogy applies almost exactly to the non-WWE Rumbles.

Advertisement

49. Ladder Variations

IMPACT Wrestling

King Of The Mountain was TNA distilled: an interesting and dumb series of ideas that cancelled one another out towards virtual irrelevance. That stip has not endured. Ultimate X peaked higher and is remembered more fondly, but the scope for embarrassing disaster is so vast that no other promoter has entertained the idea of ripping it off. The AEW Casino Ladder match almost borders on the infuriating, since it only matters when the staggered entrances are done with. Nobody can "win" until that happens, rendering the whole thing a bit farcical. ECW's Full Metal Mayhem was also daft. The idea of a weapon only being allowed in an ECW match after first being retrieved always asked a bit much.

48. Scramble

WWE.com

A flawed latter-day Pat Patterson concept, the idea was to fuse the multi-man match with the Royal Rumble. It didn't work - the staggered entrance layout didn't conjure much in the way of shock and awe, since all...five entrants were announced well in advance. The 'Interim Champion' gimmick was just weird and unflattering, and only underscored how far away certain wrestlers were from deservedly winning such a match. "Interim Champion The Brian Kendrick" was an oxymoron of bad promotion. The core idea wasn't bad at all - five wrestlers going hog wild in an urgent spree of action - but WWE over-thought it. If every wrestler started in the ring at the same time, Pat could have been onto something.

Advertisement

47. Themed Hardcore

WWE

Mostly the preserve of WWE, the themed hardcore match ranges from big dumb fun to brutally stupid every which way. None feel like they're really worthy of the violence, but the Viking Rules match, at least, allows Ivar to use his propulsive hoss awesomeness to flatten bodies against a wooden ship. The Good Old-Fashioned Donnybrook match at Extreme Rules 2022 was a fun, chaotic riot of a match, but the Symphony of Destruction stip is a disaster. A tonal mess in which the backdrop is too stupid to take the very real violence seriously, Shinsuke Nakamura once drew blood the hard way when WWE - Jesus H. Christ - failed to gimmick a piano.

AEW's Arcade Anarchy was another fun one-off, and a super-inspired setting for Kris Statlander's first return, but it didn't need to take twice as long as the Bloodline saga to get underway.

Advertisement

46. NJPW King Of Pro Wrestling Matches, Various

NJPW

As a concept, the wacky 'King Of Pro Wrestling' banner was a failure. This was New Japan basically acknowledging with a shrug, in 2020, that they were desperate for ways of capturing the imagination of the public when the promotion was attacked by the Orthrus that was the pandemic and Gedo's creative decline. Synonymous with the company's wider downfall, the KOPW title - New Japan's equivalent to cinematic matches, almost, in that they were a break from the bittersweet norm - collided against the promotion's sporting framework for the dubious benefit of the odd interesting match-up.

What's ironic is that more than one match contested for the title was excellent - the 2023 Shingo Takagi Vs. Aaron Henare Ultimate Triad bout in particular - but the stigma had long since took root. The title only served to isolate Shingo when, bereft of star power, he should have been plugged into the main event scene.

Advertisement

45. Barbed Wire Ropes

AEW

If there isn't an explosion involved, the Barbed Wire match, while painful-looking and suspenseful enough what with the teetering by the ropes and whatnot, often just feels like a lesser-than version of something better - a compromise decided upon by a promoter who doesn't want to incur any damages as a result of blowing up a building. In the case of Sabu Vs. Terry Funk, the risk:ratio balance was completely f*cked: the match wasn't as good as the best prime ECW fare, and Sabu still barely emerged with his bicep intact.

44. Last Chance

AEW

Sadly, something as ostensibly climactic and must-see and all-or-nothing rarely works in wrestling, and the medium and its history is largely to blame. It's impossible to take seriously - promoters renege on stips all the time, though Tony Khan should be commended for his attempts to buck that trend. A wrestler being unable to challenge for a title when a specific wrestler remains champion is cheap and very easily undone. When this stip isn't telegraphing the winner outright, it is an albatross. Cody losing a Last Chance match to Chris Jericho at AEW Full Gear 2019 was bold and well-intentioned and added serious heft to his subsequent programme with MJF - but given everything that followed, was it a sensible idea?

Advertisement

The fans didn't take it seriously - AEW followed through, but wrestling itself had cried wolf one too many times - and Full Gear pulled the worst AEW buy amount ever.

CONT'D...

Advertisement

43. Fight Pit

WWE

A recent addition to the gimmick vernacular, the Fight Pit falls under "very good but flawed" - and, since all but one featured the disgraced Matt Riddle, it's not exactly fun to put over. The lack of ropes lends it a different dimension, best taken advantage of by wrestlers with the ability to credibly work in the shoot-style vein. Using the cage wall to do the Anthony Pettis kick is an additional bonus specific to the stip. The platform erected above detracts from the sought-after realism, though; it only exists as a contrivance from which to launch into a high spot.

Advertisement

The potential exists for WWE to persist with the match. Lola Vice could use it as her breakthrough moment.

42. Ambulance/Stretcher/Casket

AEW (@AEW, Twitter)

The "walk and brawl towards a prop in which the loser is enclosed" match, to use a hardly snappy description, varies hugely. Virtually every WWE Casket match was bad, but Darby Allin's AEW Coffin match catalogue is studded with wild gems. He didn't even pioneer the idea of that genre being good - WWE has promoted some belting Ambulance and Stretcher matches - but he is the specialist of a genre that works best as a stunt festival, and not a tedious exercise in the grunting, histrionic struggle of closing a door with a limb stuck out.

Advertisement

41. Lion's Den

WWE.com

The Lion's Den was a rarely used structure back in the Attitude Era - a bespoke gimmick match with which to get Ken Shamrock over - and it was a lot of fun. For all intents and purposes an octagon, at SummerSlam 1998, Shamrock defeated Owen Hart in a lean, credible and unique match that, weirdly, WWE only revisited twice more. It was probably too much of a novelty to waste a big Brock Lesnar match on, but they could have given Daniel Bryan 10 minutes to do something interesting with it.

40. Pure Rules

AEW

The problem with the Pure Rules match is that, while the rules allow for a sense of tension and drama - wrestlers are allowed just three rope breaks, and two uses of closed fists result in disqualification - is, not to seem like a moron, that it's difficult to get swept up in the unadulterated drama of a contest when you need to think at the same time. The rules aren't especially complicated, and there's a unique quality to it, but it was abandoned in the first place because it was a bit pointless in a promotion in which strategic technical wrestling was already the norm.

Advertisement

39. Location-Based Hardcore

WWE

Sometimes daft but always interesting, it's just nice, what with there being no offseason and almost every wrestler alive doing long back-and-forths on TV every week, to watch a brawl unfold somewhere else. Undertaker and Mankind worked a fabulous Boiler Room Brawl at SummerSlam '96, the echoey surroundings in which put over the clanging pain of the plunder spots. Hell, Location-Based Hardcore is so easy that the WWF got something out of the Big Show in 1999 at Backlash.

The Gulf of Mexico match is never some amazing attraction, but is often a breeze to watch. The Attitude Era Dungeon match also worked well for its day, given that the unusual and unforgiving surfaces weren't meant to be bumped upon. A watchable distraction at its best, at its worst - the Ganryujima Island Death match - the location encourages tedious grappling for literally hours on end. If fans wanted a nice view, they'd simply make like Shinsuke Nakamura in WWE, and go on holiday.

Advertisement

38. Best Of Series

AEW

A rematch/TV time generator so easy to book it's a wonder you don't see the Best of Seven on US TV more often, it's a rare thing that never really lives up to its potential. It worked in an era when good wrestling for the sake of it was much more of a novelty, but was only recently dusted off during the Elite Vs. Death Triangle series. That peaked at spectacular, but, in an indictment of the idea, six of the most exciting and detail-oriented wrestlers alive ran out of ideas somewhat before they stipped-up the latter half of the programme. There's always the danger that the series peaks before the finish, with so much action to get through, and that was the case then, too: the sixth Falls Count Anywhere match was such twist-heavy excitement that Escalera de la Muerte wasn't quite as good.

37. Explosion Variations

The names, invariably, are considerably more badass than the actual matches. The Yokohama Amazon River Death Match. Swimming Pool Death Match. Anus Explosion Death Match. These names promise the most outrageous spectacles ever promoted in all of entertainment, but in reality, they were promoted when the Death Match boom was busting, just stacked gimmicks on top of gimmicks, and drifted further and further away from the gripping core premise of "move an inch and you'll explode". Really, these daft creations aren't too dissimilar to the Battle Royal and Rumble sub-genres: over-thought, better on paper, and nowhere near as good as the beautiful simplicity of the original.

36. Iron Survivor

WWE

It was thought for a long time that Money In The Bank was the last great WWE gimmick match - and while Iron Survivor is probably a bit too convoluted to one day carry a main roster PLE, it's also the best new WWE creation in years and years. A much better update on the Scramble, the idea is for each wrestler to strategically pick their spots: winning a fall earns a point, taking a fall incurs a 90-second trip to the penalty box. The back-and-forth excitement is constant, the time limit drama is hair-raising, and thus far, the stip has proven its worth in getting the opportunistic heel and never-say-die babyface over alike.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

35. Submission

WWE.com

Shockingly, a match that sacrifices near-fall drama is only really worth the compromise when contested by two technical specialists - or at least, in the case of Bret Hart Vs. Steve Austin, a submission doyen versus a man who'd rather bleed out and die than give up. WWE in later years often used the match as pretext to do sh*tty Montreal finishes, though the Submissions Count Anywhere match between Daniel Bryan, John Morrison and of all wrestlers the Miz was a fun, novel take on the genre. Even a theoretical Submission match between Danielson and Zack Sabre, Jr. however would undermine the dynamic: a great technical can wrestler can and should use the weight of their rival against them to lock in a flash pin attempt.

Advertisement

34. Loser Leaves Town

WWE

A huge draw and convincing attraction back in the territory era, when wrestlers did actually leave towns and didn't spend decades in WWE winning the Intercontinental title six times in matches few actually remember, in the internet age, the stip feels now like an obligation to "do business" on the way out. Fans already know who has one foot out of the door, undermining the stakes - so much so that wrestlers often lose their last match in a promotion without the stip being attached. A generally nicer industry these days, recently, Tama Tonga was allowed a tearful farewell from NJPW and wasn't beaten out of the territory to juice up the next pushed heel. Nice as that moment was, New Japan missed a trick: the Elite started life very strong as a sub-unit with their unceremonious betrayal of AJ Styles. Similarly, Andrade el Idolo wasn't beaten into an unrecognisable gloopy pulp by Miro at AEW Worlds End.

Not to be all Bully Ray about things, but what's wrong with a little heat?

Advertisement

33. Triple Threat / Three-Way Dance

WWE

Used mostly when a booker/promoter wishes to "save" a match of real consequence - in modern times, you usually see the Three Way/Triple Threat when there are no plans for a wrestler to drop a title early in the reign - the match is usually exciting in a compromised way. The turn-taking aspect is irritating, since the wrestler doing the selling on the outside would have popped back up 10 seconds later having absorbed the exact same move in the context of a singles match. Get some creative minds in there, however, and they can take your breath away with some breathless, complex sequencing - but more often than not the Dance is a booking crutch that has aged out of fashion.

32. Multi-Competitor Elimination

AEW

The great aspect of the multi-competitor genre will be explored in the very next entry, but while the Elimination variation is often almost as fun, the white-knuckle series of out-of-nowhere saves is sorely missing in the final stretch - although the recently-rebooted ROH Survival of the Fittest match was positively awesome at Final Battle last year. Better than the trademark convoluted TNA offering that was Deadly Draw, certainly.

Advertisement

31. Multi-Competitor One Fall To A Finish

WWE

Basically any multi-man match that isn't the Triple Threat or Three-Way Dance, for all the tedious talk of storytelling etc., it sure is incredibly fun to watch four or more wrestlers get creative in a crazed melee of a fight to the finish. It's easy to construct, yes - big move, save, big move, big move, big move, save - but it's just as easy to watch the unadulterated action unfold. Remember the awesome monster mash that was the WWE SummerSlam 2017 main event? That match absolutely rocked, and again, it's ironic: for the apparent "psychology" promotion, WWE is quite incredible at the gratuitous spot-fest. They specialise at it, in fact.

30. Battle Royale

AEW

One of the most enduring stips in the history of the sport, the first half is invariably boring and messy and difficult to track, and, sometimes, the second half is an electrifying scene of pure suspense. It exists because it allows many acts a spot on the card, rather than being paid to sit around and do nothing, and it endures, still, because the genre is compatible with modern athletic advancement and stylistic evolution. In a world of apron spots, the AEW Battle Royals are urgent and breathless half the time. Jack Perry in particular is fantastic at the high-risk near-elimination spot.

Advertisement

Seeing that many wrestlers in one ring remains a daft spectacle, the match at its best is a decent vehicle with which to advance subplots, and in a well-booked promotion, the winner often isn't telegraphed.

29. Strap

WWE.com

It makes a wonderfully satisfying noise, the strap, but the real reason it works so well will be covered in the upcoming Dog Collar entry - and that genre is ranked higher because too many Strap matches suffered from the weird insistence on the touching the corners approach. It's meant to be a hate-fuelled brawl, not a game of Duck Duck Goose or whatever goes on in your "kindergarten". Truly excellent noise though. Welts rule.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

28. Table

WWE.com

In 2024, this gimmick type is about the only way to do away with the obnoxious, greedy "We want tables!" chant that has infested wrestling. Even when the fans A) know that a hardcore variation will see a table broken at some point and B) are watching a hardcore variation that is infinitely better than a regular table/kendo stick/chair-across-the-back special, they will still demand tables there and then. If a wrestling promoter truly understood supply and demand, every match would be a Table match.

Advertisement

And you know, while it's not as venerated as the Ladder match, the Tables match is almost always a fun exercise in giving the people what they want.

27. Hardcore/No Disqualification/Street Fight/Death

WWE.com

This one covers a lot of ground - so much so that you couldn't begin to rank them all, since in ECW alone virtually every match was held under those rules (or rather, no rules). At its nadir, the match is a completely artless excuse for two lumbering bores to draw a cheap pop. At its apex, the Hardcore match is a hate-fuelled riot. Is there any true difference between a 'Hardcore' match and, for example, an Insert Name Of City Street Fight? Or is the average promoter savvy enough to play with synonyms in order to make each match appear "different"?

Advertisement

Either way, the matches while deeply familiar at this point appeal on a visceral level to the fandom. Art can be crafted, shortcuts can be taken. Monsters can even be starved in a daft but fun B-movie premise that encourages a higher level of aggression. It's a match that can take many forms, not merely in name, and is never not compelling in some sense - but a certain AEW stip has rendered that level of violence quaint.

Death Match purists won't like the conflation here at all, but it's the same thing, only with more gnarly weaponry and gratuitous gore.

Advertisement

26. Lights Out

AEW

A fondly-remembered Florida staple, AEW's version of the Unsanctioned match was also once awesome, in that savvy marketing was an effective storyline driver. When Jon Moxley promised a "level of glorious pro wrestling violence fans have not witnessed in this country in decades", he cast a spell so effective that those fans, at AEW Full Gear 2019, readily accepted the more patently "worked" spots deeper into his match against Kenny Omega. The reaction that match generated online was hugely controversial and something of a triumph, given that it was the generally desensitised millennial fanbase that were shocked and appalled. After Adam Cole Vs Orange Cassidy on Dynamite, and two glorified plunder brawls on Rampage, the AEW Lights Out match lost its aura - and has since been replaced by the Texas Death Match as AEW's ultra-violent in-house stip.

25. Unsanctioned

WWE.com

Marketing is just as effective a tool as actual violence. For example, the idea that WWE simply could not condone Triple H Vs. Shawn Michaels, in fear of a real injury occurring, enhanced the drama of the SummerSlam 2002 semi-main considerably. Michaels did an outstanding job of selling his back, and the match would have worked under any 'Hardcore' synonym, but the Unsanctioned stip sold the idea that Shawn had no business being in the ring - which of course drove his babyface comeback to a seminal, unforgettable extent. You can't take the piss with this one, mind. It promises too much. Under-deliver - as Triple H did against Seth Rollins at WrestleMania 33 - and fans will simply reject the glorified No DQ match happening in front of them.

Advertisement

24. Blood & Guts

AEW

AEW's Blood & Guts match is flawed, which is a shame, since it often gets the hard part right. The tone of animosity is there, the violence is genuinely transgressive and sickening, and the 2023 entry, through the Elite's layout mastery, arranged its terrifying plunder sequences to make it feel like impulsive, improvised violence (mostly). It's always too much. The cage is never treated as a weapon unto itself. Too many "toys" are used, defeating the purpose of an urgent, animalistic fight to the death; it's too elaborate for its own good. Also, as a TV special, the slowing down during the ad breaks further ruins suspension of disbelief. The finishes have never once felt "final" either, let down by piss-poor prop work, and the mandated WWE-style roof spots, in addition to being lame, kill the idea that there's no escape.

Excellent but flawed is the ceiling.

Advertisement

23. WarGames

WWE.com

WarGames was incredible in the vaunted early years. The 1992 version was seminal - the genius concept embodied through its hateful tone, minimalist primal violence and cinematic spectacle - but that was the peak. WCW killed it by scaling back the brutality, and WWE never booked a perfect reboot. Even the 2017 edition - an excellent match that used the unique layout to frame Killian Dain as a total badass - was baggy. Almost every version thereafter was overlong and over-reliant on contrived plunder spots. The cage, again, has never once felt like the weapon. Usually, a stipulation becomes a cliché over time - but WarGames, with its regulation cage jump spot and West Side Story-style stand-off, ate itself almost immediately. Exciting, but never quite as good as you expect it to be.

22. Survivor Series

WWE.com

Absolutely tremendous with stakes involved, and an over-long annual obligation without, for now, the match does not exist. In this post-Vince era, Triple H has elected to replace it with WarGames - an absolutely unthinkable set of circumstances when one considers why the Survivor Series pay-per-view came to exist in the first place. The original idea was to kill the NWA off, not pay tribute to it. At its best, the titular match was an incredible, layered, star-studded affair useful in both getting babyfaces over and weaving together the various strands of the umbrella programme WWE happened to be telling at the time. At its worst, equipped with the knowledge that the promoter himself deemed it "antiquated", it existed purely to exist or drive the least believable feud in wrestling history: Raw Vs. SmackDown.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

21. Last Man Standing

WWE.com

Often great, Last Man Standing for a while became a reliable attraction on the B-level WWE PPV circuit - a well-agented arrangement of powerful plunder spots (after the eye-rolling early 10 counts, anyway). The genre has gifted WWE fans some of its greatest output ever (Becky Lynch Vs. Charlotte Flair, Evolution) and cast John Cena in his best ever role. Often more dramatic than violent, WWE nonetheless has developed quite the knack of building towards one awesome centrepiece moment. Last Man Standing has its irritating quirks, but is mostly an excellent bit of business - provided you can take it as seriously these days in the wake of AEW's improved offering...

Advertisement

20. Parking Lot Fight

AEW

Promoted twice by AEW, WWE has done something similar in the past - but nothing on the level of Best Friends Vs. Santana and Ortiz. Their 2020 match was just unbelievable, one of the best plunder brawls ever, because the violence was as seamless as it was thoughtful as it was committed. Yes, the real glass used in windshield spots put it over as a rabid fight to the death, but the arrangement of the thing was sublime. Seamless is used again two sentences later because that really was the word. Nothing was awkwardly set-up. No sequence was so elaborate and so "pro wrestling" that it detracted from the spell of suspended disbelief. Santana jumping from car roof to car roof to land a splash; Santana retrieving a tyre iron from where you'd actually find it; Trent using a tailgate to launch into a tornado DDT: it was a seamless, ultra-believable and mind-melting dose of astonishing pro wrestling violence.

19. Exploding Cage

FMW

Atsushi Onita Vs. Hayabusa was one of the best Death matches ever. Hayabusa enhanced what was already an incredible stip with his awesome athleticism, using his expert body control to sprint via Irish-whip into certain incineration, before just stopping short, in excruciating moments of drama throughout Onita's "retirement" match at Kawasaki Stadium in 1995. The actual explosions were terrifying, nuts, far better than the craftily filmed moments during Funk Vs. Onita, and the portion of the match worked through ash, a lung-bursting exchange of survival, was perhaps the greatest visual effect in pro wrestling history: it looked like they were wrestling during an apocalypse.

Advertisement

18. Exploding Barbed Wire Death

FMW

Far from artless and gratuitous, the Exploding Barbed Wire Death Match is pro wrestling's version of the thriller movie: designed to ratchet up the tension to an unbearable degree, the core idea - and it's more logical than most wrestling matches, in fairness - is to avoid being exploded. Never before has the visual of a wrestler tentatively staggering backwards proved so compelling. In the right hands - the incinerated appendages of Terry Funk and Atsushi Onita - the match fuses demented spectacle with true emotional weight. Explosions are also simply awesome on a primal level impossible to articulate. Bombs in a live action fight: it's the t*ts!

The absolute t*ts!

Advertisement

Bombs and wrestling, at the same time. In some matches, wrestlers have even been German suplexed onto the bastards. Why hasn't the explosion match been revisited more often? AEW have much to answer for.

17. Steel Cage

WWE.com

Cody Rhodes and Wardlow proved that there's still magic in one of the oldest stips yet: an unhinged risk-taking babyface battled a debuting hoss warlord in that magic period of February 2020, and the blood-soaked battle of pure and simple survival was measured to perfection. What WWE has been playing at with the stip for decades is anybody's guess; that the commentators still insist that interference is not possible when it happens every single goddamn time is one of the reasons some fans simply cannot abide the promotion's "creative" ethos. The assault on the intelligence is more vile than anything Vader ever did in the ring. The days of Bruno Sammartino, badass hero, taking pity on his victims and walking out when they'd had enough are long dead - but the gimmick match is still a hit every now and then.

Advertisement

16. Retirement

WWE.com

Wrestling fans will never learn, and even though retirements simply do not happen, the Retirement match is invariably a major attraction. Fans project weight and meaning onto them despite their being a more transparent grift than a failed promoter burying AEW on the podcast racket. Ric Flair was never going to retire - there was more chance of Triple H going through a promo without saying the words "you" and "see" - and yet their WrestleMania XXIV match was utterly gripping. Terry Funk worked multiple successful retirement matches when the plural, by definition, should not have existed. The idea of watching a wrestler go one more time is as must-see as it is utterly implausible. It's a magic stip, in that the biggest lie somehow drives the most intense investment.

15. Set Time Limit

AEW

(Most matches have a set time limit, granted, but the following covers bouts that make an explicit, dramatic feature of it.)

Advertisement

Wrestling should explore this more generally - as mentioned, "injury time" can generate palpitations when the stakes are high - and, when a booker is attuned to the dramatic principles of sport, brilliance is often achieved. At his peak, during those seminal G1 Climax tournaments, the last round of block matches benefitted hugely from the set time limit (to a lesser extent, the STARDOM Cinderalla tournament and AEW Continental Classic grasped this device too). The panic of a crowd utterly swept up in the do-or-die meaning of it all; commentators losing their minds and voices at once; the furious exchange of the struggle: done right, it's never more easy to believe in wrestling when the time limit rapidly expires.

The secret to great wrestling isn't cinema or high spots: it's timing and pacing.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

14. Falls Count Anywhere

AEW

Almost always an absolute riot of a time, because you'd have to be a dog sh*t wrestler to not get fans going crazy and star-struck when you're brawling directly in front of them. And, obviously, the fact that falls do in fact count anywhere widens the scope for creative backstage chaos and wild stunts. It's only possible to do a bad Falls Count Anywhere match, a haven of creativity, if you don't possess a creative bone in your body. A match that can be both hysterically funny with slapstick and ultra-violent with plunder, it can also hide the limitations of those involved. A recipe for guaranteed entertainment.

Advertisement

13. Luchas De Apuestas

Pixabay

In Mexico, the grand tradition of Mask Vs. Hair and the various derivatives is an eternally brilliant fusion of stakes, theatre, personal animosity and mystery. You're guaranteed to see something you've never seen before, and that something means absolutely everything to the competitors involved. The deepest source of personal pride is on the line. It is drama idealised - wrestling idealised, even. While it is unique to the culture of lucha libre, the US scene should attempt something that strikes such a vein of overwhelming emotion.

12. Elimination Chamber

WWE.com

A near-guarantee of compelling action, while it has never reached the same peaks, the Elimination Chamber has proved itself a more consistent attraction than Hell In A Cell. Now that the structure itself has undergone a redesign, you see none of the (understandably) awkward and tentative bumps to the steel grids that separate the ropes and the cage. That space allows for cool spots - the visual of a body getting smashed through a pod hasn't lost its potency, all these years later - and the multi-person match structure allows WWE to interweave various beats on the "Road" to WrestleMania. That layout is also useful in portraying a wrestler like a total killer (Goldberg, Shayna Baszler, Brock Lesnar) or crafting what probably remains the best match-within-a-match in WWE history (the impossibly dramatic Daniel Bryan Vs. Santino Marella sequence).

Advertisement

The match is showing its age - there's only so much you can do with it after more than two decades - but only once was it anything less than very good.

11. Dog Collar

AEW

The hit rate on the Dog Collar match is outrageous, and, distinct from something awful like the Chairs match, there being one primary weapon works in its favour. The weapon is heavy-duty, looks like it sucks to take, and the idea that the wrestlers are bound to one another lends the match a hateful intimacy: there's just one thing - to pummel his enemy senseless - that the wrestler is literally bound and determined to do. Unlimited creativity is not always a great thing, and the Dog Collar is like a great, rigid set of dramatic rules: it focuses the talent and forces them to extract more meaning from fewer ideas.

Advertisement

It's almost a perfect stip, but there's just one ultimately trivial problem: in the modern contests, awkward moments arise when the chain refuses to play along with the sort of ambitious spot Roddy Piper and Greg Valentine didn't touch in their gritty, minimalist classic. Think MJF frantically working out how to manoeuvre the chain from the inside of the ring to the apron, or Dax Harwood tying it around his head like a child struggling with spaghetti.

10. I Quit

WWE Network

Virtually every memorable match fought under the stip was incredible because the core premise is simply that alluring: in a world in which macho energy powers everything, the idea that a wrestler would quit and surrender out loud seems impossible. Ric Flair Vs. Terry Funk was immortal in this regard, and similarly, even though he was the heel who practically always loses, it seemed impossible, after promising victory to his mother, that Eddie Kingston would say those words at AEW Full Gear 2020. Unthinkable stakes fused with ultra-violence, the I Quit match is almost invariably a guarantee of brilliance.

Advertisement

9. Iron Man

AEW

Some wrestling fans are weirdly cynical about a proven critical hit with a staggering hit:miss ratio. The argument that the falls "don't count" until the finish is baffling. The match is the closest wrestling gets to points-based sport - there's nothing like your team getting an equaliser against the run of play. Even if the talents involved aren't as good as MJF and Bryan Danielson - who perfected the genre at AEW Revolution '23 by generating "Fight Forever!" chants purely by selling in the last 10 heart-stopping moments - WWE proved that the match can be successfully gimmicked within an inch of its life with plunder and or an extravagance of falls. At its best, the Iron Man is a masterclass and flex of pacing - and pacing is that which separates a very good match from a great one.

8. Cage of Death (ROH Vs. CZW Only)

ROH

ROH and CZW in collaboration, for a magical period in 2006, utterly embarrassed countless wrestling promotions on many different levels. The intricate, subplot-rich inter-promotional rivalry blew the WWECW Invasion out of the water like a breaching orca, and while it was nowhere near as influential nor lucrative, it was a far better beginning-to-end story than the WCW Vs. nWo feud and the NJPW Vs. UWF-i programme that inspired it. The premise - the snooty technical league fighting for territory against the boorish death match savages - was as believable as pro wrestling conflict gets. Moreover, in promoting the phenomenal Cage of Death blow-off, ROH and CZW rebooted the spirit of WarGames to far better artistic effect than AEW, NXT and the WWE main roster. Violent, dramatic, unpredictable, euphoric, that masterpiece grasped the core idea - vengeance - better than even the NWA during its pomp. Chris Hero entered an all-time f*ck around/find out performance by first lounging on the ropes, watching his evil masterplan unfold, before eating a fork to the face courtesy of vengeful cult hero Homicide. Utter perfection.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

7. Ladder / TLC

WWE.com

TLC/Escalera de la Muerte is better than the ladder match itself, historically - truly, there is no context into which it is detrimental to throw a table - and as such, the Ladder and TLC match is effectively the same thing these days, hence why they are grouped together here. It's not as if the ladder match is the strategic counterpart to TLC's unrelenting madness. They're both as nuts as they are ill-advised.

Advertisement

Almost completely normalised in 2024, the old, wonderfully metaphorical idea - that the ladder was climbed by the '90s WWF upper midcard act on the cusp of the main event - is dead now. Everybody gets to work one. Spectacular even when the things are barely climbed and instead used to do disconnected spots, great ladder matches - death-defying, terrifying, very painful-looking ladder matches - are still possible today. Sammy Guevara is something of a pariah in 2024, but his unbelievable 2022 jumping cutter spot remains an all-timer of an AEW moment. Yes, the genre simply isn't what it was - but there's an intense irony within its lore. They say that a dangerous spot isn't worth it because nobody will remember or feel anything towards it - and yet half the wrestlers who trot out that line haven't done a thing as unforgettable as Edge spearing Jeff Hardy out of midair.

6. Two Out Of Three Falls

AEW

The best match of all-time was worked under the Two out of Three Falls stip: Kazuchika Okada Vs. Kenny Omega at NJPW Dominion 2018. The first Bulldog pin in that was shocking, soul-destroying, an absolutely perfect way in which to cast Okada as a man simply unbeatable - which made for unparalleled drama, since Omega then had to defeat him twice. FTR are an amazing tag team who can lean into self-indulgence, but their grasp of the stipulation is masterful (or, it gives them a good reason to go long). As long as that first fall feels like there can be coming back from it, this match type yields unrelenting drama, and most promoters are astute enough to only allocate great wrestlers such a mammoth run-time - thereby assuring a near-perfect hit rate. There's a reason it is the lucha standard: it's unreal at its most effective.

Advertisement

5. Money In The Bank

WWE

WWE has perfected the Money In The Bank match to such an exhilarating extent that AEW - a promotion that largely signs more exciting aerial talent and allows them to work a faster and more high-risk style - still hasn't bettered it with their Face Of The Revolution equivalent. MITB is a nigh-on perfect fusion of white-knuckle action and stakes, since the audience is aware that they are watching the World champion-elect, and since that future champion is not quite on the level of the act destined to headline WrestleMania, the match is often more unpredictable than the Royal Rumble. That's not to state the match is as important or as iconic, but while it borders on sacrilege, it's in some ways better - or at least more exciting.

The Rumble, though, has endured for a damn good reason...

Advertisement

4. Anarchy In The Arena / Live Stadium Stampede

AEW

An incredible innovation so perfect for the company, it's little wonder Anarchy In The Arena has become AEW's trademark. The very vision of AEW is in its unabashed, borderless creativity - and AITA allows itself to explore that to an unprecedented extent. So chaotic that it almost benefirs from the missed spots, and those incredible quick cuts that only just capture some deranged stunt at the last possible moment, the genre is monumentally awesome because of its flaws. It removes the sense of contrivance lurking in every gimmick match. What the camera does capture is a hysterically violent 10-man brawl that spills out into every corner of a vast building, a melting pot consistent with the AEW ethos that incorporates elements from prime Memphis, PWG, DDT, the WWE Attitude Era. The buffet soaked in blood, sparks and mustard, a match so unhinged that in 2022 the audience completely accepted the idea that Eddie Kingston would kill a man during it.

And it's still not the best AEW stip!

Advertisement

3. Texas Death

AEW

The Texas Death match was a great attraction in the good old days, but it's a different and better beast altogether now. This is probably naive, but it would be wonderful, were Tony Khan to truly recognise what he has with the Texas Death match and exercise some discipline with it. Promote it at an absolute minimum twice per year because you can never get that level of aura back - and in a total masterstroke, the AEW Texas Death match has restored the primal, terrifying feeling of what violence in pro wrestling should be. It's not merely in the violence itself, although the guardrail piledrivers, shoot brick work and liberal use of barbed wire don't hurt (or rather do): it's in the way it's all registered. Jon Moxley wildly stabbing Lance Archer with a fork; Swerve Strickland conveying to Hangman Page that he can't be killed by stabbing himself with a staple gun; Hangman Page drinking Swerve's f*cking blood to prove that he can: the AEW Texas Death match is body language masterclass, tonal horror and despicable, frightening, primal violence. No other match in wrestling today possesses the same aura. It cannot be allowed to wither like the Lights Out match before it.

2. Hell In A Cell

WWE.com

A stip that ranges from utterly seminal to enclosed mediocre plunder brawl, it will never reach the heights set by the Undertaker and Shawn Michaels (and should never reach the literal heights set by 'Taker and Mick Foley). The original remains the best; the Undertaker has never felt more terrifying than when brutalising a claret-drenched Michaels in 1997. WWE marketed the 'Phenom' brilliantly, projecting an aura onto him for decades, and he never embodied it more than at Badd Blood. He performed as the last person a wrestler would ever wish to be in a fight against: a true horror movie monster in thrilling live action. Triple H knew how to craft one in his prime, entering several classic performances; when he didn't disappear up his own arse, he was exceptional at cycling through modes of unstoppable warlord and ass-showing stooge. In recent years, amid far too many glorified clichéd No DQ matches, Randy Orton and Jeff Hardy did some excellent torture-themed work, after which the women (Becky Lynch, Bayley and Sasha Banks most notably) quietly redefined the stip using the right angles of the cell walls to add a new dimension of creativity.

Advertisement

For its peaks, HIAC is right up there with the absolute best of the best - and as Cody Rhodes proved in 2022, it remains a real test of a performer's mettle.

1. Royal Rumble

WWE.com

So iconic that it has entered the wider mainstream lexicon, the WWE Royal Rumble is literally the perfect formula for a special pro wrestling attraction. This is a match than can enshrine wrestlers into legend, draw massive decibel levels with a descending count of 10, build half of the biggest show of the year with its omni-layered storytelling vehicle, debut new acts as instant game-changers, delight the inner child of the viewer with its nostalgic cameos, build the next big thing in a matter of minutes through the 'Diesel push' device, make lapsed fans watch all over again, make a reality of dream matches...

Advertisement

Provided the fans can recognise the entrance themes, the field is over, and Vince McMahon isn't in the mood to tell you to go f*ck yourself, it doesn't get better than the Royal Rumble: a Pat Patterson creation that Vince thought was "stupid".