Every WWE Survivor Series Ranked - From Worst To Best

Survivor Series turns 30 this weekend, so what better time to revisit the past?

By John Bills /

WWE.com

Whilst it may be the fourth of the so-called Big Four in 2016, Survivor Series is the second longest running WWE event after WrestleMania. You've got to go all the way back to 1987 to find the first, a show put together off the back of WrestleMania III's success, and one of the first signs that Vince McMahon was serious about establishing a wrestling monopoly.

Advertisement

Survivor Series 1987 aired the same night as NWA's Starrcade '87, and cable providers were given a choice between the two for their pro wrestling Thanksgiving extravaganza. Threats of losing WrestleMania and thus serious revenue meant most plumped for Survivor Series.

The concept of the show was simple: teams of 4 or 5 men or women going head to head in an elimination tag match, with the winning team that which eliminated all of the opposition. This initial premise faded away somewhat through the 90s, to the point where modern Survivor Series events would have just one or two so-called 'Traditional Survivor Series Elimination Matches'. Bit of a mouthful that.

Advertisement

Survivor Series has played host to countless iconic debuts, memorable screwjobs, title changes, and some of the most frustrating shows in company history. Which was the finest? Which was the worst?

Here's every Survivor Series show ranked, from worst to best.

Advertisement

29. 1993

WWE.com

A steaming turd from start to finish. The 1993 Survivor Series was plagued by injuries and substitutions, not to mention an ill-advised push for Ludvig Borga, and an ill-fitting Smoky Mountain Wrestling tag title match in the middle of the card that had all the heat of a particularly cold penguin.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, the Hart Family were scheduled to take on Jerry Lawler and his band of Knights, but Lawler was unable to make the show after being indicted for the alleged sodomizing of a teenage girl (subsequently revealed to be completely untrue). Shawn Michaels was his replacement, and whilst Shawn was great, the lack of Lawler took the heat out of the story. Oh, and Greg Valentine and Barry Horowitz were involved.

Later in the show The Four Doinks (Men on a Mission & The Bushwackers) beat Bam Bam Bigelow, Bastion Booger and The Headshrinkers in a match infamous for its zany stupidity.

Advertisement

28. 1994

WWE.com

Whilst it isn't entirely fair to completely write-off any particular time in professional wrestling, the mid 1990s were somewhat disappointing for the then-WWF. The 1994 Survivor Series is a good example of this. The roster wasn't as deep as it needed to be, and the company was still transitioning out of the Hogan era and into the New Generation.

The show was headlined by The Undertaker taking on Yokozuna in a Casket Match with Chuck Norris as the Guest Enforcer, which basically involved him looking baffled by his surroundings and giving Jeff Jarrett a roundhouse kick. It wasn't the greatest casket match you've ever seen.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, Bam Bam Bigelow and King Kong Bundy were the sole survivors for The Million Dollar Team against Lex Luger's Guts and Glory, and The Royal Family (Jerry Lawler and a team of midget kings) defeated Clowns 'r Us (Doink and a team of midget clowns).

Oh, and the ancient Bob Backlund defeated Bret Hart to win the WWF Championship, smack bang in the middle of the show. Just not a good night from start to finish.

Advertisement

27. 2013

WWE.com

The 2013 Survivor Series wasn't a horrible show by any means, but it was a Big Four pay-per-view in the 21st century headlined by a Big Show World Title match, and as such has no right being anywhere near the upper echelons of any list. Why WWE thought Show would be a good replacement for a white-hot Daniel Bryan in the title scene remains a baffling mystery.

Advertisement

This show marked the true lightbulb moment for Roman Reigns, as he single-handedly eliminated four men to become the sole survivor for The Shield/Real Americans team against The Rhodes Brothers, Rey Mysterio, and The Usos. At this point in time, fans genuinely loved Roman Reigns.

John Cena beat Alberto Del Rio in a match we've seen at least 83 times, CM Punk & Daniel Bryan beat Luke Harper & Erick Rowan, and Total Divas beat True Divas to the interest of approximately nobody.

Advertisement

26. 1998

WWE.com

One year removed from the Montreal Screwjob, Vince McMahon reenacted that regrettable decision at the the climax of a tournament to crown a new WWF Champion. It seemed throughout that Mankind was the chosen champion, only for Vince to screw him over and help The Rock become the Corporate Champion.

Whilst important in the grand scheme of the Attitude Era, Survivor Series 1998 showed that an entire show centred on a tournament just doesn't work. There were 14 matches on the main show (plus four pre-show matches), including such classics as Al Snow vs. Jeff Jarrett and X-Pac vs. Steven Regal.

Advertisement

The ending was important, but getting there was a forgettable slog.

25. 2004

WWE.com

The Undertaker vs. Heidenreich? A one and a half minute Trish Stratus/Lita match? JBL vs. Booker T? Maven and Snitsky in the main event? No, the 2004 Survivor Series does not look good on paper and it wasn't much better in reality.

Advertisement

Shelton Benjamin and Christian had a decent Intercontinental Championship match early on in the show, but there really wasn't much else to hang your hat on here. The Team Guerrero (Eddie, Big Show, RVD, Cena) vs. Team Angle (Kurt, Luther Reigns, Mark Jindrak, Carlito) elimination match wasn't terrible, but it wasn't exactly good.

This show happened, people watched it, nobody remembers it.

Advertisement

24. 2010

WWE.com

In 2010 it was announced that the future of Survivor Series was in jeopardy. Well, it wasn't in jeopardy in truth, it was finished, as Vince McMahon had announced that the name would be dropped and the event rebranded. But before WWE could run WWE Wrath or WWE Miffed (not real names), fans let the company know how much they hated the idea and Survivor Series was saved.

WWE responded by giving us a show that was solidly mediocre, featuring a surprisingly great match between Sheamus and John Morrison as well as further proof that it had well and truly messed up the previously-hot Nexus angle.

Advertisement

Wade Barrett came up short against Randy Orton in the main event, a result which meant John Cena was fired. Luckily for members of the Cenation, the word 'fired' in Cenish means 'show up every week regardless'.

23. 2012

WWE.com

Much like 1998, the 2012 Survivor Series had a memorable and important ending that masked a truly boring show. The Shield made their impactful debut on WWE TV that night, hurling Ryback through the announce table and allowing CM Punk to pin a clearly-dead John Cena and retain his WWE Championship.

Advertisement

What of the rest of the night? Erm, not much in truth. Cesaro was still Antonio and he defended his United States Championship against R-Truth, Sheamus defeated Big Show by disqualification (gotta love those PPV non-finishes) and elimination matches happened.

Not much to see here, other than messrs. Ambrose, Reigns, and Rollins making their immediate presence felt.

Advertisement

22. 2015

WWE.com

The 29th annual Survivor Series was another 'just fine' show, built around three excellent matches and an ending that nobody wanted but begrudgingly had to happen. If ever there was proof that the Money in the Bank gimmick needs updating it came in the shape of WWE rehashing the Daniel Bryan/Randy Orton SummerSlam 2013 cash-in, only replacing the characters with Roman Reigns and Sheamus.

Reigns and Del Rio had opened the show with a match that way surpassed expectations, followed up by Dean Ambrose and Kevin Owens having one that met its own lofty expectations. Reigns and Ambrose thus 'closed' the show with a decent bout of their own.

Advertisement

The other moment of note saw The Undertaker celebrate his 25th anniversary with a typically monumental entrance. Taker teamed up with Kane to defeat Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper - the first inkling that Taker/Braun Strowman thankfully wasn't going to happen at WrestleMania 32 as had been rumoured.

21. 1999

WWE.com

The 13th edition of Survivor Series was another notable one, as in the early stages of the evening Stone Cold Steve Austin was run over by an unknown assailant, putting him out of action indefinitely. Big Show would replace Austin in the triple threat main event (also featuring Triple H and The Rock), picking up the victory and his first WWF Championship in the process.

Advertisement

Big Show also won a 4-on-1 elimination match earlier in the night, destroying Big Boss Man, Prince Albert, Mideon & Viscera in under two minutes. Chyna defended her Intercontinental Championship against Chris Jericho in a match the latter claimed he tried to forget, and there were a number of other similarly forgettable matches dotted throughout.

Kurt Angle made his in-ring debut that night, defeating the frankly terrible Shawn Stasiak. It was a signpost evening for sure, but the action throughout the show only ever ranged from bad to not good.

Advertisement

20. 2008

WWE.com

The 2008 Survivor Series featured an immensely miffed-looking John Cena on the promotional poster, a sight that was the polar opposite of how he ended the show itself. On that night Cena defeated Chris Jericho to become World Heavyweight Champion, somewhat undoing all the great work done by Jericho and Shawn Michaels earlier in the year.

Elsewhere, Edge shockingly won the WWE Championship after Vickie Guerrero entered him into the title match between Triple H and Vladimir Kozlov (HAH!) that was ongoing, a surprise that nobody saw coming and lifted an otherwise dull undercard.

Advertisement

The Undertaker defeated Big Show in a casket match that you shouldn't look up, and Team Orton (Randy Orton, Cody Rhodes, Shelton Benjamin, Mark Henry, William Regal) defeated Team Batista (Batista, CM Punk, Kofi Kingston, Matt Hardy, R-Truth) in what an underrated elimination match.

19. 1987

WWE.com

This might be a ranking based purely on nostalgia, but the first ever Survivor Series is an enjoyable event. Only four matches made the card, all elimination bouts, with the centrepiece being a 37 minute 10-on-10 tag team elimination match featuring the entire tag division at the time

Advertisement

The main event saw the team of Hulk Hogan, Paul Orndorff, Don Muraco, Ken Patera and Bam Bam Bigelow come up short against Andre the Giant, One Man Gang, King Kong Bundy, Butch Reed and Rick Rude, with Andre the sole survivor.

The show was a lot of fun and is worth revisiting to try and feel the nostalgia factor once again.

Advertisement

18. 1997

WWE.com

On a number of occasions already, mention has been made of notable happenings at the Survivor Series. 'Notable' isn't strong enough a word to use when describing the end of the 1997 event. As everybody knows, this was the night of the infamous Montreal Screwjob which saw Vince McMahon and forcibly remove the World Title from Bret Hart in front of a Canadian crowd.

Advertisement

What else was on the show? Does it matter? Stone Cold Steve Austin defeated Owen Hart in a short match for the Intercontinental Championship, there were a number of elimination matches, and Kane beat Mankind. None of it is worth going out of your way to watch.

If you are a young fan who has no idea what a Montreal Screwjob is, close this window and go watch the end of this show. It is perhaps the most notable moment in WWE history.

Advertisement

17. 2006

WWE.com

A strange one this. Despite having a decent card on paper, every match went under 14-minutes, meaning nothing had chance to fall into a groove and find a rhythm. A sequence of short matches is jarring anyway, but when three of these matches are elimination matches the frequent pinfalls can be a bit too much.

The main event saw Batista defeat King Booker for the World Heavyweight Championship, but the show is best remembered (ironically) for Shawn Michaels eliminating Mike Knox just 40 seconds into the Team DX vs. Team Rated RKO elimination match, before asking who he had just superkicked.

Advertisement

The show also saw a not-quite-ready Mr. Kennedy defeat The Undertaker in a First Blood match.

16. 2003

WWE.com

Survivor Series 2003 was yet another event that looked good on paper but was fairly hit and miss in reality. Goldberg headlined his one and only Survivor Series event, successfully defending the World Heavyweight Championship against Triple H. His opponent this Sunday was also in action, although Team Lesnar came up short against Team Angle.

Advertisement

Vince McMahon defeated The Undertaker in a Buried Alive match that saw the end of Biker Taker and the beginning of the road to Kane/Undertaker II at WrestleMania XX. Speaking of Kane, earlier in the night he had defeated Shane McMahon in an Ambulance match, and Team Bischoff overcame Team Austin, with Randy Orton the sole survivor.

Los Guerreros also continued down the road to breaking up as they were defeated by the Basham Brothers. Remember them?

Advertisement

15. 2014

WWE

A one-match show (Bray Wyatt and Dean Ambrose fans may disagree), but by lord what a match it was. The main event saw Team Cena take on Team Authority with everything on the line, and the almost-45 minute match didn't disappoint in the slightest.

When all is said and done and Dolph Ziggler's career is properly evaluated, this will surely stick out as the moment WWE should have strapped a rocket to his back and ran with him as a main eventer. Sure, he won thanks to the interference of a debuting icon, but his babyface fire fighting from underneath showed fans that maybe he was as good as he said he was.

Advertisement

The debut of Sting was the major talking point however, and even for someone that wasn't a huge Sting fan years ago it was still a goosebump moment.

14. 2009

WWE.com

Speaking of moments when WWE should have strapped rockets on backs, how different would WWE look today if they hadn't pulled out of Kofi Kingston's push in 2009? Whilst many point the 'midcard for life' finger at Kofi, the truth is he's only ever really had one chance at grabbing the brass ring, and it all came to nothing because of Randy Orton's petulance.

Advertisement

Kingston was the sole survivor of the Team Kingston vs. Team Orton elimination match here, overcoming both Orton and CM Punk at the last. The main event of the show saw John Cena overcome both members of D-Generation X to retain the WWE Championship, after The Undertaker had done the same in similar circumstances earlier in the show against Jeri-Show to hold onto the World Heavyweight Championship.

The show opened with Team Miz defeating Team Morrison in a match that seemed to signal the arrival of the next generation of top heels in the shape of Miz, Sheamus, and Drew McIntrye. Batista also continued his excellent heel run, defeating Rey Mysterio by knockout.

Advertisement

13. 1992

WWE.com

If The Ultimate Warrior hadn't been fired in 1992, chances are this show would be a whole lot further down the list. Warrior was originally booked to team with 'Macho Man' Randy Savage in a main event tag match here against Ric Flair and Razor Ramon, but with Warrior gone from the company Mr. Perfect stepped up to take his place.

The match was bumped to the middle of the card and as a result WWF Champion Bret Hart and Intercontinental Champion Shawn Michaels competed in Survivor Series' first ever singles main event, with Bret picking up the win.

Advertisement

This is most definitely a two-match show however, as everything else on the card was borderline-awful. Yokozuna went up against Virgil, Undertaker battled Kamala, and the Big Boss Man fought Nailz, in case you needed convincing.

12. 1990

WWE.com

An event that will forever be remember for the debut of The Undertaker (not forgetting the debut of the Gobbledy-Gooker). The 1990 Survivor Series was a great show - provided you aren't too interested in genuinely excellent wrestling. It was an elimination match heavy show, with the main event seeing all of the survivors from the previous matches come together in one grand finale.

Advertisement

Whilst it was a good way of freshening up the elimination match formula, the reality was that the finale existed as a way to end the show with both Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior standing tall. Hogan had 'passed the torch' to Warrior earlier in the year at WrestleMania VI, but it quickly became apparent that the torch didn't give anything other than light.

Not much to write home about between the ropes, but the debut of The Undertaker and the establishing of Sgt. Slaughter as an evil heel are worth the entrance fee alone.

Advertisement

11. 2000

WWE

One calendar year after being the victim of a hit and run, Stone Cold Steve Austin found himself the centre of attention at Survivor Series once more, as the Texas Rattlesnake took on Triple H in a No Disqualification match to close out the show. The match ended in a no contest after Austin dropped a car (seemingly containing Triple H) from a forklift. The Attitude Era!

Kurt Angle defended the WWF Championship against The Undertaker in a great match, two legendary performers whose chemistry if often overlooked in the pantheon of 'workers with great chemistry'. Elsewhere, The Rock defeated Rikishi in a match with decidedly less chemistry - ironic considering the two are related.

Advertisement

The usual thrown-together elimination matches also took place, as well as a singles match that saw Kane defeat Chris Jericho in their epic-coffee centred feud.

10. 2011

WWE

The return of The Great One. The main event of the 2011 Survivor Series saw future WrestleMania opponents Rocky and John Cena team up to defeat sacrificial lambs The Miz and R-Truth in a match that even Hillary Clinton could have correctly predicted. Still, the crowd ate up everything The Rock did, so it wasn't short of heat.

Advertisement

CM Punk defeated Alberto Del Rio to embark on his remarkable 434-day run as WWE Champion, and Team Barrett overcame Team Orton in yet another example from the file marked 'moments fans thought a midcard talent was going to be pushed'.

A fine show from top to bottom, full of acceptable wrestling.. and a Big Show/Mark Henry match.

Advertisement

9. 1995

WWE.com

At the beginning of this article it was stated that mid-90s WWF was the worst WWF, and whilst this statement holds true, the 1995 Survivor Series is an exception to the rule. In truth, the show has no right being so much fun.

The opening match saw the team of Skip, Dr. Tom Pritchard, the 1-2-3 Kid, and Rad Radford (Rad Radford!) overcome The Underdogs, an optimistic name for a team made up of Marty Jannetty, Bob Holly, Barry Horowitz, and Hakushi. On paper that doesn't scream excitement, but in practice it was an entertaining affair.

Advertisement

The main event of the night gave hints at the direction the company was going too, as Bret Hart ended Diesel's reign of terror as WWF Champion. Hart went through a table at ringside in this match, a spot rarely seen in the mid-90s, as both men ramped up the violence somewhat to establish the New Generation.

A much better show than you might think.

Advertisement

8. 2005

WWE.com

A difficult show in many ways, the 2005 Survivor Series took place just two weeks after the death of Eddie Guerrero. Eddie was originally booked to be in the SmackDown vs. RAW elimination match main event, and his replacement Randy Orton would go on to become the sole survivor in that contest.

Advertisement

John Cena and Kurt Angle rekindled their rivalry with a match for the WWE Championship, won by Cena as the company continued to throw all their weight behind their new champion superstar. Booker T defeated Chris Benoit in the first match in the Best-of-Seven series for the US Championship, a series that most certainly didn't end with them in a comedy tag team together.

Triple H defeated Ric Flair in a bloody Last Man Standing match, and Edge formally announced the arrival of his talk show, The Cutting Edge.

Advertisement

7. 1989

WWE.com

A nostalgia ranking if ever there was one, the 1989 Survivor Series featured some truly glorious teams and team names. The Ultimate Warriors (Warrior, The Rockers, Jim Neidhart) defeated The Heenan Family (Andre the Giant, Bobby Heenan, Haku and Arn Anderson) in the main event, something of a test run for Warrior ahead of his mega push the following year.

The Hulkamaniacs were the real dream team however, Hulk Hogan teaming up with Jake Roberts and Demolition to vanquish The Million Dollar Team (Ted DiBiase, Zeus and The Powers of Pain). You also had the 4x4s, Roddy's Rowdies, The Rude Brood, and so many more. WWE really needs to go back to naming their Survivor Series teams.

Advertisement

From top to bottom this was a stacked card full of legends and heroes. It is difficult to criticise.

6. 1991

WWE

The 1991 Survivor Series runs along similar lines, albeit without the fantastic team names. The opening match of this show is particularly fun, as Ric Flair teams with Ted DiBiase, The Warlord, and The Mountie to take on Roddy Piper, Bret Hart, The British Bulldog, and Virgil. If ever there was a wider margin between the good and the bad in a match, I'd love to see it.

Advertisement

The Undertaker won his first WWF Championship during the event, defeating Hulk Hogan thanks to Ric Flair and a chair. That damn Jack Tunney later intervened and set up This Tuesday In Texas, which in turn led to the vacating of the WWF Championship and the frankly glorious 1992 Royal Rumble.

The Rockers also continued their split on this show, Marty Jannetty inadvertently causing Shawn Michaels to be eliminated in their match. One year later, Shawn Michaels would be competing in the first ever singles main event in Survivor Series history.

Advertisement

5. 2007

WWE.com

A fabulously consistent card from top to bottom was headlined by one of the last great Hell in a Cell matches in WWE, between Batista and The Undertaker. The Animal walked out the winner and World Heavyweight Champion, thanks to the interference of Edge. It wasn't the way anyone wanted the match to end, but the quality was so high that nobody complained.

Elsewhere Jeff Hardy and Umaga put in notable performances in Team Triple H's victory over Team Umaga, and Randy Orton defended the WWE Championship in an excellent match with Shawn Michaels in which the Sweet Chin Music was banned.

Advertisement

The Great Khali defeated Hornswoggle in a match that most fans have erased from their memories, and CM Punk overcame the soon-to-team Miz and Morrison to defend the ECW Heavyweight Championship.

4. 1988

WWE.com

The second Survivor Series is an immensely fun show to go back and watch, and a lot of credit for this must fall at the feet of the 20 men involved in the 'let's put the entire tag division in one match' elimination bout. That match goes 42 minutes and is actually 42 minutes of wonderfully put together wrestling, impressive when you consider there was a confusing double turn and notable donkeys such as The Warlord, Boris Zhukov, and Jim Powers involved.

Advertisement

The main event saw further seeds sown in the Hulk Hogan/Randy Savage rivalry, as the two overcame four men to win the right to celebrate with Elizabeth at the end of the show.

The Ultimate Warrior announced his arrival on the big stage too, ending up as the sole survivor in the opening match of the show.

Advertisement

3. 2001

WWE.com

Talking about how WWE fluffed up the Invasion storyline makes all references to flogging dead horses redundant, but the event that ended it all still stands up as a great show to this day. The main event match, ostensibly for control of 'it all' but in reality a match full of WWF superstars (plus Booker T and RVD), met expectations and then some.

It was star power that was the seller here, and whilst the outcome was never in doubt if you throw Steve Austin, The Rock, The Undertaker, Kurt Angle, Chris Jericho, Kane and the rest into a main event match you are guaranteed a damn good time.

Advertisement

The Dudley Boyz and the Hardy Boyz continued their rivalry too, this time inside a steel cage. Test won an immunity battle royal that contained such, erm, legends as Shawn Stasiak, Justin Credible, and Hugh Morrus, while Trish Stratus won a six-pack-challenge to become WWF Women's Champion for the very first time.

2. 1996

WWE.com

The night of a thousand debuts. Well, the night of four debuts to be exact. Doug Furnas and Phil LaFon were the first newcomers, surviving an elimination match that saw them team with The Godwinns to go up against Owen Hart, The British Bulldog, and The New Rockers. Furnas and LaFon were a breath of fresh air in the tag division at the time, and the fact that their WWF run came to nothing will always rankle somewhat.

Advertisement

Some guy called Rocky Maivia also made his debut, overcoming Goldust and Crush at the last to be his team's sole survivor. He would go on to do some other stuff and be in movies, but nothing of any real note... Flash Funk also made his debut, his elimination match ending in a no contest when all the wrestlers wouldn't stop wrestling.

Bret Hart and Steve Austin had a #1 Contender match that was every bit as good as their WrestleMania 13 match, albeit minus the era-defining double turn. The Undertaker continued having 1996's most cartoonish feud with Mankind, defeating Foley whilst Paul Bearer was suspended above the ring in a cafe.

Advertisement

The main event saw Sycho Sid defeat Shawn Michaels for the WWF Championship after lightly pressing a camera into the chest of Shawn's elderly manager and mentor Jose Lothario, a memorable result played out in front of a famously hostile audience who cheered heel Sid's every move.

1. 2002

WWE.com

The last six months of 2002 are so very, very overlooked when fans discuss the great eras in WWE. The 2002 SummerSlam is up there as one of the best shows of all time, and the 2002 Survivor Series may well be the finest. It saw the debut of the Elimination Chamber, a monumental enough occasion topped only by Shawn Michaels improbably climbing to the top of the mountain once more to win the thing and the World Championship.

Advertisement

The SmackDown Six took part in a triple threat for the WWE Tag Team Championships, Los Guerreros surviving against the teams of Edge & Rey Mysterio and Kurt Angle & Chris Benoit. Billy Kidman defeated Jamie Noble in a fun match for the Cruiserweight Championship, and Paul Heyman shockingly turned on Brock Lesnar to side with Big Show and hand his new charge the WWE Championship.

In 2002 the WWE roster was stacked, and this show saw all of that talent put to great use. The new year promised much, with new acquisitions gaining steam and the company creating competition within itself to make up for the lack of WCW. It wouldn't last, but 2002 still stands tall as the finest Survivor Series in history.

Advertisement

Will 2016 top it?