Face Vs Heel: Bret 'The Hitman' Hart
The Best There Is, The Best There Was, The Best There Ever Will Be, and The Best Of Both Worlds?
The benefit of doing a piece like this on a career that's already concluded is how definitive it all feels.
Attempting to cover, say, Roman Reigns right now would be just about impossible. A product of the schizophrenic contemporary WWE system, 'The Big Dog' is so difficult to assess by the old pillars of good guys and bad guys that the company still struggled to make it clear which way the wind was blowing when he returned in 2020.
Only after siding with Paul Heyman, and turning up late for his own title match, and winning in a cowardly fashion did Reigns remotely resonate as a wrong'un. And only in WWE would a guy just over 12 months on from an announcement about his cancer being in remission even be one.
How does this relate to Bret Hart? Because he was the best, of course.
'The Hitman' was the best to such a degree that he'd perfected what it meant to be a pro wrestler in an industry that had narrative rules and structures. It's one of several heartbreaking reasons why things didn't work out in WCW. Hart's character, working ability and real life integrity wasn't built for the chaos of then nor WWE's now.
That's the long way of setting out a caveat that this will focus on his WWE singles run, but the distinction felt important. Your writer isn't one to doubt El Dandy, but trying to factor in his Atlanta actions would have been as painful as spearing a steel plate.
10. Attire
Face:
As the hero he always relished the opportunity to be, 'The Hitman' turned '80s baiting into '90s cool. Wearing pink was seen as a villainous trait when The Hart Foundation donned the colours, but the vibrant shades bursting forth from the black helped Hart find his own take on the neon of the early-1990s and New Generation.
Never once was the scheme greeted with a sneer, or even the idea that he was choosing the traditional base coat of a baby girl's wardrobe. It never came up because it couldn't - anybody daring to bring it up were wrapped in knots for opening their stupid mouth.
Heel:
With an eye on every detail, Bret switched almost exclusively to his all-black ensemble when he turned heel in 1997. Always believing himself to be a favourite of the cowboys from knowing his Calgary audience well, he'd treat his tights like a ten-gallon hat.
Notes of pink were evident, but if you ever liked those glorious splashes of colours, it was Hart's job to take that exact emotion away. Skulls became more prominent too. What once just added to the iconography became more pronounced in line with his own festering rage.
Winner: Face
9. Entrance
Face:
Understated compared to some of his contemporaries and uniquely defiant as a result, Bret Hart's arrival came with the sort of rock solid security his in-ring work provided.
With apologies to Jim Ross and Becky Lynch, business picked up when 'The Hitman' came around. Slapping as many fives as his arms would allow, he strode with confidence thanks to the scintillating shredding in his theme from WWE music guru Jim Johnston. Capturing the balance between Superstar and Superhero, giving away the glasses at the end brought the whole thing wonderfully full circle.
The crowds and buyrates weren't as big, but Hart at least looked like a money performer.
Heel:
Pissed off being pissed on by the American wrestling public, 'The Excellence Of Execution' showed off his surly side during his heel entrances.
Partial to the odd bird-flipping battle with the ringsiders, he held everybody in such quiet contempt that it provided a perfect contrast to the theme that had once generated the biggest pop of the night. Unless he was in Canada, when it still did. Bigger than ever in fact - Hart was every action hero and sports star wrapped in one. Vince McMahon's never been able to "make movies" despite his water-chewing assertions in Beyond The Mat, but that Bret would have made an amazing lead.
Winner: Heel
8. Crowd Interaction
Face:
Bret Hart giving his glasses away to ringside children was first a gloriously wholesome grab for support when he was still finding his feet. It later became an incredibly rich moment of magic that symbolically reflected the bond between ‘The Hitman’ and his fans.
As tight as the neoprene band connecting his shimmering specs together, Hart forged a different kind of trust than those that had come before him. The shades were more than just a cool freebie - he didn't cup his ear to ask for audience support after a match, but gave away a part of himself before the bell to show respect for what he knew was a privilege.
Heel:
More on this a little later, but Hart found his voice like never before when he managed to tweak a few genuine creative worries into a fully fledged civil war in 1997. Eyes that once so magnificently told the earnest story of struggle suddenly lit inferno red with every stomp he laid in on your new favourite wrestler.
The bond was still tight, but 'The Hitman' was so good at his craft that it felt like you were the one being excellently executed through the suffering of all your heroes.
Winner: Face
7. Range
Face:
Was anyone in this category ever better?
If that reads rhetorical, it's not. Because here's the f*cking answer - no, they weren’t. Hart’s babyface style was to treat wrestling as the sport we were asked to believe it was, and be the most perfectly well-rounded sportsman. If you were an athlete, he had to physically better you. Brawlers and bruisers were out-thought then outfought. Oak trees were cut down. Family members using and abusing emotional connections had their fragility exposed. The job was to be 'The Best There Is, The Best There Was & The Best There Ever Will Be', and Hart very literally never missed a shift.
Heel:
It broke Bret's heart to turn on his fans in 1997, but you wouldn't know it to watch him. His post-WrestleMania 13 promo is an exercise in catharsis for the man that genuinely doesn't believe he's changed, but the biliousness in his verbiage foreshadowed how he'd expertly adjust his working style.
As a villain, Hart didn't just exhibit his abilities. He punished "all the American wrestling fans" and their favourite "hyenas" with them. He changed nothing, and everything. He just didn't get to do it for quite as long.
Winner: Face
6. Drawing Power
Face:
Somebody had to follow Hulk Hogan as the company's top draw, and when The Ultimate Warrior failed, somebody had to follow him again.
Bret Hart was that man, but a business in domestic decline depressingly wasn’t addressed by excellent execution alone. The genius of 'The Hitman' was doing with his in-ring skill what WWE have done as business strategy for the last decade or so. In 2020, toy Fiend belts are priced in the four figure range to tip the last remaining hardcore fans upside down for loose change. At WWE's 1990s financial nadir, a company led by Bret Hart squeezed every ticket sale out of producing the best matches in the organisation's history. Quality isn't always reflected by quantity, reducing Hart and career rival Shawn Michaels to the hair-ruffling rung below when Mount Rushmore conversations take hold.
Heel:
WWE never won a Monday Night ratings battle with Bret Hart on Raw in 1997, but it could be argued they won just about every one of them in 1998 for the foundations he'd laid.
The thrilling landscape in Hart's last year was cultivated almost entirely by his making of Steve Austin in their iconic and enduring programme. A style that once only barely kept the ship afloat suddenly steadied it entirely. The tragic irony remains that Vince McMahon ultimately deemed him one of the few remaining holes in the boat.
Winner: Heel
5. Feuds
Face:
Every Bret Hart programme was rich due to his involvement in it, but the heights he reached with rivals during his Intercontinental and WWE Championship stints had those belts mattering more than ever before.
Being a "fighting champion" made him a great target for heels, and got them more over as a result. Shawn Michaels, Razor Ramon, Davey Boy Smith and others took runs at him and were made men after the fact. His legendary feud with sibling Owen really exploded in their failed bid to win tag gold. WrestleMania X's booking of his loss to his younger brother in the opener and glorious WWE Championship win in the headliner stands up as tall as the ladder match also on that card as another reason to reappraise WWE's leanest years.
Away from the gold, his years-long beef with Jerry Lawler consistently reheated the cartoonish 'King' as the biggest b*stard ever born, and he got impossibly good stuff from a 1995 spent working with a psychopathic presidential candidate, a ninja, a dentist and a pirate.
Heel:
Small but perfectly formed, Hart's entire heel stint in 1997 was triggered by his feud with Stone Cold Steve Austin. In terms of match and angle quality and longterm significance, it could be objectively and subjectively argued as the best in company history.
His feud with Shawn Michaels could never deliver a fake fight as good as the real hatred, but The Hart Foundation's war on The Undertaker, The Patriot or absolutely anyone that espoused American values saw him sink his teeth into television mini-series with Rocky Maivia and Vader that were as worthy as his pay-per-view programmes.
Winner: Face
4. Promos
Face:
Bret Hart's wonky way with words is overstated by his critics and adored by his fans.
He rendered participles and clauses as twisted as left and right legs trapped in a Sharpshooter, and made legendarily confusing use of "the" when you'd least expect it. But he was a pro wrestler outlining how he'd win a match - in canon, this bit wasn't what he was there to do.
If that reads as generous, it's perhaps because your writer was too young to catch a load of slightly awkward micro-flubs in the early-'90s. He was believable, even if some of those organic stumbles would be pounced upon as a botch in the modern age.
Heel:
Bret Hart completed wrestling in 1997.
Already peerless between the ropes, he'd main evented WrestleManias, helped draw at least one huge crowd for a SummerSlam in 1992, and secured the first of two huge contracts in 12 months. He only had talking left to tick off, and all of the wobbles as a face were erased with a slew of amazing speeches that shifted the tectonic plates moving beneath the business.
Refining himself as a whiner to foreshadow the turn, he deflected all his rage on the American audience only when he formally made the switch. This gave him weekly ammo against Your Town He Now Hates as well as a newly-acquired glint his eye working babyface when back in Canada.
There's no WrestleMania 13 match without his microphone skills in the weeks and months prior, and there's probably no Attitude Era without the WrestleMania 13 match, sooooo.
Winner: Heel
3. Moments
Face:
The highs and lows of Bret Hart's WWE career were the subjects of two very different in-house DVD projects in the mid-2000s, but thank f*ck that stupid Montreal-obsessed hit piece never saw the light of day.
The Survivor Series screwjob resonated because Vince McMahon put a bullet in your best mate, not a dead horse. He should know - he promoted that kinship with expert touch.
Hart's first three title wins in 1992, 1994 & 1995 were evocative shows of faith, apology and contrition respectively. His kayfabe peaks were epic in scale, his troughs as long and difficult to escape from as they looked. It was appropriate that Jerry Lawler stomped about in horse-sh*t before their Kiss My Foot payoff in 1995 - Hart helped him become more irritating than that bit on the bottom of your shoe you can never scrape off.
Heel:
'The Hitman' changed the art of the heel turn in plain sight and nobody could see it until the most important match in company history had already happened.
Inspiring a new type of persona as the justified complainer following some unfair losses in late-1996 and early-1997, Hart allowed his misery to show itself in flashes. Shoving babyface announcer McMahon on his a*se six days before the brutal WrestleMania 13 war with Stone Cold Steve Austin was the last bit of wizardry before the industry-altering double turn.
Winner: Face
2. In-Ring Work
Face:
A polar opposite to Hulk Hogan in every measure (for better and worse), Bret Hart was an exquisite professional wrestler. The greatest of all time to those that had their love of the industry enhanced through his prime years, he's also a f*cking impossibly brilliant force of nature to those that catch up through the WWE Network or playlists curated by his ardent acolytes.
Hogan's superman comebacks made everybody more millions than Bret's intricate counters, slick reversals and hard-fought turnarounds, but never had the fights felt less like fiction. He is - and, hilariously, even he knows this - one of the easiest wrestlers to recommend. He reckons you can count on one finger the amount of duds he had in WWE, and as usual, he's right.
Heel:
This list has favoured his singles runs, but it'd be impossible to not mention the revered singles match he had with Tom Magee when he was still just the workhorse in the hated Hart Foundation.
Hart's work is too sublime to be boiled into a single tweet, gif or list entry, but the one above this one tries to make the point as well as any. The contest's recent discovery wasn't just a boon for the 'Hitman' superfans that had waited years to watch it. It was a carry-job starter kit for younger fans that might have heard about Vince McMahon's heart-eyes for the "next Hulk Hogan" only two years into his run. Selfless but sharp with it, Bret made everybody better while becoming the best.
Winner: Draw
1. Final Score
Face: 5
Heel: 3
Draw: 1
The verdict is in and it turns out Bret Hart was the best there is, best there was and the best there ever will be. But also, for the purposes of this particular study, his excellent execution as a babyface just betters his superlative late-career stint as a heel.
Time and tenure seemed to swing it, though it speaks to just how much he achieved in his final few months with WWE that "heel" could win one category, let alone three.
It's an odd quirk of Hart's career that he's most revered for the influence he had when fewer people got to see it. Audiences were returning thanks to a product he was a driving force of in 1997, but those same viewers weren't interested enough to stick around years prior when he was shaping younger wrestling minds with his inimitable style.
Those who love 'The Hitman' love him loyally and dearly, and it may be in an effort to redress the historical imbalance in favour of others closer to the WWE bubble that this has become prevalent since the launch of the WWE Network.
The company can remove loads of his matches from the service, but the ones that remain are the finest way to spend your time on that app. He was mocked for being so obsessed with legacy, but that care for his career proved prescient decades after his peak. He knew its value as much as he knew his own worth - 'The Excellence Of Execution' is more "Then, Now, Forever" than most of the wrestlers in that in-house intro video.