Fighting With My Family Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs
A simple but effective wrestling biopic.
The biopic of WWE's Paige, Fighting with My Family, hit U.S. cinemas this past week ahead of its U.K. bow on February 27th, and despite some reasonable fan scepticism surrounding the project, it's actually turned out surprisingly well.
Since its late-January premiere at the Sundance Film Festival, the film has been scoring consistently positive reviews from critics, currently rocking a 90%+ Rotten Tomatoes score, surely far in excess of what most fans were expecting.
Is Fighting with My Family a great film? No, but does it provide a satisfying whistle-stop tour of Paige's humble origins and eventual signing to WWE? Absolutely.
With The Rock's backing behind it - both as a producer and in cameo form - it's an easy charmer that delivers a spin on the typical underdog story that's just weird enough to feel fitting for the bizarro world of professional wrestling.
Whether you're a WWE fan or just appreciate an easy-to-root-for hero, there's plenty here to enjoy. But first, here's what didn't quite work...
Downs...
3. There's An Unfortunate Sex Tape Joke
If you're at all familiar with Paige, you'll be aware that a sex tape featuring her and other wrestlers was leaked in March 2017, which caused her to have suicidal thoughts and be hospitalised with stress-induced anorexia.
Unfortunately, Fighting with my Family was filmed literally weeks before the leak happened, and features a scene which coincidentally includes references to a sex tape.
When Dwayne Johnson is hanging out with Paige (Florence Pugh) at WrestleMania 30, he tells her that he refers to her NXT trainer Hutch Morgan (Vince Vaughn) as "sex tape", because Hutch took an insane bump back in the day which allowed The Rock to get over with the crowd. The joke here being that a sex tape makes you famous, and so Hutch = sex tape.
With The Rock's busy schedule there probably wasn't time to re-shoot the scene without the ill-timed joke, but considering that it appears at the very end of the scene, it could've been edited out of the movie pretty easily.
Why it was included despite the awkward memories it invokes for all involved is so peculiar, especially as it wasn't an integral part of the plot nor in the middle of a vital line of expository dialogue. Yikes.
2. The Paige/AJ Match Is Poorly Recreated
The movie of course ends with Paige's 2014 Raw debut, where she interrupts AJ Lee (played here quite amusingly by WWE superstar Zelina Vega), but the dramatisation will prove pretty uninspired to anyone who remembers the match.
For starters, the film completely glosses over Paige's NXT Women's Title reign, either for pacing reasons or to heighten the drama of her Raw debut.
Moreover, Zelina Vega is dressed in a red PVC costume which is decidedly less modest than the clothing AJ actually wore during the match, while Pugh-as-Paige is conversely dressed far more modestly than she was in reality.
These might seem like nitpicks, but they're pretty basic immersion-breakers considering how easy it should be to get the costumes right.
Furthermore, the movie version of the segment has Paige freeze up nervously - something which didn't happen - and considering that the movie match was filmed after a real live show, the crowd looks mostly burned out and bored.
As a result, crowd reaction shots are spliced in to make it look more exciting, but the editing is sloppy and makes the whole thing look a bit awkward.
Also, though the real match lasted barely a minute - and, honestly, wasn't very good - it's elongated here for dramatic purposes. Not the worst thing in the world, but showing her mugging for the camera with her NXT pals post-victory is undeniably a bit jarring.
1. Paige's Retirement Is Completely Ignored
Fighting with My Family is an underdog tale about Paige's ascent to WWE stardom, but it is a touch odd that the end of the movie completely ignores the fact that an in-ring injury forced her to retire in April 2018.
Instead, a title card simply mentions that her work helped blaze the trail for the Women's Revolution...and that's basically it. To the non-fan watching the movie, they'd likely assume that Paige is still wrestling in WWE today, which obviously isn't the case.
And sure, a post-script detailing her injury would interfere with the crowd-pleasing tone, but it does seem pretty odd - if not outright manipulative of casual viewers - to elide such an important fact from her life story.
If you can accept these gripes, though, there's a lot to be entertained by. Here's everything Fighting with My Family gets right...
Ups...
7. Florence Pugh's Terrific Performance As Paige
Florence Pugh is a fantastic actress who lights up pretty much anything she stars in, and she quite aptly elevates this production significantly with her thoroughly convincing performance as the WWE superstar.
Though Pugh's stab at Paige's accent isn't totally accurate - she often sounds a little too West Country - she nevertheless embodies her mannerisms, her personality and her general physicality extremely well.
Casting a lesser-known actress was certainly a smart move here, as there's no barrier of distraction for audiences to vault over where they're constantly recognising the star beneath the makeup and wrestling gear.
Pugh effortlessly slides into the character and does a remarkable job teasing our her humanity, her drive and her passion for the industry.
6. The Rock's Cameo Is HILARIOUS
Aside from that cringe-worthy sex tape gaffe, The Rock's presence in this movie is a whole lotta fun.
He only appears in three small scenes for barely five minutes in total, but he brings his usual high-energy and boundless charisma to the screen for all of those minutes, absolutely making the most of them.
Now, some might argue that Dwayne Johnson is interjecting himself into a story that isn't at all about him, but his fateful WrestleMania meeting with Paige is at least rooted somewhat in truth, and more to the point, his involvement helps broaden the story to a much wider audience.
The trailers absolutely over-emphasise how large his role in the film is, but anything more than a quick cameo would've risked stealing the thunder away from the real star of the show.
Miraculously it doesn't feel like a vanity role for Johnson, but a performance coming from a deep place of respect and admiration for Paige.
And without spoiling it, there are also cameos from a few current WWE superstars in the bargain, but to ruin them would be nothing short of criminal.
5. It's Surprisingly Honest
If the marketing suggested that Fighting with My Family would be a fairly sanitised look at both the world of professional wrestling and also Paige's family life itself, the end result is a good deal more upfront than you might expect.
For starters, Paige's parents - played with gusto by Nick Frost and Lena Headey - are depicted as the wild, uncouth carnies that they're well-known to be in real life, with the film refusing to shy away from her father's criminal past and their general shadiness.
Furthermore, few would've been surprised if Vince McMahon mandated that the Divas Title be retroactively renamed to the Women's Title - as it's now known - but in a rare moment of restraint from the WWE, they actually keep to its dated, arguably sexist 2014 nomenclature.
The film also doesn't present a particularly romanticised view of being a professional wrestler, emphasising the difficulty of "making it" in the industry, as envisioned by the genuinely affecting tragedy of Paige's brother Zak (Jack Lowden) having to come to terms with the fact he'll never get to the grandest stage of them all.
A lot of the credit here can go to writer-director Stephen Merchant, whose previous work has shown him a dab hand at heartfelt humanism, which this film is certainly overflowing with.
4. The Strong Supporting Cast
Aiding Florence Pugh's fine effort is a distinguished cast far more talented than most would surely ever expect to appear in a movie based on the life of a WWE superstar.
In addition to Johnson's aforementioned portrayal, Jack Lowden is quite terrific as her brother Zak, selling the heartbreak of his humdrum life back in Norwich while Paige is busy getting to work in Florida.
Nick Frost and Lena Headey are also great fun as Paige's parents, diving fully into their roles and gamely selling their vulgarity with an unexpected enthusiasm.
The big surprise here, however, is Vince Vaughn, who as trainer Dutch gives one of his best performances of the last few years.
More than a mere hard-a** trainer, he brings a surprising amount of pathos to the film, especially during a sequence where he flatly tells Paige to hang it up and go home.
Few could've expected that Vince Vaughn's acting and Stephen Merchant's writing would be a snug fit, but alas, it's always fun to be surprised.
3. It's Entertaining For Fans & Newbies Alike
It's a difficult balance to strike, especially with something as insular as the zany world of wrestling, but this film should appeal well to both voracious fans of the sport and those who know nothing about it.
For fans, it's a fun breeze past the formative moments in Paige's early career with a ton of cute nods to the industry, but for the uninitiated, it spoon-feeds just enough information about the business while succeeding largely thanks to its winning charm.
It strikes an extremely delicate balance of broadening Paige's story into something a little more cinematic and simple, but not so much that it'll alienate the hardcore wrestling crowd.
It's not gritty or trying to be ultra-faithful, but where it counts, it gets the feeling right.
2. Stephen Merchant's "Rock" Solid Direction
Stephen Merchant is an incredibly odd choice to direct a film like this, and yet, in retrospect it's clear to see why he was hand-picked by The Rock himself.
Fighting with My Family is both a weirdo comedy and a homegrown underdog tale, both things Merchant has proven himself extremely well-versed in over the years.
Despite having little previous fandom of wrestling, he directs the film with a surprising visual gusto, juxtaposing the grey, washed-out dullness of Norwich with the sun-kissed beaches of Florida and also the flashy glitz of the WWE.
Merchant employs a few neat match-cuts between wrestling sequences, demonstrating a stylistic flair you wouldn't typically associate him with, elevating the visuals beyond their initial whiff of a TV movie. Not bad at all, Steve.
1. It's A Feel-Good Crowd Pleaser
If the trailers suggested that this film was going to overdose on the cheese and serve as a doting hagiography for Paige, it's actually not that.
It hits a lot of the familiar underdog tropes, yes, but it also doesn't layer on the sentiment too thickly, while leaning into the sheer strangeness of the wrestling industry.
And again, it keenly acknowledges the cutthroat nature of the wrestling industry through the storyline involving her brother, which dares to be achingly sad in a film that could've easily just cleaned up all the drama and planed the edges away.
But it manages to confess the tough mettle required to be a WWE superstar while delivering appropriately broad heart and humour.
It'll leave you smiling and likely having a little greater appreciation for how tough it is to make it in the wrasslin' business.
Excited for Fighting with My Family? Seen it already? If so, what did you think? Shout it out in the comments!