How AEW Did The Impossible
All hail!
The inaugural AEW Double Or Nothing was excellent, acclaimed, special. It was the grand return of big-time professional wrestling in virtually all of its forms, and the debut of new styles aimed to electrify an old, lapsed audience: the charming viciousness of joshi; the claret-drenched emotional war; the return, with the longest match on the card, of main-event level tag team wrestling; and, with a stellar headliner highlighted by an industry-shaking "jump", a sense of exhilaration not felt in almost 20 years.
A vital, inimitable pro wrestling feeling had returned from its knees, powered by the fans in a protest that had echoed through decades, to land a stiff forearm in the cheekbone of sports entertainment. Double Or Nothing was the start of something.
Except that weird part where a mysterious band of geeks attacked Best Friends following their win over Jack Evans and Angélico.
After a fine midcard tag team showcase, the lights went out. A roar emerged through the darkness because at a pro wrestling show, when the lights go out, you are at the very least going to recognise the person revealed. In the best case scenario, at a time when his name was projected across all things pro wrestling, you were going to see the fabled return of CM Punk.
Instead, you saw the repackaged Super Smash Bros, years removed from their awesome but incredibly niche Pro Wrestling Guerrilla pomp, joined by a group of borderline problematic "creepers".
CONT'D...(1 of 6)
The hottest pro wrestling crowd in an age reacted more silently than the empty seats at the first WWE Performance Center show. A flat dud of a debut, it felt like a bizarre and thoroughly unwanted sports entertainment glitch.
Flashes of that exhilarating act resurfaced at Fight For The Fallen in a good if overlong three-way match won by Evil Uno and Stu Grayson over Jurassic Express and Jack Evans and Angélico. Virtually every take was identical: the work is good, but the presentation is generic spooky bullsh*t at odds with the promised alternative sporting presentation. Those creepers looked worse than anything sports entertainment had spewed forth, too. Not remotely scary - as if that was even viable in this context or indeed any modern wrestling context - they looked like they were wearing sweatpants and masks imported from the über-grim leisure centre era of 1990s British pro wrestling.
The act, and this is the real indictment, failed to spark those early, rapturous Dynamite crowds. Ranging from molten to remarkably polite, by wrestling fan standards, they had no interest at all in the Dark Order's only-good output. The dissonance was too much: Grayson in particular generated pops with an arsenal precision-engineered to electrify, but he was a heel working a...well, it was hard to tell which gimmick. The very name of the act suggested a supernatural element, but, mercifully, they didn't possess any powers beyond a strange segment in which they controlled the mind of Alex Reynolds through a TV set in a hotel room. If this was in fact more of a mind control deal - and again, that was sh*t fans wanted to remain in Stamford - it wasn't effective. The Dark Order were a mildly successful midcard act per a sports-adjacent win/loss rankings system that made such a gimmick feel untenable in the first instance.
The very name of the stable was also a plot hole, one that the soft reboot didn't mask.
CONT'D...(2 of 6)
A series of vignettes that ran in November sought to explain what the Dark Order were, and what they were was a cult inspired by Scientology. This development showed mild promise, in that it tethered the act to something resembling a viable reality: the creepers, as it turned out, were incel figures rejected by society drawn to the Dark Order to improve their lives. But AEW said the quiet part loud and the loud part quiet: 'Dark Order' was something of a giveaway that one's life wasn't set for improvement.
There was always something to the act on the drawing board. The brainchild of the Young Bucks, who had worked the Super Smash Bros all over the indies to immense acclaim, this wasn't some half-baked idea. The Bucks, as shown on Being The Elite, are very meticulous and intelligent storytellers. The bare premise was thus: a heel stable were to prey on the losers in the wins and losses matter promotion (Michael Nakazawa and Brandon Cutler, originally), and recruit them in order to bolster the ranks and gain "strength in numbers". What appeared to be dated, naff b*llocks actually fit holistically into AEW's narrative framework. The concept was sound, the execution abysmal: they looked like sh*t, and Grayson and Evil Uno barely won to put themselves over as leaders worthy of belief.
The events of December 18 were so awful that they compelled Dave Meltzer to compare the show-closing angle to the very worst of WCW. Following a tremendous sprint between the Bucks and SCU, the Dark Order initiated John Silver and Alex Reynolds, and in an apparent show of force, Uno drew Day-Glo blood from the throat of Matt Jackson. It was a hokey, amateurish and wildly damaging scene: the creepers infamously punched the air, in a helpful visual aid of how far this missed, and Kenny Omega, the best wrestler of his generation and the unprecedented non-WWE draw that made all of this viable, was handily beaten down by some anonymous goobers.
In a scene drenched in as much irony as the debut was in darkness and silence, Evil Uno proclaimed that we'd "never doubt" the Dark Order again.
CONT'D...(3 of 6)
AEW persisted with the faction, and reimagined it as part of Tony Khan's period of introspection over the Christmas break. The originally planned leader, Marty Scurll, opted to re-sign with Ring Of Honor, necessitating a rethink. AEW teased the arrival of an 'Exalted One' in January, and subsequently embarked on an inspired viral marketing campaign assisted by Evil Uno in glorious, mischievous form.
This was really, really well done, in that the red herrings were plentiful and balanced perfectly. ECW legend Raven, himself a societal outcast character, appeared in the Dynamite crowd. AEW penned acrostic poems on social media spelling out the name 'Matt Hardy'. Text was hidden within text on social media. "Sitting in a dead tree," read one such post. Collaborating simultaneously, Matt Hardy released an entry in his YouTube series sat on a wooden throne. This was also a line in the nursery rhyme 'Three Chartreuse Buzzards' - a very subtle hint towards Brodie Lee.
And Brodie Lee it was, as revealed on the March 18 Dynamite. Wild as it is now, given the shocking success that the stable has become, this felt snake-bit at the time. That episode was meant to emanate from Brodie's hometown of Rochester, New York, to all but guarantee the monster pop. That pop did not materialise in the empty Daily's Place AEW had to resort to amid the ongoing global situation.
"You're not the first out of touch old man to not believe in me," Lee said to Christopher Daniels, in what was either an inspired line or, even better, an inspired storyline to arrive at it. On the following episode, to much controversy, the now 'Mr. Brodie Lee' sent up Vince McMahon by becoming a steak-eating corporate bully pitching a conniption fit at the sneezing of a subordinate. This was funny, cathartic, and looking at it generously, what happens to people when they crave power: they wield it by insidiously becoming the establishment.
CONT'D...(4 of 6)
But it got old, and the initial presentation of the Mr. Brodie Lee character suffered in contrast to Lance Archer, who debuted just weeks prior and got over big as an awesome revelation of a monster. Still, Lee entered a tremendous performance in a bomb blast opposite Jon Moxley at Double Or Nothing. In one of the best finishes in modern wrestling history, he emerged from the wreckage of the stage, catatonic, as if unable to be killed - only, temporarily, put down. In the aftermath, the Lee character attempted to recruit Colt Cabana, initiating a choice storyline that nailed the elusive emotion of the "recruitment" bit. Nobody wants to see the amiable, luckless veteran fall into the clutches of the cult.
The Dark Order stands now as a dominant - and incredibly entertaining - force. The act was tweaked and perfected, on the expressive BTE platform, when they grasped how exactly to riff on Vince. The latent menace was accurate, but not really effective: Mr. Brodie Lee blowing Vince's trademark, massive gaskets is much funnier and far more terrifying. Every week, the Dark Order stole and made relevant once more a show that had dwindled in quality following AEW's launch by gradually nailing the stable's new dynamic also.
In deft parallel, Tony Khan booked the Dark Order underlings in several Dynamite mini-bangers, establishing them as a worker's collective - crucial in getting over on a show with such high in-ring standards - just before the outrageous flex of 'Saturday Night Dynamite'.
CONT'D...(5 of 6)
It is impossible to take one's eyes off Brodie Lee. Even before he obliterated Cody in a phenomenal and ballsy squash, a grinning subversion of December 18, he was superb in six and eight-man tags. Exercising his immense power with sumptuous in-ring character work, he reordered the matches to his liking, allowing Cabana to take pins and summoning Hangman Page into his maw. His monster is as cerebral as it is brutal.
In a masterstroke of the sort WWE never really committed to with Bray Wyatt, Mr. Brodie Lee now wields tangible and credible power in the form of the prestigious TNT Championship.
There is enormous - boundless - narrative potential within this impossible success that is the new Dark Order. Lee is the autocrat monster, his minions hilarious, feckless geeks made sympathetic by his awfulness. Evil Uno and Grayson were always miscast. Uno is a delight of a person - his naivety on BTE is so great - and Grayson is an explosion of an athlete. One day, this dynamic will lead to the face turn that will reveal the real brilliance of their team. The inevitable Colt Cabana Vs. Mr. Brodie Lee match feels big and earned, by the standards of the midcard. But Mr. Brodie Lee Vs. John Silver is the one. A running gag on Being The Elite, Silver's irrepressible and massively endearing enthusiasm is the source of much fury to Brodie. It's a winning dynamic - how a "Shut the f*ck up, Silver" design isn't on ProWrestlingTees is a mystery - and it was adapted, tantalisingly, during the Dark Order's victory celebration on August 27. This is without considering the Cody rematch, nor the TNT Title defences to come.
On Saturday Night Dynamite, Mr. Brodie Lee didn't tell anybody that they'd never doubt the Dark Oder again.
This time, he didn't have to.