How AEW Saved (And RUINED) Wrestling
All Elite Wrestling: the cause of and solution to so many wrestling problems.
All Elite Wrestling is ultimately a force for good in the pro wrestling industry.
AEW's brilliance - the brilliance that it somehow conspires to capture most weeks in at least one segment of Dynamite - has been normalised. Perspective is needed as a result. To underscore just how important AEW is to the North American scene, the dark ages must be illuminated once more.
In 2018, WWE was so oppressively bad and flat that the McMahon family had to apologise for how bad it was by the end of the year, and in that exact same segment, his pathetic ego wounded by a smattering of boos, Vince McMahon put the red pen through his own apology. If there was ever a show that didn't need a last-minute rewrite, it was the one that promised a new and more focused direction, for f*ck's sake.
The idea was for Vince to show contrition. He couldn't even do that. At the merest hint of a "What?" chant, Vince, after saying "I can't do this all by myself anymore, that's for sure" turned to the crowd. His back was up. "I can do it without you guys, though," he said.
He put himself and Raw over in the same promo, of course. Stephanie McMahon had to be the one to say "We haven't been doing a very good job for you guys lately," even though she had no influence over the direction of the company. The man who tasked himself with change changed his mind in a matter of seconds. He had a little tantrum and proved himself an inveterate liar and narcissist.
And of course, WWE didn't change. 2019 was even worse than 2018. Vince McMahon didn't so much insult your intelligence as book shows under the belief that you literally didn't have a brain capable of functioning memory. The same old sh*t reeked with a stale odour; it wasn't even pungent anymore, just foul in a distant but permanent way that couldn't be shaken.
AEW Dynamite launched on October 2, 2019.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
Writing now, in March 2023, it has - subjectively - evolved into the best wrestling TV show ever. The match quality and range are out-of-this-world phenomenal. If you somehow weren't blown away by Kenny Omega Vs. El Hijo del Vikingo's physically impossible head drop festival, you must have loved Bryan Danielson and Bandido's tactical chess game. The promos are expressive, organic, outstanding. If personal issues draw money, a lot of people paid to watch CM Punk get his bloody revenge over MJF. If you prefer a more intricate, overlapping saga, the most recent chapter of the Elite "saga" is packed with mystery. Where does Konosuke Takeshita fit into it? Who's plotting against whom? Who's in on whatever Don Callis is scheming to do?
At its best, AEW isn't merely everything a disillusioned millennial fanbase asked for: it is a masterpiece factory. That should be an oxymoron. It isn't.
At Revolution 2023, yet another stellar, near-perfect four hours of pro wrestling that peaked to seminal tier, Excalibur put his promotion over as the destination of professional wrestling. It wasn't the first time AEW designated itself this way.
But is there a sense of... entitlement at play here?
Tony Khan was and is a hardcore wrestling fan with eclectic tastes. In some ways, he's the perfect booker, even if he doesn't always get the story right (and sometimes takes far too long when he does). He isn't Vince McMahon, who would only push a body guy if he could help it. He isn't Bill Watts, who valued toughness above all else. He isn't Antonio Inoki, who revered and demanded immaculate technique. He isn't Gabe Sapolsky, who at times was allergic to fun. He isn't Triple H, whose basics-first approach can often scan as very dry.
Khan is not doing what does to spitefully control pro wrestling with his own self-indulgent perception of it, but he is... hogging wrestling, if that makes any sense. AEW's USP is that it is a hub world for all of the industry.
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
By designating itself in such a way - and refining so many different philosophies to best-in-class level - AEW has robbed the wider wrestling world of so much. And it's not as if Khan is acting with malice, just to be clear. It's an unintentional byproduct. Mostly.
The wrestling world outside of the mainstream has never felt smaller nor more uninteresting. Khan's own Ring Of Honor secondary brand is great when it peaks, but it cannot operate in a way similar to Triple H's NXT of 2014-19 because it offers nothing that AEW doesn't already. This take will age horribly if Supercard of Honor is as good as the line-up suggests - the quality ceiling is an all-time great pay-per-view - but the television while good isn't terribly exciting or state-of-the-art or new or fascinating in any way.
Impact Wrestling offers high-end match quality, which sits uneasily alongside sports entertainment shenanigans. It's essentially WWE lite and doesn't make a blip. It's easy to believe in Joe Hendry, and Impact does a bang-up job of pleasing its base, but it's as niche as it has ever been. It is irrelevant, feels minuscule, and the days of something like the X division or even the 'Broken' universe are long dead. Impact is no alternative.
There is at least one fantastic match on the North American independent circuit every week. This is great, obviously, but in addition to being a problem unto itself - so much bleeds into itself at a constant rate with no cultural imprint - the "banger" match is now the preserve of AEW Dynamite. The indies no longer boast an identity. PWG made its major label debut four years ago.
The 2000s scene was incredible at its best. Something like the ROH Vs. CZW feud of 2006 is impossible now. It was scintillating back then; arguably the greatest inter-promotional rivalry ever, each side proudly embodied values that the other either despised or deemed snooty and pretentious. The 2000s catalysed a big bang of ideas. AEW has subsumed these ideas.
It's impossible for something as interesting and believable as the ROH Vs. CZW programme to happen now when AEW happily books Nick Gage and Timothy Thatcher on its programming.
This isn't necessarily a bad thing. In fact, it is tremendous. It was a disgrace that the stars of Ring Of Honor's prime years were ignored (Samoa Joe, the Briscoes), pushed reluctantly (CM Punk) or outright buried (Bryan Danielson) by WWE. The best minds of that generation were destroyed for too long by Vince McMahon's madness, cosmetic bias and arrogance. Some of the best wrestlers of all time waded through so much sh*t at the behest of people who hated wrestling in their physical primes. AEW embraces pro wrestlers as artists. The travesty of a lost generation has been resolved on the mainstream stage.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
And it's not as if Tony Khan is at fault for the indie scene's lack of new ideas. It's reductive to state that it's a fading hodgepodge of technical kick pad lads, irony and revolting edgelord garbage - and WrestleMania Weekend promises a lot of outstanding wrestling - but the days of the indie scene flourishing in defiance of established norms are all but over.
Conversely, there is an element of Khan operating with a certain impulsive greed, too. AEW fans have watched on as Daniel Garcia and Wheeler YUTA have experienced an awkward adolescence on television. Did Khan sign and push them too early - to the detriment of their progression and the independent scene? Were they ready, and did Khan really need them? Wouldn't it have been better - for the wider wrestling landscape and ultimately AEW - if both were allowed to develop their characters and create buzz before they joined AEW's bloated, rotating cast?
Both men are immensely gifted, but YUTA has been eaten alive on the microphone more than once, and Garcia, despite showing promise in the role of a TV-sized midcard heel, has faded under a sludge of near-constant f*ck finishes masquerading as "parody" with the Jericho Appreciation Society.
WWE smugly told CM Punk that he did not know how to work. The inverse of that now is that AEW would snap up CM Punk the second he showed promise, as an acerbic, loathsome stand-out capable of drawing earnest heat with his cult leader conviction, in IWA Mid-South. There's a good chance that Punk would have been flown in for a Dark: Elevation shot before he realised, when wrestling Eddie Guerrero, "boy do I suck". He didn't - as all great wrestlers do, he was being hard on himself - but he hadn't evolved into the next big superstar with his immortal Summer of Punk run.
The other end of the extreme has been reached.
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
Garcia and YUTA's increased profile on TV has also - indirectly - affected the growth of their contemporaries, many of whom have cooled off.
Within months of their breakthrough performances, the AEW audience was asked to receive Wheeler YUTA and HOOK as their new cult favourite. Neither has reached those heights since. There is too much good wrestling in All Elite Wrestling for that to have happened. A good monopoly is still fundamentally flawed and unfair, and that's where we are at with AEW.
And because AEW is the epicentre of interest and buzz and conversation, the hardcore fan experience online absolutely sucks. The promotion is the only entity worth the discussion, and as such, every single thing it does it scrutinised to death. It is exhausting.
It feels like AEW or nothing at times, for the fans talking about wrestling and the wrestlers trying to get buzz alike. AEW summons a sort of fatigue that is hard to pin down. In almost every way, it's all a bit much.
The in-the-weeds millennial fan has always had something to cling onto if the big promotions failed them (or, in the case of Vince McMahon for the last 15 years, outright told them to f*ck off). Those who grew up in the mid-'90s flocked to the renegade ECW promotion. A decade later, with WWE almost solely focused on producing the most sh*tty "wrestling" television of all time, they latched onto Ring Of Honor, the X division of TNA, and later PWG. For the first time since Vince McMahon's expansion, there is no cool, emerging subculture. There is no playground in which a wrestler can flourish and become something close to the best version of themselves before making the next step in their career. And, if a movement does develop organically, AEW is almost certain to integrate it.
AEW is the destination of professional wrestling, but the journey to get there is all kinds of broken.