How WWE Just Saved One Of Its Worst Ideas EVER

The Judgment Day were beaten black and blue before Triple H's WWE purple patch.

By Michael Hamflett /

WWE.com

Triple H is dividing opinion in his still-relatively-new role as WWE’s head of creative.

Advertisement

The honeymoon period post-Vince McMahon couldn’t last forever of course, but as a few of his early big punts start to falter, scrutiny into the things that aren’t really working has rightfully increased.

With bloom off the fresh summer’s rose, questions of how much change he can actually affect within WWE’s restrictive system - or for that matter how much he even wants to - are being asked. Fair analysis is fair game, as is diving deeper into these and other concerning creative developments heading into 2023.

Advertisement

But about as far away from any of these doubts and niggles is an act that - for the first half the year - was sweeping the board for 2022’s “worst” awards. Squash wins, too. Landslide sh*t. The Judgment Day was trending towards all-time awful territory, but a combination of real world chaos, some truly brilliant creativity and those cool inverted purple spotlights shone down on the group - and things have never been better for all four as a result.

CONT’D…

Advertisement
WWE

It cannot be understated how utterly woeful The Judgment Day was at point of conception.

Advertisement

A symbol of what we now know as Vince McMahon's final days in the job, the group persistently made no sense. Almost impressively so, in fact. The stable name alone was and is stupid, though plenty of this piece will put over the skills of a guy who has gone 25 years with "Triple" as his first name, so that's not exactly a deal-breaker. But nothing about the original idea held together.

Ahead of a WrestleMania with nothing to do, Edge begged for a challenger and received one in the form of AJ Styles. As thanks for answering his call, 'The Rated-R Superstar' hoofed the 'Phenomenal One' in the d*ck and turned heel in the very same segment. The character's switch felt forced from the first week - Edge was beloved even if WWE's booking of him had been mostly miserable since his 2022 return - and a series of cheap heat nonsensical promos made matters worse.

Advertisement

Bad, sure, but not as bad as the dreadful WrestleMania contest between the pair. As bored sighs echoed around Dallas' cavernous AT&T Stadium, the two worked a competent but wholly indulgent drag of a match that collapsed within itself before ending when Damian Priest distracted Styles.

The floundering former United States Champion had apparently seen the blue-then-purple light, and was set to join Edge on the "mountain of omnipotence", which may or may not have been the great big throne 2020's emotional comeback king now took to using as he talked down to dejected and disinterested crowds. If that reads like preposterous b*llocks from end-to-end, imagine 10 minutes a week of it and you're half way to capturing the feeling of watching The Judgment Day.

Advertisement

Change was lurking around the corner, but even the addition of a crucial new member wasn't an immediate solution...

CONT'D...

Advertisement
WWE.com

By May's WrestleMania Backlash, The Judgment Day was a problem flailing like a loose shower head bouncing around an empty bath. Pardon the rudimentary simile, but that was Edge's stock-in-trade for long enough that it started to rub off.

Advertisement

Damian Priest was just about making the grade as Edge's heater, but he too was fed waffle to regurgitate to the sound of glum confusion in arenas nationwide. He'd lose, too, denting what nominal credibility the new act had.

WrestleMania Backlash brought a beam of light, though not one anybody could have immediately forecast would burn quite so brightly. Rhea Ripley joined the group, helping 'The Rated-R Superstar' beat AJ Styles yet again, begging two questions; a) why didn't babyface AJ Styles have any friends to stop this constantly happening to him? and b) what was Edge saying backstage to be so convincing when not a single person was buying what he was selling out front?

Advertisement

Not once did WWE even attempt to answer the latter issue, but in addressing the former, they stumbled into the next bizarre fork in the road for the drain-circling stable. Styles finally found help, linking up with fellow Bullet Club alumni Finn Bálor and Ripley's former tag team partner Liv Morgan to form a makeshift trio that could take the updated Judgment Day down. June's Hell In A Cell was the destination, but through nefarious but logically sound (!) means, the numbers game was too much for the faces. The Judgement Day got the win, and it looked like at least some of the nonsense had competitive value.

For 24 hours, anyway. On Raw the next night, Finn Bálor staged a coup and joined Priest and Ripley in violently booting Edge out. A day after they'd finally gotten their sh*t together, it was drizzling away again.

Advertisement

CONT'D...

WWE.com

It took a fourth man to make whole something that still felt too flawed to ever work, but the missing piece wasn't the brilliantly useless Dominik Mysterio. Not yet, anyway.

Advertisement

In July, the earth shifted below everybody's feet when Vince McMahon resigned in disgrace. Jumping before he was pushed for a host of rotten indiscretions outside of his professional capacity, he left no handover for an incumbent Triple H beyond a simple remit of not being quite as appallingly uncreative as he'd been for the fat end of two decades.

'The Game' had a tremendously low bar to clear, and did so with ease by snatching quick wins out of Drew McIntyre uttering the word "wrestling" on a wrestling show and human beings being given their first names back. But few could have predicted what a job he'd do of rescuing an act most rational minds had rendered beyond saving. He was forgiven for plenty, and one of those things would have been just dropping the group cold and resetting completely, but heads were put together and everybody instead elected to take the much harder challenge of repairing the damage.

Advertisement

Clash At The Castle was the still point in a violently-paced turning world. En route to the Cardiff event, Edge returned to the type of pop that rendered his original heel turn all the stupider. He was chosen by The Judgment Day's newest victim Rey Mysterio as the right guy to fight them off with at the PLC. Chosen over his own son, no less. And with that, the the final piece of a seemingly unsolvable puzzle was now ready to be slid into place.

CONT'D...

Advertisement
WWE.com

Dominik Mysterio's heel turn galvanised The Judgement Day in a way hard to imagine until it was actually manifested.

Advertisement

If he was any better a wrestler, it wouldn't work as well. If he was another wrestler's son, it might not resonate as powerfully. If the rest of the group weren't absolutely sensational in the way they cruelly celebrate these specific aspects of his turn, the connection between the four wouldn't feel as authentic. They've taken to absolutely p*ssing themselves laughing whenever the smallest thing goes well, which lately has been outnumbering and out-gunning The O.C after beating Edge and Beth Phoenix back onto the injured reserve list at Extreme Rules. The boos for the group are some of the loudest on the show, and the engagement is growing in a way both revelatory and refreshing.

The one thing not surprising about any of this is that Triple H has been the head of creative behind it. They say write about what you know, and 'The Game' has a very good handle on a) being in groups and b) being an insufferable d*ckhead. The Judgment Day's shift from weirdos to w*nkers has been magnificent, and if anybody can provide salient advice on how to project lashings of the latter, it's Paul Levesque.

Advertisement

Credit where it's due to him though, and indeed the the quartet themselves. Rich in chemistry and shared purpose, the stable's road to recovery was completed at Clash At The Castle, and everything since has reflected a brand new journey entirely; onwards and upwards through WWE’s ranks, and into a WrestleMania season that wouldn’t have been anywhere near as fun without them.

CONT'D...

Advertisement
WWE

It's so encouraging - life-affirming for longstanding fans of all of this, actually - that WWE can still create situations like where The Judgment Day sit in November 2022.

Advertisement

Ahead of a Survivor Series where they'll have absolutely nothing to do with one another, red brand Women's Champion Bianca Belair and Rhea Ripley ever-so-briefly stared each other down on the November 8th edition of Monday Night Raw. This is precisely how much interaction the pair need heading into WrestleMania season. Without question the most over woman on the roster not wearing a title (and arguably that qualifier isn't required), Ripley is too fantastic to be denied at this point.

At the other end of the scale but no less awesome, Dominik Mysterio is impeccable as the entitled tosspot son of a legend, and his own inevitable 'Show Of Shows' battle with father Rey could be yet another bells-and-whistles masterwork from the same people behind Dom's blinder with Seth at SummerSlam 2020, Brock Lesnar tipping the ring with a tractor, and a Roman Reigns/Logan Paul match-of-the-year-candidate.

Advertisement

All of this doesn’t even consider the revenge original leader Edge and his wife Beth Phoenix will surely want to enact soon too, Lofty comparisons, multiple fantasy booking avenues and WrestleMania-sized expectations. There’s no greater feeling than this specific confluence of ideas and excitement when an act clicks, and - right now especially - there’s no greater representation of WWE’s new management making earnest creative strides.

The mountain was never omnipotent, but it looked almost impossible to scale. Not so anymore, and the only thing left now for the group is to try and locate the peak. Here’s hoping the continuation of that trek is just as gratifying as this summer’s remarkable climb.

Advertisement