It's Official: AEW Needs A MAJOR Wake-Up Call

The buzz is gone in All Elite Wrestling. It's time this was acknowledged.

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

Friday's edition of Rampage was the least-watched AEW TV show in history, drawing just 287,000 viewers and 0.07 in 18-49. It was a disaster. The different time slot cannot be used as an excuse; as Brandon Thurston of Wrestlenomics pointed out, the other lowest rating at 7PM was 0.15.

Advertisement

There is a tendency to catastrophise AEW when the rating is bad, or when they have the temerity to promote one middling episode after two months' worth of hot television.

Perspective is needed. This very month, on February 1, AEW Dynamite was #2 for the night on all of cable television. In a very positive new trend, AEW has for the first, sustained time in its near-four year history, attracted strong walk-up business for its TV tapings. This never used to happen; previously, the vast majority of tickets sold in one early surge. The string of awesome, action-heavy episodes in 2023 are fortifying the promotion's attendances. Tony Khan has solved a problem by effectively promoting his way around it. To the live crowd, anyway.

Advertisement

In 2023, AEW Dynamite has been a tremendous, if one-dimensional TV programme. The idea that AEW isn't telling stories or booking angles is moronic. Braindead. The matches are not random. You aren't watching a super-indie on television.

The troubling feeling that AEW is past its creative peak however is difficult to shake. Online "discourse" is a flawed metric prone to bias, depending on how one's social media activity is curated, but the general mood is low. The buzz barely exists.

Advertisement

Have you read a single sentiment to the effect of "AEW is at its very best right now?"

No, and that might very well be because it isn't. People said that in February 2020, in the summer of 2021, and in the build towards Revolution 2022. Nobody is saying it now.

Advertisement

The stories are there, but the creative, demonstrably, isn't connecting as well it has previously. There is nothing on the level of Hangman Page Vs. Kenny Omega or MJF Vs. CM Punk on AEW TV at present. Hell, outside of the MJF Vs. Bryan Danielson programme, nothing reaches the level of the super-detailed Jon Moxley Vs. Chris Jericho programme, and that wasn't even the second best storyline heading into Revolution 2020.

CONT'D...(1 of 5)

Advertisement
AEW

Mox stole a beautiful sports car and crashed it into a Dynamite with an outrun aesthetic, on which Jericho stabbed him in the eye ahead of a show on a cruise ship that allowed him to play a badass vengeful pirate. And, if this scanned as cute and location-specific, the heft of the eye-for-an-eye storyline revealed itself when Santana disclosed that his father had gone blind to set up a match with Moxley in, following an unexpected war with one-night mercenary Jeff Cobb, yet another very cool detour that preserved the big match for the big show.

Advertisement

The star name wrestles rival's stablemate trope hasn't reached that brilliant height since. That is far from the only Tony Khan signature booking device to have lost its lustre.

AEW Dynamite is simultaneously a fantastic, 8.5/10 show seven weeks out of eight and a show to which over 100 improvements could be made. It's hard to unpack, but an attempt to do so follows.

Advertisement

The standard of greatness has been normalised. That can't be overstated. One other problem might be that the core selling point is slightly flawed - with an embrace of range, it is impossible for AEW to unify the base. The people who love Jon Moxley's bloodstained wars tend not to opt into the Elite's earnest, corny melodrama. Trios aficionados aren't into Timothy Thatcher's intricate limb work. Technical wrestling devotees cannot abide the irreverence of the Best Friends or the Lucha Bros.' more choreographed brand of exhilaration. By its very design, AEW attracts criticism, but most reasonable people understand the value of a promotion with such a diverse offering. That can't be the core problem, even if the lack of one cohesive identity is by definition polarising.

The base however is unified in that something needs to change.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(2 of 5)

AEW

In 2019 and 2020, AEW soared in opposition to WWE's brutally monotonous, stakes-free rematch-heavy approach. The stable-dominated framework deployed by Khan was refreshing. Fans enjoyed the wait. What was once novel about AEW, however, simply isn't novel anymore. The way in which Khan preserves his PPV attractions no longer feels like it is worth the anticipation. Ricky Starks taking on every member of the Jericho Appreciation Society recently was such a chore. Every match, as ever, was predictable. Khan accomplished nothing here beyond padding out TV time. It was procrastination. Nothing more. A phoned-in, beyond redundant programme. A cliché of an AEW development.

Advertisement

The gauntlet is a narrative obligation. Does the stable-based framework need to go entirely? Nothing works forever, even that which is a great idea that works for a long time. Fans have lost the drive to watch a wrestler run through the gauntlet. Even when this approach is tweaked, interest levels are low. Jon Moxley didn't have to beat Evil Uno to get to Hangman Page - he was challenged by Uno directly, who was sticking up for the much-maligned Dark Order - but it simply wasn't an interesting prospect. This indirect approach to heating up big matches has become contrived in the extreme.

So many of AEW's issues emerge from a bloated roster assembled through impulsive greed.

Advertisement

It is impossible to care about so many characters because it is impossible for Tony Khan to service the amount of characters he books. This generates a lack of faith in the entire process.

In 2022, the AEW fanbase was asked to invest in both Daniel Garcia and Wheeler YUTA. You were meant to believe in Garcia as a wrestler above sports entertainment. You were meant to receive YUTA as the next badass on the block. Fast-forward to 2023, and even if Garcia realises his true calling, will it resonate? He's playing Sammy Guevara's younger brother long after people stopped caring. Those "You're a wrestler!" chants disappeared. YUTA meanwhile spends his time running his mouth, obnoxiously, to people backstage. He speaks as if he has authority, but then he simply loses. It's far more cathartic than it should be, and that can't be the point. If he's turning heel, good, but he was built as an awesome babyface after that classic Jon Moxley match. That story was told to get YUTA over as a babyface, and the follow-through was unacceptable - particularly after his performance at Forbidden Door.

Advertisement

CONT'D...(3 of 5)

AEW

What Tony Khan has arrived at in 2023 is a cast of characters that are hard to believe in navigating a landscape that is so repetitive and predictable that watching them succeed isn't compelling. Those two characters prove that your investment isn't as valued as it once was. AEW is unfocused, where it was once so thorough and immersive. Consider Darby Allin's ascent up the ranks.

Advertisement

The time limit draws. The narrowest of losses resulting from one simple error. How this pivoted to both his triumphant TNT title win over Coy Rhodes and a grudge programme in which he learned the lesson and tilted Brian Cage. Darby, an original "Pillar", was booked with an incredible attention to detail and focus. The contrast between that arc and those of his next breakthrough successors is bleak.

How exactly does AEW wake up?

Advertisement

Is it as simple as booking the Elite as the narrative epicentre of the promotion? Whenever it was hot - with those kinetic, overlapping brawls ahead of Full Gear 2019, the complex motivations in early 2020, the full-blown heel chicanery of that white-hot riot in the summer of '21 - they were the common denominator. Their sprawling, thoughtful approach elevated everything.

Khan must challenge himself to no longer operate in autopilot. Implement self-imposed bans on tired tropes like the gauntlet, at least until they can mean something again. Utilise the roster better. Unless there's a complex story at play about which the audience is unfamiliar, like a disciplinary matter, the use of Eddie Kingston in 2023 is unacceptable. Without being cruel, there are more than a handful of wrestlers that Tony Khan has frequently used on television this year that cannot lace the man's boots. Kingston might not be 100% fit, but HOOK almost certainly is. He, too, is stuck in place doing uninteresting things, constantly, with an assortment of undercard comedy heels. Khan has shown a personal bias to more than act this year - there are wrestlers in AEW who should be obvious that the audience simply does not like as much as he does - and not a one of whom was as over as HOOK was as 2021 drew to a close. Give Allison Danger full control over the women's division. It is abundantly, depressingly clear that Khan has little interest in really making something of it as a passion project.

Advertisement

Just as gauntlets and stables are tired, so too is the Dynamite format.

CONT'D...(4 of 5)

Advertisement
WWE

This is less than ideal, because the format needs to remain in place (mostly).

Advertisement

AEW is the wrestling promotion in which championships are the main objective. The announced fixtures must continue, but promoting every match in advance while logical can feel staid. The format makes it very obvious when an angle is going to happen, the outcomes are mostly obvious to begin with, and as a result, Dynamite - even when it is very good - can fail to crackle with an unexpected energy. The show is booked via spreadsheet and all too often, it shows. Wrestler whose job it is to lose in a speed run of failure - Bobby Fish (2021), Jay Lethal (2022), Brian Cage (2023) - get rid, get rid, get rid.

One way of bringing back the special, premium feeling is to introduce a fifth and sixth AEW exclusive pay-per-view outside of the traditional four and Forbidden Door. Even at its very best - special, all-time great, euphoric pro wrestling - AEW has never booked a flawless run between its pay-per-view offerings. Even the vaunted summer of 2021, as amazing as it was, started with a dismal residency at Daily's Place in the month after Double Or Nothing before Kenny Omega Vs. Hangman Page heated up and the rumours of CM Punk signing began to swirl. AEW can often meander narratively before the big angles happen, and the most intense promos are cut, in the weeks before the big shows. Bluntly, Revolution doesn't feel special. Khan faffed around with too many key stories. The long wait didn't generate anticipation; just a combination of isolated in-ring thrills and tedium.

Advertisement

In one of the very best episodic TV shows of all time, the November 16, 1985 edition of Mid-South Wrestling, Bill Watts cut an unsettled figure as he furthered the show-long storyline: Ted DiBiase was bloodied by a Dick Murdoch attack ahead of his NWA World Heavyweight title match opposite Ric Flair, but demanded his shot regardless, Watts relented. DiBiase had suffered arterial damage, but the flow of blood was halted by a pressure bandage. Were it to come loose, the show could get real gory, Watts warned. DiBiase shed an ocean of blood, was counted out in front of horrified punters - and Murdoch, the bastard, still went back for more. Suspense was built. The drama was palpable, frightening. Blood loss was sold, to stunning effect, as something life-threatening. The World champion and challenger were both protected. The territory's next big grudge feud sparked into life.

Bill Watts did more with a prop and an idea than Khan has accomplished in recent times with an all-timer of a roster. Deviating from the typical format on occasion, with an experimental show-long storyline, might disrupt the monotony. He can't do anything like the pressure bandage angle because blood has been spilled to near-meaningless excess. That is another issue.

Advertisement

There might actually be 100.