New TNA: 5 Things That Work (And 5 That Don't)

Two months since this brand new reinvention, what Impact are TNA making?

By Chris Quicksilver /

When TNA revealed that it had lost its TV deal with US network Spike TV, many fans feared the worst. The company had already said goodbye to many of its biggest stars, including A.J Styles, Sting and Hulk Hogan and the departures of Christopher Daniels, Frankie Kazarian, Chavo Guerrero and Chris Sabin, amongst others, did nothing to ease the troubled minds of the TNA fanbase. Booking-wise, the company€™s creative direction had veered wildly out of control as wrestlers were frivolously pushed and then discarded once they failed to single-handedly save TNA from extinction. To make matters worse, the company shamelessly aped WWE storylines in lieu of original content and, in the process, unwittingly began selling itself as a small time, second-rate promotion. Then, with TNA€™s fortunes locked into a deadly tailspin, a new deal was suddenly struck with TV network Destination America and a faster, fitter, leaner TNA began to slowly take shape. Eventually, this all-new TNA was launched, opening with a massive free-for-all brawl on the streets of New York City and exhibiting a vastly different show than ever before. So now, from the vantage point of about two months since this brand new reinvention, lets take a look at the new, improved TNA. What€™s working, what isn€™t and what could be improved upon. Let€™s get ready to rumble!

5. Innovative Camera Angles

TV direction is extremely important to the success of televised wrestling. A bad camera angle (e.g a mounted punch combo shown from behind the recipient, as opposed to the attacker) can really highlight the €˜fake-ness€™ of a match and thus, remove the viewer from the suspension of disbelief required to truly enjoy the show. Whilst new TNA is still finding its feet in this department, the hand-held, panoptic feel of Destination America€™s TNA tapings has been really effective thus far. The perfect antidote to WWE€™s slick, cinematic groove, new TNA€™s camerawork is frantic, brash and always at the heart of the action, giving off the impression of a wild, unscripted fight when necessary, whilst still delivering the story of the match in a clear and uncluttered manner. Take a look at the company€™s Lockdown 2015 taping. Cameras were present for ultra high angles, ultra low angles and everything in between (that€™s the middle angles, in case you wondered). Camera operators seemingly have free reign to openly zoom in on a bleeding wrestler, or a dramatic event, lending a freewheeling reality TV or (dare we say) €˜cinema verite€™ approach to wrestling coverage. With low angle cameras that rattle along with the hardest bumps and high angles that perfectly capture the high spots for the home viewer, new TNA has become far easier on the eye and, in the process, has begun to distance itself from its nearest competitors.

4. Darkened Arenas

With the lights down low, home audiences can€™t see if the arenas are empty or not, which means that even if TNA€™s live attendance figures continue to drop under the new regime, we€™ll never know it at home. Far from annexing the home viewer from the live fan reaction however, this new, €˜darkened arena€™ look creates a hive of disembodied voices, which actually presents a more united front as the action takes place. With the lights down, TNA shows can present a more theatrical feel to their events, without having to worry about the more opinionated fans squinting like they just smelled a giant fart when something they don€™t approve of happens. Also, from a psychological vantage point, this enables the crowds to become louder, as they are effectively shouting in the dark, with no way to connect the noise back to them €“ the fan response at the most recent TNA shows has actually been very healthy and it seems likely that this is partly why. Besides, if they don€™t shout, cheer, or boo the wrestling on display, then it€™s also much easier to dub crowd noise over a darkened audience, something that, before you rush to criticise, even the mighty WWE has a long, sad history of doing.

3. Josh Matthews & Taz

TNA€™s announce team are miles better than WWE€™s. Fact. In truth, it was that way even before the changeover. Veteran announcer Mike Tenay called matches with knowledge, a cheeky sense of humour and, above all, a glowing respect for the sport of pro wrestling, whilst Taz added an ever-welcome wrestler€™s perspective to proceedings. Many TNA fans were sad to see Tenay go, but Destination America obviously wanted a younger, better looking play-by-play man. Josh Matthews may not have a huge amount of wrestling pedigree, but he is sincere, respectful and eloquent enough to make it work. If one were feeling critical, he might say that Matthews occasionally lacks passion, but, to be more complementary, he also has good chemistry with Taz and the pair seems to genuinely enjoy working together.

2. The Ranking System

It€™s contentious among some fans, but a €˜star ranking€™ win/loss based system (not unlike the English Premier League table) is actually a pretty good idea. A wrestler that picks up a lot of successive wins can eventually challenge for a title, which allows the fans to emotionally engage with the outcomes of matches more. It also gives more of a reason for the wrestlers to be fighting in the first place, as well as adding an extra layer of fan anger at a run-in ending or €˜Dusty Finish€™. Of course, you can still give the champ free reign to challenge anybody he/she likes, which effectively allows the bookers and creative teams to have their cake and eat it too, which is always nice. New TNA doesn€™t quite have the system mentioned above, but they do appear to be implementing something similar and, by announcing the rankings of their wrestlers, they are bringing an interesting €˜mainstream sports€™ element to the shows, something that could be very effective indeed in gaining TNA a new audience.

1. Playing To Their Strengths...Finally

There are a lot of things to like about TNA, but in recent years, those plus points have been continually weighted down by a proliferation of nagging, sometimes infuriating, negatives. Now, with the Destination America deal, TNA appears to be playing to its strengths at long last. As a general rule, whenever the promotion attempts to compete with the might and mass media exposure of the WWE, it simply comes off as inferior and second rate. Towards the end of the Spike TV era, TNA couldn€™t seem to wash away the stench of the bargain bin. For just one example, just six days after short, bearded and likeably kooky underdog Daniel Bryan hoisted the WWE belt at WrestleMania XXX, short, bearded and likeably kooky underdog Eric Young lifted the TNA belt in Orlando, Florida. At this, even E.Y€™s most devoted fans had to facepalm a little. For years, fans have been saying that TNA should do everything in its power to come off as different to the WWE. Their product is cheaper, their houses are smaller and their appeal is narrower. However, these things are only handicaps if you look at them as such. In the immortal words of Punk magazine co-founder Legs McNeil, €œyou take the sh!t and celebrate it€. So, instead of seeing these things as negatives, TNA executives should be angling their product as scrappier, tougher and harder-edged than the WWE€™s. The venues should be presented as more €˜intimate€™ and €˜fan friendly€™ rather than €˜smaller€™ and they should market themselves as a show for wrestling fans, NOT snot-nosed, toy hungry little kids. Finally, new TNA seems to be doing just that. With the panoptic, handheld camera angles, the return of the six-sided rings and the continued promotion of great TNA talents like Austin Aries, Gunner (who really should be the company€™s next major star), Magnus, Bobby Roode, Eric Young, Kenny King, James Storm, Low Ki and others still, TNA is already a brand apart from the WWE...It just needs to realise and capitalise on this fact. Even with all the departures, TNA still boasts a truly world class talent roster and, as long as they work harder to produce quality storylines and continue to keep the wrestling to the forefront, TNA€™s product is still a strong one overall. Having said/written all that, there are a few areas that drastically need improvement...

5. Announcers In A Separate Room, Far Away From Ringside

As welcome as Josh Matthews and Taz are as the new announce team, many fans were left scratching their heads when they first saw that the pair were locked away inside a little room whilst calling the matches. Frankly, there is A LOT to be said for announcers sitting at ringside. Could you imagine classic wrestling moments like €œGood God almighty he€™s broken in half!€ being even half as effective with the announcers removed from the action? Nope. Even in €˜old school€™ TNA, when the announcers were closer to the entrance ramp than they were to the ring, it still felt more vibrant, more alive than it does with the knowledge that the two voices we can hear are calling the match from some sort of €˜control deck€™ situated somewhere else in the building. Ideally, the announcers are a sort of €˜halfway house€™ between the performer and the fan and although Destination America are obviously going for a feel similar to that of an American football or baseball game, the desired effect just isn€™t there. In mainstream American sports, the announcers are presented as having €˜the best seat in the house€™, in new TNA, they appear to be locked in a broom cupboard.

4. The Roster Isn€™t What It Once Was

The mass talent exodus that has afflicted TNA in recent years is very damaging to the company, both in terms of public image and in ring product. The losses of mainstream icons like Hulk Hogan and Sting have been worsened by the departure of hugely popular TNA stars such as A.J Styles, Christopher Daniels, Frankie Kazarian, Bully Ray, Velvet Sky, Chavo Guerrero, Samoa Joe, Chris Sabin and many others besides... Frankly, TNA fans need to see some consistency within the roster. The company needs desperately to build new stars and keep them around for a little while in the process. Its been said before, but building the show around one singles star (e.g Gunner) and signing that star to a lucrative, long term contract really wouldn€™t be the worst idea in the world.

3. Half The Remaining Roster Just Turned Heel...

SPOILERS €“ Read on at your peril. This section contains a reference to events that have yet to air on UK TV. The first broadcast of the new TNA contained something of a surprise (or it would have, if it hadn€™t aired on tape delay following a series of spoilers on Facebook, Twitter and all the wrestling rags), as effectively half the babyface locker room suddenly turned heel on TNA Champion Bobby Roode. Little, if any, reasoning was provided as to why Samoa Joe and Low Ki would align themselves with the villainous MVP and Kenny King, especially after Joe in particular had demonstrated such a fiery hatred of all things MVP, but there it was. Then, later on that same night, plucky fan-favourite Eric Young got in on the act as well, by demolishing his best friend Bobby Roode with a steel chair and costing him the TNA World Title in the process. Presumably, the move was made so that TNA Champion Lashley (who upended Roode following Young€™s betrayal) would have the deck stacked against him as he valiantly defended his title (a title that he has now dropped to Kurt Angle...So the point exactly was what?) in the wake of an outnumbering onslaught, but the effect wasn€™t really felt that strongly, as TNA tapings have been dominated by the heel stable of MVP, Lashley and Kenny King for months now anyway and the fans are used to it.

2. Airing Vignettes During Matches

No. Just no. This is a classic example of TV directors, not wrestling insiders, making a call €“ and, quite frankly, its the wrong one to make. Cutting away from the action in the ring in order to show us a pre-taped backstage segment simply disturbs the flow of the match being filmed. It short-changes the viewer and it takes us away from the story being told. On paper, one can see the appeal of having a spontaneous, €˜reality TV€™ feel to the product, but in practice, its just distracting. TNA fans don€™t want to see what Kurt Angle or Lashley are up to during the Austin Aries/Kenny King matchup; they want to see Austin Aries vs. Kenny King. TNA€™s major selling point is, and always has been, the high standard of wrestling on display €“ so let€™s cut the crap and get on with it, can we?

1. Where€™s Joe?

From the moment Samoa Joe debuted as a henchman for MVP€™s €˜Beat Down Clan€™, it was clear that €˜The Samoan Submission Machine€™ wasn€™t high on new TNA€™s priority list. One of the greatest TNA World Heavyweight Champions ever and one of the world€™s best wrestlers, Joe was reduced to doing run-ins and whacking other people€™s opponents with steel chairs when the ref wasn€™t looking. Don€™t misunderstand, a heel Samoa Joe works just fine. In fact, many fans would probably prefer it, but Joe should always have an aura about him, a €˜main event mystique€™, if you will, that is thoroughly trampled on when he engages in a largely nonsensical opening brawl or acts as a €˜run-in guy€™ during someone else€™s match. Recently, the news broke that Samoa Joe had severed ties with TNA management, which is a HUGE blow to the company. Although TNA€™s main featured performers at the moment are Lashley, Bobby Roode, MVP and Kurt Angle, amongst others, none of them can cover for the loss of Samoa Joe from the roster. Joe€™s departure is the biggest loss to the company since the Spike TV deal and the overall implications could be almost as bad. TNA€™s public up swing took a major downward turn with the loss of Samoa Joe. The company was finally shedding its image as the promotion that let A.J Styles, Sting and Chris Daniels walk out the door €“ and now this happens. FFS. The same also applies to the recent departure of Bully Ray, another of the company€™s top stars. So, as you can see, new TNA has proven to be something of a mixed bag. However, Destination America has taken more than a few steps in the right direction and the standard of wrestling, as usual, is very high overall, so there€™s still a lot to enjoy there. Despite a few early setbacks, it is pleasing to say that, at last, the future seems to be looking bright for TNA.