Ranking Every WWE NXT WarGames Match From Worst To Best
Two rings, one cage, eight superstars, and a ton of action.
Four years into the revival of WCW’s multi-ringed extravaganza of carnage, WarGames has already become something akin to NXT’s version of the Royal Rumble. The event is one of the highlights of the company’s calendar and guarantees a wild night for all involved.
Also not unlike the Rumble, there really are no bad WarGames matches.
What with the chaos, the star power, the danger and the opportunity for high spots, even the worst bouts will have at least a few moments of intrigue and irresistible chaos.
With that in mind, though, some WarGames matches are undeniably better than others. Whether it’s the storytelling, the personnel, the ingenuity, or the craft in the match’s layout, it’s the small details that separate a genuinely classic WarGames bout from just a very good clash in a big silly cage.
NXT 2.0 has rung in a lot of changes, but it’s a relief to see that the WarGames match seems to be here to stay. We can hopefully expect many more wild and crazy fights in years to come, but thus far, here’s how the developmental brand’s most enjoyable matches stack up...
8. The Undisputed Era vs Team McAfee (2020)
Though they’ve now been scattered across the wrestling landscape, Undisputed Era were the kings of WarGames, working four on the trot, and you’re pretty much guaranteed a fun match when they’re involved. 2020’s encounter has some fun moments: McAfee bringing out four tables marked with the names of each group member, the English boys bringing cricket bats to the ring, reDRagon running wild.
The men’s 2020 match finishes bottom, however, due to its sheer excess. It’s the match’s - and black and gold NXT’s - most consistent flaw, an unerring desire to throw absolutely everything at the wall. Plenty sticks, but plenty doesn’t, and when that results in a 45-minute match, it’s a bit of an issue.
There’s the Pat McAfee factor, too. The man has been nothing but a boon for WWE, particularly on commentary, but he’s been no slouch in the ring. Building much of the match around him, to the extent that he’s kicking out of Adam Cole’s Panama Sunrise, does seem daft star treatment for a man who’s not going to be a long time worker.
It means McAfee’s teammates - the mercenary gang of Pete Dunne, Danny Burch, and Oney Lorcan - are a little sidelined. The story’s sound, but the lack of focus lets it down.
7. Io Shirai, Kay Lee Ray, Raquel González, And Cora Jade Vs. Dakota Kai, And Toxic Attraction (2021)
The first of this year’s WarGames bouts tried to do something different. Instead of an overstuffed affair ending only after a truly hellacious bump, this was a cagier and more tactical scrap that ended in surprising fashion with the injured Cora Jade grabbing the pin on Jacy Jayne amid the chaos and confusion.
It’s smart to have a WarGames match conclude under different conditions, but couldn’t help feeling a little deflating, too. The rings had only just filled up, and we were ready for battle, only for the match to quickly come to a close.
There were some impressive moments - Jade’s genuinely frightening senton from the top of the cage, Raquel Gonzalez’s domineering show of strength - and some smart character work, like Io Shirai (a perennial WarGames MVP) moonlighting as a shoulder surgeon. There were also some sloppy moments, though, particularly with some of the newer performers who never quite seemed in sync.
For various reasons, this just didn’t seem to have the heft of previous WarGames matches. Not a flop by any means - indeed a perfectly enjoyable watch - but the high bar of years past was hard to clear.
6. The Undisputed Era vs AOP & Roderick Strong vs Sanity (2017)
NXT made the bold decision to break with the two teams tradition on their very first WarGames, and while the purists may question its credentials on the basis it comprised three teams of three, the swifter entry system meant that the match got underway a lot quicker than other iterations, making this a great introduction for those who didn’t grow up on WCW’s double cage extravaganzas.
In spite of the additional man to consider, this WarGames is more simply laid out than some of the wild bouts to follow. Authors of Pain and Roderick Strong played the power game, Undisputed Era embraced that pack mentality to chip away at their opponents, and Sanity provided the wild card, swinging weapons with abandon.
With NXT’s tag division in rare form, everyone’s out to impress, but special props must go to big Killian Dain who hits a vintage Van Terminator onto O’Reilly, Strong for his customary cardio - he barely needs a minute’s downtime for the entire 35 plus minutes - and Cole for rag-dolling his way through another deadly encounter.
This is such an easy watch and there’s very little not to like, but as far as NXT WarGames goes, we’re just getting started.
5. Pete Dunne, Ricochet & War Raiders vs The Undisputed Era (2018)
A particularly long edition of NXT WarGames, this match highlights the best of the black and gold brand’s 2018 heyday while being slightly stymied by its sheer indulgence. The bout clocks in at close to an hour, and may be a little too choreographed to some viewers’ tastes, with a procession of high spots taking up the back end of the match.
For those who enjoy NXT’s bravura and amazing workrate, though, that’s something to savour, rather than complain about. In one ring we have the fully formed Undisputed Era in their first WarGames as a foursome, and they’re ridiculously good heels, each getting the chance to show off their unique skillset.
In the other ring is one of the best all-star teams in WarGames history. War Raiders show off their freakish athleticism, and Pete Dunne stakes his claim as one of the most natural cage fighters with his grit and brutality. And then there’s Ricochet who gets to do Ricochet things, most notably a double moonsault from the top of the cage.
The storytelling perhaps fades into the background here in favour of bell to bell carnage, but if the excesses of 2018-vintage NXT are to your tastes, it doesn’t get much more gleefully excessive than this.
4. Team Candice vs Team Shotzi (2020)
WarGames without a crowd wasn’t an ideal situation for anyone, but the women who opened NXT’s last 2020 TakeOver did so in immense style. This match rode the line between the brutality and ridiculousness available to the performers magnificently and saw each of the eight women prove why NXT’s female roster was one of the best in the business.
Candice LeRae was at the top of her heel game here and backed up by the ascendant Racquel Gonzalez, the technical excellence of Toni Storm, and wildcard Dakota Kai. Shotzi, meanwhile, brings powerhouse Rhea Ripley, returning Ember Moon, and MVP Io Shirai.
The Women’s Champion shone at the previous year’s event, but tops herself here in one of the silliest, most enjoyable spots of the year, climbing the cage, bafflingly putting a trash can over her head, then leaping off onto everyone.
Each participant gets their chance to take gnarly bumps, with Kai piling through chairs, Shotzi crushing herself with a weapons-assisted senton, and Shirai ultimately eating a Gonzalez powerbomb through a ladder. The slight odd note is the division champ taking the pin, but this is a breakneck, chaotic, but nonetheless slick match that absolutely flies by.
3. The Undisputed Era vs Team Ciampa (2019)
Perhaps the biggest collection of stars NXT’s WarGames has offered to date, the men’s 2019 edition is packed with intrigue going in. The wily Undisputed Era are here for the third time in a row, and it’s down to the amped up Tomasso Ciampa and co to take them down. Ciampa has with him ringers Keith Lee and Dominik Dijakovic, but the fourth man is nowhere to be seen.
Just as all appears lost, Kevin Owens’ music hits, and the former Universal Champ strides to the ring to the elation of the Chicago crowd. Owens was always booked like a true bruiser on the black and gold, and he lays waste to UE in short order.
It’s one of the most brutal WarGames the brand put on; Strong and O’Reilly both take big table bumps, there’s a Panama Sunrise on the metal between the rings, avalanche Olympic Slams, and for dessert, an Air Raid Crash on Cole from way up high, which looks absolutely grizzly and brings the match to a fitting ending.
Utterly bonkers but with its own internal logic and not too many ridiculous kick outs, this is a breathless bit of action that never lets up. A glorious cameo from a star of old and the right result after a madcap spot - it’s a proper crowd pleaser.
2. Team Black & Gold vs Team 2.0 (2021)
Call it recency bias if you will, but the most recent dual cage encounter had a bit of everything, and could hardly have been better booked to provide a swansong for the old guard and a perfect platform for the new.
The main aim of the evening was clearly to make Bron Breakker look a million bucks, and the young Steiner performed admirably, lifting fools like they were pillows and spearing Ciampa through a table at the close.
Everyone got their chance to shine, though. Carmelo Hayes put on a brief chain wrestling clinic. Pete Dunne once again chose violence, breaking bones and stomping joints. Grayson Waller nabbed the high spot with a huge elbow from the top, LA Knight showed off his impressive workrate, and Tony D’Angelo was nice and brutal.
Best of all, though, Tomasso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano played the DIY hits to the baying crowd, landing their old double finisher on Breakker to a convincing near fall. For Gargano, especially, this was a night to remember. It might yet be his final NXT match, and it was an apt reminder of everything he’s given to the brand.
1. Team Ripley vs Team Baszler (2019)
If the in-ring action is crazy and fun enough, a WarGames match can survive without too much story. When the dramatic elements are on point too, though, that’s when you get something really great. WWE so often struggles with booking babyfaces. Here, the black and gold brand shows them how it’s done.
We start with Io Shirai and Candice LeRae, doing great work with a feud behind it. Bianca Belair and then Rhea Ripley enter. Kay Lee Ray joins team Baszler next, but before Ripley’s squad can even out, Dakota Kai lays out squadmate, then ditches. Baszler laughs her head off, then gets in the fray for a four on two.
This is a star-making turn for Ripley, who overcomes the numbers advantage to come out on top after absorbing hair whips, weaponry, and the Kirafuda Clutch. She handcuffs herself to Baszler for a gnarly Riptide through chairs and nabs the unlikely win.
And that’s not even mentioning LeRae’s wild bumping, Shirai’s moonsault off the cage, Belair’s surprisingly great heel-work, and Baszler’s cocky but terrifying aura that made her one of the division’s best ever villains. It’s perfectly structured and so well worked, a brutal triumph.