Ranking EVERY WWE Royal Rumble Match From Worst To Best
Counting down each incarnation of WWE's greatest gimmick...
There are a few parameters to get to before hitting the full rundown of WWE’s most beloved and irrepressible gimmick match.
Though the fans somehow taping them in their entirety on relatively primitive technology deserve modicums of credit for capturing quirky footnotes in wrestling history, the 1994 house show 30-man Royal Rumbles in New York and Osaka will not be counted here because they were never intended to be seen by an audience beyond those in attendance on the night. They are worth your time as curios if you’ve got the time to waste and find memories of the era, but that’s about it.
Similarly, a 12-man October 1987 run-through of the eventual 1988 inaugural edition was for Vince McMahon to see if he liked the idea, the St Louis live event attendees, and eventual victor One Man Gang. Ditto a March '88 20-man one won by Rick Rude. If footage exists of either, let it be for the Network's Hidden Gems section, not a critical evaluation here.
Thats not to say all scaled-back versions are prohibited. The organisation has committed several other incarnations of the match to television beyond the pay-per-view headliners over the years. Indeed, though most fans view the Rumble as the finest convergence of stipulations in company history, WWE themselves have occasionally been a little slapdash in preserving it.
These incarnations are very eligible for discussion, and in some cases very, very bad...
48. 2015
A wretched sequel to a wretched mistake, the Royal Rumble as we all knew it died on January 25th 2015. It took big gimmicks, big stars and a big addition in 2016, 2017 and 2018 respectively drive its reinvention, so hideous was this particular edition.
A scientifically engineered selection of "f*ck you" gestures even bigger than the year before, the unrelenting and unwelcome push of Roman Reigns reduced the rest of the upper-midcard to near-literal sacks of sh*t in a sequence of closing Big Show and Kane eliminations that even now beggar belief.
47. Mini Royal Rumble (Monday Night Raw, January 14th 2008)
Though WWE have done worse with minis, the match is still an entire mockery of Hornswoggle et al and proffers punching down as a punchy plot.
Exchanges between Hornswoggle and some of the minature main roster imposters are genuinely decent, but every second of this - soundtracked by Jerry Lawler's best repurposed Dink jokes - laughs squarely in the face of little people.
46. 1999
The Vince Russo Royal Rumble is closer to a chaotic extended Raw main event than the second biggest pay-per-view headliner of the year.
As is the case with so much from the time, the excitement in the arena is palpable but little of the action holds up to retrospective scritiny.
45. Raw Rumble (Monday Night Raw, January 31st 2011)
Not half bad if it was perhaps half a roster bigger, the Monday Night Raw Rumble to determine The Miz' February 2011 pay-per-view opponent featured just about every headliner on the flagship at the time and a surprise winner in Jerry 'The King' Lawler.
What it lacked in length, strength and depth, it at least made up for in a crowd-pleasing conclusion.
44. 2022 (Men’s)
The problem with the 2022 Men’s Royal Rumble was more about the total rot at the core of the company rather than a bulletproof gimmick finally absorbing some hits.
Elsewhere in this article the same point applies to the women's battle royal on the very same show, but Vince McMahon was more pinished than Pessi and Penaldo combined and never had this been clearer than during the awkward silences between music hitting and fans waiting to see a face before they decided whether to react to a wrestler.
It starkly revealed that even paying punters were tiring of the dirge on Raw and SmackDown. Deadened to the strains of yet another bland or unrecognisable entrance theme, the pop machine stalled for the very first time with the crowd so desperate for things they like that Bad Bunny's cameo proved one of the hottest spots of the night. Brock Lesnar winning was depressing, as were Shane McMahon's punches and the less said about recently-deposed WWE Champion Big E going just six minutes with zero eliminations, the better.
43. The Greatest Royal Rumble
Though Daniel Bryan broke the gimmick's longtime longevity record in a 50-man spin on the legendary gimmick and a request for the deceased Yokozuna was granted in the form of a virtually unknown sumo replacement, Greatest Royal Rumble didn't come close to living up to its name. And the match itself wasn't the only thing to fall short in Saudi Arabia.
Titus O'Neil may never again regain what little credibility he had after his entry stumble was the problematic contest's only point of significance.
42. 2022 (Women)
It got easier and easier to chart precisely how much of a hate-filled man Vince McMahon became during the final years of his time as WWE’s creative head.
A stubborn old pr*ck 4 life, things got even worse when he secured a monopoly in 2001, beyond the pale when he luxuriated in that fact for most of the 2000s and 2010s, and off a cliff entirely when another organisation dared to run a wrestling show from 2019.
Three years into that (and seven months away from his first exit from the company), Vince McMahon presented two duffer Rumbles on one show - a feat almost impressive if it wasn't wholly depressing to sit through. With Sasha Banks getting a nothing run from #1, The Bella Twins breaking up a minuscule Riott Squad reunion certain sections of the audience pined for and the divisive Ronda Rousey's shock return, this was the far crueler of the two, too.
41. 1995
Shawn Michaels' coast-to-coast victory plays like a singles match with Davey Boy Smith that gets interrupted by 28 run-ins. A desperate lack of roster depth is framed as the "fastest-paced Royal Rumble ever" but it's hard to buy what Vince McMahon desperately sells thoughout.
Everything between the pair is 24 karat, the rest is fool's gold.
40. Tag Team Royal Rumble (Monday Night Raw, June 15th, 1998)
A red hot crowd carried this beyond the usual TV Rumble experience, with most of the doubles roster gradually finding a sense of purpose as they were wont to do with Vince Russo holding the pencil.
The disparity between stars and rank-and-file - and thus, the result - was regrettably never in doubt, but it at least made contenders Kane and Mankind fight for the right to get a shot that was so obviuously already theirs.
39. 1988
A muted affair watched out of context, the inaugural televised Royal Rumble match reflects the amount of kinks still being worked out in the format at the time.
Heat segments and babyface comebacks are somewhat listless, though eventual winner Jim Duggan does at least receive a major pop for overcoming the heel odds in the closing stretch.