Ranking Wrestling's Most Shocking Surprise Every Year 1990-2020

Bombshells, blockbusters and brilliant booking from 30 years of an industry gradually going insane.

By Michael Hamflett /

This list celebrates high drama, but here are a couple of caveats on what's included below to offset more arising from what may seem like some obvious omissions:

Advertisement

- Real life proffers the most potent shocks and surprises, but this list is predominantly about the moments that took place in or adjacent to North American wrestling, rather than the wrestlers themselves. Invariably, if a year featured any kind of tragedy, it should go without saying that it was probably that year's biggest story, shock and surprise. It'll go without listing for the same reasons.

- For better and worse, the North American landscape has dominated the conversations about pro wrestling over the timeframe, and has thus been the focus here. Even now, with New Japan Pro Wrestling several years into an unprecedented global popularity boom and potentially in league with All Elite Wrestling, the company still have to compete with WWE for column inches everywhere but Japan.

Hopefully - and sooner rather than later - that pendulum will at long last swing, but in the meantime, here's to the best of the bananas bullsh*t from McMahon, Bischoff, Rhodes and...Fatu?

31. 1990 - Vince McMahon Crashes Mr Olympia

Long before the music studios or the XFL or the New York restaurant or the XFL, Vince McMahon believed the spin-off money was in Bodybuilding, and used 1990's Mr Olympia to launch his own company from within a magazine-shaped trojan horse.

Advertisement

Shocking vendors that were relatively uninterested in his planned 'Bodybuilding Lifestyles' monthly, McMahon instead handed out flyers for the World Bodybuilding Federation, promising biceps, bells and whistles that proved to be beyond what anybody in the industry even wanted.

30. 1991 - Jake Roberts' King Cobra Bites Randy Savage

A remarkable piece of pro wrestling television for how much went so so right in a situation that could have gone terrifyingly wrong, Jake Roberts setting his snake on Randy Savage unlocked a new level of terror for pro wrestling and Roberts' character.

Advertisement

Rarely did his pythons look as though they really wanted to be held aloft or thrown onto hapless jobbers. His king cobra was doing what it knew, and having a thoroughly fantastic time. The horrors that came from trying to answer the questions spiralling from this; would Savage recover? How could he get his revenge? And if Roberts could do this to the Macho Man, just what awful things awaited Elizabeth?

29. 1992 - The SummerSlam You Thought You'd Never See

Vince McMahon infamously loathes pronouns, but the "You" in SummerSlam 1992's subtitle always felt like it was replacing an "I". That's to say, the Chairman never believed business would be so rotten domestically that he'd need to hop across the pond to draw a house that looked like the good old days.

Advertisement

But it was, and he did, and it did. Going on 30 years without a sequel is starting to feel cruel.

28. 1993 - Hulk Hogan Ends WrestleMania IX As WWE Champion

Hulk Hogan's 1993 return to pay-per-view for WWE was supposed to be as one half of WrestleMania IX's double main event. Instead, he took the whole shebang.

Advertisement

Failing in his efforts to claim tag team gold earlier in the show, 'The Hulkster's white knight bullsh*t at the end of the show popped enough of that Las Vegas car park to assure Vince McMahon that he'd made the right call to turn around his ailing business. B*llocks, obviously, which Hogan himself seemed to be aware of - he was everywhere but WWE between the 'Show Of Shows' and his loss to Yokozuna at June's King Of The Ring.

27. 1994 - Hulk Hogan Signs For WCW

With Vince McMahon alienated (for now, at least), Hulk Hogan's mega-money deal with WCW ensured that wrestling as an entity couldn't move on without its biggest ever star.

Advertisement

Under McMahon's umbrella, Hogan had stuttered getting a television and film career off the ground. The move South was ostensibly set to help him do both, though it went a long way in legitimising the North American number two as far more than just WWE's sh*ttier alternative.

26. 1995 - Nitro Debuts, And So Does Lex Luger

The very idea of Monday Nitro's existence in 1995 was a bombshell big enough to rattle the cages of those within WWE not so naive as to believe it would fail, but Lex Luger's appearance on the debut addition made the show's intentions crystal clear.

Advertisement

There have been countless documentaries hitting all the clichés about this being the "first shot" and whatnot, but this is one of the few cases where the bluster isn't bullsh*t.

25. 1996 - Hulk Hogan Joins The Outsiders At Bash At The Beach

The formation of the New World Order served as the culmination of everything Eric Bischoff had attempted to achieve since gaining power in WCW three years earlier.

Advertisement

Combining original box office signing Hulk Hogan with recent headline grabbers Scott Hall and Kevin Nash and utilising elements of an invasion storyline from Japan he'd taken inspiration from, this brought together much of what he'd visualised when first getting competitively aggressive with Vince McMahon years earlier.

24. 1997 - Vince Screws Bret

Unlike Bret Hart himself, the story of Montreal has actually been beaten into submission since November 1997.

Advertisement

Finding new insights Vince McMahon screwing 'The Hitman' is almost impossible, then, but that speaks to just what a landmark moment it was. 1997 spat shocks out on a near-weekly basis, but none had the real life and storyline ramifications this endlessly divisive decision carried.

23. 1998 - The Rock & The McMahons Screw The People

Mike Tyson's run-in with Stone Cold Steve Austin was awesome, but in that way that celebrity involvement is supposed to be. Raw overturning Nitro's 83-week winning streak on Monday Nights wasn't unexpected by the time it happened.

Advertisement

The Rock going corporate and winning the WWE Championship spun heads that thought they knew better. The payoff to Vince Russo's wrestling masterpiece, his victory in Survivor Series' Deadly Game tournament completed am immaculate elevation of the 'The Great One'.

22. 1999 - Vince Russo Leaves WWE For WCW

A Crash TV crashed and burned in late-1999, so too did Vince Russo with the advent of SmackDown and a doubled WWE workload.

Advertisement

Taking a substantial sum of money to become the head writer of WCW having claimed the majority of the credit for the Attitude Era, his move seemed seismic in the moment. Within a year, it was primarily blamed for hammering the biggest nails in the Atlanta outfit's nearly-completed coffin.

Advertisement