TNA Slammiversary 2016: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

It's all downhill from the opener.

By Jack Pooley /

Now that TNA is seemingly down to just two PPV events per year, they really need to make the most of them. While the company admirably managed to get almost every active roster member on the card, Slammiversary 2016 was without question a mixed bag for the most part.

Advertisement

Pacing was a real issue above all else: the crowd were absolutely killed by four back-to-back mediocre matches, before things thankfully upturned somewhat for the show's second half.

Yes, it was far from the marquee show that TNA really should be pulling out at this point, but at least we got a number of terrific and memorable matches, and some tantalising teases for several upcoming title programs.

Here is every TNA Slammiversary 2016 match ranked from worst to best...

9. The Tribunal Vs. Grado & Mahabali Shera

Result: The Tribunal pick up the win after destroying Grado with a guillotine manoeuver (7:35).

Advertisement

Rating: There's very little that can or needs to be said about this one. There was almost nothing of interest going in and, unsurprisingly, the bout was utterly forgettable. Not totally awful or anything, just bland. We all knew how it would end, and that's exactly what we got.

Neither team did much to endear themselves to the crowd, and this honestly just felt like the sort of match that should've been relegated to the pre-show (as nine matches on a 3-hour PPV is probably one too many anyway). 4/10

8. Knockouts Title Triple Threat: Jade (c) Vs. Sienna Vs. Gail Kim

Result: Sienna wins the strap after Marti Bell knocks Jade out with a tire iron (8:11).

Advertisement

Rating: There was some really sloppy work early on from Sienna, and it was clear throughout that the three didn't really have much chemistry at all to speak of.

Thankfully the presence of Gail Kim just about helped hold things together for the most part, but ultimately this one was just pretty flat, and the bulls*** ending was both predictable and just plain lame. Plus, Gail leaving the ring for the finish to chase Maria just made her look uncharacteristically stupid when there was a title to be won. 5/10

7. James Storm Vs. Braxton Sutter

Result: Storm drills Sutter with the Last Call for the easy win (6:41).

Advertisement

Rating: There were no surprises herem, either.

The pair wrestled a brief and unremarkable bout that exited the memory the second it was over. That said, Storm picking up the decisive win was a peculiar booking decision given the build for the match and the good it could've done for Sutter to win (or at least get incredibly close to doing so).

Perhaps there's yet more to come with this one, but it was an utterly average match with little imagination in terms of booking or in-ring storytelling. It just doesn't feel PPV-worthy in the slightest. 5/10

6. King Of The Mountain Title: Eli Drake (c) Vs. Bram

Result: Eli blasts Bram with the Blunt Force Trauma out of nowhere to retain the title (8:37).

Advertisement

Rating: Nothing in this match was more entertaining than Eli Drake's pre-match stumble off the top turnbuckle (whether it was planned or a legit botch), but the bout certainly wasn't bad on the whole. Again, though, it's yet another perfectly mediocre match on the show that doesn't even touch the sides.

It was a pretty standard brawl and not much more. The pair left the ring early and spent most of the match fumbling around outside. For what it was this one probably went on a little too long, though. 5/10

5. Tag Titles: Decay (c) Vs. The Bromans

Result: Abyss powerbombs Crazzy Steve onto Jessie Godderz to retain the straps (9:18).

Advertisement

Rating: Who knows why this one played so far up the card, but anyway, it served a decent enough purpose of cooling the crowd down between Full Metal Mayhem and the main event.

This was at least more entertaining and action-packed than the PPV's array of forgettable bouts, and though it threatened to succumb to over-booking in its busy final sequence, thankfully we got a clean-ish finish when it was all said and done. Not an amazing contest, but certainly a fun little match that didn't outstay its welcome. Not bad at all. 6/10

4. Full Metal Mayhem: Matt Hardy Vs. Jeff Hardy

Result: Jeff picks up the win after hitting the Swanton Bomb through a table (16:57).

Advertisement

Rating: There's always going to be a novel appeal to seeing the Hardyz going at it, even if this one just went through a lot of the hardcore match staples - hitting each other with objects, a standard table bump and so on.

It was fun seeing the World's Biggest Ladder get balanced across the six-sided ring, but the powerbomb onto the keyboard looked a lot less cool than they probably hoped it would, and ultimately this was just missing that big marquee moment to elevate it above what we usually see in matches like this.

The finish was particularly underwhelming considering that Jeff said in the days before the PPV that he was planning to pull off "something big" at the show, and was hoping to top Shane McMahon's insane WrestleMania 32 bump. A decent enough brawl, but simply not great. 6/10

3. Mike Bennett Vs. Ethan Carter III

Result: EC3 scores the win after nailing the TKO into the One-Percenter (15:01).

Advertisement

Rating: This was an extremely physical slug-fest as you'd reasonably expect, though the pace was pretty slow from the outset even if that didn't stop it being a satisfying contest.

Even though Bennett lost, he came out of this one looking strong (especially after kicking out of the One-Percenter), and the closing minutes featured some great near-falls where it honestly could've gone either way.

The Maria shenanigans late in the match were unnecessary for the story being told in the ring and the camerawork made the whole spot feel really clumsy, but both men nevertheless emerged from the result looking good.

Plus, coming after four thoroughly mediocre matches, this one really felt like a miracle (pun intended). 7/10

2. World Heavyweight Title: Drew Galloway (c) Vs. Bobby Lashley

Result: Lashley chokes out Galloway to win the title (17:03).

Advertisement

Rating: Despite how mixed the rest of the card was, the main event certainly lived up to expectations, delivering a brutal and extremely physical contest which saw both men come out strong, even if one can certainly argue that Galloway deserved a longer title reign considering how long he had to wait for it.

If you're still a Lashley doubter (and there are plenty of them), this surely was a persuasive argument of just how much he's improved since his WWECW days, and where it counts (in the ring) he should make for a convincing monster heel champ.

Still not the best match on the card, but absolutely rock solid all the same. 7/10

1. X-Division Title Fatal 4 Way: Trevor Lee (c) Vs. Andrew Everett Vs. Eddie Edwards Vs. DJZ

Result: Edwards rolls up Lee to win the title (10:12).

Advertisement

Rating: That's right, the opener stole the show! The battle lines were pretty clearly drawn here from the outset, so it felt more like a tag match than a fatal-4-way a lot of the time.

Still, it was a thrilling bout from bell to bell. Trevor Lee continued to prove why he's one of TNA's most exciting talents with some terrific high-flying work, and all four men worked well together even if it mostly followed the Fatal 4 Way formula of two guys wrestling at any one time.

The closing minutes were absolutely killer, full of near-falls and brutal reversals, and Edwards' win was a genuine surprise, if not a particularly exciting finish. A rock solid opener and it could've gone much longer without any complaints. Plus, could we see The Wolves warring for the X-Division Title in the near-future? 7/10

What did you think of TNA Slammiversary 2016? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement